Anyone have any 'inside' info on the Alfa 4C?

Anyone have any 'inside' info on the Alfa 4C?

Author
Discussion

RichB

51,509 posts

284 months

Thursday 19th September 2013
quotequote all
snorkel sucker said:
What a rubbish review. To end suggesting Alfa bring out a manual, V6 version is to completely miss the point of the car. Typical Top Gear tosh.

It's also cheaper than a Cayman so can be forgiven some of its foibles, especially as its a 'gen 1' car - Alfa will no doubt have left room for future tweaks to the gearbox, engine, sound etc.

Honestly, with an ever increasing war against fun yet fast cars, you'd think that the press would rejoice at the 4C, especially if the trickle down effect can be harnessed - who wouldn't want a Guilietta or Mito with some of the 4C's shared tech in a couple of years?!
Indeed, the point with Clarkson et al is that they have to be extreme about everything because the characters they have built for themselves. They cannot "like" a car it has to be either total rubbish or on a different planet.

chris7676

2,685 posts

220 months

Thursday 19th September 2013
quotequote all
I think it's a good review and confirms some fears, but it should be compared to the Lotus Elise S (or whatever it's call it nowadays) as it has the same power, weight and 4 cylinders.

Squadrone Rosso

2,749 posts

147 months

Thursday 19th September 2013
quotequote all
Nice balanced review here:-

http://youtu.be/M9kpksFaZJk

Turn subtitles on wink

As predicted, the low revving turbo engine is the weakest point, and those lights (which I actually like).

Someone needs to drop a Busso or tuned Twin Spark in there but link it to the TCT & DNAR wink

Can't wait for Harris to call it has he sees it biggrin

jonby

5,357 posts

157 months

Thursday 19th September 2013
quotequote all
snorkel sucker said:
Fantuzzi said:
What a rubbish review. To end suggesting Alfa bring out a manual, V6 version is to completely miss the point of the car.

Typical Top Gear tosh.

It's also cheaper than a Cayman so can be forgiven some of its foibles, especially as its a 'gen 1' car - Alfa will no doubt have left room for future tweaks to the gearbox, engine, sound etc.

Honestly, with an ever increasing war against fun yet fast cars, you'd think that the press would rejoice at the 4C, especially if the trickle down effect can be harnessed - who wouldn't want a Guilietta or Mito with some of the 4C's shared tech in a couple of years?!
Top Gear haven't missed the point of the car - you have missed the point of the article

The review was overwhelmingly positive. TG don't yearn (the way I read the article) for a V6 or a manual box in this car. They want a solution to lag and a poor gear change - V6 & manual are one way to solve those problems

to suggest that as a gen 1 car those faults are forgivable and alfa have left room for tweaks to future models is shocking. Acceptable tweaks in that scenario are to spring rates, brake feel, ride, headlights. But basic stuff like very poor lag or very poor gear changes on a production model is not acceptable (though alfa aren't alone)

If the other reviews come to the same conclusion about these issues it will be a great shame

Fantuzzi

3,297 posts

146 months

Thursday 19th September 2013
quotequote all
jonby said:
snorkel sucker said:
Fantuzzi said:
What a rubbish review. To end suggesting Alfa bring out a manual, V6 version is to completely miss the point of the car.

Typical Top Gear tosh.

It's also cheaper than a Cayman so can be forgiven some of its foibles, especially as its a 'gen 1' car - Alfa will no doubt have left room for future tweaks to the gearbox, engine, sound etc.

Honestly, with an ever increasing war against fun yet fast cars, you'd think that the press would rejoice at the 4C, especially if the trickle down effect can be harnessed - who wouldn't want a Guilietta or Mito with some of the 4C's shared tech in a couple of years?!
Top Gear haven't missed the point of the car - you have missed the point of the article

The review was overwhelmingly positive. TG don't yearn (the way I read the article) for a V6 or a manual box in this car. They want a solution to lag and a poor gear change - V6 & manual are one way to solve those problems

to suggest that as a gen 1 car those faults are forgivable and alfa have left room for tweaks to future models is shocking. Acceptable tweaks in that scenario are to spring rates, brake feel, ride, headlights. But basic stuff like very poor lag or very poor gear changes on a production model is not acceptable (though alfa aren't alone)

If the other reviews come to the same conclusion about these issues it will be a great shame
Topgear mag tends to be a little different to the tv show, but the mags still mostly crap but it was the first review I saw so posted it up.

However if the 'character' loving topgear mag dosent like it, I can imagine it will get a mauling from proper mags.

Seems like alfa haven't really done their best, again.

RichB

51,509 posts

284 months

Thursday 19th September 2013
quotequote all
Fantuzzi said:
Seems like alfa haven't really done their best, again.
Does it? Based on one magazine review you've extrapolated that conclusion hehe

Squadrone Rosso

2,749 posts

147 months

Thursday 19th September 2013
quotequote all
The 1750 TBi engine is the weakest point. Low revving, not exactly nice sounding. Kind of A N Other engine with a barry exhaust.

The Scirocco R's 2.0 TSi engine is a much nicer unit. Revs past 7k rpm, sounds brilliant. Their DSG in it is epic too.

The good thing about it is more power is easy to get out of it. The bad thing is the TCT is right near its limits.


Fantuzzi

3,297 posts

146 months

Friday 20th September 2013
quotequote all
RichB said:
Fantuzzi said:
Seems like alfa haven't really done their best, again.
Does it? Based on one magazine review you've extrapolated that conclusion hehe
Well to be fair topgear mag tend to have the same opinions of most of the more well respected mags, just they tend to write less on the cars themselves with less description of the drive they tend to be ALOT broader.

Trust me I would LOVE to be proven wrong, but with TopGear mag loving everything Italian and with 'character' if they have been negative it dosent look good for the 4c.


But I hope I am wrong.

Alex

9,975 posts

284 months

Friday 20th September 2013
quotequote all
It really depresses me that the engine is considered the weak point by some.

The engine the weak point? In an ALFA!

RichB

51,509 posts

284 months

Friday 20th September 2013
quotequote all
Fantuzzi said:
RichB said:
Fantuzzi said:
Seems like alfa haven't really done their best, again.
Does it? Based on one magazine review you've extrapolated that conclusion hehe
Well to be fair topgear mag tend to have the same opinions of most of the more well respected mags, just they tend to write less on the cars themselves with less description of the drive they tend to be ALOT broader. Trust me I would LOVE to be proven wrong, but with TopGear mag loving everything Italian and with 'character' if they have been negative it dosent look good for the 4c. But I hope I am wrong.
Fair enough, let's wait and see, I will certainly be arranging a test drive.

Fantuzzi

3,297 posts

146 months

Monday 23rd September 2013
quotequote all
RichB said:
Fantuzzi said:
RichB said:
Fantuzzi said:
Seems like alfa haven't really done their best, again.
Does it? Based on one magazine review you've extrapolated that conclusion hehe
Well to be fair topgear mag tend to have the same opinions of most of the more well respected mags, just they tend to write less on the cars themselves with less description of the drive they tend to be ALOT broader. Trust me I would LOVE to be proven wrong, but with TopGear mag loving everything Italian and with 'character' if they have been negative it dosent look good for the 4c. But I hope I am wrong.
Fair enough, let's wait and see, I will certainly be arranging a test drive.
Seems I was wrong from various proper reviews.

I am happy!

I want a 4c in black. They look amazing on the config.

I too wish to have a drive, but the internet is being less than helpful...