Parking fine but unable to pay for parking, am I screwed

Parking fine but unable to pay for parking, am I screwed

Author
Discussion

macp

Original Poster:

4,297 posts

196 months

Thursday 3rd April
quotequote all
So I found a parking spot close to where I needed to be last week in Chester. I parked up and started looking around for a meter or signage. I dont actually remember seeing any signs. But I spotted the machine on the other side of the car park. I walked over and noticed it was totally wrapped in black pallet wrap. There was a label on the machine, or just above it. And it directed me to a website to pay. It stated no sign up so I did as instructed. I got to the point of paying where it then announced I could only use apple pay on safari. So I tried that and after two or three attempts it would not accept payment. So I decided to give up and leave.

Fast forward to today and i receive a notice demanding £100 reduced to £60 for immediate payment. This was for non payment of parking charges. The pics showed me arriving and departing 12 minutes & 10s later.

Im genuinely not a scumbag. I wasnt trying to park for free and got caught. I might be screwed here but it just doesnt seem fair.

Is it worth appealing ?

speedyman

1,585 posts

247 months

Thursday 3rd April
quotequote all
Yes, take it to appeal. I have just won a popla appeal for almost the same circumstances. 1. Signage incorrect. 2. Unable to pay or complete payment so left car park in reasonable amount of time. Was it "Parking eye" by any chance.

Dog Biscuit

678 posts

10 months

Thursday 3rd April
quotequote all
Yeah I'd appeal

You didn't do anything wrong and tried all mean to pay.

Good luck

balham123

72 posts

12 months

Thursday 3rd April
quotequote all
Don't identify yourself as the driver, respond as the keeper, otherwise you close off several avenues of appeal.

Open a case on ftla.uk and they will guide you through the process. Very high success rate if you follow thier advice

Simpo Two

88,533 posts

278 months

Thursday 3rd April
quotequote all
Quite ridiculous IMHO, you shouldn't need a bloody smartphone and an internet to pay for parking. What if the battery's flat or there was no signal? And as for only using 'apple pay on safari'...

Sheepshanks

36,482 posts

132 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
Which car park was this? I’d have been concerned it was a payment scam.

E-bmw

10,731 posts

165 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
Which car park was this? I’d have been concerned it was a payment scam.
^^^^ Wot 'e said.

Although obviously there was a real car park hiding there for the PCN to come through.

mac96

4,926 posts

156 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
I'd like to know which car park it was as well, so I can avoid it!

Racing Newt

1,260 posts

218 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
Safari?? that was discontinued in 2012 was it not??

Gixer968CS

731 posts

101 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
Racing Newt said:
Safari?? that was discontinued in 2012 was it not??
Nope, it's standard on all All devices - iOS and Mac. But, ApplePay does not use safari.

Alex_225

6,851 posts

214 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
Absolutely appeal it! There are grace periods for this kind of thing and 12 minutes is not unreasonable.


qwerty360

242 posts

58 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
IMHO appeal.

While the usual rule is 10 minutes grace, your argument is that several methods of payment didn't work and 10 minutes is to read the rules...



For future, photo the parking machine wrapped up so you can prove non-functionality.

Possibly you may also have records on apple pay and/or bank for transaction failures; These would be very, very useful as it provides proof (+timing) that you attempted to pay then promptly left when you couldn't do so.

carl_w

9,769 posts

271 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
In your appeal also ask them to provide evidence of any other payments received around the time of the driver's alleged infraction. If the machine was taped up there were probably no such transactions that day.

macp

Original Poster:

4,297 posts

196 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
Thanks all

So to update I appealed and got a letter back today. Which in amongst it all, I think means pay £20 to cover our admin costs etc.

Thank you for your appeal received on 03/04/2025 regarding the above detailed Parking Charge Notice (PCN).
We have reviewed the case and considered the comments that you have made. This appeal has been considered
in conjunction with the evidence gathered and our records show that the PCN was correctly issued as your
vehicle was parked in breach of the Terms and Conditions of Parking.
The location where the vehicle was parked is private land and for use by paying customers. It is the drivers
responsibility to ensure that the correct vehicle registration number (VRN) is entered in the electronic system
using the relevant 'on-line', 'App' pre-pay service or Pay & Display machine.
Prior to leaving the car park the driver is responsible for ensuring that the VRN has been successfully recorded on
the electronic system or machine.

However, in this instance, we will be willing to waive the PCN charge subject to an administration
payment of £20 being made which is in contribution to the costs associated with the issue of the PCN,
DVLA costs and other administration costs.
We are therefore unable to cancel the PCN as it was issued correctly. We have now extended the discounted
payment period by 14 days to allow you time to pay the discounted settlement amount. Please now make
payment of £20 to reach us by 18/04/2025 or £100 to reach us by 02/05/2025. We must advise you that once the
discounted settlement rate passes it will not be offered again.


For those asking where the parking lot was. Here is a screenshot. I have roughly circled the location of the lot.


hidetheelephants

29,483 posts

206 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
£20 for admn? rofl Thieving bds.

Pica-Pica

15,015 posts

97 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
As they are willing to waive the full amount, will they take you to court for £20?
They are saying both, we are right to charge you the full amount, but are also willing to let you pay just the admin cost. Their ‘admin’ should have pointed them in the direction of ‘no fee payable’ so any admin cost is theirs to bear, surely?

Simpo Two

88,533 posts

278 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
'Please now make payment of £20 to reach us by 18/04/2025 or £100 to reach us by 02/05/2025.'

So this admin charge quintuples after a fortnight? That's a funny way to charge admin; it smells a bit like blackmail.

You got a PCN because you drove out without paying... but now I wonder if the label you saw was fake. Did the company really have a working method of payment or have they sent PCNs to everyone because there was in fact no way to pay?

Vanden Saab

15,710 posts

87 months

Friday 4th April
quotequote all
Assuming they have given you details of how to pay then pay them for parking for the time you were there.
Covering email telling them what you have done with payment details. Stating you have paid as soon as you were able to.

Colonel Cupcake

1,235 posts

58 months

Saturday 5th April
quotequote all
hidetheelephants said:
£20 for admn? rofl Thieving bds.
The poster should be deducting his own admin. £20 should cover it.

Simpo Two

88,533 posts

278 months

Saturday 5th April
quotequote all
Vanden Saab said:
Assuming they have given you details of how to pay then pay them for parking for the time you were there.
Covering email telling them what you have done with payment details. Stating you have paid as soon as you were able to.
If this is true I'd have thought the OP is home and dry because there were no means to pay. I would also send a photo of the label and the machine with a bag over it (if still there).

Gixer968CS said:
Nope, it's standard on all All devices - iOS and Mac. But, ApplePay does not use safari.
Perhaps time to call them if possible and sort it out person to person; it usually gets better results.



Edited by Simpo Two on Saturday 5th April 09:24