Insurance advise - hit someone in rear but...
Insurance advise - hit someone in rear but...
Author
Discussion

Chris_R

Original Poster:

164 posts

227 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
What happened was I was overtook someone, perfectly safe overtake, was in outside lane of two lane NSL road passing a queue of slower moving vehicles.
This then reduces in to one lane so pulled in nicely, maintaining distance between the vehicle in front and behind, not cutting up or nothing, fluid as you like. However the guy who is now positioned behind me goes ballistic - flashing, beeping horn, gesticulating that I may have done something wrong...the typical result in this day and age. He then accelerates up to my bumper so that I can no longer see the front of his car at all (this is now a single lane NSL, moving approx 45-50 mph). I flashed my brake lights at him as he was getting a bit close for my liking, didnt brake as there was a queue of traffic we where part of.
We are now approaching the road about and I proceed to apply my brakes in line with the vehicles in front as normal (not to a stop, just slowing maintaining a distance)...however at this point the guy behind me takes even more offence, floors it and overtakes pulling into a non existent gap leaving me with nothing but around a foot of stopping distance. He then slams on hard, even with my 6 pots there was no way I could avoid him and so I hit his bumper.

I have already rang my insurance and typically they just want to put it as hit third party in the rear, I have attempted to argue with them that it is not as clear cut as that (does that mean that if someone pulls out of a junction in front of me and I plough their rear because they didnt see me its my fault???) but they seem to have little interest.

The guy I hit made the smarmy comment of "you hit me in the back its all your fault now ha ha" I was somewhat livid. He also had a parting comment of "well its a company car anyway, what do I care, how you like that?"
Real arrogant tossbag and it was only my better judgement of it would not go down well that I didnt hit him and his chav son with my car jack.

I just want to ensure that it goes to a 50/50 at worst as there is little damage on either car (probably down to the small impact distance and that we where both braking anyway) and dont want him getting away with my no-claims (though it is protected fully).
Can I ensure this by sticking to my guns that it was a "road rage" type retaliation (which it was) which made no sense.

Any advise at all appreciated.




slow_poke

1,855 posts

265 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
Witnesses?

Chris_R

Original Poster:

164 posts

227 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
I am just waiting to find out, I was with a convoy coming back from Japfest, one of the lads is a friend of a friend (he was about 3 or 4 cars back at a guess) and he recognised my car and rang my mate to let him know he just spotted me - if that makes sense smile
Bloke who knows my mate, rang my mate when he seen me pull up on the side of the road following the accident

Typically all others in the queue just went round us and rubbernecked.

Edited by Chris_R on Saturday 17th May 21:23

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
What you need to do then is go about this the official way.

Basically, whether he took offence to your cutting in or not, this guys idiotic road rage driving caused an accident. You should tell your insurance company exactly how it is, and that you have a witness.

Your insurance company need to be your friends here as you need to get them on your side, as effectively they will be fighting your corner. Do you have the 'legal coverage' as the extra that costs a tenner or so each year on your insurance, if so, now is the time to use it.

Ask the insurance company whether you should report the incident to the police. If you do so and the police look to follow this up then this obviously adds credence to what you are saying is the truth. If nothing else the police have two witnesses, in you and your mate, if he ends up taking a caution, then effectively you have some proof to the insurance company that what you are saying is true...

Chris_R

Original Poster:

164 posts

227 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
I reported it to the police at the scene. They attended and said I shouldnt have called them as there was no injury (I had called them due to the guys son started swearing/threatening and wanted a good kicking - I restrained myself so as to not to incriminate myself when the police turn up and find the pair of them with bloody noses by the side of the road). The police also "offered" me the option of us both being done with a charge of undue care and attention if I wished to push the matter. One of the coppers seemed sympathetic to my pleas of this guy basically using his car as a retaliatory weapon, the other decided (somehow with no evidence, glad to see that doesn't actually matter) that it was me who was road-raging because I said the F word when describing the other blokes actions in my statement - W.T.F?! Being annoyed because I get my car damaged is a crime apparently. I didn't realise the old good cop-bad cop thing was still done LOL.

I have legal cover so will get them on the case, I am refusing to loose out because of this guy,


The Black Duke

1,642 posts

224 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
Exactly the same thing happened to me in Cardiff except the driver was a taxi driver I was driving a video car (not police) and and he was in a rush. I noticed he was close behind me, I maintained my speed, he overtook me (city centre) he missed the fact the light was red about 25 yds in front slammed on the breaks I drove to the left and clipped the rear of the car. The tw@t then jumped out and starting hurling abuse at me in broken English and was jumping up and down calling me a hooligan, dangerous and he was shouting and swearing etc. Anyway I managed to get him to pull over to the pavement and called the police. BiB came and breathalysed both of us. The police refused to take statements from any witness (bearing in mind the video is still running). I was shaking with anger at this point and was a bit rude to the police officer and called him lazy. The officer obviously took offence to this but nothing came of it. Anyway I got 5 witness statements one was from a Barrister who was visiting a firm of solicitors. I also had the video evidence.
To be honest I have never seen so much evidence backing something up in my life. When I contacted the Insurance company they said that as I hit the other driver they would not pursue the other driver and said I was responsible.
There is good news to this story I eventually won the case with a little help from my solicitor and it was this that got me interested in the law. I am currently studying for a Law Masters (LLM).
Sorry if I go on but can't believe that someone else has had this too.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
The Black Duke said:
Exactly the same thing happened to me in Cardiff except the driver was a taxi driver I was driving a video car (not police) and and he was in a rush. I noticed he was close behind me, I maintained my speed, he overtook me (city centre) he missed the fact the light was red about 25 yds in front slammed on the breaks I drove to the left and clipped the rear of the car. The tw@t then jumped out and starting hurling abuse at me in broken English and was jumping up and down calling me a hooligan, dangerous and he was shouting and swearing etc. Anyway I managed to get him to pull over to the pavement and called the police. BiB came and breathalysed both of us. The police refused to take statements from any witness (bearing in mind the video is still running). I was shaking with anger at this point and was a bit rude to the police officer and called him lazy. The officer obviously took offence to this but nothing came of it. Anyway I got 5 witness statements one was from a Barrister who was visiting a firm of solicitors. I also had the video evidence.
To be honest I have never seen so much evidence backing something up in my life. When I contacted the Insurance company they said that as I hit the other driver they would not pursue the other driver and said I was responsible.
There is good news to this story I eventually won the case with a little help from my solicitor and it was this that got me interested in the law. I am currently studying for a Law Masters (LLM).
Sorry if I go on but can't believe that someone else has had this too.
Nice post.

As soon as you mentioned your insurance companies position, I thought it was going to end badly...

Happy ending though!

Chris_R

Original Poster:

164 posts

227 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
Actually thinking about it, do I even have to mention that I had overtaken him a mile back? It would just be conjecture on my part that this incited his manouver.
Surely the incident of him overtaking as other traffic is braking for a give way junction (a roundabout) is silly enough on its own?

Robatr0n

12,362 posts

247 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Why would you hide the fact that you overtook him if it was an legal overtake/maneuver?

If you claim that he pulled off this dangerous stunt due to road rage then perhaps the insurance company would wonder why on earth you thought that considering there was no prior history of an altercation between the two of you and may declare you as a liar.

I would just be truthful about the whole thing and hope for the best.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
You need to push your insurance company to let you know exactly how you feel here, and why they should not roll over and pay. ( They won't initially care as business wise it may even be cheaper for them to pay this bloke then haul it in from you with hiked premiums and loss of NCD )

Asking for an appointment to see the local office manager should do it. Talk face-to-face. Most claims are dealt with by very junior staff at the first junction - get them off the case.


Witnesses, independent, will clear all arguments immediately. Try to get some, even if you need to run ads in local papers.

Failing this, a decent insurer will then send an engineer to inspect both vehicles - and this is about as good as you can get without witnesses.

He will be able to tell from the damage when/where the collision occurred, and make an opinion as to who was to blame. Again, that will be the end of it then. If the other bloke's car was hit straight on the rear, you will probably lose 100%. The engineer will argue such damage indicates you were fully aware of what he was doing AND that he had pulled 'safely' in front of you - you made no effort to adjust speed or distance as he did so.

If the damage is all on the side of your car and the side of his, it becomes more a 'each bear their own costs' case - you pay for your car, he pays for his. ( So withdraw the claim then, unless the damage is way, way above your NCD and possible 20-50% premium increase )


Chris_R

Original Poster:

164 posts

227 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Robatr0n said:
Why would you hide the fact that you overtook him if it was an legal overtake/maneuver?

If you claim that he pulled off this dangerous stunt due to road rage then perhaps the insurance company would wonder why on earth you thought that considering there was no prior history of an altercation between the two of you and may declare you as a liar.

I would just be truthful about the whole thing and hope for the best.
Not hiding it, I just thought it would simplify things. See what you mean.

Chris_R

Original Poster:

164 posts

227 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
jondude said:
You need to push your insurance company to let you know exactly how you feel here, and why they should not roll over and pay. ( They won't initially care as business wise it may even be cheaper for them to pay this bloke then haul it in from you with hiked premiums and loss of NCD )

Asking for an appointment to see the local office manager should do it. Talk face-to-face. Most claims are dealt with by very junior staff at the first junction - get them off the case.


Witnesses, independent, will clear all arguments immediately. Try to get some, even if you need to run ads in local papers.

Failing this, a decent insurer will then send an engineer to inspect both vehicles - and this is about as good as you can get without witnesses.

He will be able to tell from the damage when/where the collision occurred, and make an opinion as to who was to blame. Again, that will be the end of it then. If the other bloke's car was hit straight on the rear, you will probably lose 100%. The engineer will argue such damage indicates you were fully aware of what he was doing AND that he had pulled 'safely' in front of you - you made no effort to adjust speed or distance as he did so.

If the damage is all on the side of your car and the side of his, it becomes more a 'each bear their own costs' case - you pay for your car, he pays for his. ( So withdraw the claim then, unless the damage is way, way above your NCD and possible 20-50% premium increase )
Thanks John, in that case then unless I can get the witness account then I am screwed. The damage is squarely in the centre of the cars.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
If Insurance Co persist in trying to lay the blame on you then refer them to the case

Scott v Warren [1974]

a following driver who collides with a vehicle making an emergency stop is not prima facie driving without due care and attention.

dvd

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Chris_R said:
What happened was I was overtook someone, perfectly safe overtake, was in outside lane of two lane NSL road passing a queue of slower moving vehicles.
This then reduces in to one lane so pulled in nicely, maintaining distance between the vehicle in front and behind, not cutting up or nothing, fluid as you like. However the guy who is now positioned behind me goes ballistic - flashing, beeping horn, gesticulating that I may have done something wrong...the typical result in this day and age. He then accelerates up to my bumper so that I can no longer see the front of his car at all (this is now a single lane NSL, moving approx 45-50 mph). I flashed my brake lights at him as he was getting a bit close for my liking, didnt brake as there was a queue of traffic we where part of.
We are now approaching the road about and I proceed to apply my brakes in line with the vehicles in front as normal (not to a stop, just slowing maintaining a distance)...however at this point the guy behind me takes even more offence, floors it and overtakes pulling into a non existent gap leaving me with nothing but around a foot of stopping distance. He then slams on hard, even with my 6 pots there was no way I could avoid him and so I hit his bumper.

I have already rang my insurance and typically they just want to put it as hit third party in the rear, I have attempted to argue with them that it is not as clear cut as that (does that mean that if someone pulls out of a junction in front of me and I plough their rear because they didnt see me its my fault???) but they seem to have little interest.

The guy I hit made the smarmy comment of "you hit me in the back its all your fault now ha ha" I was somewhat livid. He also had a parting comment of "well its a company car anyway, what do I care, how you like that?"
Real arrogant tossbag and it was only my better judgement of it would not go down well that I didnt hit him and his chav son with my car jack.

I just want to ensure that it goes to a 50/50 at worst as there is little damage on either car (probably down to the small impact distance and that we where both braking anyway) and dont want him getting away with my no-claims (though it is protected fully).
Can I ensure this by sticking to my guns that it was a "road rage" type retaliation (which it was) which made no sense.

Any advise at all appreciated.
Ring his Fleet Manager up at the Company I can GUARANTEE he will care smile you have the reg right? DVLA find out the company quick call scroate is sorted smile Most contracts have care provisions for company motors and if he worked for me he would be down the road smile


Cheers
On the unsubstantiated say so of someone else ?
(no disrespect to Chris, but just the principle.)

As regards to the whole thread.......avoid conflict on our roads, even if you believe you are in the right.

Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 18th May 08:50

Silent1

19,762 posts

266 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Was there not a similar case with a transit on the M25 where he pulled into a (non existant) space and then slammed on the brakes, yet he was deemed to be at fault as he hadn't provided adequate warning of the impending emergency stop and he'd also put someone else at risk by reducing their stopping distance.

Jasandjules

72,708 posts

260 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Silent1 said:
Was there not a similar case with a transit on the M25 where he pulled into a (non existant) space and then slammed on the brakes, yet he was deemed to be at fault as he hadn't provided adequate warning of the impending emergency stop and he'd also put someone else at risk by reducing their stopping distance.
I seem to think someone on here posted the case reference for something along those lines.

I also agree with ringing up the fellow's boss and advising him what was said about the company car etc.. And I know it won't help for this one, but if possible, get your phone recording before you step out and ask someone why the feck they overtook you like that......

Chris_R

Original Poster:

164 posts

227 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
On the unsubstantiated say so of someone else ?
(no disrespect to Chris, but just the principle.)

As regards to the whole thread.......avoid conflict on our roads, even if you believe you are in the right.

Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 18th May 08:50
No offence taken at all.
I dont see any point in throwing about accusations to his employers etc, only with a third party there to back up my claims of what he said would it hold any weight at all in a legal standpoint.
I know he said when the police where present that he admitted the overtake while I was braking, the only problem is the police took no statements or even broke out their notepads so that is about as much use.


The Black Duke

1,642 posts

224 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Guam said:
Chris_R said:
What happened was I was overtook someone, perfectly safe overtake, was in outside lane of two lane NSL road passing a queue of slower moving vehicles.
This then reduces in to one lane so pulled in nicely, maintaining distance between the vehicle in front and behind, not cutting up or nothing, fluid as you like. However the guy who is now positioned behind me goes ballistic - flashing, beeping horn, gesticulating that I may have done something wrong...the typical result in this day and age. He then accelerates up to my bumper so that I can no longer see the front of his car at all (this is now a single lane NSL, moving approx 45-50 mph). I flashed my brake lights at him as he was getting a bit close for my liking, didnt brake as there was a queue of traffic we where part of.
We are now approaching the road about and I proceed to apply my brakes in line with the vehicles in front as normal (not to a stop, just slowing maintaining a distance)...however at this point the guy behind me takes even more offence, floors it and overtakes pulling into a non existent gap leaving me with nothing but around a foot of stopping distance. He then slams on hard, even with my 6 pots there was no way I could avoid him and so I hit his bumper.

I have already rang my insurance and typically they just want to put it as hit third party in the rear, I have attempted to argue with them that it is not as clear cut as that (does that mean that if someone pulls out of a junction in front of me and I plough their rear because they didnt see me its my fault???) but they seem to have little interest.

The guy I hit made the smarmy comment of "you hit me in the back its all your fault now ha ha" I was somewhat livid. He also had a parting comment of "well its a company car anyway, what do I care, how you like that?"
Real arrogant tossbag and it was only my better judgement of it would not go down well that I didnt hit him and his chav son with my car jack.

I just want to ensure that it goes to a 50/50 at worst as there is little damage on either car (probably down to the small impact distance and that we where both braking anyway) and dont want him getting away with my no-claims (though it is protected fully).
Can I ensure this by sticking to my guns that it was a "road rage" type retaliation (which it was) which made no sense.

Any advise at all appreciated.
Ring his Fleet Manager up at the Company I can GUARANTEE he will care smile you have the reg right? DVLA find out the company quick call scroate is sorted smile Most contracts have care provisions for company motors and if he worked for me he would be down the road smile


Cheers
On the unsubstantiated say so of someone else ?
(no disrespect to Chris, but just the principle.)

As regards to the whole thread.......avoid conflict on our roads, even if you believe you are in the right.

Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 18th May 08:50
AVOID CONFLICT EH!!!
The only conflict I had was with the lazy rozzer who would not do their job correctly. LMAO

muttleyfool

2 posts

222 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Chris_R said:
I reported it to the police at the scene. They attended and said I shouldnt have called them as there was no injury


You weren't calling them because of the RTA, you were calling them because of the road rage.

I can't give you legal help, but I can tell you of my own experience of road rage with threatening behaviour:

www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=535486&f=10&h=0

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
jondude said:
You need to push your insurance company to let you know exactly how you feel here, and why they should not roll over and pay. ( They won't initially care as business wise it may even be cheaper for them to pay this bloke then haul it in from you with hiked premiums and loss of NCD )

Asking for an appointment to see the local office manager should do it. Talk face-to-face. Most claims are dealt with by very junior staff at the first junction - get them off the case.


Witnesses, independent, will clear all arguments immediately. Try to get some, even if you need to run ads in local papers.

Failing this, a decent insurer will then send an engineer to inspect both vehicles - and this is about as good as you can get without witnesses.

He will be able to tell from the damage when/where the collision occurred, and make an opinion as to who was to blame. Again, that will be the end of it then. If the other bloke's car was hit straight on the rear, you will probably lose 100%. The engineer will argue such damage indicates you were fully aware of what he was doing AND that he had pulled 'safely' in front of you - you made no effort to adjust speed or distance as he did so.

If the damage is all on the side of your car and the side of his, it becomes more a 'each bear their own costs' case - you pay for your car, he pays for his. ( So withdraw the claim then, unless the damage is way, way above your NCD and possible 20-50% premium increase )



This is fair advice, although somewhat off track in terms of how insurance operations work (Never seen an office manager in 15 years, and knock-for-knock disappeared 20+ years ago, anyhoo ...).

Without witnesses you are going to find it tricky, but not impossible.

The system will have allocated this based on the accident circumstances, probably to a team that just deal with "fault" claims, you need to get it back into the disupted liabilty area. Try to speak to the team leader.