Stupid engineering designs

Stupid engineering designs

Author
Discussion

crofty1984

Original Poster:

15,844 posts

204 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
I'll start.
I was doing up the front end of my Bonneville (70's) recently, the brake caliper isn't bolted on, it's a studs and nuts job. So? So to put the caliper on, you have to take the front wheel off. WHO THE fk THOUGHT THAT WAS SENSIBLE????

J B L

4,199 posts

215 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
Triumph Sprint ST 955i. Changing the bulbs, you have to take the front fairing off remove and split the lights cluster to access the buggers.

I thought that was a bit stupid on a bike destined to tour, especially when changing a bulb on my VTR is a matter of seconds. rolleyes

Esceptico

7,431 posts

109 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
Flip up side stand on Ducati 748 / 916

To me it is a design fault that to test the oil level you have to stand the bike up vertical (not easy if low down). Why not make it so that you have to test whilst the bike in on the side stand (on level ground)?

kev b

2,714 posts

166 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
You've never worked on a Ducati then or removed the rear wheel on an MV?
My Aprilia is pretty simple to work on but you have to remove the calipers to take out the front wheel, the bolts are supposed to be renewed each time, I wonder if anyone does this?

Similarly with quite a few cars owned by family I often get called in when bulbs need changing, my nieces and nephews all seem to be drawn to French cars whose propensity to blow bulbs is in proportion with their inaccessibility, removing the bumper or wheelarch liner to swap a bulb is madness.

Birky_41

4,282 posts

184 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
Centre high beam light on my Aprilia Tuono

Have to take the whole front fairing off to change the bulb and adjusting it ain't much better

Only other one I can think of was way back in 2001 when I had my carb'd sv650s and it would get crap in the front cylinder when it rained heavy or was really cold and it make the bike run on one cylinder

Gavia

7,627 posts

91 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
BMW S1000RR oil sight glass is on the opposite side of the bike to the oil filler cap, so you're constantly walking round the bike to check oil level when doing an oil / filter change.

Gavia

7,627 posts

91 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
All bikes thatbhave that stupid rear brake design, where the pads sit on a ledge unsecured. Every time you try to put the rear wheel back on the effin pads keep dropping down.

WaferThinHam

1,680 posts

130 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
Esceptico said:
Flip up side stand on Ducati 748 / 916
Pretty sure this was just a cheap way for them to get the bike homologated without having to design a cut out switch if you went to start it in gear. (Could be completely wrong, if they did have said switch, why bother with the sprung sidestand, oh right. They're Italian).

Jazzy Jag

3,417 posts

91 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
WaferThinHam said:
Pretty sure this was just a cheap way for them to sell more fairing panels .
Fixed that for you.

hehe

Birky_41

4,282 posts

184 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
Gavia said:
BMW S1000RR oil sight glass is on the opposite side of the bike to the oil filler cap, so you're constantly walking round the bike to check oil level when doing an oil / filter change.
That would drive me mad too

bimsb6

8,039 posts

221 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
My harley fxr , the rear spindle is supposed to go in from the right hand side , except this means removing the silencers . Solution , put it in from the left hand side !
My bimota sb6 , oil filler hole is behind the right hand frame spar , no possible way to get to it , oil has to be filled through the engine breather which means removing seat/ tank unit , fuel tank and fairing to remove the oil filter.

Cbull

4,464 posts

171 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
Gavia said:
All bikes thatbhave that stupid rear brake design, where the pads sit on a ledge unsecured. Every time you try to put the rear wheel back on the effin pads keep dropping down.
It took me and the father in-law about 40 odd minutes to fit the back wheel on my bike the other week. Between the brakes not lining up and the wheel spacers on either side falling off it was just a nightmare. There must be a knack to it which I'm missing. Dreading having to do it on my own one day. Just madness.

tom_e

346 posts

99 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
Cbull said:
It took me and the father in-law about 40 odd minutes to fit the back wheel on my bike the other week. Between the brakes not lining up and the wheel spacers on either side falling off it was just a nightmare. There must be a knack to it which I'm missing. Dreading having to do it on my own one day. Just madness.
I can manage it on my own in 30 seconds flat or 30 minutes of swearing, sweating and wanting to launch the wheel up the garden.
It's pure luck if everything lines up the first time or second or third or fiftieth.

Gunk

3,302 posts

159 months

Sunday 23rd July 2017
quotequote all
Esceptico said:
Flip up side stand on Ducati 748 / 916

To me it is a design fault that to test the oil level you have to stand the bike up vertical (not easy if low down). Why not make it so that you have to test whilst the bike in on the side stand (on level ground)?
First thing I did with my 600SS was to grind the nipple of the retaining bolt so the stand would stay down, crazy design, no wonder so many Ducati's of that era have been dropped on the left hand side.

King Herald

23,501 posts

216 months

Monday 24th July 2017
quotequote all
Kawasaki 550 LTD I had decades ago. When the clutch was pulled in it also pulled the side stand up. There was a cable twixt the two. Twice people sat on the bike, stood it up, pulled levers, wiggled the bars a bit, dropped it back on the stand......that was now not down....

I never saw another bike that had a stand like that.

Rubin215

3,987 posts

156 months

Monday 24th July 2017
quotequote all
King Herald said:
Kawasaki 550 LTD I had decades ago. When the clutch was pulled in it also pulled the side stand up. There was a cable twixt the two. Twice people sat on the bike, stood it up, pulled levers, wiggled the bars a bit, dropped it back on the stand......that was now not down....

I never saw another bike that had a stand like that.
A lot of 80's Kwaks had that.

My "favourite" stupid design is the Tokico caliper fitted to the rear of many Suzukis where the pad pins fit into a blind drilling.
After one unlubricated winter the pins weld in and the only way to change pads is to split the caliper.

moto_traxport

4,237 posts

221 months

Monday 24th July 2017
quotequote all
Gavia said:
All bikes thatbhave that stupid rear brake design, where the pads sit on a ledge unsecured. Every time you try to put the rear wheel back on the effin pads keep dropping down.
Sliding calipers - cannot believe how many expensive bikes still have this crap design for the rear caliper. My early R1 has a proper opposed piston design but they switched to the cheaper option later in production.

Race teams (such as Hutchy's Stock ZX10 at last years TT that did a very quick pit stop) drill and lock wire the pads (not sure where or where to) and chamfer the bottom of the pad with a grinder so it doesn't catch the disc as you push the wheel forward.

Gavia

7,627 posts

91 months

Monday 24th July 2017
quotequote all
moto_traxport said:
Sliding calipers - cannot believe how many expensive bikes still have this crap design for the rear caliper. My early R1 has a proper opposed piston design but they switched to the cheaper option later in production.

Race teams (such as Hutchy's Stock ZX10 at last years TT that did a very quick pit stop) drill and lock wire the pads (not sure where or where to) and chamfer the bottom of the pad with a grinder so it doesn't catch the disc as you push the wheel forward.
It's a proper st design. What really frustrates me though is that if I'm rushing, then there's no way the pad will stay in place, whereas when I've got all day to change it, then it just slots straight in.

Cbull

4,464 posts

171 months

Tuesday 25th July 2017
quotequote all
Cheap bolts and screws. Nothing worse than having to drill out a snapped bolt because it's either rusted in, de-threaded or the head has no intention of helping you out.

All manufacturers should use higher quality materials to suit throughout the whole bike. Even the 'cheap' brands could rid of their horrid stigma that plagues them. It honestly shouldn't add that much to the price of the bike to a point where they'd charge £100s on top of the otherwise RRP. It really baffles me.

Iang84

962 posts

166 months

Tuesday 25th July 2017
quotequote all
Cbull said:
Gavia said:
All bikes thatbhave that stupid rear brake design, where the pads sit on a ledge unsecured. Every time you try to put the rear wheel back on the effin pads keep dropping down.
It took me and the father in-law about 40 odd minutes to fit the back wheel on my bike the other week. Between the brakes not lining up and the wheel spacers on either side falling off it was just a nightmare. There must be a knack to it which I'm missing. Dreading having to do it on my own one day. Just madness.
I normally put a small dab of grease on the end of the spacer which seems to hold it in place 9/10 times