Kia EV6, Ioniq 5, Ford Mustang Mach-E, or Tesla Model Y?

Kia EV6, Ioniq 5, Ford Mustang Mach-E, or Tesla Model Y?

Author
Discussion

jamesbilluk

4,065 posts

194 months

Friday 21st February
quotequote all
JD said:
Also making this exact decision at the moment, and leaning towards the Ioniq5 due to affordability, and possibly a 58kWh version to get a newer model.

Does anyone know how the trim levels worked for a 2022 or 2023 car?

The current car seems to have changed the names, and I am struggling to find out for the older ones what is what. I see SE, Premium and Ultimate which I assume is lowest to highest trim? also Namsan?

Do they all have heat pumps?
I think on the early ones, the heat pump was an option, I have a 2021 Project 45, this was the launch edition, that came with all the options as standard, but 2023 have the heat pumps and battery pre conditioning as standard.

The ultimate came with the leather seats and HUD, which is fantastic, also the seats seem great quality.

The Namsan had all the options, and also a full length panoramic roof I believe.

drgoatboy

1,803 posts

218 months

Saturday 22nd February
quotequote all
JD said:
Also making this exact decision at the moment, and leaning towards the Ioniq5 due to affordability, and possibly a 58kWh version to get a newer model.

Does anyone know how the trim levels worked for a 2022 or 2023 car?

The current car seems to have changed the names, and I am struggling to find out for the older ones what is what. I see SE, Premium and Ultimate which I assume is lowest to highest trim? also Namsan?

Do they all have heat pumps?
Premium is the base car.
Ultimate next and actually has most everything you will need.
Namsan is the top spec but I think the main add is the digital wing mirrors. It's a pretty rare spec to be honest.

Zcd1

540 posts

66 months

Saturday 22nd February
quotequote all
JonnyVTEC said:
Of that lot… easy. An IPACE
You’re trolling, right?

‘Cause you can’t be serious…

Big Nanas

2,197 posts

95 months

Saturday 22nd February
quotequote all
drgoatboy said:
JD said:
Also making this exact decision at the moment, and leaning towards the Ioniq5 due to affordability, and possibly a 58kWh version to get a newer model.

Does anyone know how the trim levels worked for a 2022 or 2023 car?

The current car seems to have changed the names, and I am struggling to find out for the older ones what is what. I see SE, Premium and Ultimate which I assume is lowest to highest trim? also Namsan?

Do they all have heat pumps?
Premium is the base car.
Ultimate next and actually has most everything you will need.
Namsan is the top spec but I think the main add is the digital wing mirrors. It's a pretty rare spec to be honest.
And it's only the MY25 cars that have the heat pump as standard, prior to that it was a £1000 add-on. (I know that as when I ordered my Ultimate late last year, the heatpump was definitely an option. And as there was a changeover to MY25, I'm getting the updated version which has the heastpump! Lucky me).


Edited by Big Nanas on Saturday 22 February 16:29

TheDeuce

26,813 posts

77 months

Saturday 22nd February
quotequote all
Zcd1 said:
JonnyVTEC said:
Of that lot… easy. An IPACE
You’re trolling, right?

‘Cause you can’t be serious…
If you have big enough balls to not worry about the iPace being reliable... It's certainly a more lovely car to be in and drive than the other options. Charge rates and range are sub-par, but for most motorists that can home charge, both are still more than good enough.

I do think there's a temptation when buying an EV to sacrifice everything else about the car for the sake of getting the best range etc, but that's bit of fools game because I would argue it's better to have to make an additional charge stop, or charge for a few more minutes once in a blue moon than have a car that you don't actually like as much every other day of the year.

ShortBeardy

195 posts

155 months

Sunday 23rd February
quotequote all
We have a 2024 Model Y and are happy it and with the charging infrastructure here in the US but the association to Musk is unfortunate. It rides a lot better on 18s with taller sidewalls. So much so that I may get another set of wheels when it comes to put snow tires in the garage.

Where is the best resource for learning about charging infrastructure for EV6 and Ioniq 5?

JonnyVTEC

3,136 posts

186 months

Monday 24th February
quotequote all
Zcd1 said:
You’re trolling, right?

‘Cause you can’t be serious…
I was actually, much better car than all.

Byker28i

70,712 posts

228 months

Monday 24th February
quotequote all
A friend has the Extended range Mach-E, you can but low mileage ones for £20-25k, which is where he is after 3 years lease, £25k to pay off to keep it.

It's a good spec car, OK boot size, not huge but the ride is harsh. He's not had any issues with it, dealer support has been good for his few interactions

page3

5,065 posts

262 months

Monday 24th February
quotequote all
Something that has made a huge difference for me and I think doesn't get enough attention is the continual software updates Tesla do, giving new and improved features. With other manufacturers I've always pretty much felt abandoned post sale.

Evanivitch

23,194 posts

133 months

Monday 24th February
quotequote all
page3 said:
Something that has made a huge difference for me and I think doesn't get enough attention is the continual software updates Tesla do, giving new and improved features. With other manufacturers I've always pretty much felt abandoned post sale.
Nothing beats consumer Beta testing laugh


Not really a dig at Tesla, their bugs are pretty minimal. And VAG are definitely more guilty of it.

page3

5,065 posts

262 months

Monday 24th February
quotequote all
Evanivitch said:
page3 said:
Something that has made a huge difference for me and I think doesn't get enough attention is the continual software updates Tesla do, giving new and improved features. With other manufacturers I've always pretty much felt abandoned post sale.
Nothing beats consumer Beta testing laugh
Not altogether untrue laugh

Addition of things such as new UI, new services, adaptive LED matrix lights, heated steering wheel, sentry mode, remote dashcam viewing etc etc have been pretty great.

Evanivitch

23,194 posts

133 months

Monday 24th February
quotequote all
page3 said:
Evanivitch said:
page3 said:
Something that has made a huge difference for me and I think doesn't get enough attention is the continual software updates Tesla do, giving new and improved features. With other manufacturers I've always pretty much felt abandoned post sale.
Nothing beats consumer Beta testing laugh
Not altogether untrue laugh

Addition of things such as new UI, new services, adaptive LED matrix lights, heated steering wheel, sentry mode, remote dashcam viewing etc etc have been pretty great.
Feel like things that already had hardware...

ZesPak

25,204 posts

207 months

Monday 24th February
quotequote all
Evanivitch said:
Feel like things that already had hardware...
Another example I posted in another thread.

Because of her company charging card, my sister runs a Model 3 without superchargers. The Tesla was initially set up to do pre-conditioning of the battery when you arrive at superchargers. It's all very simple and no interaction needed, you set your gps to your destination and if there's any superchargers it routes you to, the battery will be preconditioned.

However, there was no way to do this for non-Tesla superchargers. Since Tesla owners have pretty cheap supercharging and the SC network has been really good compared to the competition, this was probably mostly a non issue initially.

Now they've added that functionality. Seems like a small thing but for someone like my sister, it makes a difference when traveling across the continent.

There's so much that these cars do with the infotainment, not to mention driving aids, the updates are very welcome, and in many way my car has had a lot of "upgrades" since the 5 years I've owned it.

page3

5,065 posts

262 months

Monday 24th February
quotequote all
Evanivitch said:
Feel like things that already had hardware...
Some are, some aren't. Having adaptive LED matrix lights enabled without cost or them having been an advertised feature was pretty great though.

JD

2,976 posts

239 months

Tuesday 25th February
quotequote all
Anyone posting on this thread got the small battery (58kWh) Ioniq 5 without a heat pump?

Tempted by a much newer 58kWh rather than older 73kWh, so just trying to work out how the range/efficiency is.

All I can find online seem to be range tests of dual motor versions with the larger battery (and often optioned with the heat pump of course!)

Edited by JD on Tuesday 25th February 09:43

Alickadoo

2,667 posts

34 months

Tuesday 25th February
quotequote all
JonnyVTEC said:
Of that lot… easy. An IPACE
What a good idea (irony).

The most reliable car on the planet (sarcasm).

The Kia or the Ioniq.

JonnyVTEC

3,136 posts

186 months

Tuesday 25th February
quotequote all
The Kia with the 12V battery issues or the same Webasto heater thats playing Jag an dProsche and also have the E-GMP ICCU failure thats on the Ioniq 5 and EV6?

Dont let reputation get in the way of a good story (or indeed good car).

Poor value add. Which one of these have you driven?

jamesbilluk

4,065 posts

194 months

Tuesday 25th February
quotequote all
I had a 2018 iPace, I've just ended the PCP early and it's gone to BCA sadly. An I going issue with the traction battery, and 7 modules replaced, I didn't trust it, or the dealership anymore (also my warranty had run out) and the insurance had gone way up, also as the modules could keep failing, and JLR made it clear they wouldn't be replacing the main traction battery. The battery saga contained for months, where it was limited to 72 percent which made it hopeless for longer trips.

I loved the handling, I was very tempted by an HSE to see if I had more luck reliability wise, as after sales was still less than ideal!! but I've now gone with an Ioniq 5 Project 45, not as fast, but nearly there, handling isn't bad at all, but again, not
as good as the iPace. The faster charging will come in handy though, on a longer trip.

Build quality wisez I would say they're the same, both very solid, the Ioniq has no rattles at all, and rides much better than the iPace I had (which had air suspension)

Edited by jamesbilluk on Tuesday 25th February 21:22

Zcd1

540 posts

66 months

Tuesday 25th February
quotequote all
JonnyVTEC said:
I was actually, much better car than all.
All evidence to the contrary...

https://www.roadandtrack.com/news/a63021359/jaguar...

TheDeuce

26,813 posts

77 months

Tuesday 25th February
quotequote all
Zcd1 said:
JonnyVTEC said:
I was actually, much better car than all.
All evidence to the contrary...

https://www.roadandtrack.com/news/a63021359/jaguar...
What's that got to do with anything? You can't buy the one's they bought back... The ones you can actually buy are not affected.