Where is the smart money going?
Discussion
akadk said:
Babw said:
I think the OEMs have the potential to make new cars that are as appealing as the cars from 2000-2019ish.
Many of the manufacturers have said that much bigger budgets are going into combustion engines and they can see what the market is telling them with older cars being valued over newer cars - F8 v 296 for example. Hopefully they take note and build cars that have the appeal like the modern classics.
A lot of it romance and conjecture, a 675LT is not 250k better than a 750S or a 600LT. I have driven them, all this is doing is taking these cars away from enthusiasts and just into funds or very wealthy private collectors, I think the car buyer/used car seller market with these so called experts inflating the market have a lot to answer for.
regulations categorically will not allow them to make the same cars, even if their internal budgets allow them toMany of the manufacturers have said that much bigger budgets are going into combustion engines and they can see what the market is telling them with older cars being valued over newer cars - F8 v 296 for example. Hopefully they take note and build cars that have the appeal like the modern classics.
A lot of it romance and conjecture, a 675LT is not 250k better than a 750S or a 600LT. I have driven them, all this is doing is taking these cars away from enthusiasts and just into funds or very wealthy private collectors, I think the car buyer/used car seller market with these so called experts inflating the market have a lot to answer for.
So I don’t think it’s infeasible to see 10k+ rpm cars with active aero and massive driver involvement. If these cars are being priced 200-500k then I don’t see why they don’t have the legs to build a future chapter of enthusiast cars.
Griffith4ever said:
Julian Thompson said:
We were looking for a really nice R8 V10 for a friend - good ones seem to sell instantly - if you re not ringing on the day of advertisement with something a bit tasty you re not getting the car.
This is interesting to hear. I've a V10 Gen 1 - had it over 5 years now. Popped online to look at values recently for selling (planning a 650s upgrade once my garage has been extended) nad was shocked to see they are selling for what I paid 5 years ago! I paid £45k at the start of covid, and my spyder , low miles , 2010, still can go for around £40k to £45k, and that's the R-tronic.Makes me start to doubt the wisdom of my upgrade plans... though I just have to tick the scissor door box at least once....
200Plus Club said:
Griffith4ever said:
Julian Thompson said:
We were looking for a really nice R8 V10 for a friend - good ones seem to sell instantly - if you re not ringing on the day of advertisement with something a bit tasty you re not getting the car.
This is interesting to hear. I've a V10 Gen 1 - had it over 5 years now. Popped online to look at values recently for selling (planning a 650s upgrade once my garage has been extended) nad was shocked to see they are selling for what I paid 5 years ago! I paid £45k at the start of covid, and my spyder , low miles , 2010, still can go for around £40k to £45k, and that's the R-tronic.Makes me start to doubt the wisdom of my upgrade plans... though I just have to tick the scissor door box at least once....
A lot depends on what you call the smart money.
The market sweet spot atm is £70k ish. The amount of seriously good metal offered around that is insane. Noticeable is that the 575s have moved out of there since Easter, all the cheaper ones there have gone. I think only one or two remain at 70,950 or so.
Whatever you choose of the Vanqs, DBS, V12Vs, 360s, Cali 30s, Ts, Gayardos…you aren’t going to lose money on. Even I probably wouldn’t and I tend to run my stuff as dailies.
The market sweet spot atm is £70k ish. The amount of seriously good metal offered around that is insane. Noticeable is that the 575s have moved out of there since Easter, all the cheaper ones there have gone. I think only one or two remain at 70,950 or so.
Whatever you choose of the Vanqs, DBS, V12Vs, 360s, Cali 30s, Ts, Gayardos…you aren’t going to lose money on. Even I probably wouldn’t and I tend to run my stuff as dailies.
Zorbathegreek said:
Inlineonline said:
2018 seems to be a tipping point with particular filters.
Cars up to there are as fast and handle as well as anyone could sensibly need.
Add in some froth from that auction, Influencers, generational change etc and this is what happens.
But as someone else said there s no need to feel you Veni s out. The really frothy specials (CS, pista etc) are definitely not worth 2-3x the base models in terms of enjoyment so if anything it takes away the temptation to overpay for an upgrade you don t actually need!
I m half with my collection and if anything will go older with the next addition
I m with you on that. Comparing the 675LT with the 650S for UK road driving, the 650S is the one to have. Is the 675LT worth 3x650S? I think not. The 650S performance is way beyond what anyone could need for UK roads. And that s from a car built between 2014-2017 - 12 years old now.Cars up to there are as fast and handle as well as anyone could sensibly need.
Add in some froth from that auction, Influencers, generational change etc and this is what happens.
But as someone else said there s no need to feel you Veni s out. The really frothy specials (CS, pista etc) are definitely not worth 2-3x the base models in terms of enjoyment so if anything it takes away the temptation to overpay for an upgrade you don t actually need!
I m half with my collection and if anything will go older with the next addition
They are very different cars to drive and thats why people spend the extra.
You might as well ask,
Is a GT4RS worth more than a Cayman ?
Is a GT3RS worth more than a 911C2?
Is an E46 M3CSL worth more than an M3?
Is a C63 AMG Black Series worth more than a normal C63?
Is a Type R Honda NSX worth almost 10 times a normal NSX?
It's not just the performance it's how the car feels and responds to inputs. You don't 'have' to wring a cars neck to get the best from it. Great cars are also enjoyable at 3/10ths on normal roads. That's why all the cars above are worth so much more than their siblings. Not because they are faster but because they feel better, even in daily use. Like a great tennis racquet / golf club / guitar (I could go on). They may not produce better results, for the average user, but they make you feel good and they 'feel good'
Bispal said:
Zorbathegreek said:
Inlineonline said:
2018 seems to be a tipping point with particular filters.
Cars up to there are as fast and handle as well as anyone could sensibly need.
Add in some froth from that auction, Influencers, generational change etc and this is what happens.
But as someone else said there s no need to feel you Veni s out. The really frothy specials (CS, pista etc) are definitely not worth 2-3x the base models in terms of enjoyment so if anything it takes away the temptation to overpay for an upgrade you don t actually need!
I m half with my collection and if anything will go older with the next addition
I m with you on that. Comparing the 675LT with the 650S for UK road driving, the 650S is the one to have. Is the 675LT worth 3x650S? I think not. The 650S performance is way beyond what anyone could need for UK roads. And that s from a car built between 2014-2017 - 12 years old now.Cars up to there are as fast and handle as well as anyone could sensibly need.
Add in some froth from that auction, Influencers, generational change etc and this is what happens.
But as someone else said there s no need to feel you Veni s out. The really frothy specials (CS, pista etc) are definitely not worth 2-3x the base models in terms of enjoyment so if anything it takes away the temptation to overpay for an upgrade you don t actually need!
I m half with my collection and if anything will go older with the next addition
They are very different cars to drive and thats why people spend the extra.
You might as well ask,
Is a GT4RS worth more than a Cayman ?
Is a GT3RS worth more than a 911C2?
Is an E46 M3CSL worth more than an M3?
Is a C63 AMG Black Series worth more than a normal C63?
Is a Type R Honda NSX worth almost 10 times a normal NSX?
It's not just the performance it's how the car feels and responds to inputs. You don't 'have' to wring a cars neck to get the best from it. Great cars are also enjoyable at 3/10ths on normal roads. That's why all the cars above are worth so much more than their siblings. Not because they are faster but because they feel better, even in daily use. Like a great tennis racquet / golf club / guitar (I could go on). They may not produce better results, for the average user, but they make you feel good and they 'feel good'
I’m sure. 675LT feels special but 3x a 650s? I doubt it.
I’d rather put the extra £200k towards a mother car for variety
Inlineonline said:
Bispal said:
Zorbathegreek said:
Inlineonline said:
2018 seems to be a tipping point with particular filters.
Cars up to there are as fast and handle as well as anyone could sensibly need.
Add in some froth from that auction, Influencers, generational change etc and this is what happens.
But as someone else said there s no need to feel you Veni s out. The really frothy specials (CS, pista etc) are definitely not worth 2-3x the base models in terms of enjoyment so if anything it takes away the temptation to overpay for an upgrade you don t actually need!
I m half with my collection and if anything will go older with the next addition
I m with you on that. Comparing the 675LT with the 650S for UK road driving, the 650S is the one to have. Is the 675LT worth 3x650S? I think not. The 650S performance is way beyond what anyone could need for UK roads. And that s from a car built between 2014-2017 - 12 years old now.Cars up to there are as fast and handle as well as anyone could sensibly need.
Add in some froth from that auction, Influencers, generational change etc and this is what happens.
But as someone else said there s no need to feel you Veni s out. The really frothy specials (CS, pista etc) are definitely not worth 2-3x the base models in terms of enjoyment so if anything it takes away the temptation to overpay for an upgrade you don t actually need!
I m half with my collection and if anything will go older with the next addition
They are very different cars to drive and thats why people spend the extra.
You might as well ask,
Is a GT4RS worth more than a Cayman ?
Is a GT3RS worth more than a 911C2?
Is an E46 M3CSL worth more than an M3?
Is a C63 AMG Black Series worth more than a normal C63?
Is a Type R Honda NSX worth almost 10 times a normal NSX?
It's not just the performance it's how the car feels and responds to inputs. You don't 'have' to wring a cars neck to get the best from it. Great cars are also enjoyable at 3/10ths on normal roads. That's why all the cars above are worth so much more than their siblings. Not because they are faster but because they feel better, even in daily use. Like a great tennis racquet / golf club / guitar (I could go on). They may not produce better results, for the average user, but they make you feel good and they 'feel good'
I m sure. 675LT feels special but 3x a 650s? I doubt it.
I d rather put the extra £200k towards a mother car for variety
All fancy watches perform the same - it s seven minutes past three. And Jewellery and gold doesn t even do that. So
I think you re all right here - the 675lt is not multiples the 650 dynamically - as a car - but it s rare enough and better enough to be multiples as a store of value. And that s the difficult bit to resolve as a collector.
Edited to add: I know, I know, “drive them” etc but some of us like collecting too, and so the financial implications have a bearing.
Edited by Julian Thompson on Monday 4th May 15:17
Inlineonline said:
Bispal said:
Zorbathegreek said:
Inlineonline said:
2018 seems to be a tipping point with particular filters.
Cars up to there are as fast and handle as well as anyone could sensibly need.
Add in some froth from that auction, Influencers, generational change etc and this is what happens.
But as someone else said there s no need to feel you Veni s out. The really frothy specials (CS, pista etc) are definitely not worth 2-3x the base models in terms of enjoyment so if anything it takes away the temptation to overpay for an upgrade you don t actually need!
I m half with my collection and if anything will go older with the next addition
I m with you on that. Comparing the 675LT with the 650S for UK road driving, the 650S is the one to have. Is the 675LT worth 3x650S? I think not. The 650S performance is way beyond what anyone could need for UK roads. And that s from a car built between 2014-2017 - 12 years old now.Cars up to there are as fast and handle as well as anyone could sensibly need.
Add in some froth from that auction, Influencers, generational change etc and this is what happens.
But as someone else said there s no need to feel you Veni s out. The really frothy specials (CS, pista etc) are definitely not worth 2-3x the base models in terms of enjoyment so if anything it takes away the temptation to overpay for an upgrade you don t actually need!
I m half with my collection and if anything will go older with the next addition
They are very different cars to drive and thats why people spend the extra.
You might as well ask,
Is a GT4RS worth more than a Cayman ?
Is a GT3RS worth more than a 911C2?
Is an E46 M3CSL worth more than an M3?
Is a C63 AMG Black Series worth more than a normal C63?
Is a Type R Honda NSX worth almost 10 times a normal NSX?
It's not just the performance it's how the car feels and responds to inputs. You don't 'have' to wring a cars neck to get the best from it. Great cars are also enjoyable at 3/10ths on normal roads. That's why all the cars above are worth so much more than their siblings. Not because they are faster but because they feel better, even in daily use. Like a great tennis racquet / golf club / guitar (I could go on). They may not produce better results, for the average user, but they make you feel good and they 'feel good'
I m sure. 675LT feels special but 3x a 650s? I doubt it.
I d rather put the extra £200k towards a mother car for variety
They say there is a saddle for every arse.
Until last year I ran my 675LT alongside a £1,600 - 2005 Subaru Forester 2.0L daily. So I put all my eggs in one basket and have for several years now, and loved every minute of it. There is no way I would have sold the 675LT to have a 650s & 911GTS (or similar). Just wouldn't do it for me. Then there are running costs / storage / hassle.
Bispal said:
Assuming you mean another and not mother ;-)
They say there is a saddle for every arse.
Until last year I ran my 675LT alongside a £1,600 - 2005 Subaru Forester 2.0L daily. So I put all my eggs in one basket and have for several years now, and loved every minute of it. There is no way I would have sold the 675LT to have a 650s & 911GTS (or similar). Just wouldn't do it for me. Then there are running costs / storage / hassle.
Yes I know what you meanThey say there is a saddle for every arse.
Until last year I ran my 675LT alongside a £1,600 - 2005 Subaru Forester 2.0L daily. So I put all my eggs in one basket and have for several years now, and loved every minute of it. There is no way I would have sold the 675LT to have a 650s & 911GTS (or similar). Just wouldn't do it for me. Then there are running costs / storage / hassle.
I decided to go for a 12c as possibly a better road car (alongside the NSX) and also a 991.2 GT3 for track use, but more cars does definitely bring more hassle with storage, MOT's servicing etc, so an all rounder is never a bad option!
Bispal said:
Assuming you mean another and not mother ;-)
They say there is a saddle for every arse.
Until last year I ran my 675LT alongside a £1,600 - 2005 Subaru Forester 2.0L daily. So I put all my eggs in one basket and have for several years now, and loved every minute of it. There is no way I would have sold the 675LT to have a 650s & 911GTS (or similar). Just wouldn't do it for me. Then there are running costs / storage / hassle.
Your 675 has been a cracking investment going by recent price surges. And still heading one way only.They say there is a saddle for every arse.
Until last year I ran my 675LT alongside a £1,600 - 2005 Subaru Forester 2.0L daily. So I put all my eggs in one basket and have for several years now, and loved every minute of it. There is no way I would have sold the 675LT to have a 650s & 911GTS (or similar). Just wouldn't do it for me. Then there are running costs / storage / hassle.
It s the Emperor s New Clothes - special editions of standard production cars - IMHO.
I started a thread about this some years ago - largely based on my experience with Lamborghinis, and having now had, admittedly brief, drives in standard vs special variants of other manufacturer s products, I am even more convinced that the best bang for buck is to go for the standard production model OR to move up to the next step in the food chain.
Of course losing some mass and gaining some power and fine tuning the suspension and brakes will improve any car s objective performance indices and broaden its performance envelope , but where in the UK, and increasingly in Europe, are you going to safely explore either variant s ultimate ( or barely close to 50% of either variant s ultimate ) limits?
( And re track use : so much better, on almost any measure , to go for a dedicated lightweight track car if the circuit is your chosen poison)
In other words for real-life, longterm ownership, you might as well go for the standard variant. IMHO.
I totally agree that fun at 30 mph ( and accelerating from 10mph to 70, and cornering safely at 60 ) is key to enjoying any car on most European roads
What I don t think makes sense is paying a huge premium for supposed exclusivity when that money could be spent on getting onto the next step of the supercar ladder , ie moving to a completely different model line, maybe from another manufacturer.
As one of the posters has already alluded to, there is a lot of self interest invested into special edition cars, which makes it difficult for current owners to take a completely objective view on whether the cost-upgrades on their rare , limited edition and exclusive cars are really justified.
Dealers will of course milk this opportunity- its their job after all, and equally a lot of motoring journalists who have to produce regular print simply to put food on the table, are forced to highlight small or even tiny improvements that are not really discernible in normal, safe road driving.
So it boils down to rarity and exclusivity .
And what after all what is the real value of rarity and supposed exclusivity, over and above the New Clothes that the Emperor was fooled into buying?
I started a thread about this some years ago - largely based on my experience with Lamborghinis, and having now had, admittedly brief, drives in standard vs special variants of other manufacturer s products, I am even more convinced that the best bang for buck is to go for the standard production model OR to move up to the next step in the food chain.
Of course losing some mass and gaining some power and fine tuning the suspension and brakes will improve any car s objective performance indices and broaden its performance envelope , but where in the UK, and increasingly in Europe, are you going to safely explore either variant s ultimate ( or barely close to 50% of either variant s ultimate ) limits?
( And re track use : so much better, on almost any measure , to go for a dedicated lightweight track car if the circuit is your chosen poison)
In other words for real-life, longterm ownership, you might as well go for the standard variant. IMHO.
I totally agree that fun at 30 mph ( and accelerating from 10mph to 70, and cornering safely at 60 ) is key to enjoying any car on most European roads
What I don t think makes sense is paying a huge premium for supposed exclusivity when that money could be spent on getting onto the next step of the supercar ladder , ie moving to a completely different model line, maybe from another manufacturer.
As one of the posters has already alluded to, there is a lot of self interest invested into special edition cars, which makes it difficult for current owners to take a completely objective view on whether the cost-upgrades on their rare , limited edition and exclusive cars are really justified.
Dealers will of course milk this opportunity- its their job after all, and equally a lot of motoring journalists who have to produce regular print simply to put food on the table, are forced to highlight small or even tiny improvements that are not really discernible in normal, safe road driving.
So it boils down to rarity and exclusivity .
And what after all what is the real value of rarity and supposed exclusivity, over and above the New Clothes that the Emperor was fooled into buying?
Edited by carspath1 on Monday 4th May 17:47
All of a sudden from 3 there are now 11 488 Pistas on AT.
This has all the hallmarks of a market where the depth is coming off, and people who have speculated, or who have been sitting on cars off market are trying to cash in.
I’d be careful buying anything that you don’t actually want for the medium term myself, I seen this all before!
This has all the hallmarks of a market where the depth is coming off, and people who have speculated, or who have been sitting on cars off market are trying to cash in.
I’d be careful buying anything that you don’t actually want for the medium term myself, I seen this all before!
Inlineonline said:
All of a sudden from 3 there are now 11 488 Pistas on AT.
This has all the hallmarks of a market where the depth is coming off, and people who have speculated, or who have been sitting on cars off market are trying to cash in.
I d be careful buying anything that you don t actually want for the medium term myself, I seen this all before!
This,This has all the hallmarks of a market where the depth is coming off, and people who have speculated, or who have been sitting on cars off market are trying to cash in.
I d be careful buying anything that you don t actually want for the medium term myself, I seen this all before!
The ones on autotrader seem to be the same ones for the last couple of weeks,however they are still slightly cheaper than european ones and definitely a lot less than USA cars.
Hi InlineOnline: Thank you - it’s nice to know that you agree, and I think that it is important that younger, newer potential supercar purchasers appreciate that there is disagreement, and some debate, as to how best to spend the limited money that each of us has when buying a toy.
The hype surrounding what are essentially ‘ enhanced and modernised and face-lifted ‘ variants ( from whichever manufacturer) has been fed by owners, dealers, speculators, and to some extent by journalists, for far too long.
I also agree with you that it appears to be a profitable business - but I have no personal experience on this point as I tend to keep my cars for decades - which brings the cost of supercar and sports-car ownership down massively. From that point of view it’s great that I have absolutely no interest in all these new battery-enhanced, driver-aid filled, cars that manufacturers are being forced to offer us!
Hi Andrew : I hope the Gallardo is treating you well. Yes , it’s me Carspath. I was off grid in a Toyota Estima sleeper car for 6703km and 32 days in NZ and when I returned I had forgotten my PH password - and my original PH user account is still live but linked to a very old email address that I no longer have access to. So it seemed easiest to start anew. Great driving roads in NZ , but strictly enforced speed limits, and my anticipated nightmare turned out to be a driving heaven as the Estima was perfect for the often wet , but curvy , curvy, curvy, well-sighted, beautifully surfaced , traffic free NZ tarmac . Go soon !
The hype surrounding what are essentially ‘ enhanced and modernised and face-lifted ‘ variants ( from whichever manufacturer) has been fed by owners, dealers, speculators, and to some extent by journalists, for far too long.
I also agree with you that it appears to be a profitable business - but I have no personal experience on this point as I tend to keep my cars for decades - which brings the cost of supercar and sports-car ownership down massively. From that point of view it’s great that I have absolutely no interest in all these new battery-enhanced, driver-aid filled, cars that manufacturers are being forced to offer us!
Hi Andrew : I hope the Gallardo is treating you well. Yes , it’s me Carspath. I was off grid in a Toyota Estima sleeper car for 6703km and 32 days in NZ and when I returned I had forgotten my PH password - and my original PH user account is still live but linked to a very old email address that I no longer have access to. So it seemed easiest to start anew. Great driving roads in NZ , but strictly enforced speed limits, and my anticipated nightmare turned out to be a driving heaven as the Estima was perfect for the often wet , but curvy , curvy, curvy, well-sighted, beautifully surfaced , traffic free NZ tarmac . Go soon !
carspath1 said:
It s the Emperor s New Clothes - special editions of standard production cars - IMHO.
I started a thread about this some years ago - largely based on my experience with Lamborghinis, and having now had, admittedly brief, drives in standard vs special variants of other manufacturer s products, I am even more convinced that the best bang for buck is to go for the standard production model OR to move up to the next step in the food chain.
Of course losing some mass and gaining some power and fine tuning the suspension and brakes will improve any car s objective performance indices and broaden its performance envelope , but where in the UK, and increasingly in Europe, are you going to safely explore either variant s ultimate ( or barely close to 50% of either variant s ultimate ) limits?
( And re track use : so much better, on almost any measure , to go for a dedicated lightweight track car if the circuit is your chosen poison)
In other words for real-life, longterm ownership, you might as well go for the standard variant. IMHO.
I totally agree that fun at 30 mph ( and accelerating from 10mph to 70, and cornering safely at 60 ) is key to enjoying any car on most European roads
What I don t think makes sense is paying a huge premium for supposed exclusivity when that money could be spent on getting onto the next step of the supercar ladder , ie moving to a completely different model line, maybe from another manufacturer.
As one of the posters has already alluded to, there is a lot of self interest invested into special edition cars, which makes it difficult for current owners to take a completely objective view on whether the cost-upgrades on their rare , limited edition and exclusive cars are really justified.
Dealers will of course milk this opportunity- its their job after all, and equally a lot of motoring journalists who have to produce regular print simply to put food on the table, are forced to highlight small or even tiny improvements that are not really discernible in normal, safe road driving.
So it boils down to rarity and exclusivity .
And what after all what is the real value of rarity and supposed exclusivity, over and above the New Clothes that the Emperor was fooled into buying?
It's not about 'exploring the limit' I still believe what I said stands. Its about the tactility and feedback even at low speeds. The granular feel and feedback through the steering wheel, the subtle brake modulation, better gearchanges, more dialled in front end, more sophisticated suspension, appropriate seats. An enhanced car like an RS / LT / Pista (whatever) has many subtle changes that add up to a BIG difference in feel. A 675LT isn't just a 650s its 60% different parts. A Cayman R feel better in every way than a regular Cayman even thought the changes are very subtle. I started a thread about this some years ago - largely based on my experience with Lamborghinis, and having now had, admittedly brief, drives in standard vs special variants of other manufacturer s products, I am even more convinced that the best bang for buck is to go for the standard production model OR to move up to the next step in the food chain.
Of course losing some mass and gaining some power and fine tuning the suspension and brakes will improve any car s objective performance indices and broaden its performance envelope , but where in the UK, and increasingly in Europe, are you going to safely explore either variant s ultimate ( or barely close to 50% of either variant s ultimate ) limits?
( And re track use : so much better, on almost any measure , to go for a dedicated lightweight track car if the circuit is your chosen poison)
In other words for real-life, longterm ownership, you might as well go for the standard variant. IMHO.
I totally agree that fun at 30 mph ( and accelerating from 10mph to 70, and cornering safely at 60 ) is key to enjoying any car on most European roads
What I don t think makes sense is paying a huge premium for supposed exclusivity when that money could be spent on getting onto the next step of the supercar ladder , ie moving to a completely different model line, maybe from another manufacturer.
As one of the posters has already alluded to, there is a lot of self interest invested into special edition cars, which makes it difficult for current owners to take a completely objective view on whether the cost-upgrades on their rare , limited edition and exclusive cars are really justified.
Dealers will of course milk this opportunity- its their job after all, and equally a lot of motoring journalists who have to produce regular print simply to put food on the table, are forced to highlight small or even tiny improvements that are not really discernible in normal, safe road driving.
So it boils down to rarity and exclusivity .
And what after all what is the real value of rarity and supposed exclusivity, over and above the New Clothes that the Emperor was fooled into buying?
Edited by carspath1 on Monday 4th May 17:47
When I bought my new Exige 350 I was happy, it wasn't perfect, but it was a good car. Then I had a go in a 430CUP. In the real world its no faster, but the way it delivered the power was much more exhilarating. The suspension was far more sophisticated, the damping and even ride comfort, worlds apart. The brakes better, the turn in better. Even when pottering along the whole car felt way more than twice what the 350 was. So it was worth twice the price when I px'ed. In reality, in a convoy, there was little difference. However how I felt behind the wheel was worlds apart. I felt the same when I swapped my 12C for the 675LT.
So I tend to disagree. These special cars can be enjoyed just like a better tennis racquet, you don't need to be Novak Djokovic playing at 100% in grand slam to enjoy it, just hitting the ball and feeling the improved feedback is satisfaction enough. The speed, as you say, "10mph - 70 & cornering at 60mph" is not relevant, trying to achieve a certain speed is not what its about. Its all about the feeling and the car working with you.
Bispal said:
carspath1 said:
It s the Emperor s New Clothes - special editions of standard production cars - IMHO.
I started a thread about this some years ago - largely based on my experience with Lamborghinis, and having now had, admittedly brief, drives in standard vs special variants of other manufacturer s products, I am even more convinced that the best bang for buck is to go for the standard production model OR to move up to the next step in the food chain.
Of course losing some mass and gaining some power and fine tuning the suspension and brakes will improve any car s objective performance indices and broaden its performance envelope , but where in the UK, and increasingly in Europe, are you going to safely explore either variant s ultimate ( or barely close to 50% of either variant s ultimate ) limits?
( And re track use : so much better, on almost any measure , to go for a dedicated lightweight track car if the circuit is your chosen poison)
In other words for real-life, longterm ownership, you might as well go for the standard variant. IMHO.
I totally agree that fun at 30 mph ( and accelerating from 10mph to 70, and cornering safely at 60 ) is key to enjoying any car on most European roads
What I don t think makes sense is paying a huge premium for supposed exclusivity when that money could be spent on getting onto the next step of the supercar ladder , ie moving to a completely different model line, maybe from another manufacturer.
As one of the posters has already alluded to, there is a lot of self interest invested into special edition cars, which makes it difficult for current owners to take a completely objective view on whether the cost-upgrades on their rare , limited edition and exclusive cars are really justified.
Dealers will of course milk this opportunity- its their job after all, and equally a lot of motoring journalists who have to produce regular print simply to put food on the table, are forced to highlight small or even tiny improvements that are not really discernible in normal, safe road driving.
So it boils down to rarity and exclusivity .
And what after all what is the real value of rarity and supposed exclusivity, over and above the New Clothes that the Emperor was fooled into buying?
It's not about 'exploring the limit' I still believe what I said stands. Its about the tactility and feedback even at low speeds. The granular feel and feedback through the steering wheel, the subtle brake modulation, better gearchanges, more dialled in front end, more sophisticated suspension, appropriate seats. An enhanced car like an RS / LT / Pista (whatever) has many subtle changes that add up to a BIG difference in feel. A 675LT isn't just a 650s its 60% different parts. A Cayman R feel better in every way than a regular Cayman even thought the changes are very subtle. I started a thread about this some years ago - largely based on my experience with Lamborghinis, and having now had, admittedly brief, drives in standard vs special variants of other manufacturer s products, I am even more convinced that the best bang for buck is to go for the standard production model OR to move up to the next step in the food chain.
Of course losing some mass and gaining some power and fine tuning the suspension and brakes will improve any car s objective performance indices and broaden its performance envelope , but where in the UK, and increasingly in Europe, are you going to safely explore either variant s ultimate ( or barely close to 50% of either variant s ultimate ) limits?
( And re track use : so much better, on almost any measure , to go for a dedicated lightweight track car if the circuit is your chosen poison)
In other words for real-life, longterm ownership, you might as well go for the standard variant. IMHO.
I totally agree that fun at 30 mph ( and accelerating from 10mph to 70, and cornering safely at 60 ) is key to enjoying any car on most European roads
What I don t think makes sense is paying a huge premium for supposed exclusivity when that money could be spent on getting onto the next step of the supercar ladder , ie moving to a completely different model line, maybe from another manufacturer.
As one of the posters has already alluded to, there is a lot of self interest invested into special edition cars, which makes it difficult for current owners to take a completely objective view on whether the cost-upgrades on their rare , limited edition and exclusive cars are really justified.
Dealers will of course milk this opportunity- its their job after all, and equally a lot of motoring journalists who have to produce regular print simply to put food on the table, are forced to highlight small or even tiny improvements that are not really discernible in normal, safe road driving.
So it boils down to rarity and exclusivity .
And what after all what is the real value of rarity and supposed exclusivity, over and above the New Clothes that the Emperor was fooled into buying?
Edited by carspath1 on Monday 4th May 17:47
When I bought my new Exige 350 I was happy, it wasn't perfect, but it was a good car. Then I had a go in a 430CUP. In the real world its no faster, but the way it delivered the power was much more exhilarating. The suspension was far more sophisticated, the damping and even ride comfort, worlds apart. The brakes better, the turn in better. Even when pottering along the whole car felt way more than twice what the 350 was. So it was worth twice the price when I px'ed. In reality, in a convoy, there was little difference. However how I felt behind the wheel was worlds apart. I felt the same when I swapped my 12C for the 675LT.
So I tend to disagree. These special cars can be enjoyed just like a better tennis racquet, you don't need to be Novak Djokovic playing at 100% in grand slam to enjoy it, just hitting the ball and feeling the improved feedback is satisfaction enough. The speed, as you say, "10mph - 70 & cornering at 60mph" is not relevant, trying to achieve a certain speed is not what its about. Its all about the feeling and the car working with you.
I don't agree though, less is more sometimes, especially on road. For example I wouldn't choose my GT3 were I using it predominantly on road, I think it's worse than more compliant useable variants such as a GTS or Turbo.
I'm sure the 675 LT feels special, but how much of that is because you are telling yourself it's special and how much is because it actually is better on road? I wouldn't want P1 seats in my 12c for example, the carbon buckets in my GT3 are brilliant on track, but not so good for road trips. Likewise cars with low carbon splitters are just a PITA on road, even if they have lift you WILL at some point forget to activate it and crack the carbon, more road focussed cars don't suffer that way. It's things like that that sway me away from track cars on road.
In the end they are all amazing cars, but I'm not tempted to buy a track special for road use, that's just not my priority.
carspath1 said:
Hi InlineOnline: Thank you - it s nice to know that you agree, and I think that it is important that younger, newer potential supercar purchasers appreciate that there is disagreement, and some debate, as to how best to spend the limited money that each of us has when buying a toy.
The hype surrounding what are essentially enhanced and modernised and face-lifted variants ( from whichever manufacturer) has been fed by owners, dealers, speculators, and to some extent by journalists, for far too long.
I also agree with you that it appears to be a profitable business - but I have no personal experience on this point as I tend to keep my cars for decades - which brings the cost of supercar and sports-car ownership down massively. From that point of view it s great that I have absolutely no interest in all these new battery-enhanced, driver-aid filled, cars that manufacturers are being forced to offer us!
Hi Andrew : I hope the Gallardo is treating you well. Yes , it s me Carspath. I was off grid in a Toyota Estima sleeper car for 6703km and 32 days in NZ and when I returned I had forgotten my PH password - and my original PH user account is still live but linked to a very old email address that I no longer have access to. So it seemed easiest to start anew. Great driving roads in NZ , but strictly enforced speed limits, and my anticipated nightmare turned out to be a driving heaven as the Estima was perfect for the often wet , but curvy , curvy, curvy, well-sighted, beautifully surfaced , traffic free NZ tarmac . Go soon !
The hype surrounding what are essentially enhanced and modernised and face-lifted variants ( from whichever manufacturer) has been fed by owners, dealers, speculators, and to some extent by journalists, for far too long.
I also agree with you that it appears to be a profitable business - but I have no personal experience on this point as I tend to keep my cars for decades - which brings the cost of supercar and sports-car ownership down massively. From that point of view it s great that I have absolutely no interest in all these new battery-enhanced, driver-aid filled, cars that manufacturers are being forced to offer us!
Hi Andrew : I hope the Gallardo is treating you well. Yes , it s me Carspath. I was off grid in a Toyota Estima sleeper car for 6703km and 32 days in NZ and when I returned I had forgotten my PH password - and my original PH user account is still live but linked to a very old email address that I no longer have access to. So it seemed easiest to start anew. Great driving roads in NZ , but strictly enforced speed limits, and my anticipated nightmare turned out to be a driving heaven as the Estima was perfect for the often wet , but curvy , curvy, curvy, well-sighted, beautifully surfaced , traffic free NZ tarmac . Go soon !
Gassing Station | Supercar General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


