Sold a used car. Buyer not happy
Discussion
maz8062 said:
It s not. To replace a head gasket costs more that £1500, so a car with a broken one, or one not properly tested is worth scrap money. This is the issue as the buyer probably relied on the head gasket replacement when making the decision.
The other question is who signed the bill of sale/receipt? The op or his son? I m guessing the op, so ultimately they are responsible.
It is true that they can stone wall or ignore the buyer and hope it goes away, which it might, but if it starts to get dirty or threats of legal action, the op will need to back up his claims with evidence because sold as seen is not a defence.
He sold a knacker to a self confessed trader, who is trying to increase his margin.The other question is who signed the bill of sale/receipt? The op or his son? I m guessing the op, so ultimately they are responsible.
It is true that they can stone wall or ignore the buyer and hope it goes away, which it might, but if it starts to get dirty or threats of legal action, the op will need to back up his claims with evidence because sold as seen is not a defence.
All this wibble about mot, insurance, who signed, checking repairs and fantasy invented scenarios is entertaining comedy but pointless.
maz8062 said:
It s not. To replace a head gasket costs more that £1500, so a car with a broken one, or one not properly tested is worth scrap money. This is the issue as the buyer probably relied on the head gasket replacement when making the decision.
The other question is who signed the bill of sale/receipt? The op or his son? I m guessing the op, so ultimately they are responsible.
It is true that they can stone wall or ignore the buyer and hope it goes away, which it might, but if it starts to get dirty or threats of legal action, the op will need to back up his claims with evidence because sold as seen is not a defence.
As I said up-thread, the OP should make careful notes of exactly what was said by all parties.The other question is who signed the bill of sale/receipt? The op or his son? I m guessing the op, so ultimately they are responsible.
It is true that they can stone wall or ignore the buyer and hope it goes away, which it might, but if it starts to get dirty or threats of legal action, the op will need to back up his claims with evidence because sold as seen is not a defence.
Because this could come to legal proceedings in several months' time.
The other side has a witness.
'Sold as seen' may carry some weight, but it doesn't cover the seller for anything misleading in the advertising or conversations with the buyers.
If the buyer can credibly suggest anything the seller said assured them that the car was OK, the seller has a problem.
Telling someone the head gasket was fixed months ago has connotations different from 'it has only been driven a handful of miles since the gasket was changed'.
Someone who had no confidence that the repairs were a proper fix would be quite likely to flog it or trade it in without driving it much.
This thread would be a classic if written from the buyer's side.
Driveway trader sold me a car, claimed it was his son's, it blew up 50 miles later.
IMHO the legal process in this country can be a bit random at times.
Maybe it would be reasonable to verify the facts. Ask the buyers for photos. Test whether they are scammers or whether the car has actually failed.
That will be harder to test as time goes on. We were not there, the OP has met the people and will have more than the bald facts to go on. That will influence his way forwards.
People who don't have much money are very often better off with a new car on the never-never than gambling on sheds.
HTP99 said:
Don't know why the OP is getting so much stick for this, his son too.
People spend money on fixing cars and then putting it to the sidelines all the time, work and life takes over, more important things happen.
Car is then stuck on the drive or in the garage, MOT lapses, they just want rid of the thing, advertised with no MOT, someone takes a punt and either they are lying about the problem to appeal to the sellers better nature, with a sob story thrown in, or there is an actual problem with the car, with a sob story thrown in. Tough, buy an older car with no MOT, privately at a significant reduction over a similar car with an MOT, you take your chances.
If could have had a fresh MOT, the head gasket still would've gone, if it actually has failed! I sold a car to a trader many years ago, a Fiat 500 Twin Air, the head gasket went 2 weeks later, it happens.
Regardless I can't see anything the OP or his son has done wrong.
I don t think spending £2k fixing your car, driving it home, ditching it on the drive and never driving it again happens all the time . People spend money on fixing cars and then putting it to the sidelines all the time, work and life takes over, more important things happen.
Car is then stuck on the drive or in the garage, MOT lapses, they just want rid of the thing, advertised with no MOT, someone takes a punt and either they are lying about the problem to appeal to the sellers better nature, with a sob story thrown in, or there is an actual problem with the car, with a sob story thrown in. Tough, buy an older car with no MOT, privately at a significant reduction over a similar car with an MOT, you take your chances.
If could have had a fresh MOT, the head gasket still would've gone, if it actually has failed! I sold a car to a trader many years ago, a Fiat 500 Twin Air, the head gasket went 2 weeks later, it happens.
Regardless I can't see anything the OP or his son has done wrong.
And if you d already bought another car anyway, why bother spending nearly as much as it s worth and go to the hassle of fixing the broken one?
Agree that it s not the seller s problem though. Private sale, it s tough.
I once bought a Mondeo ST 220, had a drive and it seemed fine. Sold as seen. The day after, I drove it at motorway speeds and the whining was horrendous. Turned out someone had tried to bodge the driveshaft oil seals with silicone sealer, all the oil had fallen out and the gearbox was knackered. Drove it like that for a while then scrapped it.
Chucky-egg said:
HTP99 said:
Don't know why the OP is getting so much stick for this, his son too.
People spend money on fixing cars and then putting it to the sidelines all the time, work and life takes over, more important things happen.
Car is then stuck on the drive or in the garage, MOT lapses, they just want rid of the thing, advertised with no MOT, someone takes a punt and either they are lying about the problem to appeal to the sellers better nature, with a sob story thrown in, or there is an actual problem with the car, with a sob story thrown in. Tough, buy an older car with no MOT, privately at a significant reduction over a similar car with an MOT, you take your chances.
If could have had a fresh MOT, the head gasket still would've gone, if it actually has failed! I sold a car to a trader many years ago, a Fiat 500 Twin Air, the head gasket went 2 weeks later, it happens.
Regardless I can't see anything the OP or his son has done wrong.
I don t think spending £2k fixing your car, driving it home, ditching it on the drive and never driving it again happens all the time . People spend money on fixing cars and then putting it to the sidelines all the time, work and life takes over, more important things happen.
Car is then stuck on the drive or in the garage, MOT lapses, they just want rid of the thing, advertised with no MOT, someone takes a punt and either they are lying about the problem to appeal to the sellers better nature, with a sob story thrown in, or there is an actual problem with the car, with a sob story thrown in. Tough, buy an older car with no MOT, privately at a significant reduction over a similar car with an MOT, you take your chances.
If could have had a fresh MOT, the head gasket still would've gone, if it actually has failed! I sold a car to a trader many years ago, a Fiat 500 Twin Air, the head gasket went 2 weeks later, it happens.
Regardless I can't see anything the OP or his son has done wrong.
And if you d already bought another car anyway, why bother spending nearly as much as it s worth and go to the hassle of fixing the broken one?
Agree that it s not the seller s problem though. Private sale, it s tough.
I once bought a Mondeo ST 220, had a drive and it seemed fine. Sold as seen. The day after, I drove it at motorway speeds and the whining was horrendous. Turned out someone had tried to bodge the driveshaft oil seals with silicone sealer, all the oil had fallen out and the gearbox was knackered. Drove it like that for a while then scrapped it.
Hence suggestions for the OP to limit the risk.
Also, it's a general discussion about the joys of selling cars which are past their best. Buying them too!
maz8062 said:
It s not. To replace a head gasket costs more that £1500, so a car with a broken one, or one not properly tested is worth scrap money. This is the issue as the buyer probably relied on the head gasket replacement when making the decision.
The other question is who signed the bill of sale/receipt? The op or his son? I m guessing the op, so ultimately they are responsible.
It is true that they can stone wall or ignore the buyer and hope it goes away, which it might, but if it starts to get dirty or threats of legal action, the op will need to back up his claims with evidence because sold as seen is not a defence.
My son paid £2200 to have the head gasket done.The other question is who signed the bill of sale/receipt? The op or his son? I m guessing the op, so ultimately they are responsible.
It is true that they can stone wall or ignore the buyer and hope it goes away, which it might, but if it starts to get dirty or threats of legal action, the op will need to back up his claims with evidence because sold as seen is not a defence.
I’m not liable for anything. I said head gasket had been replaced and the car hadn’t been driven since. Yhe buyer was shown the receipt with the mileage and could compare that with the mileage of the car. Nothing was hidden. It was all perfectly clear.
OutInTheShed said:
As I said up-thread, the OP should make careful notes of exactly what was said by all parties.
Because this could come to legal proceedings in several months' time.
The other side has a witness.
'Sold as seen' may carry some weight, but it doesn't cover the seller for anything misleading in the advertising or conversations with the buyers.
If the buyer can credibly suggest anything the seller said assured them that the car was OK, the seller has a problem.
Telling someone the head gasket was fixed months ago has connotations different from 'it has only been driven a handful of miles since the gasket was changed'.
Someone who had no confidence that the repairs were a proper fix would be quite likely to flog it or trade it in without driving it much.
This thread would be a classic if written from the buyer's side.
Driveway trader sold me a car, claimed it was his son's, it blew up 50 miles later.
IMHO the legal process in this country can be a bit random at times.
Maybe it would be reasonable to verify the facts. Ask the buyers for photos. Test whether they are scammers or whether the car has actually failed.
That will be harder to test as time goes on. We were not there, the OP has met the people and will have more than the bald facts to go on. That will influence his way forwards.
People who don't have much money are very often better off with a new car on the never-never than gambling on sheds.
Notes made on the evening of the sale. Including the iniiial phone conversation which I had on speaker and my wife heard. I clearly said I know little about the car, that it hadn’t head gasket done in feb and has been parked up since. I made it clear that the car hadn’t been driven and MOT was expired so I couldn’t legally drive it. I said to the buyer, “it’s your call, come and look at it and you decide if you like it”Because this could come to legal proceedings in several months' time.
The other side has a witness.
'Sold as seen' may carry some weight, but it doesn't cover the seller for anything misleading in the advertising or conversations with the buyers.
If the buyer can credibly suggest anything the seller said assured them that the car was OK, the seller has a problem.
Telling someone the head gasket was fixed months ago has connotations different from 'it has only been driven a handful of miles since the gasket was changed'.
Someone who had no confidence that the repairs were a proper fix would be quite likely to flog it or trade it in without driving it much.
This thread would be a classic if written from the buyer's side.
Driveway trader sold me a car, claimed it was his son's, it blew up 50 miles later.
IMHO the legal process in this country can be a bit random at times.
Maybe it would be reasonable to verify the facts. Ask the buyers for photos. Test whether they are scammers or whether the car has actually failed.
That will be harder to test as time goes on. We were not there, the OP has met the people and will have more than the bald facts to go on. That will influence his way forwards.
People who don't have much money are very often better off with a new car on the never-never than gambling on sheds.
maz8062 said:
It s not. To replace a head gasket costs more that £1500, so a car with a broken one, or one not properly tested is worth scrap money. This is the issue as the buyer probably relied on the head gasket replacement when making the decision.
The other question is who signed the bill of sale/receipt? The op or his son? I m guessing the op, so ultimately they are responsible.
It is true that they can stone wall or ignore the buyer and hope it goes away, which it might, but if it starts to get dirty or threats of legal action, the op will need to back up his claims with evidence because sold as seen is not a defence.
Where are you getting the idea that a private seller is liable for the condition of what they sell, beyond being as described? What evidence is there that OP lied or misled?The other question is who signed the bill of sale/receipt? The op or his son? I m guessing the op, so ultimately they are responsible.
It is true that they can stone wall or ignore the buyer and hope it goes away, which it might, but if it starts to get dirty or threats of legal action, the op will need to back up his claims with evidence because sold as seen is not a defence.
RECr said:
maz8062 said:
It s not. To replace a head gasket costs more that £1500, so a car with a broken one, or one not properly tested is worth scrap money. This is the issue as the buyer probably relied on the head gasket replacement when making the decision.
The other question is who signed the bill of sale/receipt? The op or his son? I m guessing the op, so ultimately they are responsible.
It is true that they can stone wall or ignore the buyer and hope it goes away, which it might, but if it starts to get dirty or threats of legal action, the op will need to back up his claims with evidence because sold as seen is not a defence.
Where are you getting the idea that a private seller is liable for the condition of what they sell, beyond being as described? What evidence is there that OP lied or misled?The other question is who signed the bill of sale/receipt? The op or his son? I m guessing the op, so ultimately they are responsible.
It is true that they can stone wall or ignore the buyer and hope it goes away, which it might, but if it starts to get dirty or threats of legal action, the op will need to back up his claims with evidence because sold as seen is not a defence.
The seller, the defendant, will have to put together a court bundle, take time time off work for the mediation appointment and, if it goes to a court hearing, a whole day off work, and they’ve no idea what the judge will decide. It can also take up to a year.
In my view, this will be an easy case for the plaintiff as the op has sold something, for £1500, that he didn't fully know about, so it would be easy to mislead the buyer. You can’t plead ignorance, or I was selling it for my son, your honour. Regardless, the op would likely settle before it got that far.
Civil litigation in this country is accessible to all, but it is a tough process, so it is best to try and avoid it at all costs.
Monkeylegend said:
Muzzer79 said:
As for the cock and bull about single mother and kids in the car - it s all rubbish to try and guilt trip the OP.
And you know that to be true 

maz8062 said:
sold as seen is not a defence.
Yes, it absolutely ismaz8062 said:
Because if the buyer decides to pursue it through the courts, judges don t take into account sold as seen . The civil courts are to trying to find a resolution, that s shy mediation is the first stage in the process.
The seller, the defendant, will have to put together a court bundle, take time time off work for the mediation appointment and, if it goes to a court hearing, a whole day off work, and they ve no idea what the judge will decide. It can also take up to a year.
In my view, this will be an easy case for the plaintiff as the op has sold something, for £1500, that he didn't fully know about, so it would be easy to mislead the buyer. You can t plead ignorance, or I was selling it for my son, your honour. Regardless, the op would likely settle before it got that far.
Civil litigation in this country is accessible to all, but it is a tough process, so it is best to try and avoid it at all costs.
This is absolute horsesThe seller, the defendant, will have to put together a court bundle, take time time off work for the mediation appointment and, if it goes to a court hearing, a whole day off work, and they ve no idea what the judge will decide. It can also take up to a year.
In my view, this will be an easy case for the plaintiff as the op has sold something, for £1500, that he didn't fully know about, so it would be easy to mislead the buyer. You can t plead ignorance, or I was selling it for my son, your honour. Regardless, the op would likely settle before it got that far.
Civil litigation in this country is accessible to all, but it is a tough process, so it is best to try and avoid it at all costs.
t. maz8062 said:
RECr said:
maz8062 said:
It s not. To replace a head gasket costs more that £1500, so a car with a broken one, or one not properly tested is worth scrap money. This is the issue as the buyer probably relied on the head gasket replacement when making the decision.
The other question is who signed the bill of sale/receipt? The op or his son? I m guessing the op, so ultimately they are responsible.
It is true that they can stone wall or ignore the buyer and hope it goes away, which it might, but if it starts to get dirty or threats of legal action, the op will need to back up his claims with evidence because sold as seen is not a defence.
Where are you getting the idea that a private seller is liable for the condition of what they sell, beyond being as described? What evidence is there that OP lied or misled?The other question is who signed the bill of sale/receipt? The op or his son? I m guessing the op, so ultimately they are responsible.
It is true that they can stone wall or ignore the buyer and hope it goes away, which it might, but if it starts to get dirty or threats of legal action, the op will need to back up his claims with evidence because sold as seen is not a defence.
The seller, the defendant, will have to put together a court bundle, take time time off work for the mediation appointment and, if it goes to a court hearing, a whole day off work, and they ve no idea what the judge will decide. It can also take up to a year.
In my view, this will be an easy case for the plaintiff as the op has sold something, for £1500, that he didn't fully know about, so it would be easy to mislead the buyer. You can t plead ignorance, or I was selling it for my son, your honour. Regardless, the op would likely settle before it got that far.
Civil litigation in this country is accessible to all, but it is a tough process, so it is best to try and avoid it at all costs.
RECr said:
Where are you getting the idea that a private seller is liable for the condition of what they sell, beyond being as described? What evidence is there that OP lied or misled?
I would be reasonably concerned that the scammers/buyers might hypothetically not be entirely honest and it might turn out to be one word against another, or in this case, one person's word against two people's word.Also the OP might want to be sure that anything he said or wrote could not be misinterpreted.
Do you believe that the car has actually shat itself? Or do you think the 'buyers' are in some way not entirely honest?
It might be wise to consider all the possibilities. Once you realise you might be up against people who might lie in court, you might realise that the situation is potentially precarious.
A lot of things ring alarm bells. The way they've immediately got some mechanic to allegedly look at it, which means the OP can't see what state the car was in immediately after it allegedly failed. If they've got such great contacts in the motor trade, WTF are they buying a crate with no MOT? And paying too much for it.
FreyaG said:
maz8062 said:
Because if the buyer decides to pursue it through the courts, judges don t take into account sold as seen . The civil courts are to trying to find a resolution, that s shy mediation is the first stage in the process.
The seller, the defendant, will have to put together a court bundle, take time time off work for the mediation appointment and, if it goes to a court hearing, a whole day off work, and they ve no idea what the judge will decide. It can also take up to a year.
In my view, this will be an easy case for the plaintiff as the op has sold something, for £1500, that he didn't fully know about, so it would be easy to mislead the buyer. You can t plead ignorance, or I was selling it for my son, your honour. Regardless, the op would likely settle before it got that far.
Civil litigation in this country is accessible to all, but it is a tough process, so it is best to try and avoid it at all costs.
This is absolute horsesThe seller, the defendant, will have to put together a court bundle, take time time off work for the mediation appointment and, if it goes to a court hearing, a whole day off work, and they ve no idea what the judge will decide. It can also take up to a year.
In my view, this will be an easy case for the plaintiff as the op has sold something, for £1500, that he didn't fully know about, so it would be easy to mislead the buyer. You can t plead ignorance, or I was selling it for my son, your honour. Regardless, the op would likely settle before it got that far.
Civil litigation in this country is accessible to all, but it is a tough process, so it is best to try and avoid it at all costs.
t. Dangerous misinformation like this scares sellers into falling for scam buyers. It shouldn’t be allowed on these pages.
maz8062 said:
..... the op has sold something, for £1500, that he didn't fully know about, so it would be easy to mislead the buyer. You can t plead ignorance, .....
I am not sure you can make the jump from simply not knowing things, to deliberately misleading. If you don't know, and you're asked a question and answer "I don't know", that's an honest answer. If you assume something, so what? If you make something up that's a different matter.OutInTheShed said:
.........it might turn out to be one word against another, or in this case, one person's word against two people's word.
Also the OP might want to be sure that anything he said or wrote could not be misinterpreted......
It is not the responsibility of a private seller (or any seller for that matter) to ensure the buyer doesn't misinterpret something.Also the OP might want to be sure that anything he said or wrote could not be misinterpreted......
Of course, there is the possibility the buyer invents something, then launches a court case, but as a private sale, the bar is quite low so its very unlikely to happen.
I can't believe this thread is still running. OP, I bet you wished you'd never raised it. Some contributors should be on mumsnet.
Car sold as seen. No comeback unless advert or receipt materially misrepresented cars condition.
Buyer is clearly a scammer praying on the nice OPs kindly manner and goodwill. Happens all the time. Head gasket, or lack of, would never have been fixed overnight enabling car to be driven past OPs house the next day. Any trader buying a car sat for 6 months with no MOT expects to spend time and money getting it roadworthy and reliable.
Car sold as seen. No comeback unless advert or receipt materially misrepresented cars condition.
Buyer is clearly a scammer praying on the nice OPs kindly manner and goodwill. Happens all the time. Head gasket, or lack of, would never have been fixed overnight enabling car to be driven past OPs house the next day. Any trader buying a car sat for 6 months with no MOT expects to spend time and money getting it roadworthy and reliable.
OutInTheShed said:
RECr said:
Where are you getting the idea that a private seller is liable for the condition of what they sell, beyond being as described? What evidence is there that OP lied or misled?
I would be reasonably concerned that the scammers/buyers might hypothetically not be entirely honest and it might turn out to be one word against another, or in this case, one person's word against two people's word.Also the OP might want to be sure that anything he said or wrote could not be misinterpreted.
Do you believe that the car has actually shat itself? Or do you think the 'buyers' are in some way not entirely honest?
It might be wise to consider all the possibilities. Once you realise you might be up against people who might lie in court, you might realise that the situation is potentially precarious.
A lot of things ring alarm bells. The way they've immediately got some mechanic to allegedly look at it, which means the OP can't see what state the car was in immediately after it allegedly failed. If they've got such great contacts in the motor trade, WTF are they buying a crate with no MOT? And paying too much for it.
SFTWend said:
I can't believe this thread is still running. OP, I bet you wished you'd never raised it. Some contributors should be on mumsnet.
Car sold as seen. No comeback unless advert or receipt materially misrepresented cars condition.
Buyer is clearly a scammer praying on the nice OPs kindly manner and goodwill. Happens all the time. Head gasket, or lack of, would never have been fixed overnight enabling car to be driven past OPs house the next day. Any trader buying a car sat for 6 months with no MOT expects to spend time and money getting it roadworthy and reliable.
It’s interesting to see some of the comments and the stretch people try and make to demonstrate that I am some sort of rip off merchant. Car sold as seen. No comeback unless advert or receipt materially misrepresented cars condition.
Buyer is clearly a scammer praying on the nice OPs kindly manner and goodwill. Happens all the time. Head gasket, or lack of, would never have been fixed overnight enabling car to be driven past OPs house the next day. Any trader buying a car sat for 6 months with no MOT expects to spend time and money getting it roadworthy and reliable.
But there have always been those types of asshats on PH.
Gassing Station | Car Buying | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



