04.2003 Mystic Blue E46 M3... enhanced or ruined?

04.2003 Mystic Blue E46 M3... enhanced or ruined?

Author
Discussion

Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
A simple copy/paste from a thread I started on M3cutters, but like many people I have gained a lot from reading other threads (and wasted a LOT of time) so I thought I would return the favour, as some people might be interested in knowing what it is like owning a performance car that is half your age and with a notorious (and a little unjust) reputation for being unreliable.

So, to the cut&paste bit.

This might be a TLDR post, so if so too bad, as I enjoy writing. It will get less wordy and more modificationy and picturey with subsequent posts.

2015

1. Pre-purchase

I never really coveted an E46 M3, as while I lived in Australia it just seemed like such an unobtainable and impossible car for me; I always thought a Z33 350Z would be the peak of my motoring nirvana. Scroll to 2012 and I had moved to Germany and I spent the next couple of years umming and ahhing about what car to buy. In the meantime I was a member of a car-sharing service (and I still am, seven years later).

I don't know why I decided on an E46 M3; budget played a part I guess, as in 2015 E92s were still quite expensive, especially here in Germany, but E46 M3s in the UK were at a good price point. I spent a lot of time on PistonHeads looking at cars that were manual, had no sunroof, and low miles and, as luck would have it, I found such a car in London and viewed it while there for a birthday weekend. But it is RHD; are you mad? Probably yes, but I envisaged moving back to Australia at some point, so it had to be RHD if I was to ever register and drive it there. But here I am in Germany after seven years, and coming up to four years with the car I eventually bought.

I called the small dealer selling the car and explained I would be in London for a few days, but I was very keen on this Mystic Blue example they had. It turns out that the seller had bought the car off them the year before and wanted to move it on again (should I have heard warning bells?) but I figured if the car was an out and out dog, they would have avoided it with a barge pole. I went and viewed the car and took it for a blast for about 15 minutes, and I was in awe. I had driven an SMG CS a few times before but it still took my breath away, and I was pretty smitten. After checking the paperwork they had I was satisfied it wasn't a total dog.







Here are the only two photos I took of it after the test drive. I had gotten the VIN and ran a few checks to see if it was a Cat C or D car, so I wasn't a complete novice, but I admit I would do things differently next time, as outlined below a bit.

In fairness, I did everything you should not do when looking to buy a car: fall in love with it, look at no others, and thus buy the first one you see and drive. I know it isn't perfect, this humble car of mine, and years of owning a car means unearthing little niggles, but I am still pleased I bought it as it is a dream car and I love it.

So, what is it? A pretty pov-spec, Northern Ireland-delivered, three-owner manual M3 with 37,000 miles on the clock. It had black Nappa leather and the M67 19" wheels with reasonable Conti M3 tyres. Before the dealer sold it the year before an Inspection II was carried out, along with a rebuilt VANOS unit courtesy of MR VANOS and at great expense. BMW Parklane also checked the RACP (allegedly) to find it was all OK. It also had an OEM-looking Android unit with reversing camera installed (more on this tit-bit later) and aftermarket Xenons as well (as I said, poverty-pack from factory).

I still went back home without making an offer, simply to think about it and a week later after my girlfriend asked me, do you really want to buy this car, I said yes, rang, made an offer, and it was accepted and I left a deposit before eventually transferring the money and picking it up a few weeks later.


2. Delivery

I needed to get the car to Germany. I looked at transporters but in the end settled on flying there cheaply (Ryanair from Baden Baden to Stansted for less than €30!) and getting a German vehicle border insurance (Grenzversicherung), which covered 3rd party damage but nothing of the car (more on that later as well). With a date set (after a day of drinking too much beer in Stuttgart), a very hungover flight to Stansted followed by a very spicy lamb vindaloo, the Monday morning saw me collect the M3. And about 15 minutes of getting lost trying to find the M25 so I could get to Dover, I went down a residential street with one of these stupid bloody narrow exits and kerbed a wheel. I was pretty peeved but soldiered on and enjoyed my drive to Dover.



Here it is waiting for the DFDS ferry back to the (car's) mother (and enemy) country.



Back in Europe, and driving a RHD car was proving no real issue at all. That would come when trying to pay for fuel in Luxembourg as the drive-thru is set up on the left, obviously... Brussels was a nightmare but otherwise the run back to Karlsruhe, Germany was easy and uneventful. The Android GPS unit was misbehaving though, and even now it frustrates no end. I also got a massive crack in the windscreen going through roadworks near Saarbrucken, which would cost me dearly later on as the insurance correctly did not cover such damage. Still hurt.

I got the car back home and drove it for a few days, regaling in the noise with a girlfriend who hated the thing, and soaking up the sheer pleasure of being behind the wheel of something with good power. In 2014 I was part of a BMW M driver's day and drove the new M4 (and M5 and M6) and they were great cars but I didn't think the E46 was worse, just not as fast. It felt good to drive and this circa-38,000 mile car didn't feel bad at all.

3. Roadworthy and registration

Getting the TÜV was a real pain. The front discs needed replacing, as did obviously the front windscreen. The front tyres were not the correct 225/40 size, so a pair of front tyres. The Xenons were not factory, and as the car came with halogens I needed to source LHD halogen headlights too. This was not a cheap bill. Even with a discount and me sourcing the headlights I was up to about €2,000. I will edit in the actual amount later. It was eye-watering stuff, but after that it was registration and insurance, then fun and games for about three days before the modifying bug bit.

The day I picked it up after it finally got the TÜV and registration





I will edit in some photos and continue with the next months and years ownership experience.

Edited by Nunga on Sunday 9th June 19:42

xjay1337

15,966 posts

118 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
Yes, very pov spec!!!

At least you're happy. Nice colour init.

Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
In defence of my under-equipped (phrasing) car, the less on it means the less that can go wrong. And, really, I bought the car for the driving experience, which is sublime.

I’m also on a quest to cut weight from it, which I will delve into in future posts.

Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
Some time in 2015...

I hate non-tinted windows, so early on I got the windows tinted. Funny country, Germany; you can get a tint as dark as 90 or 95%, and yet you cannot tint the front side glass... In Australia 35% is the darkest legal (har har!) but at least you can tint the front side glass as well.

I got the darkest tint I could find, and then proceeded to quiver with fear every time I tried parking the car at night.

The English would say, chavvy tint.



I love the colour. I had a Mk 6.5 Fiesta ST in Performance Blue but I don't really like blue cars, and this I bought more on spec (lack of?) and (what I thought was good) condition. But I was already on the look out for new wheels, tyres, as well as visual enhancements in the vein of CSL parts.

Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
2015 and the first mods

M3Cutters is an excellent resource; I went from wanting to turn my car into a sort-of CSL-lite to pretty much a fully-blown trackday monster. That didn’t happen overnight, but I remember researching things like CSL wheels, shocks, and ARBs and thinking, well this is quite a bit of money. But it went down the alternative path when in June 2015 I found a set of BBS RS745 wheels; 18x9.5+25, with ridiculous skinny rubber from when it was on some sort of stanced and airbagged E46 wagon. They were made for BMW as the Styling 42, and this pretty aggressive size is a rear wheel option for the E38 7er.



They’re gold (badly peeling) faced with a polished (and badly kerbed) lip and I still think they’re the cat’s miaow. This pretty much confirmed the path the car has since taken; build it as I’m sure BMW’s engineer would’ve preferred to built it (or not). Popular consensus suggested 9.5” is wide enough for a square setup, and running a 265/35 18 was also plenty aggressive enough too. More on tyres later, because another great thing about Germany is you must gain an approval or apply for an engineer’s certificate for pretty much any non-standard change you make to the car, i.e. aftermarket everything. So I wrote to BMW with the wheels (Styling42, not RS745 remember) and also the tyres I had in mind and for a letter saying yes, the wheels would be ok with these tyre sizes in mind (m-forum.de helped with some info here).

In the meantime I didn’t fit the wheels due to I guess money (none) and time, though I still managed in August to order the CSL cabin filter housings, though unfortunately the larger 64317895939 part was NLA, only the small low-density 937 piece was. The lower part was about €75.

I also eventually ordered a genuine CSL bootlid, but it took about two or three months to arrive. I was glad it did eventually! It cost €670 or so back in August 2015.

Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2019
quotequote all
End of 2015

I was enjoying the car massively, and in September or October I opted to get an oil change done as it was getting on over a year since the last one. Otherwise the car was running faultlessly, crap Android head unit aside. I bought an F10 M Performance alcantara gearknob and matching gaiter, but all I had was trouble fitting it as the gaiter was so much shorter than what an E46 requires. Huge pain in the arse and in the end I just left it. I dealt with the gear knob later.

I got the car ceramic coated in September 2015, after a slight parking accident... the improvement in finish was amazing, though it also served to highlight some 12 years worth of stone chips on the front.

Shortly afterwards, so towards November or December the CSL bottled was painted and fitted.





Look at how high it is! Mad. I thought it had such a nice stance when standard, but I look at it now and think it is way too high.



Here is the parts list for the number plate light loom; cost of wires and plugs was about €18 plus a pair of E92 LED number plate lights. I lost the rear camera doing this, but one day I will reinstall it with a new camera.

Two LEDs in the right rear light assembly had gone bust, so I was on the lookout for some new taillights and for some time I had thought about going down the amber path. It helped when on eBay.de a seller had genuine LED amber taillights for €59 or €69. Delivered. Mental. So I bought them in December and it was plug 'n' play; remove some trim, three nuts, clean out around where the gasket sits and install new lights. Happy days.




I was really really impressed with the factory look of AWRON's vent-installed digital gauge, and contacted them directly about a RHD one for the E46. About €700 and a few weeks later, I took delivery of a central dash unit with the gauge installed, as well as a direct-fitting OBD plug; good for idiots like me. Installed around the end of 2015.



I am actually onto my second gauge, as the first one got stuck on a constant screen-cycling loop that could not be stopped. Since then, three years later I can report absolutely no issues with this second one. Awron replaced it with no complaints seeing as the first was just a few months old.

Edited by Nunga on Wednesday 23 January 08:03

Sport220

632 posts

75 months

Wednesday 23rd January 2019
quotequote all
CSL bootlid and amber indicators are great mods IMHO. Very nice car

Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Wednesday 23rd January 2019
quotequote all
Early 2016

So the car is far from a garage queen (though it spends most of its nights in a garage) but I wasn’t terribly put off driving it in winter. Well I was, so I would make sure it was given a good wash after driving to try to keep the salt at bay.





In March 2016 I went on a family reunion trip to the USA west coast, and before I went I had been looking at a Total M Cars (now defunct) stud conversion Group Buy from a company called MRG Race Co. I missed out on the GB but getting the 75mm with tuner-style lugs worked out to be a lot cheaper to have them delivered to my Las Vegas hotel, at $260 including $10 shipping. They look very very good, and when I find photos I will upload them.

June 2016

In April or so I went to Mork Fahrzeug Technik (now MW Performance) on the recommendation of a German member from M3Cutters, as I was trying to find a garage that did the RACP plating. While there, I organised an appointment for the plating to be done along with the installation of KW V3 coilers, Superpro poly bushes (for rear suspension arms and diff/suspension cradle, bought at cost price as a good friend works manages a store in Oz) and a purple-tag (667) steering rack (the rack cost something like €70 off eBayde, very cheap).

I will add photos later on of the under side of the car but pleasingly there were no cracks or popped welds, just a little bit of surface rust which was treated prior to the rear end being reassembled.







It was expensive work, costing in the vicinity of €3,500 but it is incredibly labour intensive, included the KW V3s, included the installation of the steering rack with new PS fluid and a flush, and also a CSL-spec alignment.






It was very, very low to be sure, and would drag on the exhaust over particularly bad angles. It transformed the car though, and I mean in a massive way. Around Christmas 2015 I was in the hills near the Main River (still on summer tyres but temperatures were around 10 degrees and it was dry) and a fairly hotted-up Mk VI GTI totally wiped the floor with me; I was understeering everywhere, mid-corner floatiness, and it was terrible on the limit with some snap oversteer at times if I was really ham-fisted. I couldn't get close to this Golf at all. The coilovers have changed the car in a huge way and the steering rack gave a small improvement in feel and being able to place the car better, too. I know there is always a lot of discussion around what is best for handling, ride etc and while I could never suggest my M3 is pillowy soft, it doesn't buck over bumps like it did on standard suspension and the control over roll and just the vastly improved handling makes this a no-brainer.

Edited by Nunga on Wednesday 23 January 07:58

Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Wednesday 23rd January 2019
quotequote all


This angle really highlights, in my mind, how undertyred the front is. People will argue it’s for safety but really how safe is it to be all understeer-understeer-understeer-SNAP-oversteer? For info, standard M67 19s such as these are 8 and 9.5” wide.

shalmaneser

5,932 posts

195 months

Wednesday 23rd January 2019
quotequote all
To be fair that just shows BMW tucking the front wheels behind the arch for aerodynamic reasons. Pop some 12mm spacers on the front to even that out!

Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Wednesday 23rd January 2019
quotequote all
That’s also a bit more camber than standard so it wasn’t as apparent when the car was standard, but to solve the issue I just went for a wider wheel and tyre on the front instead :-)

Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Wednesday 30th January 2019
quotequote all
Miscellaneous 2016

In June 2016 I orders a BavSound Stage 1 speaker upgrade, for a very fair $497 including shipping and a toolkit, handy for removing interior trim, speakers etc. It took a while to clear customs and I had to pay a not-so-reasonable amount of money to actually get my hands on it.

BavSound have a lot of good guides and videos to assist with the installation, ranging from how to remove door trims and little tips about what needs to be left alone, adjusted, glued and so on. I did the front doors first in a couple of hours and went back to do the rear tweeters and parcel shelf a few days later. The kit comes with some glue for gluing the rear tweeters to the OEM tweeter housing, as the design is slightly different. Very easy though. Improvement in sound quality was immense, to be sure, and the fact it is plug 'n' play again makes it very easy to recommend. 13-year-old OEM speakers are always worth replacing. No pictures, but there wasn't much to be seen that would assist. What I do recommend is buying a bagful of trim clips for the door as I broke a few; they get brittle with age.

M3POWERBOY from M3Cutters sold me an LED interior lighting kit which I installed, along with LED parking lights and LED foglight. They look terrific and make a huge difference to the way the interior is lit. The foglights are really impressive, I must admit.



I also had LED indicators but the ones for the corners didn't fit, so they were a waste of money. The side indicator LEDs were no problem. I do find however two years on that my LH parking light is always illuminated; an issue with the LED itself, or it might be tied to a faulty LH-corner indicator. Have not investigated but need to...

You may notice I also went full-amber the whole way around the car; this is due to the fact I wanted to match the taillights but also because I lost a corner indicator on the autobahn after installing the LEDs... The corners were cheap at the end of 2016, at €25 each or so, but I have a crack in one now and to replace with OEM it will be about €40, so thats a fair old increase in two-odd years. Thinking about trying an aftermarket unit but then I would have to buy a pair so they definitely match. What I think I will do is buy OEM again but use a thick PPF to provide a bit of protection against stones and debris. Any recommendations appreciated.

I think the amber lights on Mystic Blue looks really really good; I remember when I was a youngster back in Australia it was all the rage to have clear everything, and not just indicators but taillights too (Lexus-style garbage and so on). Funny how what was old is new again, and so forth. Just to be clear, I was never looking for A07 Mystic Blue but it is a colour that has grown on me. It can look very similar to Topaz and Interlagos Blues in certain lighting, but had I found this car in any other colour I would have almost certainly bought it regardless (except perhaps Phoenix Yellow...)

helix402

7,859 posts

182 months

Wednesday 30th January 2019
quotequote all
Magnetti Marelli make the indicators for the E46 if you’re looking for ones that match gen BMW.

Sport220

632 posts

75 months

Thursday 31st January 2019
quotequote all
Full amber indicators, like!

1Toomanycars

85 posts

207 months

Friday 1st February 2019
quotequote all
Whilst I never rated our E46 M3 (manual cabrio), I can appreciate your mods.

The ambers look great (I've currently got an early E39 because I specifically wanted period ambers) and the CSL/Ducktail boot spoiler is something I've wanted to do for 4 years but I'd want to get a whole bootlid to do it to to preserve the originality of my paintwork.

What happened to the gold wheels, they would've looked great against the blue?

Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Friday 1st February 2019
quotequote all
^^Getting to that soon!

Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Friday 1st February 2019
quotequote all
After a surprisingly snowy drive to Bad Herrenalb, about 450m AMSL and getting stuck behind a gritting truck... 28 December 2017.

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/51iRXKlRdm92WhAq...



Its natural habitat after winter driving:


Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Friday 1st February 2019
quotequote all
Mid-2017

I pulled my finger out and finally ordered my summer tyres. I settled on Goodyear Eagle F1 Assymetric 3 in 265/35 R18 all-round, mainly because the latest Michelin Pilot Sports had not been released and I think at the time (still now perhaps) Continental Sport Contact 6 wasn't available in 18". For that matter, the PS4S isn't either.

I got the car up on stands to install the studs as well, and I had bought at some stage H&R 5mm spacers which I installed but cannot remember exactly when... it might have been for the 19s because of the slight rubbing issue I mentioned earlier.





I think the RS745 looks fantastic; again, I didn’t covet these wheels, nor was I looking for gold. I was chasing the size and, at 18x9.5+25 all-round they are almost as big as you can fit. I’m going to try 18x10s this year if money allows though.

Nunga

Original Poster:

332 posts

108 months

Friday 1st February 2019
quotequote all
1Toomanycars said:
Whilst I never rated our E46 M3 (manual cabrio), I can appreciate your mods.

The ambers look great (I've currently got an early E39 because I specifically wanted period ambers) and the CSL/Ducktail boot spoiler is something I've wanted to do for 4 years but I'd want to get a whole bootlid to do it to to preserve the originality of my paintwork.

What happened to the gold wheels, they would've looked great against the blue?
A lot of people really rave on about how good the E46 convertible is but I just can't think it anything but a floppy noodle. Try a coupe, it'll change your mind completely. I thought it was awesome before I started to play around with it, but now it is simply heroic; controllable, hooligan-like, pointy, drifty, responsive, fun, it is the works.

Glad you folk like the ambers. Happy accident but happy for it, too. The CSL bottled was a non-negotiable for me, especially for the €650 or €700 I paid for it, plus paint. I wouldn't mind a BGW if I ever go OTT, but the way the CSL bottled is so integrated with the rest of the body lines, it just screams "factory R&D". Cant fault the fitment or the guaranteed downforce performance gains.



Edited by Nunga on Friday 1st February 17:22


Edited by Nunga on Friday 1st February 17:23

HM-2

12,467 posts

169 months

Friday 1st February 2019
quotequote all
Oof cloud9 those wheels look great.