Number plate attachment in France
Discussion
A family friend who has been travelling regularly from the UK to his holiday home in France and back again to the UK by his privately owned UK Registered car was pulled in April 2008 by "le BiB" for a routine document check. All was in order with the paperwork and he wasn't doing anything to attract attention.
However, when inspecting his vehicle one of the two Gendarmes noticed that his brand new UK supplied Vauxhall Zafira had the registration plates attached to the car by screws. The Gendarme then proceeded to tell my friend that it is an offence to travel in France with registration plates attached in this manner and the registration plates must instead be attached by rivets. He was told that although on this occasion it would be overlooked the next time he returned to France he would not be allowed to use the car if it had not been modified to comply with French Motoring laws!!
So the question is can the French BiB demand that a car registered in another EU country and complying with motoring legislation of the country it is supplied and registered in, be modified to meet the local motoring laws of France?
My friend is not particularly inclined to modify his car as it currently conforms to UK motoring legislation, unless this modification to foreign owned vehicles travelling in France is definately required. However, he is concerned that his vehicle registration number will now be on a french database which will be flagged up when he next visits France. Knowing how the French like the punitive "on-the-spot-fine" he clearly does not want to take a risk in this respect but at the same time does not want to modify his vehicle unnecessarily.
Has anyone had any similar experience or knowledge on this subject?
However, when inspecting his vehicle one of the two Gendarmes noticed that his brand new UK supplied Vauxhall Zafira had the registration plates attached to the car by screws. The Gendarme then proceeded to tell my friend that it is an offence to travel in France with registration plates attached in this manner and the registration plates must instead be attached by rivets. He was told that although on this occasion it would be overlooked the next time he returned to France he would not be allowed to use the car if it had not been modified to comply with French Motoring laws!!
So the question is can the French BiB demand that a car registered in another EU country and complying with motoring legislation of the country it is supplied and registered in, be modified to meet the local motoring laws of France?
My friend is not particularly inclined to modify his car as it currently conforms to UK motoring legislation, unless this modification to foreign owned vehicles travelling in France is definately required. However, he is concerned that his vehicle registration number will now be on a french database which will be flagged up when he next visits France. Knowing how the French like the punitive "on-the-spot-fine" he clearly does not want to take a risk in this respect but at the same time does not want to modify his vehicle unnecessarily.
Has anyone had any similar experience or knowledge on this subject?
Mr2Mike said:
This is absolutely the first time I have heard this one and the RAC and AA sites mention nothing about this in there section on driving on the continent. I suspect le gendarme was on a bit of a power trip.
flatsixmaniac said:
Cheers Mike, my thoughts too. I am aware of changes coming in to newly supplied and registered cars in France in that the number plate is to be attached to the car for life, but would this affect non-French registered vehicles simply visiting the country? I am not sure?
Thats ok then, if you think it's ok. Tell your friend not to bother sorting his car, then when he gets stopped and fined and given allsorts of grief by the French Police, you can take full responsibility, and pay his fines and expenses. All for the sake of a couple of rivets.
The French bib was correct, but also incorrect in that he obviously did not know that there is EU legislation that would void it. There is an EU law that says that as long as the vehicle is fully legal in it's home state, it is also fully legal in any other member state too, temporarily, even if there is something specific that may not be legal in a country in which the car may find itself. This legislation would cover just such a technicality like screws instead of rivets on the number plates.
I used to have this particular bit of legislation on some A4 sheets in several EU languages when we used to tow a Fiat Panda on an A frame behind our motorhome, as it is illegal to do this in France, but it is legal in the UK, and Germany and many other EU countries. I used to get French motorhome owners come up to me and discuss it enviously, as they are not allowed to tow a car on an A frame. Got stopped for it just the once in four years though, bib read the note, made some enquiries, and let me on my way.
I used to have this particular bit of legislation on some A4 sheets in several EU languages when we used to tow a Fiat Panda on an A frame behind our motorhome, as it is illegal to do this in France, but it is legal in the UK, and Germany and many other EU countries. I used to get French motorhome owners come up to me and discuss it enviously, as they are not allowed to tow a car on an A frame. Got stopped for it just the once in four years though, bib read the note, made some enquiries, and let me on my way.
The A4 sheets with the particular legislation came with the towing frame, passed it all on many years ago when we sold the outfit.
I have found this though, the pertinent paragraph looks to be a fair old coverall, it's not just about trailers and towing, you may be able to find the full thing...
http://www.towtal.co.uk/a-frames,-motorhomes-and-e...
The general practice agreements of the EEC state :
“Provided a vehicle complies with the Construction and Use Regulations in its country of registrations no modifications have to be made when the vehicle or vehicle/trailer combination is subsequently temporarily imported into another member country.
I have found this though, the pertinent paragraph looks to be a fair old coverall, it's not just about trailers and towing, you may be able to find the full thing...
http://www.towtal.co.uk/a-frames,-motorhomes-and-e...
The general practice agreements of the EEC state :
“Provided a vehicle complies with the Construction and Use Regulations in its country of registrations no modifications have to be made when the vehicle or vehicle/trailer combination is subsequently temporarily imported into another member country.
Edited by Balmoral Green on Saturday 17th May 20:49
Balmoral Green said:
There is an EU law that says that as long as the vehicle is fully legal in it's home state, it is also fully legal in any other member state too, temporarily, even if there is something specific that may not be legal in a country in which the car may find itself.
If this is so, why, on Police camera road wars ect, to the Police in this country prohibit continental HGV's traveling because of weight problems which are legal on the continent? I've seen it time and time again where a driver will say "well it's legal in Belgium" for the Police to say "well it's not legal here".Very strange , I have noticed a number of times in France that broken down cars have had num plates removed .Not easy to do on the h/s
I have imported 3 cars from Belgium and the transit plates have always been screw attached given that Belgi is next to france and they visit on a regular basis i find this again very strange.
Did he mention yellow headlamps ;-)
I have imported 3 cars from Belgium and the transit plates have always been screw attached given that Belgi is next to france and they visit on a regular basis i find this again very strange.
Did he mention yellow headlamps ;-)
Fort Jefferson said:
Balmoral Green said:
There is an EU law that says that as long as the vehicle is fully legal in it's home state, it is also fully legal in any other member state too, temporarily, even if there is something specific that may not be legal in a country in which the car may find itself.
If this is so, why, on Police camera road wars ect, to the Police in this country prohibit continental HGV's traveling because of weight problems which are legal on the continent? I've seen it time and time again where a driver will say "well it's legal in Belgium" for the Police to say "well it's not legal here".Qouted from the document mentioned earlier...."The vehicle on tow is for our personal use when the motorcaravan is parked on a camp site. It will be taken back to the UK when we have completed our holiday"
Would also suggest that an HGV is not classed as a temporary import as it is here for commercial reasons and engaged in trade.
B.G.
Not up to the Luure Francaise but that EEC doc you refer to is it not the Type Approval Certificate issued when a model is first made and confirms to certain standards (Con and Use) so that every other vehicle turned out is the same.
As a member of the EEC we in UK permit the use of a vehicle from abroad in UK that does not comply with certain Con and Use Regs (mainly length, width etc) providing it conforms to
Article 21 and Article 22 of the Convention on Road Traffic concluded at Geneva on 19th September 1949 and Part I, Part II (insofar as it relates to direction indicators and stop lights) and Part III of Annex 6 to that Convention; or
paragraphs 1, III and VIII of Article 3 of the International Convention relative to Motor Traffic concluded at Paris on 24th April 1926.
(Neither exmained by me)
In this case I would hardly think the manner the VRM attached would be covered in such detail as a rivit.
I can see why Frogplod was keen, a screw is easily removed without trace whereas a rivit would be broken if plate switched in a hurry?
Dvd
Not up to the Luure Francaise but that EEC doc you refer to is it not the Type Approval Certificate issued when a model is first made and confirms to certain standards (Con and Use) so that every other vehicle turned out is the same.
As a member of the EEC we in UK permit the use of a vehicle from abroad in UK that does not comply with certain Con and Use Regs (mainly length, width etc) providing it conforms to
Article 21 and Article 22 of the Convention on Road Traffic concluded at Geneva on 19th September 1949 and Part I, Part II (insofar as it relates to direction indicators and stop lights) and Part III of Annex 6 to that Convention; or
paragraphs 1, III and VIII of Article 3 of the International Convention relative to Motor Traffic concluded at Paris on 24th April 1926.
(Neither exmained by me)
In this case I would hardly think the manner the VRM attached would be covered in such detail as a rivit.
I can see why Frogplod was keen, a screw is easily removed without trace whereas a rivit would be broken if plate switched in a hurry?
Dvd
From the previous posts (thanks guys, gave me plenty of leads) I have been (busy) reading several documents and believe the following points mean le BiB have no jurisdiction over technical specifications/condition of a vehicle temporarily imported provided it meets the conditions of use legislation of the country of registration.
1. A VRM is used primarily to determine where tax is payable on a vehicle.
2. The Council of European Communities Directive 83/182/EEC of 28 March 1983 on tax exemptions within the Community for certain means of transport temporarily imported into one Member State from another has adopted the following directive (for those who wish to read in full - http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?...
Article 1
Scope
1. Member States shall, under the conditions laid down below, exempt temporary imports from another Member State of motor-driven road vehicles (including their trailers), caravans, pleasure boats, private aircraft, bicycles, tricycles and saddle-horses from: - turnover tax, excise duties and any other consumption tax,
2. The exemption referred to in paragraph 1 shall also apply to the normal spare parts, accessories and equipment imported with these means of transport.
Furthermore, the Economic Commission for Europe agreement concerning the adoption of uniform conditions for periodical technical inspections of wheeled vehicles (i.e. MOT in the UK) and the recipricol recognition of such inspections created in Vienna on 13 November 1997 have agreed as follows (for those who wish to read in full - http://www.unece.org/trans/conventn/conf4e.pdf);
Article 1
The Contracting Parties shall establish Rules for periodical technical
inspections of wheeled vehicles registered or taken into service in their
territory and shall reciprocally recognize the inspections carried out in
accordance with those Rules.
Both France and the UK are contracted parties to this agreement as follows;
http://www.unece.org/trans/conventn/legalinst_19_V...
Any thoughts on my logic?
1. A VRM is used primarily to determine where tax is payable on a vehicle.
2. The Council of European Communities Directive 83/182/EEC of 28 March 1983 on tax exemptions within the Community for certain means of transport temporarily imported into one Member State from another has adopted the following directive (for those who wish to read in full - http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?...
Article 1
Scope
1. Member States shall, under the conditions laid down below, exempt temporary imports from another Member State of motor-driven road vehicles (including their trailers), caravans, pleasure boats, private aircraft, bicycles, tricycles and saddle-horses from: - turnover tax, excise duties and any other consumption tax,
2. The exemption referred to in paragraph 1 shall also apply to the normal spare parts, accessories and equipment imported with these means of transport.
Furthermore, the Economic Commission for Europe agreement concerning the adoption of uniform conditions for periodical technical inspections of wheeled vehicles (i.e. MOT in the UK) and the recipricol recognition of such inspections created in Vienna on 13 November 1997 have agreed as follows (for those who wish to read in full - http://www.unece.org/trans/conventn/conf4e.pdf);
Article 1
The Contracting Parties shall establish Rules for periodical technical
inspections of wheeled vehicles registered or taken into service in their
territory and shall reciprocally recognize the inspections carried out in
accordance with those Rules.
Both France and the UK are contracted parties to this agreement as follows;
http://www.unece.org/trans/conventn/legalinst_19_V...
Any thoughts on my logic?
Well, it all makes sense to me, otherwise the simple fact that it was a UK plate and therefore not conforming to French law would be just as significant to French bib as the screws were, even more so one would have thought. Let alone the steering wheel being on the wrong side of the car 

Forums | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





