Liability in car park accident
Liability in car park accident
Author
Discussion

romeogolf

Original Poster:

2,112 posts

150 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
Imagine a tight office car park. On one side, between two marked bays, is a yellow-boxed area which clears the way to an electricity substation. In this space a builder has stored an item which is low to the ground. The builder was not given permission to store the item there.

A driver reverses into this item and damages his car while trying to exit.

In your opinion, who is at fault?

counterofbeans

1,092 posts

170 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
romeogolf said:
Imagine a tight office car park. On one side, between two marked bays, is a yellow-boxed area which clears the way to an electricity substation. In this space a builder has stored an item which is low to the ground. The builder was not given permission to store the item there.

A driver reverses into this item and damages his car while trying to exit.

In your opinion, who is at fault?
The driver.

DaveH23

3,355 posts

201 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
counterofbeans said:
The driver.
This.

He crashed in to a static object. What if that was a person stood there?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
romeogolf said:
Imagine a tight office car park. On one side, between two marked bays, is a yellow-boxed area which clears the way to an electricity substation. In this space a builder has stored an item which is low to the ground. The builder was not given permission to store the item there.

A driver reverses into this item and damages his car while trying to exit.

In your opinion, who is at fault?
Driver.
Didn't check the area adequately before reversing into it.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
I would initally say Driver and if its daylight then still go with that

We had a similar incident here recently with a lorry loader being left in the middle of the loading area and someone reversed into it, but it was pitch black and the loader should have been lit so he got it fixed by the company

captain_cynic

17,657 posts

126 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
counterofbeans said:
romeogolf said:
Imagine a tight office car park. On one side, between two marked bays, is a yellow-boxed area which clears the way to an electricity substation. In this space a builder has stored an item which is low to the ground. The builder was not given permission to store the item there.

A driver reverses into this item and damages his car while trying to exit.

In your opinion, who is at fault?
The driver.
This, driver was not looking where they were going.

TartanPaint

3,367 posts

170 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
Driver.

Unless the driver happens to be a snowflake with a lot of outraged Instagram followers, and parents who never taught them to take responsibility for their actions. Then it's probably the builder.

Sir Bagalot

7,114 posts

212 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
I don't think this is going the way the OP hopedlaugh

ghe13rte

1,860 posts

147 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
romeogolf said:
Imagine a tight office car park. On one side, between two marked bays, is a yellow-boxed area which clears the way to an electricity substation. In this space a builder has stored an item which is low to the ground. The builder was not given permission to store the item there.

A driver reverses into this item and damages his car while trying to exit.

In your opinion, who is at fault?
You, the driver, by the look of it.

romeogolf

Original Poster:

2,112 posts

150 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
Sir Bagalot said:
I don't think this is going the way the OP hopedlaugh
Hah, I'm not the driver. I'm the one the driver is chasing for compensation. laugh

I specifically didn't include that in the post to ensure people gave their most nuanced replies and tried to make all 3 parties look at fault.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,294 posts

181 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
romeogolf said:
Hah, I'm not the driver. I'm the one the driver is chasing for compensation. laugh

I specifically didn't include that in the post to ensure people gave their most nuanced replies and tried to make all 3 parties look at fault.
rofl

Nice one OP. thumbup

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
Does the car park have a sign disclaiming responsibility ?

Byker28i

93,721 posts

248 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
Is the car park Private property. Sue the driver for damage to the builders property. biggrin

Dan_1981

18,129 posts

230 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
The local Golf Club.

Sue them.

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
TIght Office Ltd is to blame.

Nezquick

1,859 posts

157 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
DaveH23 said:
counterofbeans said:
The driver.
This.

He crashed in to a static object. What if that was a person stood there?
Absolutely this.

It's like kerbing your alloys and then blaming the council for putting the kerb there. Idiotic!

Pericoloso

44,044 posts

194 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
Left field reply.

Sue the electricity company.......silly

ghe13rte

1,860 posts

147 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
romeogolf said:
Sir Bagalot said:
I don't think this is going the way the OP hopedlaugh
Hah, I'm not the driver. I'm the one the driver is chasing for compensation. laugh

I specifically didn't include that in the post to ensure people gave their most nuanced replies and tried to make all 3 parties look at fault.
The driver owes you some insurance details.

Pica-Pica

16,729 posts

115 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
Stored or placed an item there?
Yellow hatched area, not in a marked bay - driver.

DocJock

8,722 posts

271 months

Tuesday 24th July 2018
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Their car doesn't have working reversing lights then?