Seat belts have not reduced the overall road death rate?
Seat belts have not reduced the overall road death rate?
Author
Discussion

Peter Ward

Original Poster:

2,097 posts

287 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Apparently, last week the government issued a press release to say that seat belts have saved 60,000 lives since their introduction, or 2400/year.

In response to that, John Adams has written a blog entry: http://john-adams.co.uk/2006/12/16/britains-seat-b...

This is supported by a scientific paper, available at the same link.

He concludes from his research that seat belts have actually moved the risk from drivers/passengers to pedestrians and cyclists. There has in fact been no noticable overall drop in deaths. He doesn't question the benefits of wearing a belt in an accident, but says that the increased perceived safety causes drivers to behave differently and therefore the risk of death for all road users does not change. He has interesting graphs in his paper that show this.

Definitely worth a read, even if just to show yet another area where the government is spinning the truth.

mmm-five

12,403 posts

315 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Airbag probably have the same effect too!

How about a spike instead of an airbag - I bet people would drive more 'cautiously' wink

I still think cars should be safest on the driver's behalf - sod the pedestrian as they shouldn't be on the road, plus to stop the car invading the pedestrian space you could use barriers, fences, etc.

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
I still think cars should be safest on the driver's behalf - sod the pedestrian as they shouldn't be on the road, plus to stop the car invading the pedestrian space you could use barriers, fences, etc.
Cobblers - anyone who pays council tax is allowed to use the road.


Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
I like the idea of a list of laws that should be repealed. I reckon that it would be better to have two chambers in government: the Commons to pass laws and an upper house to repeal those they feel unnecessary or have served their purpose. Or another method would be to say we have enough laws at the moment and if the government wants to pass a law it must repeal one first.

Whilst you can criticise the government for its ‘spin’ on seatbelts saving 60,000 lives, John Adams is just as guilty of ‘spin’ by suggesting that they have not. Risk compensation is a theory that may not be applicable to most motorists. I’m not sure I take them into consideration when considering an overtake for instance. I am considering fitting full harnesses to my TVR but I can’t see that making me take more risks. I mean, they don’t protect a car’s paintwork do they? And that’s more important than a few injuries.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
I like the idea of a list of laws that should be repealed. I reckon that it would be better to have two chambers in government: the Commons to pass laws and an upper house to repeal those they feel unnecessary or have served their purpose. Or another method would be to say we have enough laws at the moment and if the government wants to pass a law it must repeal one first.

Whilst you can criticise the government for its ‘spin’ on seatbelts saving 60,000 lives, John Adams is just as guilty of ‘spin’ by suggesting that they have not. Risk compensation is a theory that may not be applicable to most motorists. I’m not sure I take them into consideration when considering an overtake for instance. I am considering fitting full harnesses to my TVR but I can’t see that making me take more risks. I mean, they don’t protect a car’s paintwork do they? And that’s more important than a few injuries.
There is good evidence for risk homeostasis. Whether it applies in all situations is less clear. Its probably not just seat belts though, cars have got bigger and safer too, increasing the feeling of safety for occupants.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
I don't know which is being used as a measure, but the figure you need is deaths per '000 rather than the absolute number of deaths per year.

I would argue that with the road using population having increased so dramatically, this in itself has increased the likelyhood of collisions by a large multiple, based on the theory that the more cars share the same space, the more likely they are to collide.

What I would argue is that the level of injuries and fatalities is kept as it is by the improvements in active and passive car safety, rather than active and passive measures employed to enforce the RTA.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Well I like them. It saves wasting a lot of time searching for the body at fatals.... ;-)

I see what he is saying but I would suggest that although that may make a proportion of drivers increase risk taking it won't be all who wear seat belts. Its very hard to look at figures pre-legislation and now as its been in force so long and the road conditions are very different.

I would say that the net benefit is an overall reduction. Which means they are worthwhile.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Bing o said:
mmm-five said:
I still think cars should be safest on the driver's behalf - sod the pedestrian as they shouldn't be on the road, plus to stop the car invading the pedestrian space you could use barriers, fences, etc.
Cobblers - anyone who pays council tax is allowed to use the road.
What,you mean just be able to waltz across as they wish..?confused

mmm-five

12,403 posts

315 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Bing o said:
mmm-five said:
I still think cars should be safest on the driver's behalf - sod the pedestrian as they shouldn't be on the road, plus to stop the car invading the pedestrian space you could use barriers, fences, etc.
Cobblers - anyone who pays council tax is allowed to use the road.
Then I should be allowed to drive/park on the pavement then!

bryan35

1,906 posts

272 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
allowed to use the road for what?

a tea party?, a game of football?


I thought that roads were just for the use of any 'assisted' transport, - cars, bikes, horses, etc.

Not for pedestrians. (unless there's no pavement of course, but even then to rules)

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Well I like them. It saves wasting a lot of time searching for the body at fatals.... ;-)

I see what he is saying but I would suggest that although that may make a proportion of drivers increase risk taking it won't be all who wear seat belts. Its very hard to look at figures pre-legislation and now as its been in force so long and the road conditions are very different.

I would say that the net benefit is an overall reduction. Which means they are worthwhile.
I agree.

The article and the supporting 'evidence' is a work of spin, attributing a single factor into a trend of a huge number of variants and getting a biased outcome.

Let look at the situation *now*, and put his arguments into context. Lets imagine that it is no longer compulsory to wear a seatbelt.

His argument seems to suggest that since I passed my test a decade ago, I would now drive in a more risky way than if I didn't have to wear my seatbelt for this period. Rubbish. I am perfectly happy wearing my seatbelt.

I personally know of at least one of my classmates at school who dies as they were flung from a car without a seatbelt on. For God's sake, everyone has seen the huge amount of evidence from the Diana crash. One person survived, the rest died... A co-incidence that he was the only one wearing a seatbelt? Considering that it was his corner of the car that was demolished by the crash he was lucky to be alive. Of course, the fact that the driver didn't wear a seatbelt I don't think caused him to drive safely either!?

So apart from me, who would choose to exert their right not to wear a belt? It would be the particular demographic who are by nature risk takers - the same type of person who may choose to drive in a less responsible fashion and take more driving risks.

If we follow his argument through, these people would take their belts off, and consciously or subconsciously drive more slowly or safely? I think not...

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
esselte said:
Bing o said:
mmm-five said:
I still think cars should be safest on the driver's behalf - sod the pedestrian as they shouldn't be on the road, plus to stop the car invading the pedestrian space you could use barriers, fences, etc.
Cobblers - anyone who pays council tax is allowed to use the road.
What,you mean just be able to waltz across as they wish..?confused
Within the bounds of what is permissable in the highway code - yes.

rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Well I like them. It saves wasting a lot of time searching for the body at fatals.... ;-)

I see what he is saying but I would suggest that although that may make a proportion of drivers increase risk taking it won't be all who wear seat belts. Its very hard to look at figures pre-legislation and now as its been in force so long and the road conditions are very different.

I would say that the net benefit is an overall reduction. Which means they are worthwhile.
I am sure you are right but taking into account the number of lives claimed to be saved each year by speed cameras, child booster seats, mobile phone enforcement, local 20mph limits, not eating apples etc. are we approaching the time when we may look forward to zero fatalities?

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Well I like them. It saves wasting a lot of time searching for the body at fatals.... ;-)

I see what he is saying but I would suggest that although that may make a proportion of drivers increase risk taking it won't be all who wear seat belts. Its very hard to look at figures pre-legislation and now as its been in force so long and the road conditions are very different.

I would say that the net benefit is an overall reduction. Which means they are worthwhile.
I agree.

The article and the supporting 'evidence' is a work of spin, attributing a single factor into a trend of a huge number of variants and getting a biased outcome.

Let look at the situation *now*, and put his arguments into context. Lets imagine that it is no longer compulsory to wear a seatbelt.

His argument seems to suggest that since I passed my test a decade ago, I would now drive in a more risky way than if I didn't have to wear my seatbelt for this period. Rubbish. I am perfectly happy wearing my seatbelt.

I personally know of at least one of my classmates at school who dies as they were flung from a car without a seatbelt on. For God's sake, everyone has seen the huge amount of evidence from the Diana crash. One person survived, the rest died... A co-incidence that he was the only one wearing a seatbelt? Considering that it was his corner of the car that was demolished by the crash he was lucky to be alive. Of course, the fact that the driver didn't wear a seatbelt I don't think caused him to drive safely either!?

So apart from me, who would choose to exert their right not to wear a belt? It would be the particular demographic who are by nature risk takers - the same type of person who may choose to drive in a less responsible fashion and take more driving risks.

If we follow his argument through, these people would take their belts off, and consciously or subconsciously drive more slowly or safely? I think not...
But thats what the evidence suggests. It may not be all due to feeling safer due to wearing a seatbelt, as I said bigger and safer cars must have a similar effect. What cannot be denied is that there was an increased rate of pedestrian deaths coinciding with the introduction of seatbelts. Risk homeostasis is a reasonable theory to explain that.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
JustinP1 said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Well I like them. It saves wasting a lot of time searching for the body at fatals.... ;-)

I see what he is saying but I would suggest that although that may make a proportion of drivers increase risk taking it won't be all who wear seat belts. Its very hard to look at figures pre-legislation and now as its been in force so long and the road conditions are very different.

I would say that the net benefit is an overall reduction. Which means they are worthwhile.
I agree.

The article and the supporting 'evidence' is a work of spin, attributing a single factor into a trend of a huge number of variants and getting a biased outcome.

Let look at the situation *now*, and put his arguments into context. Lets imagine that it is no longer compulsory to wear a seatbelt.

His argument seems to suggest that since I passed my test a decade ago, I would now drive in a more risky way than if I didn't have to wear my seatbelt for this period. Rubbish. I am perfectly happy wearing my seatbelt.

I personally know of at least one of my classmates at school who dies as they were flung from a car without a seatbelt on. For God's sake, everyone has seen the huge amount of evidence from the Diana crash. One person survived, the rest died... A co-incidence that he was the only one wearing a seatbelt? Considering that it was his corner of the car that was demolished by the crash he was lucky to be alive. Of course, the fact that the driver didn't wear a seatbelt I don't think caused him to drive safely either!?

So apart from me, who would choose to exert their right not to wear a belt? It would be the particular demographic who are by nature risk takers - the same type of person who may choose to drive in a less responsible fashion and take more driving risks.

If we follow his argument through, these people would take their belts off, and consciously or subconsciously drive more slowly or safely? I think not...
But thats what the evidence suggests. It may not be all due to feeling safer due to wearing a seatbelt, as I said bigger and safer cars must have a similar effect. What cannot be denied is that there was an increased rate of pedestrian deaths coinciding with the introduction of seatbelts. Risk homeostasis is a reasonable theory to explain that.
Not really.

Just because around the same time the introduction of seatbelts came in force the pedestrian deaths increased, the only coincident thing there is the time.

It is a bit like saying because it only rained today because I didn't wear a coat! This would be of course denying all possibility of any other factors in play for example, the fact that whether I wear a coat or not does not change the weather...

During that period, cars got faster, got larger, would these not affect the figures? Maybe the roadsense of pedestrians decreased too?

I forget the name of the 'law' and who coined it but basically when looking at factors like these it is statistically more likely to be the most connected, direct and likely culprit that one with a more tenuous link.

I don't think there was a similar increase in pedestrian deaths when airbags or safer cars were introduced?

Pickled Piper

6,452 posts

266 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
What a load of piffle. The risk compensation theory only works if all drivers initially drove without seat belts and then changed to wearing them. We have a large number of drivers like myself who have only ever driven with seat belts.

As well as reducing deaths, seat belts and more latterly airbags reduce serious injuries and facial trauma.

Ask any long serving A&E staff if there has been a reduction in deaths and they will point you to the lack of organ donors.

So much selective interpretation and so many flaws in the argument that I haven't got the time or the will to refute it.

pp

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
s2art said:
JustinP1 said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Well I like them. It saves wasting a lot of time searching for the body at fatals.... ;-)

I see what he is saying but I would suggest that although that may make a proportion of drivers increase risk taking it won't be all who wear seat belts. Its very hard to look at figures pre-legislation and now as its been in force so long and the road conditions are very different.

I would say that the net benefit is an overall reduction. Which means they are worthwhile.
I agree.

The article and the supporting 'evidence' is a work of spin, attributing a single factor into a trend of a huge number of variants and getting a biased outcome.

Let look at the situation *now*, and put his arguments into context. Lets imagine that it is no longer compulsory to wear a seatbelt.

His argument seems to suggest that since I passed my test a decade ago, I would now drive in a more risky way than if I didn't have to wear my seatbelt for this period. Rubbish. I am perfectly happy wearing my seatbelt.

I personally know of at least one of my classmates at school who dies as they were flung from a car without a seatbelt on. For God's sake, everyone has seen the huge amount of evidence from the Diana crash. One person survived, the rest died... A co-incidence that he was the only one wearing a seatbelt? Considering that it was his corner of the car that was demolished by the crash he was lucky to be alive. Of course, the fact that the driver didn't wear a seatbelt I don't think caused him to drive safely either!?

So apart from me, who would choose to exert their right not to wear a belt? It would be the particular demographic who are by nature risk takers - the same type of person who may choose to drive in a less responsible fashion and take more driving risks.

If we follow his argument through, these people would take their belts off, and consciously or subconsciously drive more slowly or safely? I think not...
But thats what the evidence suggests. It may not be all due to feeling safer due to wearing a seatbelt, as I said bigger and safer cars must have a similar effect. What cannot be denied is that there was an increased rate of pedestrian deaths coinciding with the introduction of seatbelts. Risk homeostasis is a reasonable theory to explain that.
Not really.

Just because around the same time the introduction of seatbelts came in force the pedestrian deaths increased, the only coincident thing there is the time.

It is a bit like saying because it only rained today because I didn't wear a coat! This would be of course denying all possibility of any other factors in play for example, the fact that whether I wear a coat or not does not change the weather...

During that period, cars got faster, got larger, would these not affect the figures? Maybe the roadsense of pedestrians decreased too?

I forget the name of the 'law' and who coined it but basically when looking at factors like these it is statistically more likely to be the most connected, direct and likely culprit that one with a more tenuous link.

I don't think there was a similar increase in pedestrian deaths when airbags or safer cars were introduced?
Take a look at the research. Countries which introduced seat belt laws saw increased pedestrian incidents, countries that didnt introduce seat belt laws didnt show the same trend.
And sure it may be coincidence, but the stats analysis says its the way to bet.

Jasandjules

72,695 posts

260 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
I don't about that, some of the Darwinesque cycling I've seen in Central London indicates that a lycra covered bag of water with a hat on Vs a one tonne car doesn't mean the bag of water defers.... Oh, and the last one I saw Vs a bus, that didn't end well for the cyclist either.

I don't think anyone is driving along and thinks, I bet I can crash into that pedestrian because of my lovely seatbelt......

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
I don't about that, some of the Darwinesque cycling I've seen in Central London indicates that a lycra covered bag of water with a hat on Vs a one tonne car doesn't mean the bag of water defers.... Oh, and the last one I saw Vs a bus, that didn't end well for the cyclist either.

I don't think anyone is driving along and thinks, I bet I can crash into that pedestrian because of my lovely seatbelt......
Nobody is claiming that. Just that they are more complaisant because they feel a bit safer.

Nick_F

10,598 posts

277 months

Thursday 28th February 2008
quotequote all
An increase in the proportion of fatalities that involved a pedestrial/cyclist or an increase in the absolute number of pedestrian/cyclist fatalities?

i.e. you have 1,000 fatalities a year;

600 are drivers
400 are pedestrians

therefore 40% of road deaths are pedestrians.

You introduce cumpulsory seatbelts.

You now have 800 fatalities a year;

400 are drives
400 are pedestrians

Shock, horror! Pedestrians now account for 50% of road deaths, so you have made the roads less safe for pedestrians, haven't you?