Garage forecourt mishap - do I have a claim?
Discussion
Went to jetwash my motorbike yesterday morning. There was someone there before me so I parked up next to the jetwash, removed my helmet and placed it on the ground next to my bike, and sat on my bike to wait.
A coule of other cars joined my "queue" before the first guy finished.
So, I move my bike onto the jetwash, jetwash my bike and then start to wheel it from the washing area.
At this point, car #1 in the queue proceeds to drive over my helmet, which is still on the ground where I left it.
So that's a 300 quid Shoei totalled.
He kicked off saying I shouldn't have left it on the floor, I took his details and said I'd be claiming off him.
Thing is, I don't know if he is liable - is he? In hindsight I could have taken more care of the helmet but I wasn't to realise that the muppet was going to drive straight over it. Legally do I bear some of the responsibility?
A coule of other cars joined my "queue" before the first guy finished.
So, I move my bike onto the jetwash, jetwash my bike and then start to wheel it from the washing area.
At this point, car #1 in the queue proceeds to drive over my helmet, which is still on the ground where I left it.
So that's a 300 quid Shoei totalled.
He kicked off saying I shouldn't have left it on the floor, I took his details and said I'd be claiming off him.
Thing is, I don't know if he is liable - is he? In hindsight I could have taken more care of the helmet but I wasn't to realise that the muppet was going to drive straight over it. Legally do I bear some of the responsibility?
When you are making a claim against someone, in legal terms what you are saying is that a third party has been negligent and because of their negligence this has cost you money and therefore legally you should be recompensed for that.
This is essentially what happens when a claim goes 'through the insurance'. You can of course make a claim direct though.
However, the fundamental point is if they have been negligent. Without knowing the exact layout of the area, and just from what you say though, I think it will be very difficult to show this.
For example, when I pull forward in a queue I don't get out of my car to check that there are no objects out of the eyeline on my windscreen before pulling forward. So when you are trying to prove their negligence by saying they should have done something differently, as I have said that is difficult.
However, playing the devil's advocate here, even though IMHO your claim would fail, if there is any damage to the persons tyre or car, then IMHO of course then they would actually have more chance of succeeding in a claim against you. Their argument is that you do not usually see a helmet lying on the floor by itself, as it may not be seen...
I would put it down to a learning experience, and in hindsight I guess you wished you picked the helmet up first! I really wouldn't lose too much sleep over a claim, as I think it would be a waste of your time and money.
This is essentially what happens when a claim goes 'through the insurance'. You can of course make a claim direct though.
However, the fundamental point is if they have been negligent. Without knowing the exact layout of the area, and just from what you say though, I think it will be very difficult to show this.
For example, when I pull forward in a queue I don't get out of my car to check that there are no objects out of the eyeline on my windscreen before pulling forward. So when you are trying to prove their negligence by saying they should have done something differently, as I have said that is difficult.
However, playing the devil's advocate here, even though IMHO your claim would fail, if there is any damage to the persons tyre or car, then IMHO of course then they would actually have more chance of succeeding in a claim against you. Their argument is that you do not usually see a helmet lying on the floor by itself, as it may not be seen...
I would put it down to a learning experience, and in hindsight I guess you wished you picked the helmet up first! I really wouldn't lose too much sleep over a claim, as I think it would be a waste of your time and money.
IANAL.
1) I am surprised you left your helmet on the ground by a jet wash. It was always likely it would at least get wet.
2) I am surprised that a car was able to drive over your helmet.
3) Having a car total a helmet by driving over it would not give me confidence in the helmet (albeit, you might reasonably not want to wear the helmet again). BTW, how did you get home without a wearable helmet?
4) You were aware that other vehicles had joined the queue behind you, yet you did not take reasonable care to protect your helmet, even leaving it where it was (perhaps now out of the sight and mind of the car driver) whilst you washed your bike and pushed it away.
5) You did not place the helmet out of harm's way (i.e. you left it in an area where vehicles could drive).
I would argue that most, if not all of the fault lies with you. Indeed, perhaps you should be grateful that the car did not incur damage.
Sorry.
Streaky
ETA: JustinP1 posted whilst I was typing/taking a pee-break - S
1) I am surprised you left your helmet on the ground by a jet wash. It was always likely it would at least get wet.
2) I am surprised that a car was able to drive over your helmet.
3) Having a car total a helmet by driving over it would not give me confidence in the helmet (albeit, you might reasonably not want to wear the helmet again). BTW, how did you get home without a wearable helmet?
4) You were aware that other vehicles had joined the queue behind you, yet you did not take reasonable care to protect your helmet, even leaving it where it was (perhaps now out of the sight and mind of the car driver) whilst you washed your bike and pushed it away.
5) You did not place the helmet out of harm's way (i.e. you left it in an area where vehicles could drive).
I would argue that most, if not all of the fault lies with you. Indeed, perhaps you should be grateful that the car did not incur damage.
Sorry.
Streaky
ETA: JustinP1 posted whilst I was typing/taking a pee-break - S
Edited by streaky on Tuesday 6th May 10:17
hornetrider said:
Went to jetwash my motorbike yesterday morning. There was someone there before me so I parked up next to the jetwash, removed my helmet and placed it on the ground next to my bike, and sat on my bike to wait.
A coule of other cars joined my "queue" before the first guy finished.
So, I move my bike onto the jetwash, jetwash my bike and then start to wheel it from the washing area.
At this point, car #1 in the queue proceeds to drive over my helmet, which is still on the ground where I left it.
So that's a 300 quid Shoei totalled.
He kicked off saying I shouldn't have left it on the floor, I took his details and said I'd be claiming off him.
Thing is, I don't know if he is liable - is he? In hindsight I could have taken more care of the helmet but I wasn't to realise that the muppet was going to drive straight over it. Legally do I bear some of the responsibility?
I do not think you can blame the car driver to be honest.It sounds more like you forgot the helmet and moved off the jet wash and the accident happened.A coule of other cars joined my "queue" before the first guy finished.
So, I move my bike onto the jetwash, jetwash my bike and then start to wheel it from the washing area.
At this point, car #1 in the queue proceeds to drive over my helmet, which is still on the ground where I left it.
So that's a 300 quid Shoei totalled.
He kicked off saying I shouldn't have left it on the floor, I took his details and said I'd be claiming off him.
Thing is, I don't know if he is liable - is he? In hindsight I could have taken more care of the helmet but I wasn't to realise that the muppet was going to drive straight over it. Legally do I bear some of the responsibility?
Had you been more careful you would not have left it on the floor or picked it up before you moved the bike.
Streaky. Thanks for your sanctimonious tone.
3 of your 5 points all say words to the affect of "I'm surprised you did not take more care of your helmet" - yes, thank you teacher.
I used the word "totalled" but it wasn't actually crushed. He didn't actually drive over it - his bumper scraped it along the ground and it rolled over, chipping several bits out of it and generally scraping it to buggery. The helmet was wearable but is now U/S.
Whilst I realise with 20/20 hindsight I should have moved the lid, its a sleepy village garage and it didn't occur to me at the time.
Quite how you can say how I could be responsible for any damage to the car - is frankly bizarre.
If one drives into an stationary object then one must surely be culpable, no?
3 of your 5 points all say words to the affect of "I'm surprised you did not take more care of your helmet" - yes, thank you teacher.

I used the word "totalled" but it wasn't actually crushed. He didn't actually drive over it - his bumper scraped it along the ground and it rolled over, chipping several bits out of it and generally scraping it to buggery. The helmet was wearable but is now U/S.
Whilst I realise with 20/20 hindsight I should have moved the lid, its a sleepy village garage and it didn't occur to me at the time.
Quite how you can say how I could be responsible for any damage to the car - is frankly bizarre.
If one drives into an stationary object then one must surely be culpable, no?
streaky said:
IANAL.
1) I am surprised you left your helmet on the ground by a jet wash. It was always likely it would at least get wet.
2) I am surprised that a car was able to drive over your helmet.
3) Having a car total a helmet by driving over it would not give me confidence in the helmet (albeit, you might reasonably not want to wear the helmet again). BTW, how did you get home without a wearable helmet?
4) You were aware that other vehicles had joined the queue behind you, yet you did not take reasonable care to protect your helmet, even leaving it where it was (perhaps now out of the sight and mind of the car driver) whilst you washed your bike and pushed it away.
5) You did not place the helmet out of harm's way (i.e. you left it in an area where vehicles could drive).
I would argue that most, if not all of the fault lies with you. Indeed, perhaps you should be grateful that the car did not incur damage.
Sorry.
Streaky
ETA: JustinP1 posted whilst I was typing/taking a pee-break - S
2nded!!1) I am surprised you left your helmet on the ground by a jet wash. It was always likely it would at least get wet.
2) I am surprised that a car was able to drive over your helmet.
3) Having a car total a helmet by driving over it would not give me confidence in the helmet (albeit, you might reasonably not want to wear the helmet again). BTW, how did you get home without a wearable helmet?
4) You were aware that other vehicles had joined the queue behind you, yet you did not take reasonable care to protect your helmet, even leaving it where it was (perhaps now out of the sight and mind of the car driver) whilst you washed your bike and pushed it away.
5) You did not place the helmet out of harm's way (i.e. you left it in an area where vehicles could drive).
I would argue that most, if not all of the fault lies with you. Indeed, perhaps you should be grateful that the car did not incur damage.
Sorry.
Streaky
ETA: JustinP1 posted whilst I was typing/taking a pee-break - S
Edited by streaky on Tuesday 6th May 10:17
How you could possibly think on displacing blame when you left your everso precious helmet directly in harms way bemuses me somewhat!
hornetrider said:
If one drives into an stationary object then one must surely be culpable, no?
No 
You might be, you might not, you might be a bit. Was it foreseeable ? Was it negligent ?
I would guess that they would have a better (but by no means certain) case against you for negligence than you have against them.
hornetrider said:
Streaky.
Quite how you can say how I could be responsible for any damage to the car - is frankly bizarre.
If one drives into an stationary object then one must surely be culpable, no?
So you put YOUR helmet on the ground (not the usual place to find a skidlid) and think that its the other cars fault for not seeing it?Quite how you can say how I could be responsible for any damage to the car - is frankly bizarre.
If one drives into an stationary object then one must surely be culpable, no?
At the very least its contributary negligence on your part. Your helmet, you put it there........
The only way I could imagine this happening is if you put the helmet on the floor out of sight of any car subsequently joining your queue, so that the following car was unable at any time to see it. Personally if I was not to see, and was to hit from a standing start, something the size of a helmet on the floor in front of me then I would be astonished and would feel very guilty. I just can't imagine it happening.
herewego said:
The only way I could imagine this happening is if you put the helmet on the floor out of sight of any car subsequently joining your queue, so that the following car was unable at any time to see it. Personally if I was not to see, and was to hit from a standing start, something the size of a helmet on the floor in front of me then I would be astonished and would feel very guilty. I just can't imagine it happening.
Well, it happened. Like I say I was sat on my bike on my own, lid on the floor next to me, waiting for the guy to finish washing his car.Then another car pulls up and parks behind/beside me. He will have seen me on my bike and my lid next to me as he pulled up.
Then I jetwashed my bike, then wheeled the bike away from the jetwash, and as I was moving it he ran the helmet over trying to get on to the jetwash.
Yes I should have thought preventatively but it didn't occur to me that the guy would move so quickly nor that he hadn't seen the helmet on the floor.
If someone crashes into your car when its parked is it your fault for parking it in the wrong place? Surely its poor observation on the part of the driver?
hornetrider said:
herewego said:
The only way I could imagine this happening is if you put the helmet on the floor out of sight of any car subsequently joining your queue, so that the following car was unable at any time to see it. Personally if I was not to see, and was to hit from a standing start, something the size of a helmet on the floor in front of me then I would be astonished and would feel very guilty. I just can't imagine it happening.
Well, it happened. Like I say I was sat on my bike on my own, lid on the floor next to me, waiting for the guy to finish washing his car.Then another car pulls up and parks behind/beside me. He will have seen me on my bike and my lid next to me as he pulled up.
Then I jetwashed my bike, then wheeled the bike away from the jetwash, and as I was moving it he ran the helmet over trying to get on to the jetwash.
Yes I should have thought preventatively but it didn't occur to me that the guy would move so quickly nor that he hadn't seen the helmet on the floor.
If someone crashes into your car when its parked is it your fault for parking it in the wrong place? Surely its poor observation on the part of the driver?
To be honest I think you'll just have to put it down to experience. It could have been worse, at least your head wasn't in it.
hornetrider said:
herewego said:
The only way I could imagine this happening is if you put the helmet on the floor out of sight of any car subsequently joining your queue, so that the following car was unable at any time to see it. Personally if I was not to see, and was to hit from a standing start, something the size of a helmet on the floor in front of me then I would be astonished and would feel very guilty. I just can't imagine it happening.
Well, it happened. Like I say I was sat on my bike on my own, lid on the floor next to me, waiting for the guy to finish washing his car.Then another car pulls up and parks behind/beside me. He will have seen me on my bike and my lid next to me as he pulled up.
Then I jetwashed my bike, then wheeled the bike away from the jetwash, and as I was moving it he ran the helmet over trying to get on to the jetwash.
Yes I should have thought preventatively but it didn't occur to me that the guy would move so quickly nor that he hadn't seen the helmet on the floor.
If someone crashes into your car when its parked is it your fault for parking it in the wrong place? Surely its poor observation on the part of the driver?
Hooli said:
if the car could see the helmet next to you for that long then i'd expect them not to drive over it. however i cant see an insurance company paying out as they'll jusrt argue you put it in harms way.
Yeah I think I agree, however it was worth putting out the question to SP+L. The good news is it was my 2nd lid and being four years old I have had good use out of it.hornetrider said:
herewego said:
The only way I could imagine this happening is if you put the helmet on the floor out of sight of any car subsequently joining your queue, so that the following car was unable at any time to see it. Personally if I was not to see, and was to hit from a standing start, something the size of a helmet on the floor in front of me then I would be astonished and would feel very guilty. I just can't imagine it happening.
Well, it happened. Like I say I was sat on my bike on my own, lid on the floor next to me, waiting for the guy to finish washing his car.Then another car pulls up and parks behind/beside me. He will have seen me on my bike and my lid next to me as he pulled up.
Then I jetwashed my bike, then wheeled the bike away from the jetwash, and as I was moving it he ran the helmet over trying to get on to the jetwash.
Yes I should have thought preventatively but it didn't occur to me that the guy would move so quickly nor that he hadn't seen the helmet on the floor.
If someone crashes into your car when its parked is it your fault for parking it in the wrong place? Surely its poor observation on the part of the driver?
It sounds as if the jetwash was busy as he was the 2nd guy in the queue so he would have alrweady been waiting for 10 minutes or so by the time you finished, and I guess there might have been more behind him. Thus he would of been in a hurry.
A helmet would probably need to be 10 ft or so in front of the car for him to see it, and in a busy place it was liely he was closer than that!
hornetrider said:
If someone crashes into your car when its parked is it your fault for parking it in the wrong place?
Yes, it could be ! Rouse v Squires or Brooks v Ward & Turner all had some negligence against the stationary vehicle.Without witnesses that the lid was visible you might have a hard time proving 100% negligence against them.
What ???
Surely you occupied your space in the queue, and until you have fully moved your vehicle (and all susequent belongings...), out of said queue, the vehicle following should not take your place in queue!!! (so many queues!).
I, as the car driver, would feel responsible as i didn't take adequate care in moving my vehicle.
As the bike rider i would be extremely p*ssed that some numpty damaged my lid by being careless.
I think you should claim, although alot of the car driving gods think otherwise.
So if you'd drove into small bollard you never saw, are the garage responsible for your myopia??
Cheers Fy
Surely you occupied your space in the queue, and until you have fully moved your vehicle (and all susequent belongings...), out of said queue, the vehicle following should not take your place in queue!!! (so many queues!).
I, as the car driver, would feel responsible as i didn't take adequate care in moving my vehicle.
As the bike rider i would be extremely p*ssed that some numpty damaged my lid by being careless.
I think you should claim, although alot of the car driving gods think otherwise.
So if you'd drove into small bollard you never saw, are the garage responsible for your myopia??
Cheers Fy
Edited by flyinyam on Tuesday 6th May 22:28
flyinyam said:
What ???
Surely you occupied your space in the queue, and until you have fully moved your vehicle (and all susequent belongings...), out of said queue, the vehicle following should not take your place in queue!!! (so many queues!).
I, as the car driver, would feel responsible as i didn't take adequate care in moving my vehicle.
As the bike rider i would be extremely p*ssed that some numpty damaged my lid by being careless.
I think you should claim, although alot of the car driving gods think otherwise.
So if you'd drove into small bollard you never saw, are the garage responsible for your myopia??
Cheers Fy
It is not a 'car driving god' question, it is a legal one.Surely you occupied your space in the queue, and until you have fully moved your vehicle (and all susequent belongings...), out of said queue, the vehicle following should not take your place in queue!!! (so many queues!).
I, as the car driver, would feel responsible as i didn't take adequate care in moving my vehicle.
As the bike rider i would be extremely p*ssed that some numpty damaged my lid by being careless.
I think you should claim, although alot of the car driving gods think otherwise.
So if you'd drove into small bollard you never saw, are the garage responsible for your myopia??
Cheers Fy
Edited by flyinyam on Tuesday 6th May 22:28
Indeed, if the garage put a bollard on their forecourt which was invisible to motorists as it was that small, but damaged their cars then they could be held accountable of it could be show that they were negligent.
Look at it this way. Lets say on my way back from B&Q I leave my big bag of nails near your car at the petrol station in a position where I can see you will be driving through, in a position where it is difficult for you to see them. If you happen to move your car without me moving them, I can foresee that damage will happen. I go to pay though.
When we come back, you nasty sod you, you pulled forward and you have ruined all of my nails when you drove over them, and half are stuck in your tyres!
Now, what would you say if I asked you for the money for the nails?
Edited by JustinP1 on Wednesday 7th May 00:14
In some ways the system workings will decide this for you. If you send a bill to the car driver and he says ' sue me', then you have the worries of extra costs and still the possibility of losing.
Bikers don't get much sympathy outside of their own ranks, and although I know everyone will say our magistrates are objective and fair....I know I would never risk it as a biker.
The conter argument will be that by putting your lid in the line of fire, you contibuted to your own misfortune. Now you can quite rightly say the driver did not check the road was clear, that a crash helmet is not much bigger than a crawling baby....but if any magistrate believes you contributed to this, it will go 50-50 - you each bear your own costs.
If you have witnesses you have a much better chance. But if this driver starts saying the lid was practically under his wheels - your word against his on all the details - then your chances are low.
Bikers don't get much sympathy outside of their own ranks, and although I know everyone will say our magistrates are objective and fair....I know I would never risk it as a biker.
The conter argument will be that by putting your lid in the line of fire, you contibuted to your own misfortune. Now you can quite rightly say the driver did not check the road was clear, that a crash helmet is not much bigger than a crawling baby....but if any magistrate believes you contributed to this, it will go 50-50 - you each bear your own costs.
If you have witnesses you have a much better chance. But if this driver starts saying the lid was practically under his wheels - your word against his on all the details - then your chances are low.
hornetrider said:
Streaky. Thanks for your sanctimonious tone.
3 of your 5 points all say words to the affect of "I'm surprised you did not take more care of your helmet" - yes, thank you teacher.
I was not being 'sanctimonious' as I was not pretending to be either very religious or virtuous. My use of the phrase "I am surprised ..." (only twice) was a genuine expression given your concern at the "totalling" of a £300 helmet - Streaky3 of your 5 points all say words to the affect of "I'm surprised you did not take more care of your helmet" - yes, thank you teacher.

Forums | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


