RE: PH Origins: Head-up displays

RE: PH Origins: Head-up displays

Monday 11th December 2017

PH Origins: Head-up displays

Discover the 'world firsts' that weren't, and which technology is a lot older than it appears, in our new series - starting with HUDs



The head-up display has become an increasingly common option in the modern car - and for good reason. Instead of having to take your eyes off the road, and refocus on instruments in different light conditions, a modern HUD simply projects information into your line of sight.

The difference can be invaluable. One American study revealed that if a driver's eyes wander off the road for more than two seconds then the chance of an incident doubles. Two seconds might not sound like much but, at 70mph, you'll have travelled over 200 feet - about the length of 14 cars. So, by enabling the driver to remain focused on the road, a HUD neatly helps counter this issue.


While automotive HUDs have become more prevalent over the past several years, they are still perceived by many to be a relatively new, innovative option. The reality, however, is somewhat different.

HUDs were first developed, like the origin of much automotive technology, for aircraft. In the early 1940s, engineers began projecting extra information, like radar images, onto the windscreen of night fighters - and the concept swiftly progressed to include the likes of artificial horizons and bomb aiming markers.

As the hardware advanced, it caught the attention of General Motors. Consequently, early design renders for its 1965 Mako Shark II concept - with its aircraft-themed interior - reputedly featured a HUD. The idea remained on the drawing board, however, until a prototype was tested in 1968. The XP-856 Aero Coupe concept, displayed in 1969, also featured a HUD. Complexity and cost, presumably, prevented the idea progressing any further.


Then, in 1985, GM bought the aerospace and defence contractor Hughes Aircraft for $5.2 billion. The acquisition allowed GM to diversify into new areas but, usefully, it also granted access to a vast amount of HUD-related knowledge.

Having merged Hughes with its established Delco Electronics arm, GM ordered that the newly formed Hughes Electronics Corporation develop a HUD for the upcoming fifth-generation Cutlass Supreme. It was to feature a new front-wheel-drive platform and modern engine options, and a HUD would be the technological icing on the cake.

Finally, in May 1988, the first production HUD was unveiled in the Oldsmobile Cutlass Supreme Convertible Indy 500 Pace Car, 50 of which were offered to selected customers. The system was then made available as an option elsewhere.

GM just beat Nissan to the punch, too; Nissan had finished developing its first HUD in December 1987 but it didn't appear on the Maxima and 240SX options list until late 1988. Toyota soon joined the party, unveiling its HUD-equipped Crown Majesta in 1991.


It took the top-flight European brands, often considered the most advanced, far longer to get in on the action; BMW waded into the fray in 2003, Audi in 2010 and Mercedes-Benz in 2014 - with Mercedes citing potential driver distraction as its reason for avoiding the technology for so long.

HUDs aren't restricted to the realm of flagship models these days, mind, as the technology has trickled down through many manufacturers' model ranges. Okay, so some of the chintzy pop-up plastic ones aren't quite as technologically gratifying, but the benefits are the same.

Got an older car? Well, you need not feel left out - as there are several aftermarket and app-based solutions, many of which work well. Great, speaking from experience, for when your speedometer takes an unexpected leave of absence.

Lewis Kingston

 

 

Author
Discussion

gofasterrosssco

Original Poster:

1,237 posts

236 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all

I recently had a hire Opel Insignia for a few days which had one. I was pleasantly surprised how useful it was for speedo display and nav instructions.

saaby93

32,038 posts

178 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
Anyone else tend to look straight through it and treat it the same as any other smudge on the windscreen?
glancing back at the normal instruments

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

126 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
Lewis Kingston said:
It took the top-flight European brands, often considered the most advanced, far longer to get in on the action; BMW waded into the fray in 2003, Audi in 2010 and Mercedes-Benz in 2014
Might we be forgetting somebody in that?



Standard-fit in 2005 on the Citroen C6.

Ninja59

3,691 posts

112 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
My 640D has it the only annoying bit is that indicators do not show in BMW's original config but it can show them with a wee bit of coding.

The new g series cars have an even better one. Rarely do i look at the standard instruments there simply is no need speed, nav if being used is all displayed.

The biggest issue currently is the restrictive ability to integrate heated windscreens with HUD as the two seem incompatible.

wideangle852

20 posts

112 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
. . I recently drove a brand new Range Rover and absolutely hated a head up display, because of where it was, you end up looking at it too much rather than looking down the road . . at least you could switch it off . . a waste of money as an extra . .

RDMcG

19,142 posts

207 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
I love the things and had them on BMWs. I remain very disappointed that
Porsche has nothing on offer.

Herbs

4,916 posts

229 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
The thing I missed the most when I sold my 6 series.

I'm amazed it's not standard on most cars by now considering how easy it would be to include compared to active cruise, night vision, keyless etc

Pica-Pica

13,783 posts

84 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
Notice speed limit, adjust speed and set speed limiter (a single button, pressable by feel)
Using sat nav?, just listen to the voice.
With these I can then watch the road and hazards.
What else am I missing by not having a HUD?

oldtimer2

728 posts

133 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
wideangle852 said:
. . I recently drove a brand new Range Rover and absolutely hated a head up display, because of where it was, you end up looking at it too much rather than looking down the road . . at least you could switch it off . . a waste of money as an extra . .
I have a HUD on my Discovery Sport. It works well for me. On mine it is possible to select what you want displayed from a menu and to be able to adjust its position - either directly in front of your line of view down the road or a lower position. Did you try to adjust it on the Range Rover?

MikeGalos

261 posts

284 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
And let's not forget Cadillac having the option for a HUD display of their Night Vision camera (FLIR) display in 1999 with their 2000 model year DTS models.

unsprung

5,467 posts

124 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
One of the aftermarket solutions out there is the clever and compact Navdy. [edit: I'm adding a notation here that Navdy have closed down about a month ago]

There's an interesting review with photos of OEM HUD offerings here.

On the OEM side, the early forays by General Motors have paid dividends for consumers, as GM is now many iterations into the technology. What began as a single data point (your speed) with rudimentary turn indicators in an eight-bit blue-green font has evolved into a high-definition and multi-page user-controlled interface with multi-coloured icons, navigation, hands-free phone support, music and radio support, track day data, etc. You can roll with it feature rich, part-time feature rich, spartan or simply turned off.

Utility of course has its limits and I was a bit curious to see what consumers and regulators will say since some solutions are now integrating SMS and voice-activated SMS composition (among other mind-intensive tasks). I appreciate the genius of it all, but I'm not sure I want all those cars jostling for position on the motorway to be simultaneously on some sort of "Minority Report" version of Facebook.

Corvette has offered HUD for 20 years and, like other HUD users in this thread, it's one of the features that I rank highly on my car. One day there will be another car. Will that also have HUD? Does HUD truly matter to me? I dunno. But I have to say: One's brain welcomes the ease of HUD benefits -- the data and indications become extensions of your mind / user experience.

One recurring and sometimes amusing moment: When occasionally getting behind the wheel of a non-HUD car, I experience that slight mental stumble, when the brain realises, "Hey, who stole all the info?!"

GM has offered HUD on some Opel / Vauxhall saloons (prior to the company sale to PSA). Today, it's also on various models from Buick, Cadillac, the Camaro, as well as SUVs from Chevrolet and GMC. I like the idea that such utility has been made viable on mass market products (and not simply to the elite).







Edited by unsprung on Monday 11th December 22:36

Wills2

22,804 posts

175 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
unsprung said:
One recurring and sometimes amusing moment: When occasionally getting behind the wheel of a non-HUD car, I experience that slight mental stumble, when the brain realises, "Hey, who stole all the info?!"
I had that feeling last month when given a service loaner without HUD, it's one of those features you don't realise is great until you've not got it.



wolfracesonic

6,992 posts

127 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
Are these similar to 'Heads up' displays You see in most adverts?

RemyMartin81D

6,759 posts

205 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
Lewis Kingston said:
It took the top-flight European brands, often considered the most advanced, far longer to get in on the action; BMW waded into the fray in 2003, Audi in 2010 and Mercedes-Benz in 2014
Might we be forgetting somebody in that?



Standard-fit in 2005 on the Citroen C6.
It certainly is

Behemoth

2,105 posts

131 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
I don't know why most of these put info directly in the road field of view. imo they should be projecting somewhere neutral rather than covering the road surface & vehicles on it.

unsprung

5,467 posts

124 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
Behemoth said:
I don't know why most of these put info directly in the road field of view. imo they should be projecting somewhere neutral rather than covering the road surface & vehicles on it.
See earlier post from the PHer who raised the topic of properly adjusting the HUD features and display.

In my personal setup, the HUD appears (to the driver) to be hovering about an inch or two above the bonnet, only an inch in front of the car. No road surface or other cars are obscured.

If a driver feels that a HUD setup is blocking his view or wresting control of the experience, he's doing it wrong. Millions of units are on the road now for decades.

LuS1fer

41,133 posts

245 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
I had a HUD on my 2002 Corvette C5 Z06.
Can't say it was that useful, just faded into the background and ignored.

Ahbefive

11,657 posts

172 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
Surely everyone knows that HUD came from aircraft?

Do PH staff think that everyone here is a thicko?

unsprung

5,467 posts

124 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
Ahbefive said:
Surely everyone knows that HUD came from aircraft?

Do PH staff think that everyone here is a thicko?
PistonHeads Article said:
HUDs were first developed, like the origin of much automotive technology, for aircraft.

saaby93

32,038 posts

178 months

Monday 11th December 2017
quotequote all
unsprung said:
Ahbefive said:
Surely everyone knows that HUD came from aircraft?

Do PH staff think that everyone here is a thicko?
PistonHeads Article said:
HUDs were first developed, like the origin of much automotive technology, for aircraft.
and probably by some PHers