write off valuation
Author
Discussion

pinchmeimdreamin

Original Poster:

10,919 posts

249 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Hi guys,

It looks like our megane is going to be a write off, my problem is when they value it I believe they don't take into account factory fitted options ( the car had all the boxes ticked by its original owner plus full world series body kit).

I have checked autotrader etc and cannot find a similar specced car for sale anywhere, so am I going to have to settle for the value of a basic model or do I have any room for manouvre.

Any help appreciated.

bradjsmith88

117 posts

159 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
http://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/publications...

Glasses guide has the facility to include options.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
When it was insured did you declare all the factory fitted options?

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
It's a question of fact really. If the options add value, you'd be entitled to that value in the write-off.

The fact that you can't realistically obtain that spec again doesn't mean that you can add on the new parts cost to a base price, if only because that would get you a much nicer car than the retail value of the car would.

pinchmeimdreamin

Original Poster:

10,919 posts

249 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
I don't expect to be able to add on the cost of the extras per se, but the difference in value of a used car with and without the options would be fairly different if I was able to find any for sale.

AndyNetwork

1,849 posts

225 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
CYMR0 said:
It's a question of fact really. If the options add value, you'd be entitled to that value in the write-off.

The fact that you can't realistically obtain that spec again doesn't mean that you can add on the new parts cost to a base price, if only because that would get you a much nicer car than the retail value of the car would.
But by the same extent - he should be returned to the position he was in prior to the write off, therefore if the only way to get a similar spec of car is to buy a basic car, and add the options afterwards, then why should this not be acceptable.

Perhaps if it is so difficult to source a similar spec of car for the price offered, ask the insurance co to source one. It could change their minds on the value.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
When it was insured did you declare all the factory fitted options?
This!
Most people don't bother to declare the factory options as they don't think they need to.
But, if you want to claim for them you need to declare them.

There are a few exceptions where there are standard options for a model type.
For example a lx might have leather while an l has cloth (with leather as an option).

Afaik, it's not illegal to not declare a factory option at all - but it can change the amount you get in the event of a write-off.

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
This!
Most people don't bother to declare the factory options as they don't think they need to.
But, if you want to claim for them you need to declare them.

There are a few exceptions where there are standard options for a model type.
For example a lx might have leather while an l has cloth (with leather as an option).

Afaik, it's not illegal to not declare a factory option at all - but it can change the amount you get in the event of a write-off.
Conversely should you declare if your car has a big scratch down one side and rusty wheel arches to ensure you don't get betterment?

Isn't it enough to tell them the value of the car when you take out the policy and then justify that value when the time comes to make a claim? I don't recall ever being asked to declare factory fitted options.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
General Fluff said:
Conversely should you declare if your car has a big scratch down one side and rusty wheel arches to ensure you don't get betterment?

Isn't it enough to tell them the value of the car when you take out the policy and then justify that value when the time comes to make a claim? I don't recall ever being asked to declare factory fitted options.
I don't know, I guess that's why they ask you the value of the car and why they employ insurance adjustors.

I guess it's only a problem with cars with loads of nonstandard options or with a particularly rare option or combination of options.


Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
General Fluff said:
Conversely should you declare if your car has a big scratch down one side and rusty wheel arches to ensure you don't get betterment?
No. The pre crash condition can be determined after an accident, although if you're going to write off your rusty old motor, a good old burn up is probably a good idea biggrin

I've been asked to declare factory options when taking out car insurance.

rscott

17,532 posts

222 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
General Fluff said:
Conversely should you declare if your car has a big scratch down one side and rusty wheel arches to ensure you don't get betterment?

Isn't it enough to tell them the value of the car when you take out the policy and then justify that value when the time comes to make a claim? I don't recall ever being asked to declare factory fitted options.
I don't know, I guess that's why they ask you the value of the car and why they employ insurance adjustors.

I guess it's only a problem with cars with loads of nonstandard options or with a particularly rare option or combination of options.
This varies from insurer to insurer - my current one wasn't interested in details of any factory options, but stated they would be covered.

AndyNetwork

1,849 posts

225 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
No. The pre crash condition can be determined after an accident, although if you're going to write off your rusty old motor, a good old burn up is probably a good idea biggrin

I've been asked to declare factory options when taking out car insurance.
OK, we on here are likely to know what are and are not factory or even dealer fit options, but not everyone will know - how many Mk iv golfs do you see with alloys over steel wheels? most of them are options, but would you know for sure?

I know that my Skoda has an upgraded stereo, and cruise control which are options, but given this was the one and only car I looked at when buying it, had I not looked up the spec after I bought it, I would not necessarily know they were options.

That is why I declare those options, as I know they are options, however, the first time I insured it, and was asked "Is it a standard UK Model?" I answered "As far as I am aware" It is then down to the insurance company to prove that you know they are options.

Edited by AndyNetwork on Tuesday 26th November 15:21

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
AndyNetwork said:
OK, we on here are likely to know what are and are not factory or even dealer fit options, but not everyone will know - how many Mk iv golfs do you see with alloys over steel wheels? most of them are options, but would you know for sure?

I know that my Skoda has an upgraded stereo, and cruise control which are options, but given this was the one and only car I looked at when buying it, had I not looked up the spec after I bought it, I would not necessarily know they were options.

That is why I declare those options, as I know they are options, however, the first time I insured it, and was asked "Is it a standard UK Model?" I answered "As far as I am aware" It is then down to the insurance company to prove that you know they are options.

Edited by AndyNetwork on Tuesday 26th November 15:21
Good point and something that has crossed my mind before. How do I know what is an option and what isn't on a second hand car...

AndrewEH1

4,922 posts

184 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
AndyNetwork said:
OK, we on here are likely to know what are and are not factory or even dealer fit options, but not everyone will know - how many Mk iv golfs do you see with alloys over steel wheels? most of them are options, but would you know for sure?

I know that my Skoda has an upgraded stereo, and cruise control which are options, but given this was the one and only car I looked at when buying it, had I not looked up the spec after I bought it, I would not necessarily know they were options.

That is why I declare those options, as I know they are options, however, the first time I insured it, and was asked "Is it a standard UK Model?" I answered "As far as I am aware" It is then down to the insurance company to prove that you know they are options.

Edited by AndyNetwork on Tuesday 26th November 15:21
Good point and something that has crossed my mind before. How do I know what is an option and what isn't on a second hand car...
+1

Bought a used 2004 Audi in the summer, not sure what is and isn't an option...

Anyone know if you can contact a dealer and get them to look it up?

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
AndrewEH1 said:
+1

Bought a used 2004 Audi in the summer, not sure what is and isn't an option...

Anyone know if you can contact a dealer and get them to look it up?
I'm sure you can. I've done it before, not for insurance purposes, but because i'm a bit of a car geek. I've also kept fuel consumption data in a spreadsheet before now nerd

AndrewEH1

4,922 posts

184 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
I'm sure you can. I've done it before, not for insurance purposes, but because i'm a bit of a car geek. I've also kept fuel consumption data in a spreadsheet before now nerd
I'll give them a call at some point soon then!

I've already got a MPG spreadsheet running... getmecoat

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
AndyNetwork said:
But by the same extent - he should be returned to the position he was in prior to the write off, therefore if the only way to get a similar spec of car is to buy a basic car, and add the options afterwards, then why should this not be acceptable.
Because if the base car is worth £7k and the options would cost £5k to add, no one would actually spend £12k on a base car and then adding the options.

Instead the nicer car may have been worth £7,500.

If, instead of "car A, worth £7,500" OP now has either £7,500, or "car B, worth £7,500" how has he really lost out?


Edited by CYMR0 on Tuesday 26th November 23:39

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
AndrewEH1 said:
Devil2575 said:
I'm sure you can. I've done it before, not for insurance purposes, but because i'm a bit of a car geek. I've also kept fuel consumption data in a spreadsheet before now nerd
I'll give them a call at some point soon then!

I've already got a MPG spreadsheet running... getmecoat
You can't beat a good spreadsheet! biggrin

pinchmeimdreamin

Original Poster:

10,919 posts

249 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
CYMR0 said:
Because if the base car is worth £7k and the options would cost £5k to add, no one would actually spend £12k on a base car + options.

Instead the base car may have been worth £7,500.

If, instead of "car A, worth £7,500" OP now has either £7,500, or "car B, worth £7,500" how has he really lost out?
Funny you should mention £7,500.
The cheapest car I can find within 200 miles, same model, similar miles not as well specced is £7495

elanfan

5,527 posts

258 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Insurance is meant to put you in the same position after a claim as before it. If they don't offer enough to replace then tell them to obtain a replacement the car for you.