EV car when no option to charge at home
Discussion
PetrolHeadInRecovery said:
After four years with an EV & no home charging:
As long as you can charge during one of your routine stops (shopping, gym, movies,...), the local driving is not really a problem. Barring extreme weather (or orchid-like constitution that has zero-tolerance for temperature variations), your city-driving range is about 180% of WLTP. So you can typically drive 15-20 hours in the city and still have enough charge to reach the next fast charger on longer trips - and from then on the long-distance travel is easy (at least on the Continent).
There's also much less wear and tear caused by actually using the "similar power":
Actually accelerating a 5-second ICE car from rest to 60 in under 6 seconds seems to mean faffing around the menus, stomping the accelerator to the floor, and waiting for the revs to rise before releasing the brake (or, in the old days, releasing the clutch and quick prayer for the health of the friction surfaces). A 5-second EV will be at 60 in under 6 seconds from the moment the safe opportunity and immaturity collide, and does it discreetly.
What price are you charging at?As long as you can charge during one of your routine stops (shopping, gym, movies,...), the local driving is not really a problem. Barring extreme weather (or orchid-like constitution that has zero-tolerance for temperature variations), your city-driving range is about 180% of WLTP. So you can typically drive 15-20 hours in the city and still have enough charge to reach the next fast charger on longer trips - and from then on the long-distance travel is easy (at least on the Continent).
There's also much less wear and tear caused by actually using the "similar power":
Actually accelerating a 5-second ICE car from rest to 60 in under 6 seconds seems to mean faffing around the menus, stomping the accelerator to the floor, and waiting for the revs to rise before releasing the brake (or, in the old days, releasing the clutch and quick prayer for the health of the friction surfaces). A 5-second EV will be at 60 in under 6 seconds from the moment the safe opportunity and immaturity collide, and does it discreetly.
Most public charging is pretty much equivalent to running an ICE car
Panamax said:
Surely this is precisely what plug-in hybrids are for. Reasonable electric range and never any fear of going flat.
I had a hybrid 11 years ago, Outlander, second worst car I’ve driven and the worst I’ve owned. The power delivery change from battery to ICE was about a second which made overtaking a pain. There were less chargers then, but a free charger at the office I worked at so it was effective. My worry would be 1) I’ll never charge it because I’ll have fuel and. 2) the 1.5p VED grab from PHEVs seems really s
t. I’ve driven 2 Volvo PHEV, one in Austria and one in the U.K. they suffered the same problem as the Mitsubishi that if they deal it too cold they start the ICE, even on short commutes. I’m not going down that route again.
The other issue is that my wife really likes Mercs so we have to stay with that brand.
The PHEV Mercedes make all seem to be 2.0 litres engines and they’ll be a bit crap. Even the c63 has a 2 litre engine. No thank.
Suspicious_user said:
The catch is I only have on street parking, I live in a conservation area so can't change the front garden to a drive way (it's also too short)
Charging gully?https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/cross-p...
SP_ said:
What price are you charging at?
Most public charging is pretty much equivalent to running an ICE car
Really depends on the country. Switzerland (where we live) averages maybe 0.45€/kWh, Italy a bit more, Nordics somewhere between 0.25 ans 0.35€. Bosnia is usually free, or the price of an overnight parking in a garage.Most public charging is pretty much equivalent to running an ICE car
Maintenance costs have dropped more dramatically than fuel.
SP_ said:
What price are you charging at?
Most public charging is pretty much equivalent to running an ICE car
I'm not sure where you see that - with Ionity I am seeing 55p kwh which is cheaper than petrol right now (for my 30 mpg car). With MB charge Ionity is 55p kWh, Shell, bp and Arnold Clark are 59p a kWh.Most public charging is pretty much equivalent to running an ICE car
slievenashaska said:
Suspicious_user said:
The catch is I only have on street parking, I live in a conservation area so can't change the front garden to a drive way (it's also too short)
Charging gully?https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/cross-p...
https://aberdeenclimateaction.org/2024/11/21/home-...
There will come a time where people won't want a house in the inner city without charging, but the council want to keep the look of the area.
kambites said:
hidetheelephants said:
The intransigence against gullies in pavements is ridiculous.
If they're serious about the ICE car ban, I think the government is going to have to make it much harder for local planning authorities to block that sort of installation. hidetheelephants said:
Is there no means of running SWA to your garage? Moles can put things in place without digging up tarmac/pavement/etc. The intransigence against gullies in pavements is ridiculous.
Sadly it's a little distance away. There is a power line I can tap in to not very far away, I've asked SSEN for a new quote (I had previously asked about power install in 2016)Martyn76 said:
House a couple of doors down have a Tesla MY but no home charger, I presume they charge at work so depending on your circumstances it is possible.
A relative works for a company which is 'persuading' its staff to have EVs, company cars I guess, including some people who can't seem to charge at home. It's not always about saving 10p a mile, especially when the total cost per mile is a lot more.In the OP's position, I would consider whether the local chargers will be so lightly used in a few years time when more people have EVs?
OutInTheShed said:
Martyn76 said:
House a couple of doors down have a Tesla MY but no home charger, I presume they charge at work so depending on your circumstances it is possible.
A relative works for a company which is 'persuading' its staff to have EVs, company cars I guess, including some people who can't seem to charge at home. It's not always about saving 10p a mile, especially when the total cost per mile is a lot more.In the OP's position, I would consider whether the local chargers will be so lightly used in a few years time when more people have EVs?
Suspicious_user said:
There are many more local chargers and public chargers than there used to be. I've been monitoring them from ABRP and they currently not in high use.
There are over 50 chargers in the relatively small town I live in, ranging from 7kW chargers in all the council car parks and supermarkets, up to 350kW chargers at numerous petrol stations and pubs.It is incredibly rare to see anyone using any of them, slow or fast.
slievenashaska said:
There are over 50 chargers in the relatively small town I live in, ranging from 7kW chargers in all the council car parks and supermarkets, up to 350kW chargers at numerous petrol stations and pubs.
It is incredibly rare to see anyone using any of them, slow or fast.
Apparently in the UK BEV & PHEV make up about 10% of the total car fleet now. Here in NL where they make up about 13%, I have probably 6 or 8 double charger posts within a few minutes walk of my house. I've never had a problem getting on one of them but it's rare to see more than one or two spaces free. So it might not need much of an increase in uptake to make those chargers a lot busier. Mind you my local ones are 41c/kWh (about 31.5 pence) and I believe a lot of UK ones tend to be more expensive.It is incredibly rare to see anyone using any of them, slow or fast.
RizzoTheRat said:
Mind you my local ones are 41c/kWh (about 31.5 pence) and I believe a lot of UK ones tend to be more expensive.
Around 50p/kWh (59c/kWh) for the 7kW chargers and 65p/kWh (76c/kWh) for the 150-350kWh chargers, and much more expensive on motorways. You might find slightly cheaper, particularly off-peak, and there are membership schemes where you can pay to access cheaper rates, but overall it isn't cheap.The low use of commercial chargers in towns is down to an awfully large proportion of those who have EVs, which up to now have been expensive and new, have houses that have drives and where you can charge cheaply (7p/kWh) and conveniently.
The single best part of owning an EV is the convenience of plugging in at night and waking up with your set charge in the morning, if you can park at home. Paying 10x the price to charge eats into so much of what could be a saving. I would never entertain owning one without being able to charge at home. 11.5% of my 9.5k miles since April have been public charged but this is 53% of my total cost of charging and this is at an average of 45p/kW, mainly dragged down with Tesla off peak pricing, although the one I use just increased 10% October 1st. It has cost £263 to do 9.5k miles. Had all my charging been public it would have cost just shy of £1,200, and this is based on 45p a mile. Assuming you are lucky to have plug in kerb side charging nearby these are typically 55-60p where I have visited even for slow 7kW charging which could take it up to £1.6k. Anybody who cannot charge at home is getting shafted and the number one reason I do not think it should be forced on us through legislation at all when it does not work for a large portion of the country, but that is another argument.
The closest public chargers to my house are Lidl and BP and they have had their cables cut off twice this year. The BP one has been down for 8 months now and the Lidl chargers must be coming up to 4. They fixed them and they were cut off and stolen again in a month. If you were local and relied on this it would be infuriating.
My little Renault 5 is taking a beasting this week. 125 miles Monday, 240 yesterday, 125 today, 210 tomorrow and 190 on Friday. This is a much higher than typical week (usually average 500 miles) but on the days when I want to leave at 100% having a home charger is a must. I think if I had a real world 300 mile EV range I would never need to public charge but the lure of the R5 design was too strong and I love it. Even with its lower range it has not been much effort to public charge to be honest. I tend to find slow AC chargers that tend to be cheaper (and better for the battery) in car parks near where I will be working. By the time I am done the car is charged to the set percentage again and I haven't even gone out of my way to public charge or wasted any time.
The closest public chargers to my house are Lidl and BP and they have had their cables cut off twice this year. The BP one has been down for 8 months now and the Lidl chargers must be coming up to 4. They fixed them and they were cut off and stolen again in a month. If you were local and relied on this it would be infuriating.
My little Renault 5 is taking a beasting this week. 125 miles Monday, 240 yesterday, 125 today, 210 tomorrow and 190 on Friday. This is a much higher than typical week (usually average 500 miles) but on the days when I want to leave at 100% having a home charger is a must. I think if I had a real world 300 mile EV range I would never need to public charge but the lure of the R5 design was too strong and I love it. Even with its lower range it has not been much effort to public charge to be honest. I tend to find slow AC chargers that tend to be cheaper (and better for the battery) in car parks near where I will be working. By the time I am done the car is charged to the set percentage again and I haven't even gone out of my way to public charge or wasted any time.
Edited by Goatwidcoat on Wednesday 7th October 17:31
Goatwidcoat said:
The single best part of owning an EV is the convenience of plugging in at night and waking up with your set charge in the morning, if you can park at home. Paying 10x the price to charge eats into so much of what could be a saving. I would never entertain owning one without being able to charge at home. 11.5% of my 9.5k miles since April have been public charged but this is 53% of my total cost of charging and this is at an average of 45p/kW, mainly dragged down with Tesla off peak pricing, although the one I use just increased 10% October 1st. It has cost £263 to do 9.5k miles. Had all my charging been public it would have cost just shy of £1,200, and this is based on 45p a mile. Assuming you are lucky to have plug in kerb side charging nearby these are typically 55-60p where I have visited even for slow 7kW charging which could take it up to £1.6k. Anybody who cannot charge at home is getting shafted and the number one reason I do not think it should be forced on us through legislation at all when it does not work for a large portion of the country, but that is another argument.
The closest public chargers to my house are Lidl and BP and they have had their cables cut off twice this year. The BP one has been down for 8 months now and the Lidl chargers must be coming up to 4. They fixed them and they were cut off and stolen again in a month. If you were local and relied on this it would be infuriating.
My little Renault 5 is taking a beasting this week. 125 miles Monday, 240 yesterday, 125 today, 210 tomorrow and 190 on Friday. This is a much higher than typical week (usually average 500 miles) but on the days when I want to leave at 100% having a home charger is a must. I think if I had a real world 300 mile EV range I would never need to public charge but the lure of the R5 design was too strong and I love it. Even with its lower range it has not been much effort to public charge to be honest. I tend to find slow AC chargers that tend to be cheaper (and better for the battery) in car parks near where I will be working. By the time I am done the car is charged to the set percentage again and I haven't even gone out of my way to public charge or wasted any time.
Wow thanks for sharing. That’s 0.000013% of my life that I never get back. The closest public chargers to my house are Lidl and BP and they have had their cables cut off twice this year. The BP one has been down for 8 months now and the Lidl chargers must be coming up to 4. They fixed them and they were cut off and stolen again in a month. If you were local and relied on this it would be infuriating.
My little Renault 5 is taking a beasting this week. 125 miles Monday, 240 yesterday, 125 today, 210 tomorrow and 190 on Friday. This is a much higher than typical week (usually average 500 miles) but on the days when I want to leave at 100% having a home charger is a must. I think if I had a real world 300 mile EV range I would never need to public charge but the lure of the R5 design was too strong and I love it. Even with its lower range it has not been much effort to public charge to be honest. I tend to find slow AC chargers that tend to be cheaper (and better for the battery) in car parks near where I will be working. By the time I am done the car is charged to the set percentage again and I haven't even gone out of my way to public charge or wasted any time.
Edited by Goatwidcoat on Wednesday 7th October 17:31
Goatwidcoat said:
I think if I had a real world 300 mile EV range I would never need to public charge
I do yearly round trips to Europe, 2500 miles isn't unheard of. E43 got 25mpg on that one, when I did it in a Diesel GLE I managed 35mpg. An EV will be cheaper given the prices to charge in Germany and Austria compared to petrol. I do like to press on through Germany. Gassing Station | EV and Alternative Fuels | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


