RE: EV conversions for Morgan and Triumph

RE: EV conversions for Morgan and Triumph

Wednesday 14th April 2021

EV conversions for Morgan and Triumph

UK firm Electrogenic has converted a Stag and 4/4 to run on battery power - with manual gearboxes



Oxfordshire firm Electrogenic is bidding to get more people excited about EVs with a brace of 'world first' conversions, a Triumph Stag and Morgan 4/4 that use battery power and manual gearboxes. Officially the first electric Stag – authenticated by the owner’s club, no less – and almost certainly the first for a 4/4, the work further demonstrates how even some of the most ‘traditional’ offerings can be adapted for a tailpipe-free future. It seems nothing is too old for a battery pack, with this Stag hailing from 1976, and the 4/4 1957.

Of course, the news might frustrate as many people as it impresses, what with these being two resolutely popular British classics – not to mention the 3.0-litre V8 which had to make way in the Stag. But for those who want to continue enjoying their cars in urban environments, these conversions potentially make sense. Because let’s face it, even if emissions limits don’t currently block classics from city centres (they’re exempt from London’s ULEZ), you wouldn't bet on the situation staying that way forever everywhere.


Clearly, Electrogenic’s creations appease these people as much as they do those wanting to experience the style and aura of classic motoring, with a simplified, less oily setup. With 107hp and 173lb ft of torque going to rear wheels through the Stag’s original four-speed manual gearbox, there’s plenty of potential for fun. Albeit without the burble and whiff of a V8; here, there’s a 37kWh battery in its place. The space left by the fuel tank and spare wheel is occupied, too. The conversion uses a Type 2 charger and offers an approximate range of 150 miles of range.

The same ‘Hyper9’ high-voltage brushless motor setup is deployed in the Morgan, with identical outputs to the Stag, with the 4/4’s original manual gearbox also retained for three-pedal driving. Again, range is rated at about 150 miles per charge, in a car that might be more widely liked because it only traded a four-cylinder for the battery-powered layout. Also, the new power output is more closely aligned with the original engine’s 114hp; by contrast, the Stag has been ‘downgraded’ by 38hp. Although the instant delivery of EV torque probably compensates for that.

That said, speed isn’t the point of these Electrogenic conversions, nor has it been the point of earlier classic conversions by firms like Lunaz. This is all about keeping vintage vehicles on the roads in a world where attitudes are clearly changing. To some, the operation of a literal plug-and-play vehicle, which doesn’t require constant tinkering and frequent servicing, will be a Godsend, and the fact these cars are electric is second to that change in usability. Although don’t expect a quick saving in running costs. Pricing isn’t out, but Electrogenic’s earlier classic Beetle conversion cost about £35k, excluding the car.


“Converting older cars like these to electric power is about using modern technology to bring out the best characteristics in the cars,” said Steve Drummond, director and co-founder of Electrogenic. “For us this means increasing power within the capabilities of the original vehicle, optimising weight distribution and not using too many batteries to keep the handling crisp and precise. Our proprietary electronics integrate the batteries and motor into a seamless system, making the cars as safe as possible.”

Obviously, it’ll depend which side of the EV fence you sit on as how you feel about classic conversions in the first place, but Electrogenic is adamant that it tries to stay faithful to each car's original design - including redeploying things like gauges. Switching out the engine is certainly the hardest alteration to get onboard with, but if it keeps classics on the road (and out of the garage), it's easy to make a case for a burgeoning trend. 




Author
Discussion

TommyBuoy

Original Poster:

1,269 posts

167 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
May seem a daft question but I assume the motor is coupled to the gear box? If so, do they upgrade them? How long will they last with that torque going through them?

Triumph Man

8,690 posts

168 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
Bleugh

swisstoni

16,986 posts

279 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
I can imagine some rich clots who live in central london doing this just because they can.
But I can’t see a reason to alter these cars otherwise.
It’s not like they’ll be crushed in 2030 or something.

Jacobyte

4,723 posts

242 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
swisstoni said:
I can imagine some rich clots who live in central london doing this just because they can.
But I can’t see a reason to alter these cars otherwise.
It’s not like they’ll be crushed in 2030 or something.
The engines in some old cars really were terrible, often making them unroadworthy for most of the year whilst someone tries to find time to tinker with them before they break again. These wonderful looking cars can now actually reach their destination without dribbling oil everywhere from their knackered old cornflake-packet gaskets.
This is the way forwards, as long as it's a reversible procedure.

Steamer

13,857 posts

213 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
Triumph Man said:
Bleugh
hehe

I was wondering how to best sum up my thoughts on this subject too.

romac

595 posts

146 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
Brilliant idea. Shame it is so expensive at the moment. Not everyone loves driving because of the noise a car makes. Some of us love driving despite the noise a car makes. Open-top, quiet electric cruising must be bliss!

If you can't live without the sound, just need to add a soundracer.se product to get the sound you want! tongue out

chrispmartha

15,447 posts

129 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
Love the idea of electrifying some classics...

As a former Citroen DS owner an Electric powered DS Pallas would be a thing of beauty, the Engines in the DS was the only rubbish thing about them, wafting about in an Electric DS would be amazing

Triumph Man

8,690 posts

168 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
Steamer said:
Triumph Man said:
Bleugh
hehe

I was wondering how to best sum up my thoughts on this subject too.
I tried to come up with something insightful and considered, but the above was all I could manage hehe

Re the DS, however, I think they would work quite well converted to Electric power - it would suit the car. The ICE was just something that propelled the car, rather than part of the character.

Part of a Stag is that V8 burble.

Roger Irrelevant

2,932 posts

113 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
Jacobyte said:
The engines in some old cars really were terrible, often making them unroadworthy for most of the year whilst someone tries to find time to tinker with them before they break again. These wonderful looking cars can now actually reach their destination without dribbling oil everywhere from their knackered old cornflake-packet gaskets.
This is the way forwards, as long as it's a reversible procedure.
I agree with this - as I mature the idea of poncing about the dales where I live in a classic car is becoming ever more attractive. However I have no interest whatsoever in the 'romance' of frequent breakdowns, skinned knuckles, and spending more time scouring the internet for engine parts that went out of production 30 years ago than I spend actually driving the thing. Tbh I'd quite happily forego a manual gearbox too if it meant the thing was more likely to just work.

chrispmartha

15,447 posts

129 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
Triumph Man said:
Steamer said:
Triumph Man said:
Bleugh
hehe

I was wondering how to best sum up my thoughts on this subject too.
I tried to come up with something insightful and considered, but the above was all I could manage hehe

Re the DS, however, I think they would work quite well converted to Electric power - it would suit the car. The ICE was just something that propelled the car, rather than part of the character.

Part of a Stag is that V8 burble.
The engines in the DS range were terrible and for a car that was so advanced it was the one thing that let the cars down.

I think they originally wanted to develop a new 6 cylider engine for it but couldn’t get it to fit.

jeremy996

320 posts

226 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
I have a 1972 Morgan 4/4 1600 that is currently being rebuilt. Converting it to electricity today would be silly expensive, but in 20-30 years I could see me being quite amenable towards it. (Kent engines usually get rather baggy after 100,000+ miles).

I just wondering how happy the authorities will be to have a car driven by a real person in traffic dominated by pods driven by algorithms. I expect the private car will be as relevant as the horse as transport.

Triumph Man

8,690 posts

168 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
chrispmartha said:
Triumph Man said:
Steamer said:
Triumph Man said:
Bleugh
hehe

I was wondering how to best sum up my thoughts on this subject too.
I tried to come up with something insightful and considered, but the above was all I could manage hehe

Re the DS, however, I think they would work quite well converted to Electric power - it would suit the car. The ICE was just something that propelled the car, rather than part of the character.

Part of a Stag is that V8 burble.
The engines in the DS range were terrible and for a car that was so advanced it was the one thing that let the cars down.

I think they originally wanted to develop a new 6 cylider engine for it but couldn’t get it to fit.
Yes a flat 6 I believe - so they tarted up the old Traction Avant engine and that was that.

chrispmartha

15,447 posts

129 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
Triumph Man said:
they tarted up the old Traction Avant engine and that was that.
And a horrid thing it was too!

Equus

16,883 posts

101 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
Speaking of Citroens, surely the 2CV is the obvious choice for this treatment - the ultimate car for yoghurt-weaving hippies, and the original is so underpowered (and light) that all you'd need would be a cheap permanent magnet pancake motor?

mat205125

17,790 posts

213 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
Would it really have been that hard to have the electronics under the Morgan bonnet a little more horizontal so it looks a little more like it was designed to be there and not lobbed in

Reckon they could add a small reservoir of filthy oil to periodically dispense onto the ground, in the interests of nostalgia?

chrispmartha

15,447 posts

129 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
Equus said:
Speaking of Citroens, surely the 2CV is the obvious choice for this treatment - the ultimate car for yoghurt-weaving hippies, and the original is so underpowered (and light) that all you'd need would be a cheap permanent magnet pancake motor?
Citroen have sort of already done a revamp with the Ami...

(and I think its a fab little thing) :-)


Bobby Lee

224 posts

55 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
jeremy996 said:
I just wondering how happy the authorities will be to have a car driven by a real person in traffic dominated by pods driven by algorithms. I expect the private car will be as relevant as the horse as transport.
Since a lot of people who are the authorities (or their voters) have huge amounts of money tied up in private cars as investments, I can’t see them being forced off the roads.

They might be as relevant as a horse as transport, but suspect they’ll remain just as road legal. Doubt anyone in 1950 imagined you’d still be allowed to ride a horse on the road in 2021 but here we are.

reeventu

73 posts

188 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
The whole idea is quite frankly rubbish, if you want an old/classic buy one ,accept breakdowns , skinned knuckles whatever,

To plonk as someone rightly said an electric motor in an old car is crazy.

Consider handling , brakes , electrics, corrosion etc ,all need updating or revising or repairing. you then end up with an old shape with modern probably unsuitable power system , giving limited performance , limited range at a vast expense. the vehicle will be worth nothing in a very short time. Enthusiasts wont want it , those that first bought it will realise the mistake and those with enough money will buy a new conversion .

I cannot even understand how it could be road legal surely it would need proper examination to show it complied with all safety requirements for electric vehicles . I suspect the fire service would be very unhappy with this concept

If you want an EV buy a properly made model

If you want a classic buy a proper original car

rampageturke

2,622 posts

162 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
oh gosh oh no, 3, maybe 4 triumph stags and a couple of morgans will be changed to electric power! the sky is falling! the apocalypse is now! nanny state gone mad!

pete06

9 posts

132 months

Wednesday 14th April 2021
quotequote all
“bring out the best characteristics in the cars”

I think this should say: bring out what little character is now left in the cars.....