RE: EV sales falter despite new car market growth
RE: EV sales falter despite new car market growth
Author
Discussion

Tiglon

1,116 posts

73 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Many decades ago we needed trade unions to protect employees from blood-sucking SMEs. Now we could do with trade unions who can protect SMEs from huge national/global blood-sucking corporations.

The problem hasn't gone away, it's just moved further up the chain.

The way that companies like amazon and booking.com work just pushes up prices for consumers and cuts margins in SMEs, all in return for nothing but a little convenience.

ajm_ph

1,625 posts

106 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
DonkeyApple said:
ajm_ph said:
Leasing isn't a sale though. Lease means you are essentially hiring the car from the lease company; that's why all the lease adverts end with the disclaimer "you will not own the car". As I understand it, legally, for the entirety of the lease period, the car is the property of the leasing company.
Even with PCP the asset sits on the vendors balance sheet for the duration of the term and is another form of rental.

Basic rule of thumb is that if a bailiff can come and take it away when you stop paying for something then it's a rental of some form. biggrin
Sure, but the question was about whether something counts as a private sale or business sale for the sake of SMMT figures. A PCP car might appear as a line on the company balance sheet, as it hasn't been paid for yet and they expect to get it back at the end, but I believe the SMMT would count it as a private sale as technically the registered keeper is "buying" the car; albeit with the plan to hand it back for the GFV at the end. Wheres with a lease there is no pretence of the car having been sold to the driver.

The difference may only exist on paper, but that may define what counts as a business or fleet sale in the SMMT figures.

SpeckledJim

34,596 posts

284 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Clad-Hach said:
DonkeyApple said:
Hungrymc said:
Uk manufacturing jobs were about 10% of the total population in 1990, it s down to about 3% today. And it s a similar ratio in Automotive manufacturing to wider manufacturing. But it s inevitable in a relatively high Labour cost country and a global economy without some serious market restrictions and if that s healthy or sustainable is another discussion.

I guess we ll see something similar with AI in the service sector soon enough. The employment market is very complex now.
As an aside, I'd ban chain stores from using automated tills those till jobs are absolutely crucial for a local economy. I'd just levy a big tax on each automated till for any business above a certain size so that it was cheaper for them to hire local people.
That is a very good point, the greed of the supermarkets has caused untold damage to a once thriving high street and local shops.

When an Asda opened in the town near by most of the shops in our village closed very soon after...and they had been there for decades.
On the other hand, households used to spend 30% of their income on food and now it's about 15%. So it's not all bad news.

Those people were all free to continue to use the small shops, but they just didn't want to. It's not the supermarkets to blame.

Sir Keith Stormer

1,203 posts

16 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
SpeckledJim said:
On the other hand, households used to spend 30% of their income on food and now it's about 15%. So it's not all bad news.

Those people were all free to continue to use the small shops, but they just didn't want to. It's not the supermarkets to blame.
Yep why would you pay double for the same product, I have fond memories of the local shops where I grew up but when I had to buy my own food I went to the cheapest place like everybody else.

Hungrymc

7,452 posts

168 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
SpeckledJim said:
On the other hand, households used to spend 30% of their income on food and now it's about 15%. So it's not all bad news.

Those people were all free to continue to use the small shops, but they just didn't want to. It's not the supermarkets to blame.
Which ties us back to the country of manufacture of cars. There is an angle where if you are fortunate enough to have benefited from an economy such that you have the funds to exercise choice. There is some merit in being mindful of which economy and which employment you support with your spending. Is buying the Chinese car a bit like shopping at the supermarket next to the local grocer ? It's far from black and white of course, but it is a consideration.

DonkeyApple

70,886 posts

200 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Hungrymc said:
Which ties us back to the country of manufacture of cars. There is an angle where if you are fortunate enough to have benefited from an economy such that you have the funds to exercise choice. There is some merit in being mindful of which economy and which employment you support with your spending. Is buying the Chinese car a bit like shopping at the supermarket next to the local grocer ? It's far from black and white of course, but it is a consideration.
True but in reality the local grocer went bust in the 90s and the choice is between Aldi or Lidl, both foreign owned and where people just choose by which is cheaper or easier.

At a national level we ideally want to be importing from two different geographic zones but it's up to the European mainland to deliver competitive alternatives if they want our business.

Meanwhile, trendy, artisan local grocers can exist in the melee.

wisbech

4,391 posts

152 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Tiglon said:
Many decades ago we needed trade unions to protect employees from blood-sucking SMEs. Now we could do with trade unions who can protect SMEs from huge national/global blood-sucking corporations.

The problem hasn't gone away, it's just moved further up the chain.

The way that companies like amazon and booking.com work just pushes up prices for consumers and cuts margins in SMEs, all in return for nothing but a little convenience.
Way more than a little convenience, it s transformed living in the sticks. Before if you wanted anything out of the ordinary, you had to live in or travel to a city - probably London. It s the geographical basis behind village/ market town/ city development, where demand had to be concentrated to make specialist services viable (ie Stow on the Wold and its antique shops back in the day). Is it annoying that the nearest fishmonger is now 15 miles away, not 5, sure. But I can now get amazing seafood delivered direct from Scotland/ Cornwall etc

The internet has to an extent removed that (though not for services that need to be delivered on site, like theatre/ restaurants)




WTDMM

564 posts

15 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
DonkeyApple said:
Even with PCP the asset sits on the vendors balance sheet for the duration of the term and is another form of rental.

.
with a pcp/hp/finance lease the asset would sit on the purchasers balance sheet (if it was a company) the vendor/finance house just have a receivable and if it was an operating lease it would be an asset for the vendor/finance company.

Tuggy

215 posts

8 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Anyone watch the channel 5 "petrol v. EV" last night? I know, but I lost control of the remote. Every EV critic rolled into one.

Range test. Drive to a destination 100 miles away 1/4 tank petrol vs. some level of charge. Artificial forcing of a mid-way charge - who the hell wouldn't plug the EV to charge it night before to make sure they don't need to stop and instead charge at public charge rates?

Pricing - so the used petrol thing was £2k less than the same car as an EV (that had huge amount of depreciation more). No factoring in a previous test of fuel costs, or mention of servicing. Or that the EV will be a more pleasant drive.

Just annoying cheap programming. TV equivalent of click-bait and probably done to death on here.

SDK

3,778 posts

284 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
The Polestar 5 review embargo ends tomorrow.
I think this is the best looking car available on sale today, and looking forward to the reviews, videos.....and comments tongue out


otolith

69,754 posts

235 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
SDK said:
The Polestar 5 review embargo ends tomorrow.
I think this is the best looking car available on sale today, and looking forward to the reviews, videos.....and comments tongue out

Bad timing, is it not the new Jag’s launch day tomorrow?

ZesPak

26,164 posts

227 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
SDK said:
The Polestar 5 review embargo ends tomorrow.
I think this is the best looking car available on sale today, and looking forward to the reviews, videos.....and comments tongue out

Ah the Model S competitor we've been waiting for for over 5 years, just in time to replace it smile

craigjm

21,704 posts

231 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
SDK said:
The Polestar 5 review embargo ends tomorrow.
I think this is the best looking car available on sale today, and looking forward to the reviews, videos.....and comments tongue out

Will get zero attention as the Jaguar Type 01 is launched at the same time

CoolHands

23,712 posts

226 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
You can t be serious, aren t we all fed up with this constant ev design ‘trick’ to try and hide the depth? Looks gash


otolith

69,754 posts

235 months

Tuesday 6th October
quotequote all
CoolHands said:
You can t be serious, aren t we all fed up with this constant ev design trick to try and hide the depth? Looks gash

Would it look better without it?

DonkeyApple

70,886 posts

200 months

Tuesday 6th October
quotequote all
Tuggy said:
Anyone watch the channel 5 "petrol v. EV" last night? I know, but I lost control of the remote. Every EV critic rolled into one.

Range test. Drive to a destination 100 miles away 1/4 tank petrol vs. some level of charge. Artificial forcing of a mid-way charge - who the hell wouldn't plug the EV to charge it night before to make sure they don't need to stop and instead charge at public charge rates?

Pricing - so the used petrol thing was £2k less than the same car as an EV (that had huge amount of depreciation more). No factoring in a previous test of fuel costs, or mention of servicing. Or that the EV will be a more pleasant drive.

Just annoying cheap programming. TV equivalent of click-bait and probably done to death on here.
Were there nazis and sharks?

ashenfie

3,442 posts

77 months

Tuesday 6th October
quotequote all
Tuggy said:
Anyone watch the channel 5 "petrol v. EV" last night? I know, but I lost control of the remote. Every EV critic rolled into one.

Range test. Drive to a destination 100 miles away 1/4 tank petrol vs. some level of charge. Artificial forcing of a mid-way charge - who the hell wouldn't plug the EV to charge it night before to make sure they don't need to stop and instead charge at public charge rates?

Pricing - so the used petrol thing was £2k less than the same car as an EV (that had huge amount of depreciation more). No factoring in a previous test of fuel costs, or mention of servicing. Or that the EV will be a more pleasant drive.

Just annoying cheap programming. TV equivalent of click-bait and probably done to death on here.
Why watch it then?

craigjm

21,704 posts

231 months

Tuesday 6th October
quotequote all
ashenfie said:
Tuggy said:
Anyone watch the channel 5 "petrol v. EV" last night? I know, but I lost control of the remote. Every EV critic rolled into one.

Range test. Drive to a destination 100 miles away 1/4 tank petrol vs. some level of charge. Artificial forcing of a mid-way charge - who the hell wouldn't plug the EV to charge it night before to make sure they don't need to stop and instead charge at public charge rates?

Pricing - so the used petrol thing was £2k less than the same car as an EV (that had huge amount of depreciation more). No factoring in a previous test of fuel costs, or mention of servicing. Or that the EV will be a more pleasant drive.

Just annoying cheap programming. TV equivalent of click-bait and probably done to death on here.
Why watch it then?
Why not pay attention to his first paragraph?

ZesPak

26,164 posts

227 months

Tuesday 6th October
quotequote all
otolith said:
CoolHands said:
You can t be serious, aren t we all fed up with this constant ev design trick to try and hide the depth? Looks gash

Would it look better without it?
Nah, I think the A6 is a prime example.
It looks way too tall without it.





It's not just EV's btw, a lot of people carriers have done this for years to be sold as SUV's, without any real added ride height.

ashenfie

3,442 posts

77 months

Tuesday 6th October
quotequote all
craigjm said:
ashenfie said:
Tuggy said:
Anyone watch the channel 5 "petrol v. EV" last night? I know, but I lost control of the remote. Every EV critic rolled into one.

Range test. Drive to a destination 100 miles away 1/4 tank petrol vs. some level of charge. Artificial forcing of a mid-way charge - who the hell wouldn't plug the EV to charge it night before to make sure they don't need to stop and instead charge at public charge rates?

Pricing - so the used petrol thing was £2k less than the same car as an EV (that had huge amount of depreciation more). No factoring in a previous test of fuel costs, or mention of servicing. Or that the EV will be a more pleasant drive.

Just annoying cheap programming. TV equivalent of click-bait and probably done to death on here.
Why watch it then?
Why not pay attention to his first paragraph?
What you are doing with your right hand has no interest to me, how do you know what is in the vid. without watch it? if you didn't watch it, you can't really provide a balanced of review. If you did watch it then the question stands.