Speed limit on SC road
Discussion
Vaux said:
On a single carriageway road, can you have (legally) a different speed limit in each direction?
The Traffic Regulation Orders usually specify a Schedule of "lengths of road affected". The schedules would normally say something like "Main Street, between its junction with side road 1, and a point 45 metres or thereby south of its junction with side road 2". In other words, that specifies a length of road, not the direction.I suppose it would be possible, technically, to write the Order so that it applied two different schedules, one for each direction, and applied a different speed limit to each. I am sure that there is something somewhere though (I can't remember where) that says that you can only apply a speed limit to a length of road, not to a particular direction.
I don't think that I have ever seen different speed limits on an SC road (except by somebody getting the signing wrong and having to put it right!)
esselte said:
Don't know about S/Cs but I'm sure I've seen it on D/Cs ....(frantically trying to remember where.....)
A50 on approach to M1 J24 Dual Carriageway - 50mph towards M1, 70 away from M1.When I complained against the daft limit reduction of the A610 west from J26 from NSL 70 to 40/50 - I asked why they could not just change the limit on the eastbound side heading to the M1 where there's peak time queues. The reply was that there was no real need for a limit reduction heading away from the motorway, but they wouldn't do this as it may be 'confusing' for the poor little drivers. Aw bless

Edited by alphadog on Friday 9th May 12:49
alphadog said:
esselte said:
Don't know about S/Cs but I'm sure I've seen it on D/Cs ....(frantically trying to remember where.....)
A50 on approach to M1 J24 Dual Carriageway - 50mph towards M1, 70 away from M1.When I complained against the daft limit reduction of the A610 west from J26 from NSL 70 to 40/50 I asked why they could not just change the limit on the eastbound side heading to the M1 where there's peak time queues. The reply was they won't do this as it may be 'confusing' for the poor little drivers. Aw bless

esselte said:
alphadog said:
esselte said:
Don't know about S/Cs but I'm sure I've seen it on D/Cs ....(frantically trying to remember where.....)
A50 on approach to M1 J24 Dual Carriageway - 50mph towards M1, 70 away from M1.When I complained against the daft limit reduction of the A610 west from J26 from NSL 70 to 40/50 I asked why they could not just change the limit on the eastbound side heading to the M1 where there's peak time queues. The reply was they won't do this as it may be 'confusing' for the poor little drivers. Aw bless

Quinny said:
There's part of a road that goes from Wrexham to Mold.
DC
In one direction its 70 NSL and in the other its 40mph.
The 40 mph is there for good reason, its twisty as hell, and a few years ago a guy I know quite well was killed along there, along with his son and his son's best mate.
Very tragic
Isn't the other side of the DC twisty as well?DC
In one direction its 70 NSL and in the other its 40mph.The 40 mph is there for good reason, its twisty as hell, and a few years ago a guy I know quite well was killed along there, along with his son and his son's best mate.
Very tragic
esselte said:
Quinny said:
There's part of a road that goes from Wrexham to Mold.
DC
In one direction its 70 NSL and in the other its 40mph.
The 40 mph is there for good reason, its twisty as hell, and a few years ago a guy I know quite well was killed along there, along with his son and his son's best mate.
Very tragic
Isn't the other side of the DC twisty as well?DC
In one direction its 70 NSL and in the other its 40mph.The 40 mph is there for good reason, its twisty as hell, and a few years ago a guy I know quite well was killed along there, along with his son and his son's best mate.
Very tragic

In answer to the OP - I'm thinking hard - there must be an example somewhere

Just been through D of T 01/2006 - Setting local speed limits.
They do not make any recommendation for a two tier speed limit on a SC but there again they do not prohibit such a move.
As such a policy if brought in departs from the norm then special authorisation would be required from Sec of State for the Order to be made and beyond the authority of the LA.
As such an Order could cause confusion to the general motoring public including conflict in signage I doubt one would ever be brought into force.
dvd
They do not make any recommendation for a two tier speed limit on a SC but there again they do not prohibit such a move.
As such a policy if brought in departs from the norm then special authorisation would be required from Sec of State for the Order to be made and beyond the authority of the LA.
As such an Order could cause confusion to the general motoring public including conflict in signage I doubt one would ever be brought into force.
dvd
Dwight VanDriver said:
Just been through D of T 01/2006 - Setting local speed limits.
They do not make any recommendation for a two tier speed limit on a SC but there again they do not prohibit such a move.
As such a policy if brought in departs from the norm then special authorisation would be required from Sec of State for the Order to be made and beyond the authority of the LA.
As such an Order could cause confusion to the general motoring public including conflict in signage I doubt one would ever be brought into force.
dvd
Good find DVD. They do not make any recommendation for a two tier speed limit on a SC but there again they do not prohibit such a move.
As such a policy if brought in departs from the norm then special authorisation would be required from Sec of State for the Order to be made and beyond the authority of the LA.
As such an Order could cause confusion to the general motoring public including conflict in signage I doubt one would ever be brought into force.
dvd
I recall that the previous Technical Memorandum on setting Speed Limits (which was dated about 1976 or something - I chucked my last surviving copy out, about 4 weeks ago!) recommended that speed limits in different directions should be the same, for the reasons you mention. I wasn't sure if that had been changed in more recent advice / guidance. Apparently not.
I've thought hard about this and I'm not aware of any differential speed limits on SC roads.
esselte said:
Quinny said:
There's part of a road that goes from Wrexham to Mold.
DC
In one direction its 70 NSL and in the other its 40mph.
The 40 mph is there for good reason, its twisty as hell, and a few years ago a guy I know quite well was killed along there, along with his son and his son's best mate.
Very tragic
Isn't the other side of the DC twisty as well?DC
In one direction its 70 NSL and in the other its 40mph.The 40 mph is there for good reason, its twisty as hell, and a few years ago a guy I know quite well was killed along there, along with his son and his son's best mate.
Very tragic
There were some old trees on the green bit between the two and most of the accidents I recall in the last 20 years seemed to be cars leaving the road and colliding with the trees. I know about the tragic triple fatality which occurred just as the SC turns in to the DC leaving Pontybodkin. I also know the people who were lost and believe a speed limit would have had no effect on the outcome.
And guess what, Arrive Alive like to park a van at the other end where the Wrexham bound carriageway straightens out for 800 yards down hill where people naturally spoeed up a bit.
I was on a narrow single carriage road over Surrey way iirc last week and it had large 30 mph signs going in, but was 50 mph coming out.This was only over a section which was a few hundred yards in length.The road had a small roundabout at the start by the 30 mph signs and was tree lined for a while before you came into an area with houses etc.Coming back out, as you got to the same tree lined part it was 50 mph.I seem to remember (but may be wrong) seeing 100 yard markers under the 30 mph signs, so is it possible it appeared to be 30 going in but was actually still 50 mph and it was suggesting it was 30 mph in xx amount of yards time? There were definately no 50 mph signs on the way in anyway, just on the way out.
I can't say i ever remember coming across a situation like it before anyway.
I can't say i ever remember coming across a situation like it before anyway.
Edited by Digby on Friday 9th May 17:36
Dwight VanDriver said:
Just been through D of T 01/2006 - Setting local speed limits.
They do not make any recommendation for a two tier speed limit on a SC but there again they do not prohibit such a move.
Local road is newly signed 30 - 50 - 30 - 50 one way. (Was 30 - NSL)They do not make any recommendation for a two tier speed limit on a SC but there again they do not prohibit such a move.
T'other way is 50 - 30 - - 30, so for a section it's 50 one way and 30 the other.
I think they've just forgotten the 50. Plus you get a 30 and then several hundred yards later another 30, which doesn't make sense.
Also, as there are no lamp posts, and no 30 repeaters, I would have thought it hard to enforce a 30?
DucatiGary said:
why dont they just make the road 30-40-60-nsl-40-50-40-30-20 (to pass the school)-30-50-nsl-50-30-40 ?
would make things a whole lot easier and safer too
I'll suggest it to the CC. Thanks. would make things a whole lot easier and safer too
PS - No school though, just a junction that apparently is impossible to get out of without reducing the limit to 30, although it's been NSL (60) forever on that road.
Forums | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




