Dropping a tree in conservation area
Dropping a tree in conservation area
Author
Discussion

Wilco500

Original Poster:

113 posts

92 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
Hi all, have a very big tree leaning, weakened and diseased in direct line of a public building next door.

Tree surgeon confirmed and said it needs dropping asap.

The council replied as you’d expect “you need planning” and if it’s a “threat to life” you can take it down but you could be prosecuted, suitably vague!

I have the report saying it’s a danger to life, 8 weeks for planning would be too risky.

So in answering my own question am I over thinking the risk of prosecution and should just drop it?

Wilco500

Original Poster:

113 posts

92 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
He has, and I’m not normally a worrier, l’m just concerned the council could change like the wind and come after me

Wilco500

Original Poster:

113 posts

92 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
Desiderata said:
Speak to your council's tree officer. If he/she agrees with your tree surgeon, you'll get the go-ahead straight away, no need for planning permission.
I'm surprised your tree surgeon didn't tell you this, most decent ones have a working relationship with the council tree officer and it's virtually a rubber stamping.
Tried this, was told to apply for planning and sent the email of could risk prosecution.

Wilco500

Original Poster:

113 posts

92 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
loskie said:
Speak to your insurer if you have legal advice cover. I'd say go for it BUT would the tree surgeon/Arborist be happy to stand as a witness in court if so required?
He would yes, stands by his advice to drop it.

Wilco500

Original Poster:

113 posts

92 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
RichB said:
Do you not fell trees these days or does 'drop' sound a bit more hard core? hehe
Makes me sound like I know what I’m doing 😂

Wilco500

Original Poster:

113 posts

92 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
TT86 said:
It depends on your council. My parents neighbour employed a tree surgeon to fell two ash trees with TPOs on them in my parents garden (rear wooded section they rarely check) as I suspect they were shading his garden.

Parents realised what was happening when one was down and the other 2/3 down. The council couldn't have cared less. Absolutely no hint of a prosecution.

I went back and reclaimed all the ash though which I've burnt this winter in the stove so it's not all bad news.

The research I did however did suggest if dangerous they can be felled to the degree to make them safe. If a dangerous limb, just remove that. If the whole tree is dangerous then of course it'll all have to come down and you alert the council afterwards.
Fortunately not a TPO tree, just conservation area. The 2 sycamores next to it are tagged and fine. It’s just this huge lime tree that spilt and a right pain. Decent stock of fire wood I guess (when dry)

Wilco500

Original Poster:

113 posts

92 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
TownIdiot said:
Wilco500 said:
Fortunately not a TPO tree, just conservation area. The 2 sycamores next to it are tagged and fine. It’s just this huge lime tree that spilt and a right pain. Decent stock of fire wood I guess (when dry)
All trees are TPO in a conservation area - or they certainly are in England.
Scotland so perhaps different but the ones on our land are tagged with a badge that are.

Wilco500

Original Poster:

113 posts

92 months

Thursday 13th March 2025
quotequote all
TownIdiot said:
Wilco500 said:
Scotland so perhaps different but the ones on our land are tagged with a badge that are.
If there's no TPO (blanket or otherwise) why would you need planning?
Conservation area. Council site stipulates planning is needed.