New MacBook Pros

Author
Discussion

bitchstewie

Original Poster:

51,207 posts

210 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
My understanding is it's soldered/onboard so it's down to whether the stores stock any custom models - they can't "expand" a stock one.

To those comparing SSD speeds keep in mind sequential speeds are mostly meaningless unless you do a lot of video or things that use sequential access.

Random IO is most likely to impact you day to day.

P924

1,272 posts

182 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
DELETED: Comment made by a member who's account has been deleted.
How long before you might replace? if your hoping for 2-3yrs+ I'd go with 16GB.


silentbrown

8,831 posts

116 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
DELETED: Comment made by a member who's account has been deleted.
16.

  • You can't add more later.
  • Memory requirements for Apps and OS just keep going up.
  • More memory improves resale values
Just ran the number on a 15" 32GB/1TB i7 machine : over £3400! My 11 month old similarly specced XPS-15 cost just over £1400 from Dell outlet...

Troubleatmill

10,210 posts

159 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
silentbrown said:
16.

  • You can't add more later.
  • Memory requirements for Apps and OS just keep going up.
  • More memory improves resale values
Just ran the number on a 15" 32GB/1TB i7 machine : over £3400! My 11 month old similarly specced XPS-15 cost just over £1400 from Dell outlet...
It isn't just the tech spec with Apple, the R&D costs include things like...

When you open the lid with a finger - the base of the laptop doesn't move. ( Try that with ant other make )

I'm sure there are dozens of other things too.


When I compare my 2017 MacBook pro - to my customer issued Dell - you really do notice and appreciate the difference.

It isn't just the tech specs.

silentbrown

8,831 posts

116 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
Troubleatmill said:
I'm sure there are dozens of other things too.
Oh, certainly, and they cut both ways. Neither's perfect.

The Dell is a tad heavier, has a webcam that points up your nose. If you're gaming the i7 versions overheat the voltage regulators and start throttling the CPU speeds. From my experience they're not as well manufactured as Macs either.

On the other hand, XPS memory and SSD are user-upgradeable, you get a full touchscreen, a decent selection of ports (rather than a bag of dongles), and excellent on-site service rather than return to store. Neither has magsafe now frown







dmsims

6,519 posts

267 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
silentbrown said:
rather than return to store.
People say how wonderful Apple service is but when you have to do this (and you will IME) it really is an utterly crap experience

LeadFarmer

7,411 posts

131 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
If the new ones don't have magsafe, what do they now have?

leglessAlex

5,448 posts

141 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
LeadFarmer said:
If the new ones don't have magsafe, what do they now have?
All of the ports can be used for charging. They're USB-C ports.

leglessAlex

5,448 posts

141 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
Troubleatmill said:
It isn't just the tech specs.
Of course!

In fact, that's rather the point isn't it? If you're not paying for the spec, you have to look at the other things.

OSX is wonderful to use I think, and the trackpads are always leagues ahead of anything else. The screen is always fantastic colour wise even if it isn't touch or 4k. Macs look very professional too, which can sometimes matter depending on where you work. After sales service is generally quite good as long as there's nothing seriously wrong with it. If there is, then it seems to be luck of the draw. They work brilliantly with other Apple devices too.

There are loads of reasons to buy Apple I think, but do they justify the premium? When the premium was several hundred or so, I thought it absolutely was worth it, hence me having two MacBook Pros in a row and an iMac, as well as quite a few iPads.

Now the premium is well over a thousand pounds, I personally find it hard to justify. I just don't have enough money to burn it like that. Plenty of people do though, and that's completely their choice.

thebraketester

14,226 posts

138 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
ecs said:
Been waiting for these for such a long time - my mid-2014 is really showing it's age now.
What have you been waiting for that wasn't in the 2017 MBP TB?

thebraketester

14,226 posts

138 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
Monty Python said:
Nope - I don't see why I should line Apple's pockets when I can buy something equally as good for significantly less.
Whilst I kind of agree, I would rather saw my arm off with with a spoon than have to use windows.

megenzo

239 posts

136 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
wiffmaster said:
Finally! My Macbook Air 2011 is basically dead (top Qwerty row broken, meaning I have to use on-screen-keyboard to type)

New 13" touch bar, but upgraded from 8GB to 16GB RAM. Due to get here on the 31st and can't come quickly enough.

Edited by wiffmaster on Sunday 15th July 00:08
thats probably what I'll be ordering when i come back from my holibobs, hopefully by then some decent reviews will be up online. I love my MacBook air but it struggles a bit with some photography post processing.

ashleyman

6,986 posts

99 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
LeadFarmer said:
If the new ones don't have magsafe, what do they now have?
USB-C. MagSafe was such a great idea.

ashleyman

6,986 posts

99 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
thebraketester said:
ecs said:
Been waiting for these for such a long time - my mid-2014 is really showing it's age now.
What have you been waiting for that wasn't in the 2017 MBP TB?
I have a 2017 MBP TB that replaced a Mid 2012 MBP.

Spec of the 2012 machine was i7 2.3, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD and the 1.5GB graphics memory.
Spec of the TB was i7 2.7, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD with the AMD 455 chip.

The difference between the 2 when using it for live work within Adobe Creative Suite was negligible. I think the 2017 machine was 0.2 seconds faster to ingest, process and display a Canon 5D4 RAW file when using Capture One. The difference when exporting files and doing processing tasks wasn't that great but I rarely use a laptop to do those tasks. Apart from perception it wasn't a necessary upgrade. I think I've had mine out of its bag 6x in the 14 months I've owned it.

I can imagine these new ones would probably widen this gap a fair bit and make it a worthy update.

thebraketester

14,226 posts

138 months

Sunday 15th July 2018
quotequote all
ashleyman said:
LeadFarmer said:
If the new ones don't have magsafe, what do they now have?
USB-C. MagSafe was such a great idea.
Its the only thing I really hate about my 2017 MBP. The magsafe was such a great idea and it seems like a step back to me.

Has anyone tried the magnetic usb C things you can buy that turns it into a "Magsafe"?

bakerstreet

4,763 posts

165 months

Monday 16th July 2018
quotequote all
WinstonWolf said:
Think my MBP is a 2010 model, it's running High Sierra and it's fine for my uses. Popped an SSD in it a few years ago but it still works admirably for an eight year old laptop. I reckon it's still got a few more years in it yet...
I also have an 11 MBP that is still working pretty well and people on these threads do make me laugh 'My 2014 is getting a bit slow now'. They would be surprised to know that national Newspapers are assembled on 2014-2015 kit!

dmsims

6,519 posts

267 months

Monday 16th July 2018
quotequote all
bakerstreet said:
I also have an 11 MBP that is still working pretty well and people on these threads do make me laugh 'My 2014 is getting a bit slow now'. They would be surprised to know that national Newspapers are assembled on 2014-2015 kit!
Indeed, how many tasks are processor bound ?

and if you want real speed you don't use a Macbook

Phunk

1,976 posts

171 months

Monday 16th July 2018
quotequote all
ashleyman said:
thebraketester said:
ecs said:
Been waiting for these for such a long time - my mid-2014 is really showing it's age now.
What have you been waiting for that wasn't in the 2017 MBP TB?
I have a 2017 MBP TB that replaced a Mid 2012 MBP.

Spec of the 2012 machine was i7 2.3, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD and the 1.5GB graphics memory.
Spec of the TB was i7 2.7, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD with the AMD 455 chip.

The difference between the 2 when using it for live work within Adobe Creative Suite was negligible. I think the 2017 machine was 0.2 seconds faster to ingest, process and display a Canon 5D4 RAW file when using Capture One. The difference when exporting files and doing processing tasks wasn't that great but I rarely use a laptop to do those tasks. Apart from perception it wasn't a necessary upgrade. I think I've had mine out of its bag 6x in the 14 months I've owned it.

I can imagine these new ones would probably widen this gap a fair bit and make it a worthy update.
I think some of that is due to the Adobe software.

Using Final Cut on my 2016 MacBook is night and day compared to my old one

silentbrown

8,831 posts

116 months

Monday 16th July 2018
quotequote all
Phunk said:
I think some of that is due to the Adobe software.

Using Final Cut on my 2016 MacBook is night and day compared to my old one
Maybe because FCP can use the GPU for a lot of processing tasks, and that's probably had more significant updates?

TheJimi

24,986 posts

243 months

Monday 16th July 2018
quotequote all
DELETED: Comment made by a member who's account has been deleted.
hehe Honestly, only on PH biggrin