RE: BMW M135i: PH Fleet

RE: BMW M135i: PH Fleet

Tuesday 3rd October 2017

BMW M135i: PH Fleet

Power is nothing without control, right? Time to get the BMW's springs and dampers swapped...



With the standard BMW suspension junked in favour of a set of Bilstein dampers and Eibach springs, the M135i project is officially under way. To recap, we've bought a five-year-old M135i for £17,500 to see if, with a few choice modifications, we can turn it into the car it always should have been. We're working with BMW tuning specialist Birds on this project and, by the end, we should have a truly brilliant little hatch.

Kind of ring binder we like to see...
Kind of ring binder we like to see...
The first thing we wanted to address was the M135i's ride and handling. As standard, it's a curious mix of uptight ride quality and soggy body control. It's liquorice syndrome: terrible for your health, but at least it tastes disgusting. A relatively small, rear-wheel drive hatchback with more than 300hp should be a right old hoot to drive, but as it rolled out of the factory the M135i just doesn't feel quite right.

Rather than off-the-shelf parts, Birds' suspension upgrade uses springs and dampers that have been tuned specifically for the M135i. The Iver-based company recruited former racing driver James Weaver and experienced motorsport engineer Peter Weston to develop the upgrade package. Between them, James and Peter selected the correct springs and arrived at their own damper curves. The latter are valved accordingly at the Bilstein factory - this isn't simply a matter of bolting on stock parts and fiddling with damper clicks.

But hold on a minute. What do a couple of circuit boffins know about tuning a road car chassis? I wondered that myself, but when I heard James had some initial input into the Noble M600's chassis - one of the best suspended cars I've ever driven - I left my cynicism at the door.

James - who raced single seaters, touring cars and endurance racers across a four-decade career - wasn't particularly impressed with the M135i's chassis. 'I drove the standard car and it was a bit of an eye opener to say the least,' he says. Ride quality was his main bugbear. Peter reckons the issue is that German cars are generally developed for German roads, which are typically much smoother than our own, and that they're actually optimised for a very narrow set of circumstances. 'In Europe new cars have to do 200kph five-up with a boot full of luggage, so that's what the suspension is optimised for,' he comments. 'But normally, when your car is heavily loaded you moderate your driving anyway; you're not trying to find the limits of the car. You really want the car to be at its best two-up.'

Out with the old and in with the new!
Out with the old and in with the new!
Using a short loop made up of narrow, bumpy lanes close to Birds' HQ, James and Peter assessed the standard set-up. They found that the springs were too soft - an effort, perhaps, to put some ride quality back into the car - and there was far too much rebound damping. Rebound is the rate at which the wheel is allowed to drop out of its arch. Too much rebound keeps the wheel hanging up in there, which knackers ride quality and reduces grip. Why would BMW give the M135i so much rebound damping? It's all to do with that 200kph, five-up, fully loaded boot requirement, reckons Peter. If you optimise a car for those very specific circumstances, it'll feel massively over damped 95 per cent of the time when the car is much lighter.

James and Peter arrived at a set-up that uses stiffer springs - 15 per cent at the rear and 10 per cent at the front - and dampers that have much less rebound. The front end also sits 10mm lower. The stiffer springs should keep the body better controlled while less rebound damping will allow each wheel to drop into and roll through negative road features - potholes, sunken drain covers and the like - vastly improving ride quality.

That's the theory, at least. Having driven the car a few hundred miles on its new set-up I reckon that's exactly what James and Peter have achieved. There's greater plushness to the ride now, the new suspension smoothing out those negative road features rather than thumping through them. Very rough patches of tarmac are also much better ironed out. On particularly bumpy stretches of road, the kind of back lane that's almost unique to the UK, the body is much more settled now, rather than skipping and bouncing around, and the car also feels better tied down over crests whereas before it felt like the body and wheels might separate entirely.

"Chaps, anyone know how to get this down?"
"Chaps, anyone know how to get this down?"
Very useful improvements then, and our first step towards making a proper gem of the M135i. The new springs and dampers took half a day to fit, costing £1554.23 with installation, but not VAT. Incidentally, they can also be fitted to the M235i, as can all of the forthcoming upgrades.

Along with the new suspension Birds also fitted 10mm spacers to the front axle, subtly changing the steering geometry to try and bring some feel and precision to the wheel. The steering is better now and the car also looks a little meaner with a touch more track width, but it's not a night-and-day improvement.

So what's next? We'll be fitting a limited-slip differential soon, which should get the car to where we want it to be in terms of dynamics. Only then will we look at obtaining more power from the turbo straight-six.


FACT SHEET
Car:
BMW M135i
Run by: Dan Prosser
Bought: July 2017
Mileage: 32,400 total, 900 this month
Purchase price: £17,500
Last month at a glance: Shockingly good improvement with new suspension fitted

Previous reports:
'You could get an M135i for that' - so we have!

 

 

 

 

Lead image Luc Lacey, all other pics Stan Papior

Author
Discussion

jason61c

Original Poster:

5,978 posts

174 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
I had a ride in one that had an Intrax setup fitted. It was great fun along bumpy Devonshire roads.

With the car though, 17.5k seems a lot to spend on one to then throw loads of money at it. No 8k cars that'd make a more sensible start point?


http://www.motorsport24.de/intrax-racing-rennfahrw...

MR2 Steve

280 posts

107 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
This sounds like a great upgrade. When I had mine I took it on the Evo triangle and the car was laughably bad on a demanding bumpy B road. It just tied itself in knots.

How does the ride/handling compare to a Leon Cupra 290 which is much better as a stock set up.

ZX10R NIN

27,598 posts

125 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
I'd say forget the price of the car it's giving owners & potential owners a heads up as to what they could expect from the upgrades without spending a penny, then if they wish they can cherry pick the parts that suit them best.

urquattroGus

1,847 posts

190 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
I had my 13 plate M135i for just under 4 years, waved goodbye to it this March.

2 years in a had the Birds Springs, Anti Roll Bars and Quaife diff installed (B1 or B2 dynamics package)

What a transformation! The car was band on really, much less unsettled and more steering feel, for the first time I was able to drive it with real confidence.

A great little car that was.

17.5K seems a lot to spend on a 62 plate car though...

Sold My high spec 63 plate, with the birds goodies for that in March.

D200

514 posts

147 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
Suspension changes sound great - looking forward to reading about the LSD and the engine tuning in near future

Dan, can you please performance test the car before [using proper timing equipment: D] before and after all the modification you make? 0-60, 0-100 and in gear comparisons like 30-100mph etc. I read about all these car being remapped etc. but you rarely hear how much faster they actually are

I also assume the when getting the engine tuned they will dyno it before and after?

D200

514 posts

147 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
urquattroGus said:
I had my 13 plate M135i for just under 4 years, waved goodbye to it this March.

2 years in a had the Birds Springs, Anti Roll Bars and Quaife diff installed (B1 or B2 dynamics package)

What a transformation! The car was band on really, much less unsettled and more steering feel, for the first time I was able to drive it with real confidence.

A great little car that was.

17.5K seems a lot to spend on a 62 plate car though...

Sold My high spec 63 plate, with the birds goodies for that in March.
Out of interest, did you also get the car remapped?

Deadlysub

512 posts

158 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
I have had mine for over two years and you find yourself driving around the suspensions short comings, which takes some of the fun out of driving it on my favourite B roads.

urquattroGus

1,847 posts

190 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
D200 said:
urquattroGus said:
I had my 13 plate M135i for just under 4 years, waved goodbye to it this March.

2 years in a had the Birds Springs, Anti Roll Bars and Quaife diff installed (B1 or B2 dynamics package)

What a transformation! The car was band on really, much less unsettled and more steering feel, for the first time I was able to drive it with real confidence.

A great little car that was.

17.5K seems a lot to spend on a 62 plate car though...

Sold My high spec 63 plate, with the birds goodies for that in March.
Out of interest, did you also get the car remapped?
No in the end, didn't like that fact that all of the tuning was piggyback tuning boxes, and the drivetrain as standard is peachy anyway. Had the M perf back box, that was also a good extra that added some spice.

D200

514 posts

147 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
urquattroGus said:
No in the end, didn't like that fact that all of the tuning was piggyback tuning boxes, and the drivetrain as standard is peachy anyway. Had the M perf back box, that was also a good extra that added some spice.
Yeah, I guess they have enough performance as standard

Ex Boy Racer

1,151 posts

192 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
I recall many years ago that the magic that Lotus managed to bring to their cars was due to soft springs allied to stiff dampers. Shows it's more complicated than that

John Laverick

1,992 posts

214 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
Interesting article .... I've been considering one of these as my brother has just bought one.

I've driven it and it didn't feel right to me in the handling department and I wondered how the birds kit might transform it.

I know it's not an M135i but on a similar vain I had an E92 with the Birds Bilsteins / anti-roll bars / Quaife LSD and re-map. It was epic.

Krikkit

26,527 posts

181 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
Sounds like a high-quality bit of kit, not just chucking a set of shelf dampers on and deciding on your own click setup. Seems pretty cheap at less than £2k all-in as well.

MikeGoodwin

3,338 posts

117 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
Good to know the steering can be improved with a few mods.

culpz

4,882 posts

112 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
jason61c said:
With the car though, 17.5k seems a lot to spend on one to then throw loads of money at it. No 8k cars that'd make a more sensible start point?
It's alot of money on face-value. However, considering used MK7 Golf R's are more towards the 19/20k mark, cheapest, these M135i's do look like terrific value in comparison. I'm a big VW fan but these do look alot more appealing to me. I'd prefer an M235i though as i really dislike the 1-Series shape. But, i do believe they command a higher premium for the privilege.

I think the whole point here is to see how good the M-Lite can be with a few tweaks. I believe that these are criticised for being an 8/10th's car, meaning that they do have a limit where the car has no more to give and starts to lose composure. Potentially, with a bit of money thrown at it and a varied amount of aftermarket parts installed, maybe it can make up those last few tenths.

MustardCutter

238 posts

120 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
I have an unmodified 14 plate on standard passive suspension and the article's statement about the suspension being optimised for the car being loaded up with occupants and full boot rings true; mine felt much more comfortable three up with the boot and roof box full with camping gear earlier this year.

I suspect this series of articles is going to have terrible consequences on my finances biggrin

Harry_mac

353 posts

99 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
Sounds like a high-quality bit of kit, not just chucking a set of shelf dampers on and deciding on your own click setup. Seems pretty cheap at less than £2k all-in as well.
Not when the kit its based on (b12 pro-kit) is £700 quid.

Ive yet to see a review of the "off the shelf" kit vs the Birds kit but id bet the £1300 quid difference could be better spent elsewhere on the car

HJMS123

988 posts

133 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
MustardCutter said:
I suspect this series of articles is going to have terrible consequences on my finances biggrin
I suspect that is the main point of this whole blog ... more customers for Birds driving

urquattroGus

1,847 posts

190 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
Incidentally, to change the ARB's you have to drop the subframes, so if you can afford it makes sense to do springs, dampers, arbs and diff in one go.

The crown wheel is also bolted not welded to the diff flange so birds do an exchange service within the price.

I tried buying Eibach ARBs to fit myself but had to send them back when I realised they weren't an easy bolt on for me, without dropping subframes etc at least.

crusty

752 posts

220 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
Maybe I am out of touch with pricing, but is anyone surprised at the cost - nearly 2 grand for springs and dampers!!

Scottie - NW

1,288 posts

233 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2017
quotequote all
The Bilstein dampers and Eibach springs are a great combination.

I had a Prodrive RX8 and some of the changes on that included the above combination, you didn't need any of that adjustable suspension nonsense, the setup worked great on road and track.