MOT - wheel bearing wear
MOT - wheel bearing wear
Author
Discussion

tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
Took the TVR for its MOT yesterday and it failed because the front wheel bearing is "noisy"

The tester agrees that there is no play in the bearing. He agrees that it doesn't even feel rough. When you spin the wheel, he says it's noisy. If you put your ear 1/2 inch from the wheel you can just hear a slight whisper from the bearing.

I tried to persuade him to an advisory but he says it's a fail.

I've ordered new bearings for £20, and I'll change it in a day, and the old MOT doesn't expire till 3rd June, so I'm not overly bothered, but I've checked the MOT Tester Manual and although it mentions testing for bearing play, I can't see where it says anything about "noise" on its own, being a fail.

Last year he failed it only because when you had the back lights, the fog lamps, the brake lamps and reverse lamps all on at the same time, and then put the indicators on, the other lights dimmed amost imperceptibly in time with the flashes. I fixed that in 5 minutes with a bit of emery paper on the contacts. Wheel bearings take a little longer!

I think I need to find another MOT centre!

Gemsbok1000

1,958 posts

235 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
I think I need to find another MOT centre!
yes

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
Yep time for a new MOT station

probably fishing for work

Slinky

15,704 posts

280 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
Took the TVR for its MOT yesterday and it failed because the front wheel bearing is "noisy"

I've ordered new bearings for £20, and I'll change it in a day, and the old MOT doesn't expire till 3rd June, so I'm not overly bothered
I may be wrong here, but your car has just failed an MOT, does the failure not supersede the previous pass and therefore mean that your car is currently not legal?

tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
Slinky said:
tvrgit said:
Took the TVR for its MOT yesterday and it failed because the front wheel bearing is "noisy"

I've ordered new bearings for £20, and I'll change it in a day, and the old MOT doesn't expire till 3rd June, so I'm not overly bothered
I may be wrong here, but your car has just failed an MOT, does the failure not supersede the previous pass and therefore mean that your car is currently not legal?
Good question, don't know (it didn't used to but in this new computerised system, who knows?). I suspect it's still "legal" but if something were to happen (like that wheel fly off and kill babies) the fact of the MOT failure would probably emerge, and not do me any favours.

I don't intend to use it until it's fixed anyway, and it's not going to be on the public road until I take it back to the MOT centre, so it's academic, but I would like to know the answer anyway.

I would also like to know if I can take it somewhere else for another test as it is... Again you used to be able to do this but probably not now.

falcemob

8,248 posts

267 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
Slinky said:
tvrgit said:
Took the TVR for its MOT yesterday and it failed because the front wheel bearing is "noisy"

I've ordered new bearings for £20, and I'll change it in a day, and the old MOT doesn't expire till 3rd June, so I'm not overly bothered
I may be wrong here, but your car has just failed an MOT, does the failure not supersede the previous pass and therefore mean that your car is currently not legal?
Good question, don't know (it didn't used to but in this new computerised system, who knows?). I suspect it's still "legal" but if something were to happen (like that wheel fly off and kill babies) the fact of the MOT failure would probably emerge, and not do me any favours.

I don't intend to use it until it's fixed anyway, and it's not going to be on the public road until I take it back to the MOT centre, so it's academic, but I would like to know the answer anyway.

I would also like to know if I can take it somewhere else for another test as it is... Again you used to be able to do this but probably not now.
You can still use it until your current MOT expires but if you get pulled by VOSA it will still be illegal if they deem it so, although it would make no difference as to whether it had failed an MOT or not.
You can take it to another test centre but you will have to pay the full fee for a complete test as if it was me I wouldn't trust anyone elses opinion on a car's roadworthyness for MOT purposes.

tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
falcemob said:
You can take it to another test centre but you will have to pay the full fee for a complete test as if it was me I wouldn't trust anyone elses opinion on a car's roadworthyness for MOT purposes.
I remember I had an NSA Prinz (the shame of it!) which failed on a list of 4 things including front kingpin wear. I took it to 3 different garages (full test fee each time) until I found one that failed it on 4 things that were fixable (ie not the kingpin wear)... so I fixed those then took it back. I wasn't sure if you were still able to do that (I don't think that it was ever entirely technically "legal" ahem) or if the computerised system would pick it up now.

falcemob

8,248 posts

267 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
falcemob said:
You can take it to another test centre but you will have to pay the full fee for a complete test as if it was me I wouldn't trust anyone elses opinion on a car's roadworthyness for MOT purposes.
I remember I had an NSA Prinz (the shame of it!) which failed on a list of 4 things including front kingpin wear. I took it to 3 different garages (full test fee each time) until I found one that failed it on 4 things that were fixable (ie not the kingpin wear)... so I fixed those then took it back. I wasn't sure if you were still able to do that (I don't think that it was ever entirely technically "legal" ahem) or if the computerised system would pick it up now.
I'm not sure either but I would take it back to the bloke who failed it, unless he is a complete arse he shouldn't at the beginning again, although the brakes will have to be retested.

Mojocvh

16,837 posts

293 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
falcemob said:
You can take it to another test centre but you will have to pay the full fee for a complete test as if it was me I wouldn't trust anyone elses opinion on a car's roadworthyness for MOT purposes.
I remember I had an NSA Prinz (the shame of it!) which failed on a list of 4 things including front kingpin wear. I took it to 3 different garages (full test fee each time) until I found one that failed it on 4 things that were fixable (ie not the kingpin wear)... so I fixed those then took it back. I wasn't sure if you were still able to do that (I don't think that it was ever entirely technically "legal" ahem) or if the computerised system would pick it up now.
Nope, faults are supposed to be logged, or so I was told, prior to getting the parts and with some help from local car club fixed them for 10% of what testers garage wanted. IT WORKS BOTH WAYS NOW smile

TVR 3X

1,233 posts

298 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
I don't know how similar the S and the Wedge front hubs are but be sure not to overtighten them.

I did once and the bearings locked up through heat transfer from the disks and ended up writing off the stub axles.

I used the old rule of tighten up until the wheel stops rotating then back off a flat. This isn't enough on the Wedge front suspension. You really need a dial gauge to set the "end float".


Russ

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
Look carefully at the wording of the failure sheet.

If it says on the sheet something that is not clearly listed as a reason for failure the garage and the tester ore in deep st.

Get hold of an appeal form.

Complete it, send it to VOSA who will arrange to meet with you at an independent garage and the VOSA guy will check your car.

If he passes it then the failing garage will have the tester suspended.

VOSA are VERY hot on the MOT being done TO THE LETTER of the manual from my (bitter ish) experiance.

If it does not give noise as a reason for failure in the MOT manual then the garage cannot fail it.

tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
I think the S is different. I know when I've done Escorts and Cortinas in the past, you follow the procedure you describe.

These ones are tightened up to 200-and-something lbft, no backing off or enfloat ot any of that complicated stuff. Tighten it till you can't jump on it anymore then put the rest together....

Russian Rocket

874 posts

267 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
"noisy bearing" is a bit non scientific.

I got a "may need attention" type warning on my MGB 5y ago, bought a new bearing, lost mot sheet, forgot which one it was.

no amount listening by me or my dad (who is mechanic) could work out which one

passed every MOT since whit no problems

tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
Look carefully at the wording of the failure sheet.

If it says on the sheet something that is not clearly listed as a reason for failure the garage and the tester ore in deep st.

Get hold of an appeal form.

Complete it, send it to VOSA who will arrange to meet with you at an independent garage and the VOSA guy will check your car.

If he passes it then the failing garage will have the tester suspended.

VOSA are VERY hot on the MOT being done TO THE LETTER of the manual from my (bitter ish) experiance.

If it does not give noise as a reason for failure in the MOT manual then the garage cannot fail it.
What he said at the time was that it was NOISY (albeit barely a whisper). He agreed it didn't feel rough and that there was no play.

What it says on the sheet is that it FEELS ROUGH. Not what he said.

I don't want to appeal, I don't have the time to run about meeting people, I'm busy enough as it is and the car (and garage) are miles from my work. I don't even have time this week to book it into another MOT centre and see how it gets on. I'll fix it and get it passed and that's it.

lgw

305 posts

241 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
Wording from the testers manual is as follows

2. With the steered wheels clear of the ground, rotate each wheel in turn and listen for any sound indicating roughness in the bearing.


esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
odyssey2200 said:
Look carefully at the wording of the failure sheet.

If it says on the sheet something that is not clearly listed as a reason for failure the garage and the tester ore in deep st.

Get hold of an appeal form.

Complete it, send it to VOSA who will arrange to meet with you at an independent garage and the VOSA guy will check your car.

If he passes it then the failing garage will have the tester suspended.

VOSA are VERY hot on the MOT being done TO THE LETTER of the manual from my (bitter ish) experiance.

If it does not give noise as a reason for failure in the MOT manual then the garage cannot fail it.
What he said at the time was that it was NOISY (albeit barely a whisper). He agreed it didn't feel rough and that there was no play.

What it says on the sheet is that it FEELS ROUGH. Not what he said.

I don't want to appeal, I don't have the time to run about meeting people, I'm busy enough as it is and the car (and garage) are miles from my work. I don't even have time this week to book it into another MOT centre and see how it gets on. I'll fix it and get it passed and that's it.
And hope it doesn't fail on something else at the new Test Centre....

tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
esselte said:
And hope it doesn't fail on something else at the new Test Centre....
No I meant I'll fix it and take it back, this time.

falcemob

8,248 posts

267 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
I was just wondering if he had mistaken a slight bearing noise for brake pads rubbing against the disc.

tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
falcemob said:
I was just wondering if he had mistaken a slight bearing noise for brake pads rubbing against the disc.
No it's not loud enough for that.

He may have mistaken the noise of a butterfly farting in Thailand for the noise of a wheel bearing though. (Can you tell I'm not still bitter?)

It really is almost imperceptible (either that or I'm going deaf)

BMWBen

4,906 posts

232 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
why not be deeply cunning and tell him you fixed it when in fact you haven't and see if he falls for it?