Wrong Colour Car in Police Statement
Discussion
That doesn't make the statement invalid, technically.
If you go to court, he will give his testimony verbally. you will then get the chance to cross examine him.
At that time you could question his memory of the events by asking him the colour of your car, and what he wrote. The magistrates may read into that the rest of his evidence may be slightly out too, they may not.
In my appeal, it was the officer's memory of event a year ago which was what the case rode upon. He later admitted to the court that he could not remember the colour of my car. It was pretty remarkable though, as it is bright yellow.
However, was found guilty. Therefore if this is all you have to go on, I would suggest that the difference between white and silver will not be enough to discount his other evidence.
If you go to court, he will give his testimony verbally. you will then get the chance to cross examine him.
At that time you could question his memory of the events by asking him the colour of your car, and what he wrote. The magistrates may read into that the rest of his evidence may be slightly out too, they may not.
In my appeal, it was the officer's memory of event a year ago which was what the case rode upon. He later admitted to the court that he could not remember the colour of my car. It was pretty remarkable though, as it is bright yellow.
However, was found guilty. Therefore if this is all you have to go on, I would suggest that the difference between white and silver will not be enough to discount his other evidence.
toxicfrog said:
Ive successfully had another case thrown out on the colour of the car I was driving.
Im not going to court, going to do it via post.
Just wondered whether I should plea, and if so guilty or not - or whether I should ask for it to be thrown out.
Paul
Perhaps the CPS couldnt be bothered with the case before.Im not going to court, going to do it via post.
Just wondered whether I should plea, and if so guilty or not - or whether I should ask for it to be thrown out.
Paul
You either have to plead guilty, or not guilty. You can of course add any reasons why you are not guilty, and I suppose on the odd occasion if they think they will get a difficult case they may decide not to follow it up.
On the face of it though, if you plead not guilty, that will mean coming to court if they decide not to drop the case. Then you are chancing your arm if you can win the case on that. IMHO, you may have got lucky the first time, I don't think that is the usual procedure.
JustinP1 said:
At that time you could question his memory of the events by asking him the colour of your car, and what he wrote. The magistrates may read into that the rest of his evidence may be slightly out too, they may not.
In my appeal, it was the officer's memory of event a year ago which was what the case rode upon. He later admitted to the court that he could not remember the colour of my car. It was pretty remarkable though, as it is bright yellow.
However, was found guilty. Therefore if this is all you have to go on, I would suggest that the difference between white and silver will not be enough to discount his other evidence.
I am partially colour blind (although not bad enough to consider bright yellow as a suitable colour for a car) although this was not apparent to me. After discovering it I used to avoid mentioning colour of cars in court statements. If I stopped a car I used to ask the driver what colour it was. The problem was exacerbated under some lighting conditions. It came up in evidence once and I explained my condition before answering and the brief pulled the question before I could say what I thought it was.In my appeal, it was the officer's memory of event a year ago which was what the case rode upon. He later admitted to the court that he could not remember the colour of my car. It was pretty remarkable though, as it is bright yellow.
However, was found guilty. Therefore if this is all you have to go on, I would suggest that the difference between white and silver will not be enough to discount his other evidence.
It used to be a bar on joining the Job but it's since been found to be sexual discrimination. I joined in 1975 where the only requirement was to turn up for interview. Two arms and two legs was just an added advantage. If you didn't walk into walls your eyesight was 20/20.
JustinP1 said:
Chrispy Porker said:
OK
I'll ask the stupid question.
How does colour blindness add up to sexual discrimination?
Are there no colour blind women??
Well, er no actually! I'll ask the stupid question.
How does colour blindness add up to sexual discrimination?
Are there no colour blind women??

Seriously, I believe that the most common one, red/green I think is male only or 99% male anyway.
toxicfrog said:
Hi,
HMs finest are taking me to court over a driving offence. The coppers statement which has been signed/submitted states I was driving a White Mercedes, when in fact the car is silver.
Any comments?
Paul
It will not be terribly relevant depending upon the circumstances. What are the circumstances (without giving too much away which may incriminate).HMs finest are taking me to court over a driving offence. The coppers statement which has been signed/submitted states I was driving a White Mercedes, when in fact the car is silver.
Any comments?
Paul
For example, if there were two silver cars racing away at the lights, and you were not one of them, but got pulled for allegedly racing away at the lights, you may have a shout.
[quote=Derek
It used to be a bar on joining the Job but it's since been found to be sexual discrimination. I joined in 1975 where the only requirement was to turn up for interview. Two arms and two legs was just an added advantage. If you didn't walk into walls your eyesight was 20/20.
[/quote]
Are certain jobs. (ok trumpton) which have varying standards for people of varying ethnicities/sex etc, exempt from the sex discrimination law due to the fact that they could be dealing with red or green gas cylinders etc which carry different gases, train drivers who have red and green signals etc,
The above examples are going back a while, but at the time speaking to an aussie they were surprised at some of our systems, tv remote's etc with colours, they had a system of square,triangle, circle etc on the screen/buttons to avoid the issue.
It used to be a bar on joining the Job but it's since been found to be sexual discrimination. I joined in 1975 where the only requirement was to turn up for interview. Two arms and two legs was just an added advantage. If you didn't walk into walls your eyesight was 20/20.
[/quote]
Are certain jobs. (ok trumpton) which have varying standards for people of varying ethnicities/sex etc, exempt from the sex discrimination law due to the fact that they could be dealing with red or green gas cylinders etc which carry different gases, train drivers who have red and green signals etc,
The above examples are going back a while, but at the time speaking to an aussie they were surprised at some of our systems, tv remote's etc with colours, they had a system of square,triangle, circle etc on the screen/buttons to avoid the issue.
F i F said:
Derek Smith said:
I am partially colour blind (although not bad enough to consider bright yellow as a suitable colour for a car)
Justinp1, I think we can effectively point and say:- Burn!I bought it because it was cheap and sold it because it was cheap. To be frank the colour was the least of my worries with that motor!
NobleGuy said:
toxicfrog said:
Hi,
HMs finest are taking me to court over a driving offence. The coppers statement which has been signed/submitted states I was driving a White Mercedes, when in fact the car is silver.
Any comments?
Paul
Get it resprayed blue HMs finest are taking me to court over a driving offence. The coppers statement which has been signed/submitted states I was driving a White Mercedes, when in fact the car is silver.
Any comments?
Paul
.If however you do think of trying it, remembber yo invest in some soap on a rope
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/hereford/worcs/...
Forums | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




t....start another thread instead of ruining mine.