Same offence different fines
Discussion
Near where i live two 24 yr old drivers got done for driving with no insurance(no other offences) (seperate incidents in same area)
Driver 1 got 8 pen points and total of £492 in fines/costs
Driver 2 got 6 pen points and total of £142 in fines/costs
So why big difference- is Driver 2 a first time offender or is Driver 1 unlucky?
Driver 1 got 8 pen points and total of £492 in fines/costs
Driver 2 got 6 pen points and total of £142 in fines/costs
So why big difference- is Driver 2 a first time offender or is Driver 1 unlucky?
Jasandjules said:
One must question the legal ethics of fining someone based upon their income. The offence is at issue, NOT the ability of the offender to pay - at least, if JUSTICE was in mind.
So a multi millionaire should be able to commit crime with impunity. Means testing is intended to level the playing field so that the impact of punishment is the same. I think that is fair otherwise thelegal system would be even more waited in favour of those with money. Jasandjules said:
Not a bit of it. If the crime is serious enough to warrant meting out equivalent justice, then jail and various other options are available.
However, to stipulate that one is more culpable for a crime because one has a higher income is preposterous.
We've been here before, it's not a bigger fine for the richer it's a reduced one for those with an inability to pay that higher fine. You can't set the poor a fine they can't afford to pay, because that will result in prison for them (which the rich offender will not be in danger of through default).However, to stipulate that one is more culpable for a crime because one has a higher income is preposterous.
I know we've been here before, but my position hasn't changed...
If a crime is a crime, then it has a set value in terms of fine based upon various factors. For example, we could say speeding at night, reduce fine, speeding during day past a school during pick up time with kids all over the place, increase fine.
The offence is the offence, the punishment ought to be the punishment, income ought not to be a factor.

If a crime is a crime, then it has a set value in terms of fine based upon various factors. For example, we could say speeding at night, reduce fine, speeding during day past a school during pick up time with kids all over the place, increase fine.
The offence is the offence, the punishment ought to be the punishment, income ought not to be a factor.
But if a fine of X pounds for one person is 1% of their annual income and for another person is 5%, then the qualitative impact is vastly different as as such the richer person is being punished less.
If however we are talking about costs rather than fines then I agree whatever the costs are is what should be paid.
If however we are talking about costs rather than fines then I agree whatever the costs are is what should be paid.
jaik said:
But if a fine of X pounds for one person is 1% of their annual income and for another person is 5%, then the qualitative impact is vastly different as as such the richer person is being punished less.
If however we are talking about costs rather than fines then I agree whatever the costs are is what should be paid.
However, I might work 60 hour weeks to earn £30k per year, pay £6k in tax, have a mortgage of £12k a year, £2k council tax, bills etc, leaving me with £100 per week spare.If however we are talking about costs rather than fines then I agree whatever the costs are is what should be paid.
Compared to that there is someone who pays nothing to society, doesn't work and gets £100 per week in benefits from the state.
Who's £100 is more valuable?
And who's fine would likely be 2 or 3 as much as the others?
JustinP1 said:
jaik said:
But if a fine of X pounds for one person is 1% of their annual income and for another person is 5%, then the qualitative impact is vastly different as as such the richer person is being punished less.
If however we are talking about costs rather than fines then I agree whatever the costs are is what should be paid.
However, I might work 60 hour weeks to earn £30k per year, pay £6k in tax, have a mortgage of £12k a year, £2k council tax, bills etc, leaving me with £100 per week spare.If however we are talking about costs rather than fines then I agree whatever the costs are is what should be paid.
Compared to that there is someone who pays nothing to society, doesn't work and gets £100 per week in benefits from the state.
Who's £100 is more valuable?
And who's fine would likely be 2 or 3 as much as the others?
jaik said:
JustinP1 said:
jaik said:
But if a fine of X pounds for one person is 1% of their annual income and for another person is 5%, then the qualitative impact is vastly different as as such the richer person is being punished less.
If however we are talking about costs rather than fines then I agree whatever the costs are is what should be paid.
However, I might work 60 hour weeks to earn £30k per year, pay £6k in tax, have a mortgage of £12k a year, £2k council tax, bills etc, leaving me with £100 per week spare.If however we are talking about costs rather than fines then I agree whatever the costs are is what should be paid.
Compared to that there is someone who pays nothing to society, doesn't work and gets £100 per week in benefits from the state.
Who's £100 is more valuable?
And who's fine would likely be 2 or 3 as much as the others?
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Jasandjules said:
One must question the legal ethics of fining someone based upon their income. The offence is at issue, NOT the ability of the offender to pay - at least, if JUSTICE was in mind.
So a multi millionaire should be able to commit crime with impunity. Means testing is intended to level the playing field so that the impact of punishment is the same. I think that is fair otherwise thelegal system would be even more waited in favour of those with money. Do you believe scrotes on the social shouldn't get fines at all??
What about single Mum's who can't afford to feed their kids, you not going to give them a ticket??
Jasandjules said:
I know we've been here before, but my position hasn't changed...
If a crime is a crime, then it has a set value in terms of fine based upon various factors. For example, we could say speeding at night, reduce fine, speeding during day past a school during pick up time with kids all over the place, increase fine.
The offence is the offence, the punishment ought to be the punishment, income ought not to be a factor.
Yes they do set it like that, but if the poor person can't afford what the fine would be set at, an adjustment has to be made to the fine that they can afford. The court are not permitted to set a fine that the defendant can't possibly afford.
If a crime is a crime, then it has a set value in terms of fine based upon various factors. For example, we could say speeding at night, reduce fine, speeding during day past a school during pick up time with kids all over the place, increase fine.
The offence is the offence, the punishment ought to be the punishment, income ought not to be a factor.
First how is the matter going to be disposed (right we've decided on a fine).
Next circumstances/aggravating factors that suggest fine level.
Next does the defendant have the ability to pay that ?
If not then it must be at a level that the defendant can afford to pay within 12 months.
It's immoral to set a fine at a level that from the outset it is obvious will disadvantage the person who has no means of complying with that order, resulting in them defaulting & going to prison because of it. The sentence must be achievable.
If you want to dispose with a fine it's got to be adjusted to be affordable, or you are not disposing with a financial imposition.
Edited by vonhosen on Saturday 26th April 08:45
paoloh said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Jasandjules said:
One must question the legal ethics of fining someone based upon their income. The offence is at issue, NOT the ability of the offender to pay - at least, if JUSTICE was in mind.
So a multi millionaire should be able to commit crime with impunity. Means testing is intended to level the playing field so that the impact of punishment is the same. I think that is fair otherwise thelegal system would be even more waited in favour of those with money. Do you believe scrotes on the social shouldn't get fines at all??
What about single Mum's who can't afford to feed their kids, you not going to give them a ticket??
vonhosen said:
It's immoral to set a fine at a level that from the outset it is obvious will disadvantage the person who has no means of complying with that order, resulting in them defaulting & going to prison because of it.
I do know the process ta Von, I've trained in it and spent plenty of time in and around the criminal courts.However, to my mind it is immoral to charge one person more than another simply due to income, for the same offence. It's as simple as that to me.
Jasandjules said:
vonhosen said:
It's immoral to set a fine at a level that from the outset it is obvious will disadvantage the person who has no means of complying with that order, resulting in them defaulting & going to prison because of it.
I do know the process ta Von, I've trained in it and spent plenty of time in and around the criminal courts.However, to my mind it is immoral to charge one person more than another simply due to income, for the same offence. It's as simple as that to me.
Fixed sentencing would be the result. Is that what you would prefer?
Jasandjules said:
However, to my mind it is immoral to charge one person more than another simply due to income, for the same offence.
I really don't have a problem with fine being proportional to a person's ability to pay. To me, its common sense. After all, a fine is supposed to be a financial penalty; it is supposed to be felt by the defendant and, presumably, act as a deterrent against further transgression.Forums | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


