So how short are the police?
So how short are the police?
Author
Discussion

johnnywb

Original Poster:

1,631 posts

239 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
5'3" 5'6" ??? (sorry)

Reading in the post about H&S when breaking up raves;

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&t=531854 

and considering the views experessing that the Police are short on numbers, how short do the BIBs resident here feel that the Police are nationally?

If you consider how many BIB you would like to have, or perhaps rather, would need to get jobs done properly and allow you to do your job to a level you are happy with, where are we at? On a national basis are we at 90% of this figure, 80% etc?

And with this in mind, do you feel that the apparent rise in violent crime in city centres (London is the obvious example) is a result of forces being short on officers?

And i' talking about proper fully trained police officers here, not PCSOs.

Edited by johnnywb on Tuesday 13th May 14:33

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Put it this way.

I used to put out a shift of 5 pc's maximum for a large area.

To deal with all the incomming jobs i would have needed to double or triple that.

Violent crime is partly due to numbers, but also to do with factors such as drugs or alcohol, fights will break out in front of a transit full of coppers.



Edited by ^Slider^ on Tuesday 13th May 14:40

JulianHJ

8,871 posts

293 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
My section is 30% light on numbers. The funding is there I think (as section strength is an agreed figure) we just can't get people recruited quickly enough to fill the exodus away from response, particuarly to the Met and other forces but also to other departments. This applies across my force.

It means we're run ragged.

Battenburg Bob

8,858 posts

223 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Response Officer numbers (the ones that count) are down massively. They have all been moved sideways to create nu-Labours 'neighbourhood teams'. Unfortunately, they don't deal with crime....but apparently you can have their mobile number if you want it.

As a response shift Sgt, I had four people to Police 500 square miles. That included a couple of good sized towns and countless villages. Now, as a traffic officer, I have between four and ten (depending upon holidays/courses) for 500 miles of motorway.

johnnywb

Original Poster:

1,631 posts

239 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
We commented on Friday night when two bobbies (a sergeant and a PC) came into the pub we were in on the Kings Road that it was the first time since before i went to uni (5 years ago) that we'd actually seen Police officers on foot patrol on a Saturday night, rather than arriving in a reactionary role.

It was refreshing to see, but i do wonder how long it will be until i see it again.

Do people think the situation will change? Will we get police back on the streets (and please god on the roads)? And if so, what's going to be the catalyst?

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
I'll put down my pipe, put my slippers on, get out of the rocking chair and tell you what's different.

There are three major changes:

1/ Expectation has increased tremendously and, on top of that,

2/ Workload has increased tremendously.

Public expectation has gone up no end. I can't remember all that many shed burglaries being reported, many burglaries, shop breaks and such were not reported either. Only posh people asked the police to attend burglaries in the old days as everyone knew that there would be limited investigation into them. If there were a spate of those with a similar MO then someone would be detailed to sort it out but in general there were few enquiries made. If the local beat officer hadn't a clue, then no one else had either. Nowadays it seems that all burglaries are reported if there's an insurance claim and if it's reported the victims wants to know why nothing is being done about it.

The same goes for such things as domestic violence. They were hardly ever dealt with in the past but nowadays there's normally a prisoner involved.

And the list goes on.

Police are called to so many occurrences that they were never called to before and each requires work.

On top of that there is the workload which increases year on year. Much has been said on these forums about the paperwork and such that there's no need to repeat it here. However, I once had 13 prisoners one night and dealt with them all by the time I went off duty. A couple or so went to crown court so required a report for the prosecution solicitors but these took little time and I probably completed them whilst on paterol in the personnel carrier.

The last prisoner I had virtually took me the whole day to document, interview and such and this still left me with work the following day. It started with the introduction of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act. The extra work required from the police was not funded.

And the third thing is the politicisation of the police. What this means is that in order to look good on the hustings MPs will start initiatives and such which the police will have to create reports and such. So police are taken off the streets and put in offices where they receive congratulations for producing unreadable and unread reports that have no effect. I've had courses on racial awareness, domestic violence, health and safety, equal opportunities, problem solving (this last one despite the fact that not only did I used to teach it but the course was based on my work). Oh, and tactical firearms awareness, air sea rescue, financial liability for damages, probably another on equal opportunities, one on the new discipline procedures, two on the changes to the shift system that would revolutionaise policing for 50 years - it lasted four - and so many others that the brain goes blank. There are, of course, very few courses on how to be an effective police officer. Can you see why raves or not policed? By the time he's considered equal opportunities, produced a healt and safety report, taken into account the likely costs of overtime and public liability, worked out if the group has an obvious ethnic mix and therefore needing some racial consideration as to ethnic recreation diversity the crowd have gone home, are tucked up in bed and the hierachy are pleased that no one's actually done anything.

An inspector used to be able to tell who were the keen PCs as these were the ones who turned up early for briefing and were also able to grab the chairs. I have run a brief where me and the sergeant outnumbered the patroling officers available for calls. For the first three hours of the shift we had three response cars, one driven by an inspector, another by the sergeant and the third by the PC. This was a Sunday morning and I also had reviews to do.

So there's more calls, there's more paperwork and there's less PCs. Strikes me as an odd way to run the policing of this country.

This might come over as a bit cynical. And you are right.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
We have enough coppers, just too many laws.

petermansell

868 posts

237 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
We have enough coppers, just too many laws.
+1 clap

Taita

8,021 posts

234 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
fking well open up for new applicants then. Can't remember the last time Merseyside recruited, or am I just missing the slots!

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
This is probably the most depressing post I have seen on here since I came on PH back in 2001 (I think), it sums up what is wrong with ALL our public services.
I have a solution to the problems with our schools, hospitals, dentists and police. It is simple and there is a 100% chance of it working.

All we have to do is to pass a law which says that MPs have to use the National Health Service, can only go to a dentist providing Natinal Health cover, sends all their children to a school - which may or may not be the one nearest to them - and have their requests for police assistance, such as their rather pathetic conferences, their special branch officers, their armed guards, their traffic escorts and the rest, simply stuck on the list of calls to be dealt with when an officer is available.

I promise you that we would have a health service second to none, just like the one the MPs have now, they would not interfere with the way the head teachers run their schools and would not make the kids have exams on a daily basis, nor would they force them to have lessons that no one wants, and the police would be properly funded, the CPS would be told that they cannot make stupid demands, and, most importantly of all, no public service would be required to hit targets.

And, not only that, it would all happen in a week. Blunkett wouldn't be allowed near the schools, health service or the police, nor Jack Smith come to that. Instead they'll have a doctor in charge of the health service, a teacher in charge of the school and a police officer running the police.

Anyone reckon that I'm wrong? Anyone that stupid?

BOF

991 posts

254 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
"Anyone reckon that I'm wrong? Anyone that stupid?"

Aren't the MPs talking about giving themselves a 23% salary increase?

After giving the Police what... 3% was it...

If we let them get away with this, we are ALL that stupid.

On the day they increased their pensions by 40% some years ago - 1200 workers in my area discovered that their fund was empty.

I did write to my MP asking about the morality of this - got the usual waffle, including..."the working life of an MP can be uncertain and provision must be made etc".

WE let them get away with it - every time - US!

BOF.

Jasandjules

72,695 posts

260 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
Anyone reckon that I'm wrong? Anyone that stupid?
Whilst I am quite probably stupid, I don't think you're wrong.

It never ceases to amaze me how they can put a Road Sweeper in charge of Schools etc (you know what I mean) - but then saying that, we had a Barrister in charge of new laws, and that went t*ts up.

Battenburg Bob

8,858 posts

223 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Police got 1.9%. And we should be grateful for that apparently. If they pay us 2.5%, the £40 million extra would bring the country to its knees according to Brown.

Although he managed to give India £1 billion pounds in 'aid' the same week.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
It never ceases to amaze me how they can put a Road Sweeper in charge of Schools etc (you know what I mean) - but then saying that, we had a Barrister in charge of new laws, and that went t*ts up.
When they passed a new Criminal Justice Act, one with aggravating factors - 1996? - I was told (tasked) to produce a report on how to impliment it. I did lots of research, went to the Home Office and saw some 18-year-old department head (rather pretty though) who knew the answers to none of my questions, and kept saying, "Leave that with me and I'll get back to you." Then saw the CPS who gave me all sorts of pointers. I then went to see the resident judge at Lewes (sitting at Hove) crown court. Lovely bloke with a bit of sense and an honesty in his dealings with the police that was refreshing. His language might have been direct but I always knew what he meant - as did the defendants when being sentanced. And he seemed the only person who had any knowledge of the new law. When I told him that I wanted his input and gave him my draft report he asked for half an hour to read it. He then came back, gave me a court commendation for its throughness and clearness, and then told me that the system was unworkable and a new law, replacing the new one (if you follow) would be passed in a few weeks. Meaning, of course, that all the work I'd put in was wasted.

Mind you, I'd already formed the opinion that it was unworkable but I had to try. The judge, Gower, said he thought one of my ideas was excellent and innovative and it was such a shame that it was useless.

BOF

991 posts

254 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Battenburg Bob said:
Police got 1.9%. And we should be grateful for that apparently. If they pay us 2.5%, the £40 million extra would bring the country to its knees according to Brown.

Although he managed to give India £1 billion pounds in 'aid' the same week.
Extracts from Darling Alastairs' speech today...

""So, at a cost of £2.7 billion, I will increase the individual personal tax allowance by £600 to £6035 for this financial year, benefiting all basic rate taxpayers under 65.

I am able to finance this proposal through borrowing this year ensuring that we do not take money out of the economy at this time.""

Does this mean I CAN afford the new Jag after all...even if I'm skint?

BOF

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
[quote=Battenburg Bob]Response Officer numbers (the ones that count) are down massively. They have all been moved sideways to create nu-Labours 'neighbourhood teams'. Unfortunately, they don't deal with crime....but apparently you can have their mobile number if you want it.

quote]

On response -sorry bob - we had two briliant CBO in this area a few years ago --diference between response and CBO - CBO sorted things out long term - response only interested in a quick fix.

Now -I aghree with you -we have one (or is it two plastic cops -PCSO)as one beat Sergeant said -"now we ain't going to be short of donuts -we can send them out (but don't expect them back this shift)

And he was acredited with the saying -Why do PCSO's go out in threes -
One to find the way there ,another to find way home ,another to ask questions.

Chrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
Jasandjules said:
It never ceases to amaze me how they can put a Road Sweeper in charge of Schools etc (you know what I mean) - but then saying that, we had a Barrister in charge of new laws, and that went t*ts up.
When they passed a new Criminal Justice Act, one with aggravating factors - 1996? - I was told (tasked) to produce a report on how to impliment it. I did lots of research, went to the Home Office and saw some 18-year-old department head (rather pretty though) who knew the answers to none of my questions, and kept saying, "Leave that with me and I'll get back to you." Then saw the CPS who gave me all sorts of pointers. I then went to see the resident judge at Lewes (sitting at Hove) crown court. Lovely bloke with a bit of sense and an honesty in his dealings with the police that was refreshing. His language might have been direct but I always knew what he meant - as did the defendants when being sentanced. And he seemed the only person who had any knowledge of the new law. When I told him that I wanted his input and gave him my draft report he asked for half an hour to read it. He then came back, gave me a court commendation for its throughness and clearness, and then told me that the system was unworkable and a new law, replacing the new one (if you follow) would be passed in a few weeks. Meaning, of course, that all the work I'd put in was wasted.

Mind you, I'd already formed the opinion that it was unworkable but I had to try. The judge, Gower, said he thought one of my ideas was excellent and innovative and it was such a shame that it was useless.
You would not believe ( Derek would) the amount of time, money and aggravation that our force has invested in producing a succinct user friendly HRA and PACE oompliant Cannabis Warning Form.

Just in time to see the bloody stuff re-classified.



sidaorb

5,595 posts

237 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
You would not believe ( Derek would) the amount of time, money and aggravation that our force has invested in producing a succinct user friendly HRA and PACE oompliant Cannabis Warning Form.

Just in time to see the bloody stuff re-classified.
Seems to be total despair in our place about this classic u-turn, but as one officer said to me the other day.......'At least it will boost my sanctioned detections'wink

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
BOF said:
Battenburg Bob said:
Police got 1.9%. And we should be grateful for that apparently. If they pay us 2.5%, the £40 million extra would bring the country to its knees according to Brown.

Although he managed to give India £1 billion pounds in 'aid' the same week.
Extracts from Darling Alastairs' speech today...

""So, at a cost of £2.7 billion, I will increase the individual personal tax allowance by £600 to £6035 for this financial year, benefiting all basic rate taxpayers under 65.
With the exception of some 1.1 million (at the last night's count) taxpayers who will stil be worse off! When this load of incompetents fcensoredk up, they do so in spades and cost us even more money each time ... and the fcensoredk up every time they try to do anything - Streaky

ypauly

15,137 posts

231 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Taita said:
fking well open up for new applicants then. Can't remember the last time Merseyside recruited, or am I just missing the slots!
i was thinking similar thoughts
how do they find thousands of PCSO's but are not able to find good coppers who are paid and respected alot more than a pcso?