Man prosecuted for taking dead deer
Man prosecuted for taking dead deer
Author
Discussion

otolith

Original Poster:

68,467 posts

233 months

Yesterday (20:46)
quotequote all
Given how overstretched our justice system is, how on earth is this in the public interest?

https://www.darlingtonandstocktontimes.co.uk/news/...

Foss62

1,975 posts

94 months

Yesterday (21:56)
quotequote all
Seems like madness to me. It also calls into question what most people believe regarding roadkill - that as long as you didn’t hit it yourself, you can take it.
The landowner here, is presumably the highways authority?

bobtail4x4

4,392 posts

138 months

Yesterday (22:01)
quotequote all
its theft

it belongs to whoever owns the land it died on,

must be more to this,

Hereward

5,090 posts

259 months

Yesterday (22:14)
quotequote all
May be one of those cases where the letter of the law is being applied with no recourse to common sense. Hopefully common sense will now prevail.

There was a squashed fox on my road. As I was carrying it to move it into the undergrowth a police car drove by. I did a shrug and a lame smile and they drove on by. Seems like I got away with it.

Landlubber

1,320 posts

78 months

Yesterday (22:15)
quotequote all
I dont think you are mate.

Courser

98 posts

2 months

Yesterday (22:15)
quotequote all
If it was on a main road or roadside verge it would be the council.
They lift them and put them in the bin,

Stupid of the police to think this is a worthwhile prosecution, and who the hell decided it should go to court ?

God knows I’ve lifted plenty, usually in front of the person who hit it.
On one occasion the driver was on the phone to the police so I told them directly I was taking it, they were quite happy.
The drivers face when I folded it into the boot of an MX5 was a picture.

I’ve also killed a fair number of deer that had been hit by cars just as I was passing ( dense population of Roe in my area)

Courser

98 posts

2 months

Yesterday (22:16)
quotequote all
Hereward said:
May be one of those cases where the letter of the law is being applied with no recourse to common sense. Hopefully common sense will now prevail.

There was a squashed fox on my road. As I was carrying it to move it into the undergrowth a police car drove by. I did a shrug and a lame smile and they drove on by. Seems like I got away with it.
This law only applies to deer.

LunarOne

7,302 posts

166 months

Yesterday (22:20)
quotequote all
A friend of mine spends a significant portion of his time shooting deer at the behest of the landowner, and he takes many of them home to gralloch and butcher.

He told me many years ago that anyone may take roadkill as long as they were not involved in the death of the animal itself - and I must admit that this was already my understanding of the law. If it isn't correct, then it does nevertheless seem to be prevailing wisdom.

I remember him being hauled in front of HR after parking in the office car park with a dead deer (which he'd come across on his way to work) hanging from one of his roof rails. He'd made every effort to park at the far end of the car park with the carcass facing towards the woods that surrounded the car park so as not to alarm anyone, but someone still made a complaint.

Anyway, I think it's pretty ridiculous that the police have taken it this far.

Hereward

5,090 posts

259 months

Yesterday (22:20)
quotequote all
Courser said:
This law only applies to deer.
Doh, thanks, I hadn't processed that key bit of information.

Starfighter

5,342 posts

207 months

Yesterday (22:22)
quotequote all
That could create some unintended consequences. If a person were to hit a dead der deer causing damage does the driver then have a claim on National Highways?

LunarOne

7,302 posts

166 months

Yesterday (22:25)
quotequote all
Starfighter said:
That could create some unintended consequences. If a person were to hit a dead der deer causing damage does the driver then have a claim on National Highways?
I don't see how if they only become the property of National Highways upon death.

Leptons

5,493 posts

205 months

Yesterday (23:25)
quotequote all
Is this the same Durham police that allowed a large crowd to gather, release balloons and set fire to stolen cars unchallenged last week?

Mumsnet

57 posts

4 months

Hereward said:
Courser said:
This law only applies to deer.
Doh, thanks....
A female deer? [/Simpsons Movie]

Hereward

5,090 posts

259 months

Mumsnet said:
Hereward said:
Courser said:
This law only applies to deer.
Doh, thanks....
A female deer? [/Simpsons Movie]
I've no idea (geddit?).

Yellow Lizud

2,920 posts

193 months

Hereward said:
Mumsnet said:
Hereward said:
Courser said:
This law only applies to deer.
Doh, thanks....
A female deer? [/Simpsons Movie]
I've no idea (geddit?).
That's a blind elk, completely different!

Pica-Pica

16,541 posts

113 months

Yellow Lizud said:
Hereward said:
Mumsnet said:
Hereward said:
Courser said:
This law only applies to deer.
Doh, thanks....
A female deer? [/Simpsons Movie]
I've no idea (geddit?).
That's a blind elk, completely different!
Still no idea, that's a dead, blind elk.