RE: Why Audi Sport won't build an RS1 | PH Meets

RE: Why Audi Sport won't build an RS1 | PH Meets

Friday 28th February 2020

Why Audi Sport won't build an RS1 | PH Meets

PH chews the Audi Sport fat with Oliver Hoffman and Julius Seebach



Before flying home from the Audi RS6 Avant launch earlier this month, I sat down with the bosses of Audi Sport for a wide-ranging conversation. I spoke to co-managing directors Oliver Hoffmann and Julius Seebach about the British government's plan to ban the sale of new combustion engine cars from 2035, the next R8 supercar and the company's motorsport activities. I even pitched my idea for a hot version of the A1 hatchback. It takes inspiration from the Group B-derived Sport Quattro. It's hard to say if Hoffmann and Seebach shared my vision for a four-wheel drive S1 with 300hp and a manual gearbox - read on and see what you think.

Q: The British government has announced plans to ban the sale of new petrol, diesel and hybrid cars from 2035. Does that seem realistic to you?

Hoffmann: Electrification is a foundation for Audi Sport's future. We kicked off electrification last year with mild-hybrid models like the RS6. Later this year we will present our first fully electric sports car, the e-tron GT. We will also develop plug-in hybrid cars in future, which means we will have a wide range of powertrains. I'm a fan of our five-cylinder engine -- we will continue to have this engine in the future.

Q: Will 15 years be enough time to switch the electric cars only?

Hoffmann: It's a question of market regulations. If we have some markets where combustion engines will be forbidden, there is no other choice but to go with fully electric cars. But my opinion is we will continue with plug-in hybrids in the future. We will have the right answer for each market.

Q: How is Audi Sport's Formula E programme influencing its road cars?

Hoffmann: We work very closely with the guys from our motorsport division regarding battery technology, power electronics and so on. This is a good opportunity for us to get experience from our motorsport guys and bring it into our series cars. It's not just battery technology; it's also the cooling system, where we see very high development speeds.

Q: What does the immediate future hold for Audi Sport?

Seebach: Last year we celebrated 25 years of RS, starting with the RS2 in 1994. Since then we've seen a constant increase in our portfolio and also volumes. We're seeing big demand in markets worldwide and we will bring our cars to more markets than in the past - for instance, making the RS6 available in the United States. We will double our sales figures by the end of 2023 with this strategy. There are lots of opportunities with BEV technology. We see a bright future and we think we can bring Audi Sport to the next level.

Q: I have an idea for a hot version of the A1. That car already has three slots in the nose like the Group B Sport Quattro. All it needs now is four-wheel drive, wider bodywork, 300hp and manual gearbox... What do you think?

Hoffmann: The RS3 is our entry point into the RS world at the moment. The platforms it uses is already available with four-wheel drive, cooling...everything you need for an RS model. But to make an RS1, for example? We would have to spend a lot of money on the platform. We are focusing instead on B and C segment models, starting with the RS3.


Q: So that's a no to an RS1. But what about an S1?

[A PR minder steps in to say they can't discuss an S model right now.]

Hoffmann: No decision has been taken yet.

Q: Have we now reached the top of the curve in terms of power output, or will Audi Sport's next generation performance cars be even more powerful?

Hoffmann: We see very high demand from our customers for more and more and more power. Electrification is a foundation for our future in terms of meeting all the regulations worldwide, but with electrification we also have the chance to increase the full system power of our cars. I remember a few years ago everyone was talking about downsizing and decreasing weight - no, there is still high demand for power from our customers and we have a chance to fulfil this with electrification. But consequently, weight is a big challenge for the next generation RS models.

Q: Sound is an important part of a performance car, but electric cars are almost silent. How will you address that?

Hoffmann: We are working very hard to design a special electric sound. A synthetic combustion engine sound is not the correct answer. We will see differentiation between brands, so there will be a special Audi Sport electric sound. Every brand will have a specific electric sound. But we will still have plug-in hybrids with combustion engines, which I'm very happy about.

Q: The R8 was updated last year, but it's been with us since 2015. Is the third-generation R8 on its way?

Hoffmann: First of all, we introduced the facelifted one last year so we are in the middle of the lifecycle of the current mode. We are working very hard to reach a concept for the next R8. It will have to fulfil all the regulations worldwide, which means it will be electrified. We are working on the concept, but there is no decision yet regarding technology or a platform.

Q: And are you already working with Lamborghini on this project?

Hoffmann: Yes, we are working very closely with all the others brands in the group, which means Porsche as well as Lamborghini.

Seebach: Being part of the Volkswagen Group gives us opportunities, economies of scale and access to technology. That means we can focus on the things that bring Audi Sport high performance DNA to the car, and work together with the other brands on its platform, electric strategy and so on.


Q: Does that mean the next R8 will be full electric?

Hoffmann: No decision has been taken yet regarding the technology of the next R8. But an important consideration is that the current model is the basis for our customer racing programme, and we have to fulfil the demand for customer racing in the future. The next R8 has to fit together with this. Last year we ran more than 700 races worldwide with the R8 GT4 and R8 GT3.

Seebach: We can manufacturer the R8 alongside the e-tron GT on the same production line. With regards to assembly, it would be a small step to bring the two concepts together.

Q: I love the emotional side of driving a mechanical performance car. Is there anything you can say to make me believe an electric sports car can be not just very fast, but also fun to drive?

Hoffmann: [After a long pause] Look at watches - you can have a mechanical one or something like an Apple Watch. The Apple Watch doesn't try to copy the mechanical one. If you drive our e-tron GT, it feels very different to a completely mechanical car, but it's still an emotional car. Not just the design, but also the behaviour of the car, the response...it's very direct. The throttle response is amazing. It is different to a combustion engine car, but it's just another type of emotional driving.


So, to sum up. Electrification - which encompasses hybrids as well as full EVs - is about to become a big deal for Audi Sport, just as it is for every major car maker on the planet. Not only will electrification help to ramp up horsepower figures, it will also underpin an unprecedented two-fold increase in Audi Sport sales over the next three years.

Meanwhile, there might well be an S1 on the cards. That stock response so beloved of car company execs - 'no decision has been taken yet' - means one of two things: one, 'you will hear about this new model very soon'; or two, 'no decision has been taken yet'. If the idea for an S1 had already been discussed and dismissed entirely, wouldn't Hoffmann or Seebach just say so?

We know for certain the next R8 is being planned already and that it will be electrified in some way, but that doesn't necessarily mean it'll be a full EV. The need for it to support Audi Sport's customer racing programme tells us there will be a combustion engine version, or at the very least, a hybrid one.

Finally, you can add Audi Sport to the long list of performance car manufacturers that haven't yet been able to reassure me a fully electric sports car could actually be fun to drive the way a mechanical, combustion engine car can be, and not merely very fast in a straight line. In that sense, the future of the sports car still looks somewhat uncertain from where I'm sitting...

Watch the PH video review of the RS6 Avant here


Author
Discussion

sidesauce

Original Poster:

2,470 posts

218 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Very intrigued to see what the next R8 will be like - whilst I like the current model, part of the original's appeal was its forwardness; Audi created something that looked like nothing else on the market, much less its own catalogue, at the time. I'm quite happy to accept a hybridised or even full BEV R8; can't wait to see what they'll bring out!

Bladedancer

1,265 posts

196 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
15 years will be enough for manufacturers to go full electric.
Is it going to be enough for the national grid to prep for everyone coming home at 5:30pm and plugging in their electric cars? I sincerely doubt that.
And yes, I know it won't be a binary switch that overnight everyone will go electric. But look at how many new cars are registered in the UK each year and the fateful date they will all be electric. At the moment UK has a tiny margin of power reserve.
In all that eco prancing the politicians are doing, feeling all good about themselves being green and whatnot, I doubt they are seriously considering implications of their decisions or investments in the infrastructure required to support their ideas.
But we'll see. Who knows, perhaps the politicians will surprise me by being competent for once. But based on past experiences (or even recent ones like handling of Brexit) I'm not holding my breath.

Gorbyrev

1,160 posts

154 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Spot on about the prospect of an RS1. There is a gap in the market for a compact performance car with 4wd. There is something about the A1 that is just the right size for a pugnacious Impreza or Evo replacement, but with a nicer interior! What is the point of all that power but no options on cat placement when you come to a B road corner? Only upside is S1 residuals will continue to be strong.

Olas

911 posts

57 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
There was an A1 quattro with 330bhp and there is currently an S1 with 227bhp.

irrespective of badges they are adequately powered small cars - an 'RS' label would only give less compliant suspension and a shouty exhaust.

Jasey_

4,856 posts

178 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Gorbyrev said:
Spot on about the prospect of an RS1. There is a gap in the market for a compact performance car with 4wd. There is something about the A1 that is just the right size for a pugnacious Impreza or Evo replacement, but with a nicer interior! What is the point of all that power but no options on cat placement when you come to a B road corner? Only upside is S1 residuals will continue to be strong.
I guess it's the gap Toyota hope to fill with the GR Yaris.

Be interesting to see how it does (commercially).

FA57REN

1,017 posts

55 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Hoffmann said:
I remember a few years ago everyone was talking about downsizing and decreasing weight
And yet the cars that are consistently rated 'most fun' to drive are invariably small and weight-focused. Hence why an R8 is lighter than an RS4, and why the M2 caused so much excitement.

If 'sport' was just a case of dropping in more power then driving would be boring.

Edited by FA57REN on Friday 28th February 09:06

wab172uk

2,005 posts

227 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Clearly an S1 is on the way then. Otherwise they'd have said no.

But for the UK to go fully electric by 2035 is doable for a car manufacturer. Just sell Electric cars only.

However, the UK infrastructure to allow millions of cars to be charged at nigh all at the same time, probably won't come. Then the infrastructure to allow people to charge up quickly and conveniently at every service station won't be. You'll need every parking space with a charger. Not just 3 parking spaces with a charger as it is now.

Will the Government invest on such an infrastructure change? No. Will they invest £100+ Billion into the HS2 project that only a handful of people will use? Yes.

If they want real change (outside the London Bubble) then scrap HS2 and use that money plus many times more to get charge points literally everywhere.

Wish all these car manufacturers would just say no. What would Governments do then? Stop them selling cars? No.

ricmcl14

45 posts

66 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Where and how are we supposed to get the infrastructure in the national grid to charge all these electric cars and how are we generating all this electricity?! It's easy to make promises like those being made by our politicians at the minute if you know for a fact that you won't be in your job a decade and a half from now. It reeks of 'tell them what they want to hear'.

In less apocalyptic scepticism; we have an Audi S1 and it's a fantastic little car. It's geared a little long and 'Auto' mode doesn't really know what it wants to be but left in 'Dynamic' it's solid without being jarring and has an amazing torque band that just keeps pulling. It's plenty quick and bolstering it to RS levels feels a bit like saying that a Clio 182 Cup needs a turbo, if that makes sense? Still, it would be a lunatic of a thing therefore I support it!

RSchneider

215 posts

164 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Politically correct interview. Some thoughts: The Audi Sx/RSx people depend on the bread and butter Ax models as their basis. Taking into account how the automotive industry develops, to increasingly militant regulatory environment, to economic warfare between the countries and power blocks, to social engineering efforts against anything individual and not 110% goose stepping with the system, to sharply dropping mass disposible income ... their basis will be getting smaller and smaller. I see a lot of wild cosmetic plastic parts in their future (S) and less and less substance (RS). But that's not just Audi. BMW M and Mercedes AMG as well. And: Battery cars are not a solution for individual mobility (only in a tiny tiny part of the spectrum), they are a social control tool and a waste of ressources. Hybridization on the other hand is justifyable and has some real benefits. The long term future is probably hydrogen fuelcells.

Gio G

2,946 posts

209 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Gorbyrev said:
Spot on about the prospect of an RS1. There is a gap in the market for a compact performance car with 4wd. There is something about the A1 that is just the right size for a pugnacious Impreza or Evo replacement, but with a nicer interior! What is the point of all that power but no options on cat placement when you come to a B road corner? Only upside is S1 residuals will continue to be strong.
I purchased my little S1 knowing they were not going to make another. To put 4WD into the current platform would be expensive to do, just like the existing S1. It is not perfect, but I love mine..

G

Ahonen

5,016 posts

279 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Bladedancer said:
Is it going to be enough for the national grid to prep for everyone coming home at 5:30pm and plugging in their electric cars? I sincerely doubt that.
And yes, I know it won't be a binary switch that overnight everyone will go electric. But look at how many new cars are registered in the UK each year and the fateful date they will all be electric. At the moment UK has a tiny margin of power reserve.
Absolutely. I was idly looking at how much electric cars cost to charge the other day and happened on the EDF website. It reckoned that to charge an electric car enough to do 8000 miles a year our annual household electricity usage would more than double. I do 15k miles a year and Mrs Ahonen does closer to 20k. That's a huge increase in usage! We'd be looking at using four times as much electricity as we do now. Now I fully appreciate that the UK's usage wouldn't increase by this amount as a whole for multiple reasons, but I can't see that we're really going to be anywhere near ready for this potential explosion in usage.

Leins

9,460 posts

148 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
It seems that Audi Sport are very quick to leverage the heritage of the RS brand, but it would be nice if they were a bit more accommodating with parts supply for their older models. They have a lot to learn from Mercedes and BMW in this regard

big_rob_sydney

3,401 posts

194 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Maybe it means that Audi will go electric, and ICE will go with Lambo. He did say they can run things side by side with only a small step between.

tomsugden

2,235 posts

228 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Olas said:
There was an A1 quattro with 330bhp and there is currently an S1 with 227bhp.

irrespective of badges they are adequately powered small cars - an 'RS' label would only give less compliant suspension and a shouty exhaust.
The A1 quattro was nothing like 330bhp, it was 252bhp.

Olas

911 posts

57 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
tomsugden said:
The A1 quattro was nothing like 330bhp, it was 252bhp.
my mistake, it was the one they down-tuned to 252. the same engine in other platforms was calibrated for 300+

bungle

1,874 posts

240 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Gio G said:
I purchased my little S1 knowing they were not going to make another. To put 4WD into the current platform would be expensive to do, just like the existing S1. It is not perfect, but I love mine..
Always fancied one as well, especially as they do a 5-door so can fit in kids (easier than 3 door, but that's just personal preference).

Would have to be yellow as well - off to classifieds (again).

(always liked the A1 Quattro as well).

fido

16,796 posts

255 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
tomsugden said:
Olas said:
There was an A1 quattro with 330bhp and there is currently an S1 with 227bhp.

irrespective of badges they are adequately powered small cars - an 'RS' label would only give less compliant suspension and a shouty exhaust.
The A1 quattro was nothing like 330bhp, it was 252bhp.
I'm happy with 250'ish bhp - except for the turbo lag. It's not huge but if they could hybridise the S1 - maybe an electric motor just for the rear wheels or an electrified turbo (probaably easier to package) - that would make it more fun to drive.

tomsugden

2,235 posts

228 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
I had an S1 too. Great little car, until some scumbags broke into our house to get the keys and steal it.

Rudeboy350Z

122 posts

195 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Bladedancer said:
binary switch
Yup. Just about heard it all now.

corden

72 posts

134 months

Friday 28th February 2020
quotequote all
Bladedancer said:
15 years will be enough for manufacturers to go full electric.
Is it going to be enough for the national grid to prep for everyone coming home at 5:30pm and plugging in their electric cars? I sincerely doubt that.
And yes, I know it won't be a binary switch that overnight everyone will go electric. But look at how many new cars are registered in the UK each year and the fateful date they will all be electric. At the moment UK has a tiny margin of power reserve.
In all that eco prancing the politicians are doing, feeling all good about themselves being green and whatnot, I doubt they are seriously considering implications of their decisions or investments in the infrastructure required to support their ideas.
But we'll see. Who knows, perhaps the politicians will surprise me by being competent for once. But based on past experiences (or even recent ones like handling of Brexit) I'm not holding my breath.
I am interested in this a lot. The national grid will surely have to up its game, but I don't think it's necessarily as bad as you've suggested. Very few people will actually be charging a fully depleted battery at 5:30pm. Many will need just a smallish top-up at some point before 7am. That's 13.5 hours to top up a smallish amount in a large number of cars. This is surely a lot less of an issue than everyone turning on kettles at half time in an England World Cup game - and the grid doesn't fall over then (a specific one-off scenario I know). Having a much higher rate of consumption throughout the night but at a relatively steady rate may not be that much of an issue comparatively.

There are also trials of vehicle to grid charging, and the thought of being paid to return energy to the grid from your car battery - particularly at peak time (like in the evening when solar is nil and wind may be limited) could actually help further stabilise the grid (although again, I don't want my battery constantly being depleted and charged reducing its useable life).

I think there are options. And in tech terms, 15 years is an age. In 2005 we'd never even heard of a smart phone...