Without prejudice
Author
Discussion

phillvr6

Original Poster:

3,785 posts

291 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
What exactly does this mean? After several months or wrangling I've been offered the full amount of costs from the 3rd party insurer.

However their previous offers were 95 /5 in their favour, then 75 / 25 in my favour, this offer is "without prejudice". Why are they not accepting 100% liability, although they have offered me 100% of my claim?

Thanks,

Phill

Timsta

2,779 posts

277 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
Without prejudice means that you won't be able to show that letter if it ever went to court. The best thing to do is to quote what they say in a letter back to them, accepting/declining or whatever. Just make sure you have quoted the important bits. Then you can produce your letter in court if needed, and any response they may have sent to your letter confirming it.


anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
Timsta said:
Without prejudice means that you won't be able to show that letter if it ever went to court. The best thing to do is to quote what they say in a letter back to them, accepting/declining or whatever. Just make sure you have quoted the important bits. Then you can produce your letter in court if needed, and any response they may have sent to your letter confirming it.
haha nice trick smile probably doesnt need response letter just proof of delivery?

Timsta

2,779 posts

277 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
The reason a response from them is preferable is that they may confirm what they said in the original. Your letter "quoting" them may have been completely fictitious, their response will confirm what they originally said.



Jasandjules

72,695 posts

260 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
phillvr6 said:
What exactly does this mean? After several months or wrangling I've been offered the full amount of costs from the 3rd party insurer.

However their previous offers were 95 /5 in their favour, then 75 / 25 in my favour, this offer is "without prejudice". Why are they not accepting 100% liability, although they have offered me 100% of my claim?

Thanks,

Phill
A without prejudice offer is only valid when it relates to a settlement (bear in mind for when someone sends a random letter and marks without prejudice on it!) and does it mention costs at all? Often if you put without prejudice save as to costs, then any costs incurred after that letter may be recoverable.

AS above, the idea is that they can offer you money but the court don't get to see that, so that in the event it goes to court you can't just say "but you offered me X before".

If they are saying they will offer you the full money but not accept liability they are attempting to ensure that should any further costs arise (let's say you develop a condition later on which was traced to the accident) then they have no admitted liability so would not be liable automatically for those further costs/claim.

phillvr6

Original Poster:

3,785 posts

291 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
phillvr6 said:
What exactly does this mean? After several months or wrangling I've been offered the full amount of costs from the 3rd party insurer.

However their previous offers were 95 /5 in their favour, then 75 / 25 in my favour, this offer is "without prejudice". Why are they not accepting 100% liability, although they have offered me 100% of my claim?

Thanks,

Phill
A without prejudice offer is only valid when it relates to a settlement (bear in mind for when someone sends a random letter and marks without prejudice on it!) and does it mention costs at all? Often if you put without prejudice save as to costs, then any costs incurred after that letter may be recoverable.

AS above, the idea is that they can offer you money but the court don't get to see that, so that in the event it goes to court you can't just say "but you offered me X before".

If they are saying they will offer you the full money but not accept liability they are attempting to ensure that should any further costs arise (let's say you develop a condition later on which was traced to the accident) then they have no admitted liability so would not be liable automatically for those further costs/claim.
Right that makes sense, so, if they are not accepting liability does this still stand as a fault claim against me? Or as they are offering me the full sum, does this mean it is no longer a fault claim against me?

Thanks,

Phill

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
Doesn't matter what your Uninsured Loss Settlement is for "non fault" all that matters is that the Insurer made a full recovery. Best to ask them.

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
Timsta said:
Without prejudice means that you won't be able to show that letter if it ever went to court. The best thing to do is to quote what they say in a letter back to them, accepting/declining or whatever. Just make sure you have quoted the important bits. Then you can produce your letter in court if needed, and any response they may have sent to your letter confirming it.
But if you did that and it went to court they could ask to have your letter/evidence dismissed iirc. So would be better not to quote what they said but later on to suggest something similar smile

Jasandjules

72,695 posts

260 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
phillvr6 said:
Right that makes sense, so, if they are not accepting liability does this still stand as a fault claim against me? Or as they are offering me the full sum, does this mean it is no longer a fault claim against me?

Thanks,

Phill
I don't know exactly how it works with respect to insurance, but my guess would be if there is a without prejudice settlement then you haven't actually won and therefore liability is not established one way or the other - I'd speak to your insurance company about it if I were you and ask them what their position would be in respect of your NCB if the other side settle the claim.


Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
The two are not connected. I think it is the 1999 Access to Justice Act that means that an Insurers case and a case for uninsured losses must be kept separate. Certainly insurers should not upload ULR cases to operational areas and compare the two. Systems and data for Customer cases and our cases have "chinese walls".

Makes sense, if your insurer decides to go 50:50, it should not prejudice YOUR case for uninsured losses. And vice-versa.