RE: PH Service History: Buying a black sheep

RE: PH Service History: Buying a black sheep

Sunday 19th August 2018

PH Service History: Buying a black sheep

Prices on the exotics you want to buy putting them out of reach? Maybe it's time to have a look at the ones you supposedly don't...



I've read it a million times before. I'm probably even guilty of writing it a million times myself. "This is the model you want." The implication being, of course, that there are other models of the particular make in question that you don't.

This sort of thing is at its most prevalent in the world of exotics. Where a Ferrari 355 is hallowed turf, a 348 or a Mondial is... well... not. There are reasons for this, though; in the 348's case, it's the tricky driving experience. The Mondial, meanwhile, suffers from those awkward looks.

But are these reasons enough to forego them, if they're all your budget will stretch to? A recent article in our esteemed sister title, Classic & Sports Car, made me think otherwise. It discussed the ins and outs of buying a Mondial, and in fact, made some very good points.


For one thing, the Mondial's a terrific grand-tourer. If you don't want to spank your Ferrari down a B-road periodically, but instead plan to take it on jaunts to visit friends or across Europe, that means it makes a lot of sense.

You also get one of the best interiors of a contemporary Ferrari - light and airy, and spacious too. Let's not forget, of course, those rear seats - enabling you to take the whole family out (and, perhaps, justify it to other members of the household who might need to be placated).

But you still have those familiar Ferrari tropes of an open-gate gear change and a mid-mounted V8; not to mention terrific, user-friendly handling ideal for a Ferrari novice. Ok, so it wasn't that quick even by the standards of the day - but thanks to that V8's yowl, it'll still make you feel special.


So, how about it, then? This one will cost you £27,950. So if you've always wanted a Ferrari, that makes it perhaps the most cost-effective way to treat yourself. And who here would begrudge anyone the chance to live that dream?

There are a few other exotics that deserve to come in from the cold, too. Perhaps the most obvious of these is the Lamborghini Gallardo. Sure, when it was new, it was the 'not-Murcielago' - but to see it purely through that lens is to deny that it's still a desirable car in its own right. Massive grip and traction, fabulous steering and beautifully judged balance all combine with styling that looks tame only in the shadow of its bigger brother - by any other measure, the Gallardo is a heck of a head-turner.

And when £67,500 gets you this rakish, black UK example with reasonable miles and a good history, it's a very tempting toy indeed. It needn't just be a toy, mind you; let's not forget one of the Gallardo's key benefits is its usability, with fantastic ride comfort and a properly-built interior.


You might not say the same about the Aston Martin DB9. Indeed, when it was launched there were a few too many Ford bits still floating around inside it for some road testers to feel it befitted the money it cost. And while the DB9 is an unutterably lovely thing, there's no doubt it lacks the finesse of later Astons.

This example features the slusher; the manual version is around £10-15,000 more. Either way, £35,995 is not a lot of money for a car which looks and sounds this good. The mileage is right, the history's there, and the colour scheme's suitably old money. Nice.

But maybe £35,995 is still a bit rich for you. In which case, let's look for a truly cut-price exotic, one you'll be able to afford for less than ten grand. How about this Maserati Quattroporte?


Anyone who's ever heard anything about the Quattroporte will take one look at the fact it's an early Duoselect auto and run a mile. Possibly with good reason. These things eat clutches - a new one every 20k miles will cost you £1,500 or so - and when they're not doing so, they're chomping hydraulic gear selectors, which are even more costly. So, y'know, buyer beware and all that.

And yet, here we have a truly exotic four-door with one of those achingly beautiful Maserati interiors and a fabulous V8 engine for the price of a base-model Skoda Fabia. Budget correctly for the repairs and ownership might not be too onerous an experience.

Still, it's the Mondial whose time in the sun is, I can't help but feel, most overdue. It's certainly the one that's grabbed my fancy most of all. And there's a phrase I never thought I'd hear myself say.

Author
Discussion

Robert-nszl1

Original Poster:

401 posts

88 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
I must say the Gallardo is tempting, especially with a proper manual, recognising it won't be cheap to run. One of my bugbears is the sheer size of so many new cars. The 911 is now a GT, and having seen the new Vantage next to the old one, the thing that struck me was how big it was, particularly how wide. Part of the joy of the Gallardo is the size of it; I think I'm right in saying their footprint isn't much more than a Focus. Punting a Murcielago down a British B road I'd imagine is pretty daunting, let alone up and over one of the tighter Alpine passes, whereas one of these is just a better fit.

Different balls of steel required for the QP...esp a £10k one..... I'd imagine that might be your annual repair bill! And Ferrari values going up will never make me want to own a Mondial. They say in a rising tide, the crap goes up too, and never does the adage suit a car more. The question is, have Gallardo prices bottomed out? Still feels a bit early....

WojaWabbit

1,112 posts

218 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
I'd take a 3200 before a Quattroporte, assuming four doors weren't a requirement. I mean, boomerang rear lights cloud9

Gecko1978

9,708 posts

157 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
is there a good indi service market for the QP because lets face it is bordering on sub zero levels of cool....

what do you drive e class, 5 series, gs lexus etc people say then you say oh you know a masarati....course it will be a lie you will have come on the bus as its broken but still its so cool

Iamnotkloot

1,426 posts

147 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
The Maser for me; as someone else said, it’s just so cool.
If your first year’ running costs are going to be £10k, what about doing a manual conversion? No idea how but got to be worth a look......

big_rob_sydney

3,402 posts

194 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
I don't mind older cars (I prefer them TBH). In saying that, I do also like to have the top of the performance tree within the models. That's because I believe they're enjoyable, keeping a smile on my face for the duration of my stewardship, before I inevitably pass it on to its next keeper.

Looking at the Mondial, I don't think I would ever buy one, simply because its a slug. I don't care that it came from a famous marque. The idea of such a slow car would make me feel somehow...less. 0-62 in the mid sevens and 214 bhp 35 years ago (so god only knows how few bhp remain today), would leave me pulling out my precious few remaining grey hairs.

Mondial? No thanks. I'd say you're better off with a Maser 3200 / 4200, change for some repairs, plus buy yourself another nice enough car as well for continental trips. The point wasn't made, but I'm not so sure I'd trust a 35 year old car that wasn't that reliable to begin with, to take me and my family / friends around for a few thousand miles. Getting stranded wouldn't be an enjoyable ownership proposition.

samoht

5,713 posts

146 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
Robert-nszl1 said:
recognising it won't be cheap to run
I think this is a key point - these cars in general won't be any cheaper to run than their more sought-after siblings. The total cost of ownership could even end up more, depending on what values do in the future.

So it only makes sense if you actually want them for what they are. As mentioned above, the Gallardo is perhaps the closest thing to a naturally aspirated, mid engined, 4wd performance car that isn't vast. The QP is desperately cool, single-clutch gearbox or not. The other two, not so much for me.

Mackofthejungle

1,070 posts

195 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
Who would buy a black car though? No wonder it's cheap. Horrid colour on any car - like a fat bloke dressed in black in a poor attempt to cover up his man tits.

markj113

169 posts

175 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
Bought a 996 C4 about 5 years ago as a daily driver, can stick a few bags in the front and get the daughter in the back. Small and fun to chuck around the twisties.

Also purchased a Gallardo LP560-4 Spyder just before last xmas as a weekend toy. Plenty quick enough for the road, drop dead gorgeous to look at and not that expensive to run (compared to their V12 family members)


gigglebug

2,611 posts

122 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
If I was going to buy a Mondial I'd go for this one personally.

https://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/...

I'd try and knock them down a bit though.

QuartzDad

2,250 posts

122 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
Probably just the perspective but the Mondial accelerator looks to be left of the steering wheel, perfect if your right leg is 3" longer than the left....

Ace-T

7,697 posts

255 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
'There are reasons for this, though; in the 348's case, it's the tricky driving experience.'

rolleyes The same tedious and lazy regurgitation of utter bks. Have you actually driven one?

Early 348s were tricky on the limits until they revised the suspension mounting points. After that they were an absolute go-kart to drive. The steering feedback and feel was sublime, just don't lose your nerve as you pitch it into a corner and the car looks after you.

One of the very few cars I regret selling.

Catchpole's takle on the 348:

https://www.evo.co.uk/ferrari/458/12164/ferrari-45...

BigChiefmuffinAgain

1,062 posts

98 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
I remember trying a Mondial t about 20 years ago and being seriously impressed. Great engine and lovely steering. Ended up buying a 328 instead as didn't need the extra space and of course the looks aren't great but I think it was the better car....

wab172uk

2,005 posts

227 months

Sunday 19th August 2018
quotequote all
As tempting as a Gallardo is. And it would be very very nice to open the garage door and find `your lambo` sat waiting for you. It is a 14 year old car. So parts etc will be tried and need replacing to keep the car tip top. It's one thing being able to afford to buy it, it's the running cost that could be the killer, especially if it's a new clutch or something similar that requires and engine out job.

It's still a supercar, with super car bills. Part & labour don't get cheaper, to coincide with the drop in value of the car.

oilit

2,625 posts

178 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
That Aston looks tired - the wood looks faded (and dated these days!) esp on the ski slope - where it's faded on the edges. Awful color combo also imho.

The 2008(?) facelift definitely made the interior a better place to be.

Collaudatore

1,055 posts

202 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
gigglebug said:
If I was going to buy a Mondial I'd go for this one personally.

https://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/...

I'd try and knock them down a bit though.
From €44.95?

Bargain.

JaseB

857 posts

261 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
Ace-T said:
'There are reasons for this, though; in the 348's case, it's the tricky driving experience.'

rolleyes The same tedious and lazy regurgitation of utter bks. Have you actually driven one?

Early 348s were tricky on the limits until they revised the suspension mounting points. After that they were an absolute go-kart to drive. The steering feedback and feel was sublime, just don't lose your nerve as you pitch it into a corner and the car looks after you.

One of the very few cars I regret selling.

Catchpole's takle on the 348:

https://www.evo.co.uk/ferrari/458/12164/ferrari-45...
This, in it's entirety.

Mine was a GTS so last of the last but the noise and go karty nature round the Alps was awesome fun, fairly big dollar now though sadly.

aeropilot

34,581 posts

227 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
Mackofthejungle said:
Who would buy a black car though? No wonder it's cheap. Horrid colour on any car - like a fat bloke dressed in black in a poor attempt to cover up his man tits.
hehe


simonrockman

6,852 posts

255 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
The three cars I think are comparatively undervalued are:

1. Ferrari 456 . c.£50k
2. Bentley Conti GT c.£20k
3. Lotus Evora c. £30k

They all have names. In particular the Ferrari where anything else with a prancing horse is astronomical - remember when Top Gear did the £10k supercars and got a 308GT4 for under £10k, that would be £30k now. The 456 seems like the car that prices left behind. And it's got pop up headlights.

The Bentley is very much a lot of car for the money. It's in that hiatus between being new and impressive and old and statesmanlike.

But the thing that the early Evoras have going for them is the way Lotus pricing has moved. When the Evora came out the list price was around £50k. Today, albeit significantly faster, lighter and better screwed together, a new Evora is £100k.

I think the Ferrari will get discovered and prices will rise. The Bentley will rise gently and the Lotus you but today for £30k you can sell in five years time fror £30k.

Simon

thegreenhell

15,330 posts

219 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
simonrockman said:
The three cars I think are comparatively undervalued are:

2. Bentley Conti GT c.£20k

The Bentley is very much a lot of car for the money. It's in that hiatus between being new and impressive and old and statesmanlike.

The Bentley will rise gently.

Simon
I doubt the Conti Gt will rise any time soon. They made far too many of them for it to have any rarity value - nearly 70,000 of them. They're just at that age where you won't get a meaningful warranty on one and they can produce some scarily massive bills. It's a brave person who buys a high miles one of these for £20k, or a naive one who thinks they can buy one for £20k and run it cheaply.

Helicopter123

8,831 posts

156 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
thegreenhell said:
simonrockman said:
The three cars I think are comparatively undervalued are:

2. Bentley Conti GT c.£20k

The Bentley is very much a lot of car for the money. It's in that hiatus between being new and impressive and old and statesmanlike.

The Bentley will rise gently.

Simon
I doubt the Conti Gt will rise any time soon. They made far too many of them for it to have any rarity value - nearly 70,000 of them. They're just at that age where you won't get a meaningful warranty on one and they can produce some scarily massive bills. It's a brave person who buys a high miles one of these for £20k, or a naive one who thinks they can buy one for £20k and run it cheaply.
Scratch the surface of a Conti GT and you will discover very little actual Bentley.