EVs... no one wants them! (Vol. 2)
EVs... no one wants them! (Vol. 2)
Author
Discussion

cerb4.5lee

39,956 posts

200 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
JQ said:
cerb4.5lee said:
eldar said:
cerb4.5lee said:
Apparently BMW are loaning me an iX1 on Monday when the M4 goes in for it's service. So I'll let you know how I get on with it. biggrin

I'd personally like the quicker 30 model, but I'm presuming it will be the 20 model though.
You'll hate it.
Even if I don't...I'll still find a way of hating it as you know! hehe
When you collect it, ask them to disable all the speed bings and bongs and the driver assistance aids - if left on the car will brake for corners and traffic, and sound alarms when over the speed limit, which I found very irritating. Once disabled they stay off. The only thing you can't permanently disable is the lane departure warning, you either have to turn it off for every journey or just use your indicators irrespective of whether or not they're needed.
Thanks for that. thumbup

cerb4.5lee

39,956 posts

200 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
Pandox2096 said:
otolith said:
JQ said:
When you collect it, ask them to disable all the speed bings and bongs and the driver assistance aids - if left on the car will brake for corners and traffic, and sound alarms when over the speed limit, which I found very irritating. Once disabled they stay off. The only thing you can't permanently disable is the lane departure warning, you either have to turn it off for every journey or just use your indicators irrespective of whether or not they're needed.
They're going to hand it over with no charge in the battery and set in eco-driving mode hehe
Please let this be true! hehe
I've already got a touch of anxiety about that to be honest! hehe

ACCYSTAN

1,233 posts

141 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
I regret buying an EV

Purchased a pre reg Vauxhall combo Life MPV earlier this year and my main 2 issues are as follows -

  • The range is pathetic. Peak summer I could get 180 miles out of it in mixed driving, against a claimed figure of 208
In the recent cold snap that went down to 155 miles; I dread what it will be when it gets to 0 or below.

The car itself is great, it s exactly what I want in terms of space and practicality. Just the EV is frustrating to use as compared to the diesel and petrol version both of which I have owned, I am having to fill it up 3 X more often.

It s also a headache to live with, I would never think twice in my previous petrol or diesel version putting on the heater or using the air con but now I check if I have enough range and have a few times be unable to use functions such as air con or the heater as I know it drains the range.
Its meant to be 2025 and I can t help think these crappy range on Stellantis EVs is sending us backwards, that is how I feel


  • public charging is problematic, especially away from main motorway networks. Recently had a business trip to Aberystwyth; very little charging infrastructure and the prices were insane, one charger was £1.05 a KW.
Stellantis have no skin in the game when it comes to the charger network like Tesla; you would think a large European manufacturer may consider building its own network or partnering with a current network.

  • on a plus point, the EV drives far nicer than the diesel or petrol versions; it s not even close. The weight of the batteries keep it glued to the road and it s seems to suit the chassis, work colleagues who drive the diesel van version have tried it and said the same the EV version drives far nicer.
My summary after 6 month of ownership is I should have paid extra and got the petrol or diesel version.
Right car, wrong fuel choice.

For those who haven t done their research and asking would the Peugeot/Citroen/Toyota version of this vehicle be any better, the answer is no they all use the same battery tech, the same as the ICE versions they are 99% identical Stellantis products.



Edited by ACCYSTAN on Thursday 6th November 13:36


Edited by ACCYSTAN on Thursday 6th November 13:37

Ankh87

1,073 posts

122 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
ACCYSTAN said:
I regret buying an EV

Purchased a pre reg Vauxhall combo Life MPV earlier this year and my main 2 issues are as follows -

  • the range is pathetic. Peak summer I could get 180 miles out of it in mixed driving, against a claimed figure of 208
In the recent cold snap that went down to 155 miles; I dread what it will be when it gets to 0 or below.

The car itself is great, it s exactly what I want in terms of space and practicality. Just the EV is frustrating to use as compared to the diesel and petrol version both of which I have owned, I am having to fill it up at 3 times more often.

It s also a headache to live with, I would never think twice in my previous petrol or diesel version putting on the heater or using the air con but now I check if I have enough range and have a few times be unable to use functions such as air con or the heater as I know it drains the range.
It s meant to be 2025 and o can t help think these crappy range on Stellantis EVs is sending us backwards, that s how it feels


  • public charging is problematic, especially away from main motorway networks. Recently had a business trip to Aberystwyth; very little charging infrastructure and the prices were insane, one charger was £1.05 a KW.
Stellantis have no skin in the game when it comes to the charger network like Tesla; you would think a large European manufacturer may consider building its own network or patterning with a current network.

  • on a plus point, the EV drives far nicer than the diesel or petrol versions; it s not even close. The weight of the batteries keep it glued to the road and it s seems to suit the chassis, work colleagues who drive the diesel van version have tried it and said the same the EV version drives far nicer.
My summary after 6 month of ownership is I should have paid extra and got the petrol or diesel version.
Right car, wrong fuel choice.

For those who haven t done their research and asking would the Peugeot/Citroen/Toyota version of this vehicle be any better, the answer is no they all use the same battery tech, the same as the ICE versions they are 99% identical Stellantis products.
How many miles do you do a week?

I do a lot of miles and I'm not bothered by the range I get in my M3LR at all. I just put it on charge on an evening, sometimes don't even do that if I know I'm not off on a long drive the next day.

mobile chicane22

383 posts

208 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
Ankh87 said:
Again they can't do this until the cars have an MOT so for the first 3 years you could just lie. Then when you return the car if lease or on PCP etc, the Government will not know.

It is a stupid idea and if this is to make up money that they need. Maybe they should look at themselves. Many of them have multiple homes, pay naff all tax, allow certain companies to pay hardly any tax etc. That's just a few examples.
Careful the thought police will be on you for accusing our illustrious leaders of being anything less than perfect……

Oh wait they are absolutely incompetent and just in it for themselves cheating and stealing all the way, carry on

ACCYSTAN

1,233 posts

141 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
My driving varies, some days around 450 miles.

I wish there was a way to pay for a battery upgrade or a battery software upgrade to improve the range output.

Or for there to be a shed load more Tesla superchargers around the UK

loudlashadjuster

5,928 posts

204 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
ACCYSTAN said:
I regret buying an EV

Purchased a pre reg Vauxhall combo Life MPV earlier this year and my main 2 issues are as follows -

  • The range is pathetic. Peak summer I could get 180 miles out of it in mixed driving, against a claimed figure of 208
In the recent cold snap that went down to 155 miles; I dread what it will be when it gets to 0 or below.

The car itself is great, it s exactly what I want in terms of space and practicality. Just the EV is frustrating to use as compared to the diesel and petrol version both of which I have owned, I am having to fill it up 3 X more often.

It s also a headache to live with, I would never think twice in my previous petrol or diesel version putting on the heater or using the air con but now I check if I have enough range and have a few times be unable to use functions such as air con or the heater as I know it drains the range.
Its meant to be 2025 and I can t help think these crappy range on Stellantis EVs is sending us backwards, that is how I feel


  • public charging is problematic, especially away from main motorway networks. Recently had a business trip to Aberystwyth; very little charging infrastructure and the prices were insane, one charger was £1.05 a KW.
Stellantis have no skin in the game when it comes to the charger network like Tesla; you would think a large European manufacturer may consider building its own network or partnering with a current network.

  • on a plus point, the EV drives far nicer than the diesel or petrol versions; it s not even close. The weight of the batteries keep it glued to the road and it s seems to suit the chassis, work colleagues who drive the diesel van version have tried it and said the same the EV version drives far nicer.
My summary after 6 month of ownership is I should have paid extra and got the petrol or diesel version.
Right car, wrong fuel choice.

For those who haven t done their research and asking would the Peugeot/Citroen/Toyota version of this vehicle be any better, the answer is no they all use the same battery tech, the same as the ICE versions they are 99% identical Stellantis products.
I would posit that a Vauxhall Combo Life MPV is never the right choice...

SpeckledJim

31,931 posts

273 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
ACCYSTAN said:
My driving varies, some days around 450 miles.

I wish there was a way to pay for a battery upgrade or a battery software upgrade to improve the range output.

Or for there to be a shed load more Tesla superchargers around the UK
That thing you did: it was a bonkers thing.

Sell the car and get one that suits the job you need it to do.

SDK

2,323 posts

273 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
ACCYSTAN said:
My driving varies, some days around 450 miles.

I wish there was a way to pay for a battery upgrade or a battery software upgrade to improve the range output.

Or for there to be a shed load more Tesla superchargers around the UK
That daily mileage is currently outside of recommended EV use!

CMTMB

264 posts

15 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
ACCYSTAN said:
My driving varies, some days around 450 miles.
I don't think you can place too much blame on the car.






JQ

6,504 posts

199 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
ACCYSTAN said:
I regret buying an EV

Purchased a pre reg Vauxhall combo Life MPV earlier this year and my main 2 issues are as follows -

  • The range is pathetic. Peak summer I could get 180 miles out of it in mixed driving, against a claimed figure of 208
In the recent cold snap that went down to 155 miles; I dread what it will be when it gets to 0 or below.

The car itself is great, it s exactly what I want in terms of space and practicality. Just the EV is frustrating to use as compared to the diesel and petrol version both of which I have owned, I am having to fill it up 3 X more often.

It s also a headache to live with, I would never think twice in my previous petrol or diesel version putting on the heater or using the air con but now I check if I have enough range and have a few times be unable to use functions such as air con or the heater as I know it drains the range.
Its meant to be 2025 and I can t help think these crappy range on Stellantis EVs is sending us backwards, that is how I feel


  • public charging is problematic, especially away from main motorway networks. Recently had a business trip to Aberystwyth; very little charging infrastructure and the prices were insane, one charger was £1.05 a KW.
Stellantis have no skin in the game when it comes to the charger network like Tesla; you would think a large European manufacturer may consider building its own network or partnering with a current network.

  • on a plus point, the EV drives far nicer than the diesel or petrol versions; it s not even close. The weight of the batteries keep it glued to the road and it s seems to suit the chassis, work colleagues who drive the diesel van version have tried it and said the same the EV version drives far nicer.
My summary after 6 month of ownership is I should have paid extra and got the petrol or diesel version.
Right car, wrong fuel choice.

For those who haven t done their research and asking would the Peugeot/Citroen/Toyota version of this vehicle be any better, the answer is no they all use the same battery tech, the same as the ICE versions they are 99% identical Stellantis products.



Edited by ACCYSTAN on Thursday 6th November 13:36


Edited by ACCYSTAN on Thursday 6th November 13:37
Is the range issue not a lack of research, you've bought a van without the range you needed. Although you do seem to be doing rather well against the actual range figures :



My wife got an EV with crap range, but we knew that before we got it, so it wasn't an issue as it was only used for local journeys.

Aberystwyth has a Tesla Supercharger site that you could have used for £0.55.

ACCYSTAN

1,233 posts

141 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
I probably will sell it at Christmas when I have 2 weeks off and get a petrol or diesel version.

EVs are frustrating to live with

Mi would have another EV but with 2 stipulations

1. Minimum claimed range of 400 miles
2. Not a Stellantis product

There are very few 400 mile EVs on the market, none of which are big enough like a van MPV for my needs.
Infact none of the van MPVs do much more than 200 miles, some of the Fords such as the Tourneo Courier EV are worse than the Stellantis models with only 177 max claimed range.
Even the new Kia PV5 passenger in long range is only claiming 253 miles.
Aerodynamics of a brick are great for practicality, terrible for EV range.



nickfrog

23,676 posts

237 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
^ I think they're only frustrating to live with because your needs can be matched by the product you chose.

Pandox2096

179 posts

2 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
No one is seriously suggesting that for someone who needs a van with. 450 mile range EVs are the best choice (yet)

Did your research before buying it not tell you that?

ACCYSTAN

1,233 posts

141 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
Well it’s based on Van but it’s the passenger version

But I take your point, they are van MPVs aka vans with extra windows and seats

I must admit, I did not look up the highway range only the headline range of 213 miles.

Some days I only do 20-30 miles so it’s no issue, but I do see people in rural areas which can be a long drive and well as it’s been established, EVs and long range is not there yet.

I’m not anti EV; I just wish they were better.

Ankh87

1,073 posts

122 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
If you are doing over 250 miles a day then an EV isn't the right choice if you can't charge up at location or stop to charge up. It would be like buying any car such as a WRX STI and saying it can't do 400 miles on a tank of petrol. If you can stop to put fuel in, you can stop to charge up. Most EVs will charge up to 70% in like 10 minutes from a fast charger. You just need the right EV.

In your case though 450 miles a day is huge. That's around 6.5 hours driving a day. Do you actually work or just drive around all day?

nickfrog

23,676 posts

237 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
ACCYSTAN said:
I m not anti EV; I just wish they were better.
I sympathise but I think what you're saying is that you wish they met your needs which is somewhat different.

JQ

6,504 posts

199 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
ACCYSTAN said:
Well it s based on Van but it s the passenger version

But I take your point, they are van MPVs aka vans with extra windows and seats

I must admit, I did not look up the highway range only the headline range of 213 miles.

Some days I only do 20-30 miles so it s no issue, but I do see people in rural areas which can be a long drive and well as it s been established, EVs and long range is not there yet.

I m not anti EV; I just wish they were better.
This site is great for checking real world range : https://ev-database.org/uk

Could you get away with a car? One of my mates is a handyman - boarding lofts, fitting bathrooms and basic building work. He uses a Tesla Model 3 and absolutely loves it. Makes me cry every time I see the inside of his car as the car now looks like the inside of a builders van, but he's happy.

RizzoTheRat

27,469 posts

212 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
JQ said:
When you collect it, ask them to disable all the speed bings and bongs and the driver assistance aids - if left on the car will brake for corners and traffic, and sound alarms when over the speed limit, which I found very irritating. Once disabled they stay off. The only thing you can't permanently disable is the lane departure warning, you either have to turn it off for every journey or just use your indicators irrespective of whether or not they're needed.
Depends on the age of the car, since last summer it's mandatory to have the bongs if you go over the limit, and you can only turn them off temporarily, the next time you start the car they'll be on again. And of course this is for all cars not just EVs

limpsfield

6,447 posts

273 months

Thursday 6th November
quotequote all
uktrailmonster said:
loudlashadjuster said:
Roll up! Roll up! Takes your seats! Eyes down!

Brilliant! laugh
clap