M11 today, almost a pile up...
M11 today, almost a pile up...
Author
Discussion

Digby

Original Poster:

8,361 posts

277 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Reason? The person a few cars in front of me slammed their brakes on due to the scamera van sitting on a bridge.Sigh.
Everything was just fine and dandy up until then and all of a sudden it was all mass panic as we had to anchor up to
under 50 mph! They had no reason to brake, but i assume the various limits that are used in road works, those '50 mph, debris in road' type signs which stay lit for 3 weeks and idiotic variable limits etc made them panic at the thought of being "caught" at the wrong speed.I am just glad i looked up at the right time as i was doing just the same as everyone else no doubt, namely, checking the speedo numerous times as we approached the van.

This situation will only get worse and worse as people get more and more points.


There actually was a crash on the opposite side of the carriageway though, just before the bridge the scamera van was parked on as it happens and i wondered if the same thing had happened over that side, but the people hadn't looked up in time to avoid an impact.

qooqiiu

753 posts

228 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Where abouts exactly?

Anywhere near the newly installed average speed traps?

Scraggles

7,619 posts

255 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
saw one last week, just after the harlow turn off, then a long hill with a bridge half way to the m25, scamera van on the bridge but think it was in the 50 mph roadworks, not totally sure - tend to slow a bit for vehicles on bridges, esp vans smile

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Digby said:
There actually was a crash on the opposite side of the carriageway though, just before the bridge the scamera van was parked on as it happens and i wondered if the same thing had happened over that side, but the people hadn't looked up in time to avoid an impact.
More likely they hadn't looked down again in time. The scameras must love the accidents they cause, it's grist to their mill - Streaky

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
In a perfect world, the police in the van would have seen what happened and reported the driver slamming on his brakes for dangerous driving.

Selfish people like that don't deserve to be on the road - their driving licenses are not more important than the safety of the people behind them.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
Selfish people like that don't deserve to be on the road - their driving licenses are not more important than the safety of the people behind them.
It's a bit daft though. A "selfish" person like that (if indeed they can be described as such) might well have continued on their journey without incident had the camera van not been placed.

Perhaps they were a professional driver already scammed three times when not speeding (don't forget the camera vans are proven to be unreliable) and desperate not to get done again becuase losing his licence means not being able to put food on his family's table or a roof over their head.

Besides, people behind are responsible for not running into the back of people in front when they brake for emergencies.

My problem is that the speed camera businesses routinely and knowingly introduce "emergencies" for a living.

SM

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
It's a bit daft though. A "selfish" person like that (if indeed they can be described as such) might well have continued on their journey without incident had the camera van not been placed.
He may well have, or he may have caused danger for other road users further up the road, we don't know.

supermono said:
Perhaps they were a professional driver already scammed three times when not speeding (don't forget the camera vans are proven to be unreliable) and desperate not to get done again becuase losing his licence means not being able to put food on his family's table or a roof over their head.
If this was the case, it would make him even more selfish - by driving at those kinds of speeds, knowing that getting caught would mean his family starving.


supermono said:
Besides, people behind are responsible for not running into the back of people in front when they brake for emergencies.
They certainly are, but common sense would suggest that hitting the brakes hard in the middle of a motorway to be a bad idea.

supermono said:
My problem is that the speed camera businesses routinely and knowingly introduce "emergencies" for a living.

SM
Bad drivers cause these incidents, not speed cameras (Just as it is a bad driver who kills, not the concept of speed)wink

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
some stuff
I'm saying hypothetically maybe his other tickets were wrong. Like the 100mph milkfloat and other highly publicised "funnies". If your car is capable of the speed they've charged you with, you cannot get off. If you're in a milkfloat accused of 100, it gets in the papers as a humourous story. Supposing his van was clocked at 100. No defence because it could have done 100 and not very funny either.

I don't understand your logic though. Someone who brakes and crashes in front of a camera van DID have an accident. If the van wasn't there, they MIGHT have an accident further up the road. The van CAUSED that accident, any notional accidents that might happen elsewhere on the journey are imaginary.

Do you see that?

SM

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
supermono said:
My problem is that the speed camera businesses routinely and knowingly introduce "emergencies" for a living.

SM
Bad drivers cause these incidents, not speed cameras (Just as it is a bad driver who kills, not the concept of speed)wink
I've just thought up an analagy that might help you see this more clearly. I've a friend who routinely uses his circular saw without a guard. I keep telling him it's unsafe and one day he'll come unstuck but he assures me he knows what he's doing. The other day he was in his workshop using the saw dangerously so I crept up behind him and yelled into his ear as loud as I could. He jumped and cut off his arm.

So who's to blame for his missing arm?

SM

Scamper

732 posts

253 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
ahhh the wurzel is alive and kicking.....still posting when it suits and ignoring my call for a demonstration drive to see how we should all be driving.

BTW the original driver who panic braked is symptomatic of the paranoia every driver (except wurzel obviously) has when driving along and spots a scamera i.e. they havent looked at their speedo for a while (why should they) so do not know of their exact speed at that exact moment.

jwo

989 posts

280 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
the wurzel is alive and kicking - in a parallel universe it would appear and clearly provoking people with idealistic nonsense (is it half term or day release?)

irrespect of the cause of the brake application the driver behind should have enough space to react and avoid collision (in a perfect world), and also be suitably observant to have recognised the risk posed by the camera van and the likelihood that similarly observant people may be dropping acnhor sharpish.

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
The clear issue is that in normal driving, not everyone is doing the same thing at the same time, so overall there is a good level of safety. Not everyone is looking at their speedo at the same time for example.

This is changed when there is a camera van parked somewhere. Everyone is looking at their speedo without exception, and I do not believe anyone who says that they don't. Add to that, that people will brake, so you have a combination of a lot of people looking away from the road to their speedo at the same time, and a number of people braking at that time as well. That changes the balance of the normal level of safety.

With everything in life, if everyone does something at the same time - things don't work, whether it is using the phone or getting petrol. Changing parameters from the norm causes issues, and that is why I think those camera vans cause accidents as the normal balance is altered.

whyohwhy

280 posts

243 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Digby said:
Reason? The person a few cars in front of me slammed their brakes on due to the scamera van sitting on a bridge.Sigh.
Everything was just fine and dandy up until then and all of a sudden it was all mass panic as we had to anchor up to
under 50 mph! They had no reason to brake, but i assume the various limits that are used in road works, those '50 mph, debris in road' type signs which stay lit for 3 weeks and idiotic variable limits etc made them panic at the thought of being "caught" at the wrong speed.I am just glad i looked up at the right time as i was doing just the same as everyone else no doubt, namely, checking the speedo numerous times as we approached the van.

This situation will only get worse and worse as people get more and more points.


There actually was a crash on the opposite side of the carriageway though, just before the bridge the scamera van was parked on as it happens and i wondered if the same thing had happened over that side, but the people hadn't looked up in time to avoid an impact.
Wasn't the crash in the contraflow, which is covered by the average speed cameras? If so what was a Camera van doing covering the same stretch of road.

I've been through there eevery day, except last night (when I diverted through villages to avoid the queues) and traffic flows freely, albeit at 48 mph Don't see the point of a Scamera Van.

Scamper

732 posts

253 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
whyohwhy said:
Wasn't the crash in the contraflow, which is covered by the average speed cameras? If so what was a Camera van doing covering the same stretch of road.
Obviously people are now wise to the average speed cameras and once through accelerate to "highly dangerous" speeds - hence the mobile scamera van. End result is no loss of revenue!!!

Is it safer??? Well, thats not really the reason they are there.....is it?

Digby

Original Poster:

8,361 posts

277 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
The scamera van was either before or after that spec roadwork section, i don't remember which now.
That's two close calls i have had now due to speed cameras, i doubt i am alone.Suddenly, those video clips of
people crashing due to the van someone posted, feel all the more real.

It can't go on like this for ever surely? People really will only take so much BS and fact altering etc so others can get rich before civil unrest reaches fever pitch.I get the feeling the poll tax riots will be small fry compared to what's coming if this
continues.

Digby

Original Poster:

8,361 posts

277 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
jwo said:
irrespect of the cause of the brake application the driver behind should have enough space to react and avoid collision (in a perfect world), and also be suitably observant to have recognised the risk posed by the camera van and the likelihood that similarly observant people may be dropping acnhor sharpish.
Why would anyone be dropping an anchor when they were not speeding though? This guy wasn't speeding, he was doing 70 mph in a 70 mph zone, as were we all, he just did the same as i see people doing at red light cameras etc, he went into panic mode and decided the safest bet was to crawl past the sodding thing.

As for being observant and seeing the police van, what about builders vans and horse boxes etc with cameras in? Unless of course we should all start dropping back (causing confusion to those behind no doubt and forcing overtakes) every time we see a parked vehicle or odd looking wheelie bin - just in case the driver ahead thinks it's a camera and is about to lock up.This would mean that as well as the usual things we need to concentrate on when driving - you know, the ones that keep you and others safe, you would now have even more to think about and distract you when approaching scamera vans or potential scamera vans, because there is the chance of a nasty crash.Superb!

The main gripe here is that despite the fact we all avoided a crash, people could have easily crashed simply because they noticed the van and were concentrating on their speedos as a result, we sure came close that's for sure.I just happened to look back up at the right time to see brake lights all lit up.Had the same guy just overtaken me and pulled back in for example (less distance between us for a short time) i would have slammed straight into him due to looking at the bridge and my dials.


thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
I'm saying hypothetically maybe his other tickets were wrong.
Then hypothetically, I'd have some sympathy, but crawling past a camera van won't sort that out anyway.

supermono said:
I've just thought up an analagy that might help you see this more clearly. I've a friend who routinely uses his circular saw without a guard. I keep telling him it's unsafe and one day he'll come unstuck but he assures me he knows what he's doing. The other day he was in his workshop using the saw dangerously so I crept up behind him and yelled into his ear as loud as I could. He jumped and cut off his arm.

So who's to blame for his missing arm?
Consider another:

I have a friend who routinely uses his circular saw without a guard (despite it being compulsory by law to use one, widely accepted as the safe thing to do, and he works in a workshop with other people in close proximity)

The other day, he was in his workshop using his saw dangerously, and he saw a police car draw up outside the window. In his panic to reattach the guard to his saw, he cut somebody elses arm off.

Who's to blame for the missing arm?


Scamper said:
BTW the original driver who panic braked is symptomatic of the paranoia every driver (except wurzel obviously) has when driving along and spots a scamera i.e. they havent looked at their speedo for a while (why should they) so do not know of their exact speed at that exact moment.
Sometimes I wonder how people like that manage not to run out of fuel on a regular basis - after all, without having your eyes glued to your fuel gauge, there's no way to tell when you're running out rofl

EU_Foreigner said:
Changing parameters from the norm causes issues, and that is why I think those camera vans cause accidents as the normal balance is altered.
But if you believe some of the scaremongering done by certain websites, we're so saturated by cameras that they are the normwink

Digby said:
As for being observant and seeing the police van, what about builders vans and horse boxes etc with cameras in?
If visible cameras cause so many accidents, these are most definitely a good thing.

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Please people, don't feed the troll.

atom111

1,039 posts

256 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
What time was the scamera van on the M11 went up and down it today didn't see it frown

Edited by atom111 on Friday 16th May 20:59

Digby

Original Poster:

8,361 posts

277 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
atom111 said:
What time was the scamera van on the M11 went up and down it today didn't see it frown

Edited by atom111 on Friday 16th May 20:59
I saw it there yesterday, it was around 2.00/2.30pm i think.As i say, nobody was speeding, but the panic element which was also evident in the video clips posted a while back, was in full effect.'Safety cameras', you have to laugh..