Google hardware event 2019

Author
Discussion

768

13,657 posts

96 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
I wanted another Nexus when the Pixel came out - from something like £449 for the 6P to £719 for the XL was where they lost me, I bought a 3t too. The gap from t to XL has closed by about £40 since then, probably worth it for not sending that data to AWS. smile

768

13,657 posts

96 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
Seems to be narrowing, broadly the intent of the move away from Nexus to Pixel. There's Xiaomi, LG, Oppo. Doubt many look to Sony or HTC these days. I haven't heard of a successor for the Pocophone. Wileyfox died. Essential might have a leftfield option coming but I'd be a bit nervous taking a product from them. Hopefully I've missed a couple.

ging84

8,885 posts

146 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
wombleh said:
It's not risk free but argusbly lower risk than running old versions. If you're using a phone that's not had Android 10 after 2019-09-01 then there's a fair list of vulnerabilities:
https://source.android.com/security/bulletin/andro...
You have misunderstood that page

Google are providing security updates going back to android 7, any vulnerability discovered affecting any supported version is patched and disclosed.

That page exists because there were vulnerabilities in android 10 that were discovered and patched before release. Anything just affecting android 10 would not go into the monthly builtins because it was unreleased, but they wanted to give credit and show transparency.

The only people who could have been affected by these would have been those running beta versions of android 10.

flight147z

971 posts

129 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
Every year I decide it's the year to move over to a Pixel

Every year the pricing just makes it impossible

I'm used to huge screen phones, so would have to stick with the Pixel XL - I also store a lot of media locally so I need 128gb.

That puts the price of entry at £929

Last year I ended up buying a OnePlus 6T for £499, if I was buying another phone this year I'd get the 7T for £549. Admittedly the OnePlus phones are not as good value as they used to be but still way better value than the Pixel's

I don't understand how a phone costing £829 can only have 6GB of RAM and 64GB of storage

Funk

26,266 posts

209 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
flight147z said:
Every year I decide it's the year to move over to a Pixel

Every year the pricing just makes it impossible

I'm used to huge screen phones, so would have to stick with the Pixel XL - I also store a lot of media locally so I need 128gb.

That puts the price of entry at £929

Last year I ended up buying a OnePlus 6T for £499, if I was buying another phone this year I'd get the 7T for £549. Admittedly the OnePlus phones are not as good value as they used to be but still way better value than the Pixel's

I don't understand how a phone costing £829 can only have 6GB of RAM and 64GB of storage
What about a 3XL as they'll be cheap as now. Can you live with the notch though?

768 said:
I wanted another Nexus when the Pixel came out - from something like £449 for the 6P to £719 for the XL was where they lost me, I bought a 3t too. The gap from t to XL has closed by about £40 since then, probably worth it for not sending that data to AWS. smile
It's a shame OnePlus fked up so badly. The 3T was a very good phone but as a Chinese phone-maker they were already on a short leash. That they then got caught doing something suspect meant that trust evaporated. The way they handled it was terrible and I swore I'd never buy another one because of it.

Edited by Funk on Sunday 20th October 18:35

flight147z

971 posts

129 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
Funk said:
What about a 3XL as they'll be cheap as now. Can you live with the notch though?
I can't see how a 3XL is better than even my 6T (barring the camera)

I could not live with a notch like that (my other (work) phone is an iPhone XR) and the notch on that is appalling

Plus, 4GB of RAM gives no assurance over future performance

ging84

8,885 posts

146 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
flight147z said:
I don't understand how a phone costing £829 can only have 6GB of RAM and 64GB of storage
You wouldn't like iPhones
iPhone 11 pro max, probably the most expensive phone ever that doesn't include gem stones still only has 64g storage and 4g of ram.
Apple stopped chasing numbers long ago, Google are trying to do the same.
The technical benefits of adding more ram to smartphones is low, but adds weight, takes space and consumes energy.
64gig of storage is plenty for most people most of the time, and the benefit of having cloud storage is you don't have to provision for just in case you'll need it in the future.
Of course it really doesn't help Google that Samsung is the market leader in not just android phones but also memory and nvme storage.

Funk

26,266 posts

209 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
ging84 said:
flight147z said:
I don't understand how a phone costing £829 can only have 6GB of RAM and 64GB of storage
You wouldn't like iPhones
iPhone 11 pro max, probably the most expensive phone ever that doesn't include gem stones still only has 64g storage and 4g of ram.
Apple stopped chasing numbers long ago, Google are trying to do the same.
The technical benefits of adding more ram to smartphones is low, but adds weight, takes space and consumes energy.
64gig of storage is plenty for most people most of the time, and the benefit of having cloud storage is you don't have to provision for just in case you'll need it in the future.
Of course it really doesn't help Google that Samsung is the market leader in not just android phones but also memory and nvme storage.
I agree about the RAM etc - phone makers are desperate to go 'one better' in order to win a sale. No-one needs a 120Hz screen on a phone for example!

flight147z

971 posts

129 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
Funk said:
ging84 said:
flight147z said:
I don't understand how a phone costing £829 can only have 6GB of RAM and 64GB of storage
You wouldn't like iPhones
iPhone 11 pro max, probably the most expensive phone ever that doesn't include gem stones still only has 64g storage and 4g of ram.
Apple stopped chasing numbers long ago, Google are trying to do the same.
The technical benefits of adding more ram to smartphones is low, but adds weight, takes space and consumes energy.
64gig of storage is plenty for most people most of the time, and the benefit of having cloud storage is you don't have to provision for just in case you'll need it in the future.
Of course it really doesn't help Google that Samsung is the market leader in not just android phones but also memory and nvme storage.
I agree about the RAM etc - phone makers are desperate to go 'one better' in order to win a sale. No-one needs a 120Hz screen on a phone for example!
Understand both points but I've never heatd anyone complain about having too much RAM or storage

A bigger battery also adds cost, weight and heat(?) but people are always asking for bigger batteries

When RAM and ROM are so cheap, on a top end phone I think it's very "tight" of a manufacturer not to be generous, especially when they recognise some people might need more storage by offering two tiers - I can't see why Google couldn't make the base model 128gb and just sell a single version. It's not like the 64gb version is any kind of bargain

ajprice

27,451 posts

196 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Making the whole phone 1mm or so thicker to get rid of the camera sticking out would suit me.

Otispunkmeyer

12,580 posts

155 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
OnePlus??

Easily one of the best choices both hardware and software wise. They don't fiddle with Android too much, don't load bloat and now provide timely updates to phones that are older than 2 years! Hardware is usually tip top and if you really want pixel camera works...then load a GCam port. Job jobbed. Can't argue with the prices either.

Re security. Get an iPhone if you want that.

Edited by Otispunkmeyer on Monday 21st October 05:59

nmd87

835 posts

190 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
The main selling point of the Pixel phones is the camera. Yes, you can load the GCam app onto other phones like my Galaxy S8, but it doesn't process photos as quickly as the Pixel does. Apparently it's due to an additional chip that the Pixel has.

As an alternative to the expensive Pixels, the Realme X2 Pro looks like a very interesting device. It's from the same company as One plus and seems to tick all the boxes for <£400.



wombleh

1,788 posts

122 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
ging84 said:
wombleh said:
It's not risk free but argusbly lower risk than running old versions. If you're using a phone that's not had Android 10 after 2019-09-01 then there's a fair list of vulnerabilities:
https://source.android.com/security/bulletin/andro...
You have misunderstood that page

Google are providing security updates going back to android 7, any vulnerability discovered affecting any supported version is patched and disclosed.
The point is simply that it's better to upgrade than not. In this specific case you'd upgrade and have 1 potential vulnerability that applies in a very limited set of circumstances, or stay on an old version and be vulnerable to a larger number of publicly known vulnerabilities, the link was just to show that there are lists of public vulns around, e.g. for Android 9 Mitre or CVE. I suspect all of those will have been fixed by Google if you look in detail, but how many will 3rd party vendors have ported to their tweaked version of Android. And back to the original point if the 3rd party phone has gone out of vendor support then they won't be backporting any more security fixes for it, so paying extra for a Google Pixel may be worth it even if specs aren't as good on paper.

OnePlus seem like one of the better ones for keeping up, possibly they don't add so much on top?

Edited by wombleh on Monday 21st October 10:49

leglessAlex

5,434 posts

141 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
leglessAlex said:
I've pre ordered a 128GB 4 XL, in Clearly White.
Now shipped, should be here tomorrow. Looking forward to getting away from my S10+, it's objectively a great phone but I think I'm just never going to like Samsung.

AJB88

Original Poster:

12,384 posts

171 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
Yeh mines shipped as well, although the tracking bit doesn't work.

Corso Marche

1,718 posts

201 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
Google have confirmed the eyes open face unlock will be activated on the 4XL shortly. Just wasn't finished to their satisfaction for the phone launch event.
But as ever the internet lit up with click bait news stories and people jumped on the bandwagon. Life in 21st century society I guess.

AJB88

Original Poster:

12,384 posts

171 months

TuonoPants

279 posts

144 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
flight147z said:
Funk said:
ging84 said:
flight147z said:
I don't understand how a phone costing £829 can only have 6GB of RAM and 64GB of storage
You wouldn't like iPhones
iPhone 11 pro max, probably the most expensive phone ever that doesn't include gem stones still only has 64g storage and 4g of ram.
Apple stopped chasing numbers long ago, Google are trying to do the same.
The technical benefits of adding more ram to smartphones is low, but adds weight, takes space and consumes energy.
64gig of storage is plenty for most people most of the time, and the benefit of having cloud storage is you don't have to provision for just in case you'll need it in the future.
Of course it really doesn't help Google that Samsung is the market leader in not just android phones but also memory and nvme storage.
I agree about the RAM etc - phone makers are desperate to go 'one better' in order to win a sale. No-one needs a 120Hz screen on a phone for example!
Understand both points but I've never heatd anyone complain about having too much RAM or storage

A bigger battery also adds cost, weight and heat(?) but people are always asking for bigger batteries

When RAM and ROM are so cheap, on a top end phone I think it's very "tight" of a manufacturer not to be generous, especially when they recognise some people might need more storage by offering two tiers - I can't see why Google couldn't make the base model 128gb and just sell a single version. It's not like the 64gb version is any kind of bargain
Apple and Google are limiting the RAM so they can push there cloud storage solutions, ultimately all these platforms are gateways to subscription services. Samsung have been trying to do the same but with very limited success.

There is also the desire to make the phones as slim as possible for marketing purposes and cut out cost (to the manufacturer, not the consumer!) which is why so many phones seem to be memory constrained. Like others I'd happily have a little more bulk and get more memory and a bigger battery but that just isn't in the manufactures business model. 20% of Apple's revenue comes from services and the margins are double that of their hardware products.

And before someone says "get a OnePlus", I'm not interested due to the aforementioned security concerns.


Funk

26,266 posts

209 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
Corso Marche said:
Google have confirmed the eyes open face unlock will be activated on the 4XL shortly. Just wasn't finished to their satisfaction for the phone launch event.
But as ever the internet lit up with click bait news stories and people jumped on the bandwagon. Life in 21st century society I guess.
It was a valid concern and Google tried to play it down. They'd have done better to have said, "It's not perfect yet so we'd prefer to make sure it works perfectly before rolling it out later."

leglessAlex

5,434 posts

141 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2019
quotequote all
Pixel 4 Box by Alex D, on Flickr

Pixel 4 Box Open by Alex D, on Flickr

Heh... This was neat.