After-mark HIDS?, dash warning lights? -you've failed MOT!

After-mark HIDS?, dash warning lights? -you've failed MOT!

Author
Discussion

stuwalsh

225 posts

153 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
AngryPartsBloke said:
Personally i dont see why i have to be blinded on the way home from work so some t**ts have the freedom to show off who has the brightest blue headlights outside Mcdonalds on a friday night.
But you're happy for everyone else who's not blinding you, and only upgraded to have better night vision, to be punished by the same 'law'.

Surely if they're aligned correctly then they're not going to dazzle anyone, or next you'll be demanding the death sentence for anyone who doesn't switch of their main beam quickly enough for you.

BTW, both my M5s and Z4MC have HIDs. The M5's were aftermarket but have headlight washing and suspension levelling, so would pass the test even if they were fitted with 't**t-blue' bulbs. The Z4MC ones are original, but bounce around a lot more due to the car being so stiff that it doesn't absorb the bumps as well as the M5s.
So if your z4 bounces round and blinds others why don't you seem to realise that's why self levelling systems are a must??

Nothing against real improved systems.....................but the legalities are there for good reason.

GTRCLIVE

4,186 posts

283 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
"The new test includes a check on the presence and correct function of the steering lock where fitted as standard."

That will ps off alot of C5 Corvette owners, as there was a issue with it some time ago and most people me included removed them because they where failing while driving... Very dangerous.


GTRCLIVE

4,186 posts

283 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all

"It must be possible to secure the driver's seat fore and aft adjustment mechanism in two or three different positions. On electric seats the motors must move the seat fore and aft."

So thats going to fail half the kit cars on the road....


jagracer

8,248 posts

236 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
GTRCLIVE said:
"It must be possible to secure the driver's seat fore and aft adjustment mechanism in two or three different positions. On electric seats the motors must move the seat fore and aft."

So thats going to fail half the kit cars on the road....
Why is that?

madmover

1,725 posts

184 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
Good, Hate the things with a passion. People who support it are normally those that have them and i ask them now are you not p***ed off when someone blinds you occssionally.... yes im sure the answer is so how do you come to the conclusion its fair to blind everyone all of the time...

Jim1556

1,771 posts

156 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
GTRCLIVE said:
"It must be possible to secure the driver's seat fore and aft adjustment mechanism in two or three different positions. On electric seats the motors must move the seat fore and aft."

So thats going to fail half the kit cars on the road....
Only if it has a fore and aft adjustment...

m8rky

2,090 posts

159 months

Saturday 14th January 2012
quotequote all
stuwalsh said:
mmm-five said:
AngryPartsBloke said:
Personally i dont see why i have to be blinded on the way home from work so some t**ts have the freedom to show off who has the brightest blue headlights outside Mcdonalds on a friday night.
But you're happy for everyone else who's not blinding you, and only upgraded to have better night vision, to be punished by the same 'law'.

Surely if they're aligned correctly then they're not going to dazzle anyone, or next you'll be demanding the death sentence for anyone who doesn't switch of their main beam quickly enough for you.

BTW, both my M5s and Z4MC have HIDs. The M5's were aftermarket but have headlight washing and suspension levelling, so would pass the test even if they were fitted with 't**t-blue' bulbs. The Z4MC ones are original, but bounce around a lot more due to the car being so stiff that it doesn't absorb the bumps as well as the M5s.
So if your z4 bounces round and blinds others why don't you seem to realise that's why self levelling systems are a must??

Nothing against real improved systems.....................but the legalities are there for good reason.
I am in no way a fan of aftermarket HID systems,especially in reflector rather than projector lenses,but the Law states that some sports cars that have stiff suspension and little luggage capacity are exempt from having self levelling systems for the lights.
I think the main problem is the fitting of these to reflector lenses they were not designed for these and the beam pattern is uncontrollable which causes the dazzle.

mmm-five

11,239 posts

284 months

Saturday 14th January 2012
quotequote all
stuwalsh said:
So if your z4 bounces round and blinds others why don't you seem to realise that's why self levelling systems are a must??

Nothing against real improved systems.....................but the legalities are there for good reason.
You misread my post.

The Z4's HIDs are standard fitment from the factory, along with a self-levelling & headlight washer system = MOT pass, but probably annoy other motorists.

So the Z4's HIDs are perfectly legal as per the new MOT, but they'll distract/annoy other motorists more than the 'illegal' aftermarket ones on the M5 (which also had self-levelling & headlight washer, but were originally halogen).

Plank

147 posts

266 months

Sunday 15th January 2012
quotequote all
Good, a chap at work has had aftermarket HID lamps fitted and complains people are allways flashing him. His answer is to "give them the lot on full beam" ! Lets hope he fails the MOT.

Jetl3on

1,409 posts

196 months

Monday 30th January 2012
quotequote all
Im surprised this is such a big issue, as the 8000k Ice blue HID is no longer the popular choice and are a rarity these days. The number of cars with ill fitting kits that dazzle are minute compared to the overall number fitted.
I drive a relatively `low` car and I find that most 4x4`s headlights are directly inline with my mirrors which are extremely bright, that is a far more common problem than aftermarket kits.

Jetl3on

1,409 posts

196 months

Monday 30th January 2012
quotequote all
I should also add that I have fitted a HID kit without a levelling system, as the OEM bulbs are simply not good enough in extreme weather conditions, which justified fitting of the HID kit and for safety reasons I am reluctant to reverse.

Dodsy

7,172 posts

227 months

Monday 30th January 2012
quotequote all
jagracer said:
Why is that?
Friend of mine has a Marcos. Seat is permanently fixed to the rear bulkhead. The pedals move instead of the seat.

XG332

3,927 posts

188 months

Monday 30th January 2012
quotequote all
jagracer said:
Why is that?
Radical SR3s has about 3 inches of adjustment forward and back as its bolted to the chassis directly.

GBDG

896 posts

154 months

Monday 30th January 2012
quotequote all
Anyone who can't see the road ahead with normal headlights, clearly doesn't have good enough vision, and shouldn't be allowed on the roads at night. Even if these lights aren't pointing in your eyes, very white light is much more distracting that a yellow hue.

Edited by GBDG on Monday 30th January 23:00

DaveEssex

252 posts

157 months

Monday 30th January 2012
quotequote all
Jetl3on said:
I should also add that I have fitted a HID kit without a levelling system, as the OEM bulbs are simply not good enough in extreme weather conditions, which justified fitting of the HID kit and for safety reasons I am reluctant to reverse.
Very sad, because I know you are wrong, and worse still YOU KNOW YOU ARE WRONG!!!

Jetl3on

1,409 posts

196 months

Tuesday 31st January 2012
quotequote all
DaveEssex said:
Jetl3on said:
I should also add that I have fitted a HID kit without a levelling system, as the OEM bulbs are simply not good enough in extreme weather conditions, which justified fitting of the HID kit and for safety reasons I am reluctant to reverse.
Very sad, because I know you are wrong, and worse still YOU KNOW YOU ARE WRONG!!!
Explain?

DaveEssex

252 posts

157 months

Tuesday 31st January 2012
quotequote all
Jetl3on said:
Explain?
As an employee of a multi-national automotive manufacterer for many years, I have very detailed experience of the "homoligation" processes required to validate the suitability and safety of in-vehicle systems.
Who did your homoligation, on which you based your conclusions about safety?

Jetl3on

1,409 posts

196 months

Tuesday 31st January 2012
quotequote all
GBDG said:
Anyone who can't see the road ahead with normal headlights, clearly doesn't have good enough vision, and shouldn't be allowed on the roads at night. Even if these lights aren't pointing in your eyes, very white light is much more distracting that a yellow hue.

Edited by GBDG on Monday 30th January 23:00
Define `normal headlights`, you mean Halogen? I dont know much about the technology behind it, but arent Xenons of a similar `intensity` to HIDs fitted as standard in many cars, which emit a white light? Why would manufacturers fit these if `normal` yellow lights are just as effective?

HIDs come in varying degrees of brightness and hue, if you stay away from the competition bulbs, such as maybe the stupid 8000k upwards and are fitted correctly, you wouldnt know the difference between them and the neighbours brand new 4x4 headlights.

DaveEssex

252 posts

157 months

Tuesday 31st January 2012
quotequote all
GBDG said:
Anyone who can't see the road ahead with normal headlights, clearly doesn't have good enough vision, and shouldn't be allowed on the roads at night. Even if these lights aren't pointing in your eyes, very white light is much more distracting that a yellow hue.

Edited by GBDG on Monday 30th January 23:00
Now you explain!!!

Jetl3on

1,409 posts

196 months

Tuesday 31st January 2012
quotequote all
DaveEssex said:
Jetl3on said:
Explain?
As an employee of a multi-national automotive manufacterer for many years, I have very detailed experience of the "homoligation" processes required to validate the suitability and safety of in-vehicle systems.
Who did your homoligation, on which you based your conclusions about safety?
I did, after scaring myself driving in torrential rain in the dead of night with no street lights, no solid white lines and no cats eyes in Europe.

I dont need to know the Homologation processes of a Mullti National Automotive Manufatcurer to tell me I can change the bulbs or change the car, I chose the former. No Offence.

Whilst I understand the ill feeling towards HID`s and you all have a right to b*tch, when your sat in a car with lights barely brighter than a candle, its a no brainer.