Legalities of towing with an A frame
Legalities of towing with an A frame
Author
Discussion

eggchaser1987

Original Poster:

1,620 posts

179 months

Sunday 27th May 2018
quotequote all
Hi all, I'm after a bit of advice on towing. Not sure if this is the correct part to put this in but if it's not I'm sure the mods will move it.

I am trying to find out if I can tow a car using an 'A frame' with out having to go through the B+E licence. I have no issue of doing this but it will not be as soon as I would want to tow, also an A frame would take up a lot less space than a trailer.

I have the 'B' category on my licence as i passed my test prior to 2013 but this will not let me have a trailer over 750kg, I do have experience with tractor trailers and reversing parents horse box and estate (as they could not really get the hang of it so asked me!) but no doubt this will help me with a test.

If it makes any difference I am looking at towing a 2005 Ford fiesta st to hill climb and sprint races behind ether a T4 camper or a Mondeo Estate.

Thanks

bolide

582 posts

284 months

Monday 28th May 2018
quotequote all
In the eyes of the DOT a car on an A-frame is a trailer so you'll need the appropriate licence

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/a-frame...

The trailer (ie, Fiesta) will have to have brakes operated by the tow car as it will be > 750 Kg

You'll be better off with a small trailer and the correct licence

Nick Froome

R0G

5,036 posts

185 months

Monday 28th May 2018
quotequote all
Lets see if this works on a B licence …..

Ford Mondeo GVW 2000kg with a tow limit of 1500kg

Ford Fiesta empty weight 1000kg

Now we need a car transporter trailer which has a max MAM of 1500kg and weighs no more than 500kg empty
Trailer Tek have one which is 400 empty and plated at 1600 but that be down plated to 1500 which means you end up with a trailer able to carry an 1100 load

Set up done



TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

156 months

Monday 28th May 2018
quotequote all
Trailer, with B+E if you need it.

A-frames really are an utter compromise, even before you get to the legality. If you have an off and bend it, you're not A-framing it home. If you blow the gearbox up, you're not A-framing it home. If you're A-framing a pure track car, which isn't (or doesn't look) road-legal, you're going to get police attention at the very least.

eggchaser1987

Original Poster:

1,620 posts

179 months

Monday 28th May 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice. Fiesta is fully road legal so that would not be a problem, but by the sound of it I will have to get saving, do my test and find somewhere to put a trailer.

Thanks

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

156 months

Monday 28th May 2018
quotequote all
eggchaser1987 said:
...and find somewhere to put a trailer.
Rent one when required...?

grumpy52

6,064 posts

196 months

Monday 28th May 2018
quotequote all
A frames are illegal in many Euro countries, for good reason in my opinion .
Get your test done and get a trailer .
Do as I used to do , park the racer on the trailer .
My garage was big enough to push the trailer in nose first and then run the car on .
Tip , block the rear of the trailer to stop the front tipping up and wrecking the workbench then punching a hole in the roof as you load the car on .

In Arduis Fouette

97 posts

101 months

Monday 28th May 2018
quotequote all

unless it part of a full conversion ( linking brakes and lighting) as seen with some of the cars towed behind motorhomes an A frame is a recovery tool ( even then the recovery firms tend not to use them any more in favour of RDTs)

Chozza

808 posts

182 months

Monday 28th May 2018
quotequote all
grumpy52 said:
Tip , block the rear of the trailer to stop the front tipping up and wrecking the workbench then punching a hole in the roof as you load the car on .
Ouch... Got any pics?

grumpy52

6,064 posts

196 months

Monday 28th May 2018
quotequote all
Chozza said:
grumpy52 said:
Tip , block the rear of the trailer to stop the front tipping up and wrecking the workbench then punching a hole in the roof as you load the car on .
Ouch... Got any pics?
Pre camera phone days !
Thankfully most of my "blunders" were pre internet .
God I feel old at the realisation that was over 35 years ago !

dhutch

17,827 posts

227 months

Monday 28th May 2018
quotequote all
I would certainly say trailer if you can, and certainly not worry about the trailer test.

Yet to do mine, and it is faff to get the time off work, but I know quite a few who have done it and in the grand scheme it's not expensive or hard.

Obviously if you can store the trailer under the car that saves space, if putting one on the other often you can fit rear stands.

I've got a (tatty) covered box trailer and when I want garage space the car moves out into the trailer, which is where it lived when I was at uni.


Daniel

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

156 months

Tuesday 29th May 2018
quotequote all
dhutch said:
I would certainly say trailer if you can, and certainly not worry about the trailer test.

Yet to do mine, and it is faff to get the time off work, but I know quite a few who have done it and in the grand scheme it's not expensive or hard.
And, of course, if you DO find it hard, then it's definitely for the best that you're not tooling about without doing it...

Derek Smith

49,867 posts

278 months

Tuesday 29th May 2018
quotequote all
I've done a little towing with an A-frame as well as a great deal of towing a single axle trailer. The latter is by far the easier method.

The A-frame requires a skills level that takes a time to learn and there is little similarity between it and trailer towing when it comes to reversing. It's great fun to try but that's not, I assume, what you are after. I'd towed various trailers for years and the transition was not smooth.


syl

693 posts

105 months

Tuesday 29th May 2018
quotequote all
eggchaser1987 said:
I have the 'B' category on my licence as i passed my test prior to 2013 but this will not let me have a trailer over 750kg, I do have experience with tractor trailers and reversing parents horse box and estate (as they could not really get the hang of it so asked me!) but no doubt this will help me with a test.
That’s not the rules though, is it?

As someone else has already mentioned, without actually pointing out your error, you can tow more than 750kg without B+E - you’ll be limited by a combined MAM of 3500kg.

dhutch

17,827 posts

227 months

Thursday 31st May 2018
quotequote all
syl said:
As someone else has already mentioned, without actually pointing out your error, you can tow more than 750kg without B+E - you’ll be limited by a combined MAM of 3500kg.
This.

With the right towcar you can get upto about a 1200kg MAM trailer. Which allows for a car of maybe 800kg with the right trailer.

You can down-plate a trailer to whatever weight you want, just buy a blank plate of eBay, mark it up and stick it on.


Daniel



TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

156 months

Thursday 31st May 2018
quotequote all
dhutch said:
You can down-plate a trailer to whatever weight you want, just buy a blank plate of eBay, mark it up and stick it on.
And if a trailer doesn't have a VIN/weight plate (because it's <ahem> old enough), the MAM is simply the sum of the tyre loads.

dhutch

17,827 posts

227 months

Friday 1st June 2018
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
And if a trailer doesn't have a VIN/weight plate (because it's <ahem> old enough), the MAM is simply the sum of the tyre loads.
I was told it was 3x the unladen weight. Unless the exceeded the tyres/suspension. But just put a plate ob it!


Daniel

R0G

5,036 posts

185 months

Sunday 10th June 2018
quotequote all
dhutch said:
You can down-plate a trailer to whatever weight you want, just buy a blank plate of eBay, mark it up and stick it on.


Daniel
Not legal to do that

Only the trailer manufacturer can down plate a trailer

dhutch

17,827 posts

227 months

Monday 11th June 2018
quotequote all
Interesting. Where have you heard that?

I asked a couple of places, can't remember details as it was a while ago, and was repeated told there wasn't anywhere I could go to get it down plated in terms of a dvla/vosa (now dvsa) type job and just do it myself, make sure the numbers where not more than the tyres said. This included ringing the local police force and being put though to a traffic officer. However, mine is also a diy built affair if not built by me. So that might have played a factor.

At what point do you become the manufacturer? Change of tyres, new floor and adding some tie down points?

Daniel

Edited by dhutch on Monday 11th June 08:27

R0G

5,036 posts

185 months

Monday 11th June 2018
quotequote all
My info comes from DVSA and traffic police as well as the manufacturers

If you wish to verify the law you can email your MP who will get the DfT minister to verify the law and then send that reply to you