PCNA Centrelock recall
PCNA Centrelock recall
Author
Discussion

Digga

45,772 posts

305 months

Wednesday 30th October 2024
quotequote all
Seen a lot of people complaining about discolouration and breakdown of the surface finish. In a way, just that alone, in and of itself could create an issue with the interface between the nut and wheel.

Freakuk

4,375 posts

173 months

Wednesday 30th October 2024
quotequote all
I wonder how many cars on forecourts will be stuck and not selling now?

I say that as I was at my OPC yesterday having a service and looking at their stock and pondering my next car, I assume some of them will be there until Feb now and cannot be sold and delivered until the parts have been replaced.

av185

20,464 posts

149 months

Wednesday 30th October 2024
quotequote all
Jon_Brown91 said:
My OPC has just informed me that all affected UK registered cars must not be driven until fixed and that Porsche will be arranging loan cars via Enterprise, but will not be a Porsche!
Yep am hearing c1150 UK cars also confirmed Enterprise loaners and no chance of a Porsche. Does beg the question whether the Enterprise offer just relates to the initial period of inspection to confirm whether that particular Porsche is affected or not. Can't imagine most owners would want anything else other than a decent Porsche loaner plus monthly compensation package particularly if the cars are off road for extended period until the earliest fix i.e. Feb 25.

Reminiscent of the 991.1 GT3 engine saga.

During the last warranty work in 2022 I actually rejected the BMW 5 series loaner delivered from Enterprise due to the stty condition.... it was a real shed btw! Used another car of mine instead for the period.

av185

20,464 posts

149 months

Wednesday 30th October 2024
quotequote all
Freakuk said:
I wonder how many cars on forecourts will be stuck and not selling now?

I say that as I was at my OPC yesterday having a service and looking at their stock and pondering my next car, I assume some of them will be there until Feb now and cannot be sold and delivered until the parts have been replaced.
Yep posted about this on another thread. Stop sale on affected new and mainly used cars.

Should prove interesting for OPCs stocking policy /finance.


s2000db

1,346 posts

175 months

Wednesday 30th October 2024
quotequote all
Just thinking, (for those that purchased outright) it might be worth getting a WBAC valuation now, and one when you get your car back, this could be a 6-9 month wait (according to Porsche HQ) and there’s serious potential loss of value in the meantime.

TDT

6,087 posts

141 months

Wednesday 30th October 2024
quotequote all
https://www.auto-motor-und-sport.de/verkehr/porsch...

Porsche has to recall a total of around 10,600 vehicles with central locking rims worldwide. The manufacturer confirmed this when asked by auto-motor-und-sport.de. In Germany, around 2,150 cars with corresponding wheels have to go to the workshops. Special model versions of the 911 (type 992), 718 (type 982) and (type G3) series are affected. The recalls have not yet been listed in the databases of the Federal Motor Transport Authority (KBA) and the US traffic safety authority NHTSA.

Incorrectly screwing the wheels can lead to damage or even breakage of the central locking nut. As a result, the wheel attachment can come loose, which can lead to loss of the wheel and loss of control of the vehicle. Until the problem is resolved, "the affected vehicles should no longer be driven until the remedial action has been carried out," Porsche wrote in a statement.

According to the car manufacturer, the defect was noticed sporadically during continuous field observation of the affected models. The manufacturer is aware of individual accidents caused by the problem, but no personal injuries occurred.

Specifically, the following model versions are affected by the recall:

Porsche 911/Type 992 (GT3, GT3 RS, Turbo, Turbo S, GTS and Sport Classic), production period September 1, 2023 to October 23, 2024

Porsche 718/Type 982 (GT4 RS and Spyder RS), production period September 1, 2023 to October 23, 2024

Porsche Panamera/Type G3 (Turbo S E-Hybrid, Turbo and GTS), production period September 1, 2023 to October 23, 2024
The central screw connections will be checked in a Porsche center and replaced if necessary. The workshop visit takes about an hour and the action taken is documented in the warranty and maintenance booklet. The owners of affected vehicles have been contacted directly by the Porsche centers since October 25, 2024; they will not incur any costs as a result of the recall. Porsche offers all customers replacement mobility. If necessary, this may also require the rental of rental vehicles, according to the manufacturer.

ChrisW.

8,015 posts

277 months

Wednesday 30th October 2024
quotequote all
So Porsche think that they were still building cars that might have had this faulty centre locking nut as recently as one week ago ?

I'm amazed if there was more than one batch or supplier that they will know which "batch" was fitted to which individual vin numbered car .... what a mess.

P.S. I tried putting two vin numbers from OPC 992 GT3RS cars for sale (and manufactured within this production period) into the vin number checker and neither of them were shown as requiring this recall ... ??

Edited by ChrisW. on Wednesday 30th October 17:21

TDT

6,087 posts

141 months

Wednesday 30th October 2024
quotequote all
ChrisW. said:
So Porsche think that they were still building cars that might have had this faulty centre locking nut as recently as one week ago ?

I'm amazed if there was more than one batch or supplier that they will know which "batch" was fitted to which individual vin numbered car .... what a mess.

P.S. I tried putting two vin numbers from OPC 992 GT3RS cars for sale (and manufactured within this production period) into the vin number checker and neither of them were shown as requiring this recall ... ??

Edited by ChrisW. on Wednesday 30th October 17:21
As mentioned before… the recall website is not updated with the campaign. Notices are coming to current owners via phone call, email, mail or in most cases the Porsche app.

As for the date range… maybe they are doing a fair bit of rump covering…. from the various group I’m in… no-one with a car delivered later than May 2024 has had notice yet.
But this is UK.

Could be that other territories have cases later in the MY.

ChrisW.

8,015 posts

277 months

Wednesday 30th October 2024
quotequote all
Well just looking at the number of OPC Approved GT4RS and Spyder RS that are shown as available to buy, nothing appears to have changed ... yet.

As for the vin number check ... it's a shame that this isn't yet updated because it makes it very difficult for anybody to buy a car with centre locks in the quoted production range.

In short, currently no car in the above category is above question .... and therefore cannot be accurately valued.

RBT0

1,547 posts

141 months

Wednesday 30th October 2024
quotequote all
Wow.

Still not clear whether limited issue or spread to current production.

So confirmed they don’t want customers driving their cars?

Think all the damage when transporting these cars, all door sills scuffed as they’re cheap plastic sills prone to scratching.

J_Dreamer

24 posts

64 months

Thursday 31st October 2024
quotequote all
I got a call from Porsche yesterday about my C4 GTS MY24 and was told not to drive it (even 3 miles home from work) and they would send a transporter to pick it up and drop it home! They must be very concerned…
It’s now back home.

Probably like other owners I am extremely disappointed with this situation. I get that it’s not safe to drive and I am grateful to have been told to stop using it before something bad potentially happens but not having a fix until next year is poor. Porsche told me that it won’t be fixed until next year in the call yesterday.

The compensation they are talking about better be substantial.

johnny senna

4,073 posts

294 months

Thursday 31st October 2024
quotequote all
TDT said:
https://www.auto-motor-und-sport.de/verkehr/porsch...

Porsche has to recall a total of around 10,600 vehicles with central locking rims worldwide. The manufacturer confirmed this when asked by auto-motor-und-sport.de. In Germany, around 2,150 cars with corresponding wheels have to go to the workshops. Special model versions of the 911 (type 992), 718 (type 982) and (type G3) series are affected. The recalls have not yet been listed in the databases of the Federal Motor Transport Authority (KBA) and the US traffic safety authority NHTSA.

Incorrectly screwing the wheels can lead to damage or even breakage of the central locking nut. As a result, the wheel attachment can come loose, which can lead to loss of the wheel and loss of control of the vehicle. Until the problem is resolved, "the affected vehicles should no longer be driven until the remedial action has been carried out," Porsche wrote in a statement.

According to the car manufacturer, the defect was noticed sporadically during continuous field observation of the affected models. The manufacturer is aware of individual accidents caused by the problem, but no personal injuries occurred.

Specifically, the following model versions are affected by the recall:

Porsche 911/Type 992 (GT3, GT3 RS, Turbo, Turbo S, GTS and Sport Classic), production period September 1, 2023 to October 23, 2024

Porsche 718/Type 982 (GT4 RS and Spyder RS), production period September 1, 2023 to October 23, 2024

Porsche Panamera/Type G3 (Turbo S E-Hybrid, Turbo and GTS), production period September 1, 2023 to October 23, 2024
The central screw connections will be checked in a Porsche center and replaced if necessary. The workshop visit takes about an hour and the action taken is documented in the warranty and maintenance booklet. The owners of affected vehicles have been contacted directly by the Porsche centers since October 25, 2024; they will not incur any costs as a result of the recall. Porsche offers all customers replacement mobility. If necessary, this may also require the rental of rental vehicles, according to the manufacturer.
So it could be that the majority of cars are inspected and found to be ok? And the car is quickly back on the road?

honda_exige

7,833 posts

228 months

Thursday 31st October 2024
quotequote all
In today's climate where these cars are depreciating and sometimes heavily - especially over the winter months - I think Porsche might have a big headache on their hands with people requesting refunds or replacements via consumer regs on cars they've sold both new and used in the previous 6 months.

By definition the fault was present at the time of purchase and Porsche are presently unable to fix it.


TDT

6,087 posts

141 months

Thursday 31st October 2024
quotequote all
Well people will probably lose out, as full refunds are not guaranteed.
They might just about get a trade in offer… which will be on the floor.

Most people will just want a car that works, and wont fail, and some goodwill compensation because of the inconvenience.

av185

20,464 posts

149 months

Thursday 31st October 2024
quotequote all
Good luck trying to reject a car on this current issue there are no guarantees whatsoever it is potentially a very costly process and Porsche won't accept rejection easily even if you have a finance partner on board should the car be say pcp'd.

Likely Porsche will at worst try and get away with just Enterprise loaners and at best loaners and monthly compensation reflecting loss of use potential depreciation and or finance payments.

Alternative strategy is a class action brought against Porsche similar to the 991.1 GT3 engine situation but somehow can't see that happening for this current issue.

ChrisW.

8,015 posts

277 months

Thursday 31st October 2024
quotequote all
There was a time when the perception was that Toyota were suffering more recalls than any other manufacturer.

Over time it has become clear that they just cared more for their customers than any other company ... look at their 10 year 100000 mile warranty now. All you have to do in exchange for this extended warranty is have your car serviced to schedule by a Toyota approved service agent.

Of course fair use and the question of consumables will always arise ... but maybe an extended warranty would be a good and hopefully inexpensive way for Porsche to compensate ??

As Porsche owners we do all need Porsche to survive, but we do also need them to consider their customers needs as well.

PRO5T

6,823 posts

47 months

Thursday 31st October 2024
quotequote all
What did Porsche offer in way of compensation during the 991 engine debacle other than an extended warranty?

av185

20,464 posts

149 months

Thursday 31st October 2024
quotequote all
ChrisW. said:
. but maybe an extended warranty would be a good and hopefully inexpensive way for Porsche to compensate ??
By coincidence as part of the overall compensation package in 2014 for the relacement engine issues all affected new 991.1 GT3 owners also received an additional 12 months warranty on their cars thrown in.

av185

20,464 posts

149 months

Thursday 31st October 2024
quotequote all
PRO5T said:
What did Porsche offer in way of compensation during the 991 engine debacle other than an extended warranty?
For those with delivered cars OPC engine swap monthly compensation and free unlimited mileage decent brand new loaner I got a new Cayman GTS PDK.

ContactName

377 posts

16 months

Thursday 31st October 2024
quotequote all
What will happen to dealer stocks of these cars. Will they have to stop selling them until they're been checked and/ or rectified or will they be allowed to sell them with the 'no drive' instruction in place provided buyers are happy with that?