RE: Shed of the Week: Peugeot 306 GTI-6

RE: Shed of the Week: Peugeot 306 GTI-6

Author
Discussion

Pebbles167

3,445 posts

152 months

Saturday 28th October 2017
quotequote all
angels95 said:
daytona111r said:
Anyone agree with me that these are better to drive than a 205 1.9 GTI? Not Elamite as electric sharp, but more forgiving handling on the limit and thus more fun to play around with
Sadly I can't comment as the only 205 I've driven was a 1.1, but as a GTI-6 owner I would love to see how a 205 GTI compares.
The 306 is quicker than a 205, but as for handling, the 306 is supposed to a bit less likely to lose the back end (some guys i know own both). The same is said about the 306 compared to the 106. I think all three hatches have similar handling characteristics, so they are all fun. I've not owned a 205 but I've had lots of 106s & 306s and can say the 306 is more planted. The most stable to drive I've had was actually a 206 Gti180, but still felt very 'Pug' like, I think they get an unreservedly bad rep.

greenarrow

3,592 posts

117 months

Saturday 28th October 2017
quotequote all
Pebbles167 said:
angels95 said:
daytona111r said:
Anyone agree with me that these are better to drive than a 205 1.9 GTI? Not Elamite as electric sharp, but more forgiving handling on the limit and thus more fun to play around with
Sadly I can't comment as the only 205 I've driven was a 1.1, but as a GTI-6 owner I would love to see how a 205 GTI compares.
The 306 is quicker than a 205, but as for handling, the 306 is supposed to a bit less likely to lose the back end (some guys i know own both). The same is said about the 306 compared to the 106. I think all three hatches have similar handling characteristics, so they are all fun. I've not owned a 205 but I've had lots of 106s & 306s and can say the 306 is more planted. The most stable to drive I've had was actually a 206 Gti180, but still felt very 'Pug' like, I think they get an unreservedly bad rep.
Its an interesting question. I owned a 205 GTI for 11 years and had an extensive drive in a 306 Rallye some years ago. I'd say the 306 is the more capable all round car, but as for "better", drive, I am not sure.

Our 205 didn't have power steering and nothing else I've driven communicated so much and felt so rewarding just driving down any road. The 306 on the other hand felt much faster and probably had a better ride-handling balance.

Honestly I would put both in my all time hot hatch top 10, probably top 5.

Pebbles167

3,445 posts

152 months

Saturday 28th October 2017
quotequote all
Well said. And you're right, Its hard to class either as 'better' as it's mostly down to preference, since neither of them handle badly.

My 106 XSI has no PAS, and was very involving to drive. Loved it.

I've know owners of 205's with an MI16 engine or the 306 Gti engine. They are very quick on track and seem to handle well.



s m

23,223 posts

203 months

Sunday 29th October 2017
quotequote all
Pebbles167 said:
The 306 is quicker than a 205, but as for handling, the 306 is supposed to a bit less likely to lose the back end (some guys i know own both). The same is said about the 306 compared to the 106. I think all three hatches have similar handling characteristics, so they are all fun. I've not owned a 205 but I've had lots of 106s & 306s and can say the 306 is more planted. The most stable to drive I've had was actually a 206 Gti180, but still felt very 'Pug' like, I think they get an unreservedly bad rep.
I'd quite like to try a 206 180 - have tried/owned all the others mentioned plus the old 309Gti. It would be down to personal preference for the handling unless you were going to quantify it with lap/slalom times

Pebbles167

3,445 posts

152 months

Sunday 29th October 2017
quotequote all
s m said:
I'd quite like to try a 206 180 - have tried/owned all the others mentioned plus the old 309Gti. It would be down to personal preference for the handling unless you were going to quantify it with lap/slalom times
It's a good car, you can grab a real nice one for under £1k. Not as 'fun' as a 306 perhaps, and doesn't feel as fast, but over a lap at combe I put in near enough the same times as my 306 Rallye.

The 180 is considered a bit or an iffy figure. Most seem to put out around 160bhp.

I really liked mine, i'd have another.

aaron_2000

5,407 posts

83 months

Sunday 29th October 2017
quotequote all
About a year ago I was offered a 309 GTI 3 door for £1000, turned it down as I was holding out for a 205 (That didn't happen) that 309 sold for £6000 a few weeks ago.

s m

23,223 posts

203 months

Sunday 29th October 2017
quotequote all
aaron_2000 said:
About a year ago I was offered a 309 GTI 3 door for £1000, turned it down as I was holding out for a 205 (That didn't happen) that 309 sold for £6000 a few weeks ago.
smile

Back when my friends were all getting 205 1.9s ( late 80s ), I really wanted one too after various drives of their cars and a long test drive

That was until I had a go in a 309 ( which were a fair bit cheaper as well secondhand ).
I ended up with a Graphite Grey one for quite a few years. Same sort of motoring .....but less money if you didn't mind the looks of the ugly sister!

aaron_2000

5,407 posts

83 months

Sunday 29th October 2017
quotequote all
s m said:
smile

Back when my friends were all getting 205 1.9s ( late 80s ), I really wanted one too after various drives of their cars and a long test drive

That was until I had a go in a 309 ( which were a fair bit cheaper as well secondhand ).
I ended up with a Graphite Grey one for quite a few years. Same sort of motoring .....but less money if you didn't mind the looks of the ugly sister!
I think in a way the 309 looks better, probably not though. Heard they're just as good, in some ways better to drive though