Under Age Driver
Author
Discussion

Chrisgr31

Original Poster:

14,300 posts

286 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
I have the misfortune to be chair of the local village hall committee and today my mother takes my daughter (who's 3) to a dance class at the hall.

She parks in the hall car park and gets my daughter out of the car and starts to walk through the car park to the hall, when a car comes from a gar workshop opposite, drives into the car park at speed, and parks. The driver gets out and turns out to be young (16 it later becomes apparent). My mother is disgusted by the speed and standard of driving as well as the age of the driver so phones the police.

They turn up and say nothing they can do because the offence occured on private land.

However I am not sure they are right.

The facts are that the hall sits on a rectangular site, the shirt edge at the front boundary fronts the public highway. The car park is at the rear of the site, accessed from an entrance on the rear short edge.

There is a private roadway which runs down one long edge of the site and this roadway serves a number of businesses including the car workshop. At the end of our site an access comes off this priave road and seves a number of lock up garages on the opposite side of it to us. , and then a number of houses. I don;t know the status of this road.

To get into our car park from the workshop, the lad needs to have driven along a small length of the private road, along half the road of unknown staus and turned into our car park.

None of the roads are marked as private and as stated serve a number of businesses and houses.

So is an underage, unlicenced driver permitted to drive on these roads?

Although my initial plan was to take it up with the local police inspector who I know, on reflection if it is an offence I think I might just write to the garage owner pointing him in the direction of the legislation. Might limit the consequences. Apart from anything else I guess if there was an accident the driver ould not be insured and of course the car is a customer car!

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Might be public, might be private ... there were some postings on this topic very recently (try searching for "street lighting" and "private" / "public road") - Streaky

PottyMouth

470 posts

227 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
So what would you expect the police to do? Sit outside the garage all day in the hope of catching the 16 year old driver in the act of his daily 30-second drive?

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
PottyMouth said:
So what would you expect the police to do? Sit outside the garage all day in the hope of catching the 16 year old driver in the act of his daily 30-second drive?
How about going into the garage, finding the culprit (or his boss) and having a quiet, or if necessary loud, word. Would be nice if the police would actually police once in a while, it doesn't all have to be done through the courts in any sane world.

Chrisgr31

Original Poster:

14,300 posts

286 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Einion Yrth said:
PottyMouth said:
So what would you expect the police to do? Sit outside the garage all day in the hope of catching the 16 year old driver in the act of his daily 30-second drive?
How about going into the garage, finding the culprit (or his boss) and having a quiet, or if necessary loud, word. Would be nice if the police would actually police once in a while, it doesn't all have to be done through the courts in any sane world.
Indeed I would expect them to know the law, and would expect them to have a word with the garage owner to suggest that it's not the brightest idea having someone of that age driving cars in an area where the public, including young children have access.

I don't want the Police to bring the full power of the law on to the offender, well unless I get continued reports about it happening again and again.

After all is there a danger if I do nothing and someone gets knocked over they then sue me because I knew this 16 year old was driving and had done nothing about it?

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
If its private land and he has not gone onto the road he does not commit an offence of having no licence or no insurance as far as I'm aware.

However he may commit offences of careless or dangerous driving if the land can be shown to be a public place.

The police attended its not their fault the law says what it does.

Had he been on a road the car could have been taken and the driver dealt with.

I never have a 'quiet' word unless I am in a strong legal position to do so, otherwise bluffs get called or you get told where to go.

Chrisgr31

Original Poster:

14,300 posts

286 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
If its private land and he has not gone onto the road he does not commit an offence of having no licence or no insurance as far as I'm aware.

However he may commit offences of careless or dangerous driving if the land can be shown to be a public place.

The police attended its not their fault the law says what it does.

Had he been on a road the car could have been taken and the driver dealt with.

I never have a 'quiet' word unless I am in a strong legal position to do so, otherwise bluffs get called or you get told where to go.
Thanks for the explanation. I knew I had read about drink driving, careless driving etc in a public place, and rashly assumed that they meant you'd need insurance and a licence to drive in a public place. Where the law is concerned you can never assume anything!

Anyway the good news is that the Police did attend and the work of the garage was disrupted whilst they attended etc so perhaps they'll desist in future. In the meantime in addition to users of the hall complaining about the workshop using the car park I now have my wife and mother complaining about it and asking why I don't do anything about it. At the same time they complain about the about of time the hall management takes! Can't win!

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Chrisgr31 said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
If its private land and he has not gone onto the road he does not commit an offence of having no licence or no insurance as far as I'm aware.

However he may commit offences of careless or dangerous driving if the land can be shown to be a public place.

The police attended its not their fault the law says what it does.

Had he been on a road the car could have been taken and the driver dealt with.

I never have a 'quiet' word unless I am in a strong legal position to do so, otherwise bluffs get called or you get told where to go.
Thanks for the explanation. I knew I had read about drink driving, careless driving etc in a public place, and rashly assumed that they meant you'd need insurance and a licence to drive in a public place. Where the law is concerned you can never assume anything!

Anyway the good news is that the Police did attend and the work of the garage was disrupted whilst they attended etc so perhaps they'll desist in future. In the meantime in addition to users of the hall complaining about the workshop using the car park I now have my wife and mother complaining about it and asking why I don't do anything about it. At the same time they complain about the about of time the hall management takes! Can't win!
Insurance, licence and I think all the con and use offences require you to be on a road. Drink driving etc - all things that are considered directly dangerous to others are applicable on public spaces. If they are public at that time.

It a 'loop hole' probably going back to farming or similar.