Points for no seatbelt........
Points for no seatbelt........
Author
Discussion

catso

Original Poster:

16,584 posts

298 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
WTF.....

http://www.telegraph.co.uk:80/news/newstopics/fair...

Penalty points for drivers not wearing seat belt

While 94 per cent of drivers normally wear seat belts, accident investigators found that only 65 per cent of drivers who were killed in crashes did so.
The statistics have led to pressure on the Government from road safety groups to take tougher action.

Until now the Department for Transport had been willing to rely on persuasion and was mounting another publicity campaign in the hope of convincing a hard core of drivers who refused to belt up. However, it signalled its readiness to take tougher action in a review of road safety strategy.

The department said it was ready to consider “making non-compliance with seat belt wearing an endorsable offence”. One option available to ministers would be to follow the example of Northern Ireland, where drivers can get penalty points on their licence if they are not wearing a seat belt but passengers failing to do so are fined.

In the rest of Britain, motorists and passengers over 14 can be fined £30 for not wearing a seat belt. A driver is also responsible for any passenger 13 or under.

The case for taking stronger action has been bolstered by casualty figures that show that the number of car occupants being killed is declining far slower than the number of pedestrians.

While the death toll of pedestrians was 33 per cent lower in 2006 than the average for 1994-98, the figure for drivers fell by only five per cent and passengers 14 per cent.

“Seat belts save lives yet even now a small minority refuse to buckle up,” said Robert Gifford, the executive director of the Parliamentary Advisory Council for Transport Safety. “On current estimates around 300 lives could be saved a year if wearing rates both front and back were raised to nearer 100 per cent.

“Not wearing your seat belt puts both the driver and passengers at risk. Increasing the penalty would send a clear message to all drivers that a seat belt is not an optional extra but a life saver.”

Proposals for the change were also endorsed by Brake, the road safety charity.

“Something has to be done to get at the last group of people who are unconvinced about the need to wear seat belts,” said Cathy Keeler, the charity’s head of campaigns.

“People are being killed because they failed to belt up. For these people education is not enough, some form of deterrence is necessary.”

But the proposals were condemned by the Association of British Drivers. “Why don’t they just give us nine points as soon as we get a licence?” said Hugh Bladon, a spokesman.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Casualty figures that show, in the majority of cases, that fatal accidents are fatal accidents seat belts or not?

Still dont let the figures come in the way of more control freakery.

wrs

Battenburg Bob

8,858 posts

223 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Absolutely, totally against this. Lies, damned lies and statistics. And that's from someone who regularly deals with fatals.

This Government is doing everything in it's power to alienate the Police from the public. I despair.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
Casualty figures that show, in the majority of cases, that fatal accidents are fatal accidents seat belts or not?

Still dont let the figures come in the way of more control freakery.

wrs
Can you point us to some figures that show that nearly all those who died in a crash while not wearing a seatbelt would have died even if wearing a seatbelt.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
Plotloss said:
Casualty figures that show, in the majority of cases, that fatal accidents are fatal accidents seat belts or not?

Still dont let the figures come in the way of more control freakery.

wrs
Can you point us to some figures that show that nearly all those who died in a crash while not wearing a seatbelt would have died even if wearing a seatbelt.
Read the article.

65% of those killed in car crashes were wearing a belt.

I didnt say nearly all I said majority and 65% is a majority.

mchammer89

3,127 posts

244 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
I remember seeing an ad showing a crash with one person not wearing a seatbelt, where they were flung about the car hitting others, so i guess it's got some good reason, however, i don't see why they should give points if you are in the car on your own, which they do.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
herewego said:
Plotloss said:
Casualty figures that show, in the majority of cases, that fatal accidents are fatal accidents seat belts or not?

Still dont let the figures come in the way of more control freakery.

wrs
Can you point us to some figures that show that nearly all those who died in a crash while not wearing a seatbelt would have died even if wearing a seatbelt.
Read the article.

65% of those killed in car crashes were wearing a belt.

I didnt say nearly all I said majority and 65% is a majority.
Perhaps the name Brake has scrambled your brain. smile
According to these figures, 65% of the fatals are drawn from the 6% of drivers without seatbelts.

Isoproturon1

3,641 posts

232 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Why would you NOT wear a seatbelt?

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
Plotloss said:
herewego said:
Plotloss said:
Casualty figures that show, in the majority of cases, that fatal accidents are fatal accidents seat belts or not?

Still dont let the figures come in the way of more control freakery.

wrs
Can you point us to some figures that show that nearly all those who died in a crash while not wearing a seatbelt would have died even if wearing a seatbelt.
Read the article.

65% of those killed in car crashes were wearing a belt.

I didnt say nearly all I said majority and 65% is a majority.
Perhaps the name Brake has scrambled your brain. smile
According to these figures, 65% of the fatals are drawn from the 6% of drivers without seatbelts.
or yours.

94% of drivers wear belts whereas 65% of those killed were wearing belts.

The 6% that dont account for the 35% that were killed.

Proportionatly you're correct, however in the majority of cases a fatal is a fatal belt or no belt.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
herewego said:
Plotloss said:
herewego said:
Plotloss said:
Casualty figures that show, in the majority of cases, that fatal accidents are fatal accidents seat belts or not?

Still dont let the figures come in the way of more control freakery.

wrs
Can you point us to some figures that show that nearly all those who died in a crash while not wearing a seatbelt would have died even if wearing a seatbelt.
Read the article.

65% of those killed in car crashes were wearing a belt.

I didnt say nearly all I said majority and 65% is a majority.
Perhaps the name Brake has scrambled your brain. smile
According to these figures, 65% of the fatals are drawn from the 6% of drivers without seatbelts.
or yours.

94% of drivers wear belts whereas 65% of those killed were wearing belts.

The 6% that dont account for the 35% that were killed.

Proportionatly you're correct, however in the majority of cases a fatal is a fatal belt or no belt.
I can see you've started early. Don't let me disturb you.

Finlandia

7,818 posts

262 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Isoproturon1 said:
Why would you NOT wear a seatbelt?
If you have been in an crash, where the B pillar (which has the seatbelt attached to it) was pushed 20 inches towards the back of the car, then you might have second thoughts about seatbelts.

i was in that crash, and no i didn't wear a seatbelt, and yes I survived, badly injured but alive. Even the police confirmed that had I been wearing the seatbelt, it wouldn't have been a pretty sight.



Why can't seatbelts be mounted fully to the seat? I remeber an -72 Range Rover had this, and it would fully remove this crash scenario.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
So tell me how your interpretation of that sentence leads you to the conclusion that 65% of fatal crashes involved drivers with no belt?

As it clearly says the opposite.

eldar

25,366 posts

227 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Scares me the amount of people that drive around with unrestrained kids in their cars. Lunatics.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
So tell me how your interpretation of that sentence leads you to the conclusion that 65% of fatal crashes involved drivers with no belt?

As it clearly says the opposite.

Oh yeah, sorry, must be me started early. Re-phrasing: 35% of the fatals are drawn from the 6% of drivers without seatbelts.
However a fatal is not a fatal belt or no belt. There’s no evidence for that.
Unless you know different?

isoproturon1

3,641 posts

232 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Finlandia said:
Isoproturon1 said:
Why would you NOT wear a seatbelt?


If you have been in an crash, where the B pillar (which has the seatbelt attached to it) was pushed 20 inches towards the back of the car, then you might have second thoughts about seatbelts.

i was in that crash, and no i didn't wear a seatbelt, and yes I survived, badly injured but alive. Even the police confirmed that had I been wearing the seatbelt, it wouldn't have been a pretty sight.



Why can't seatbelts be mounted fully to the seat? I remeber an -72 Range Rover had this, and it would fully remove this crash scenario.


Not likely to happen that often though surely? So the risks of this happening are outweighed by the benefit in other forms of collision.

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
For every one person who claims to have been saved by not wearing a seatbelt how many are there who would have been worse off without theirs? Hundreds, thousands, hundreds of thousands...........

mchammer89

3,127 posts

244 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
eldar said:
Scares me the amount of people that drive around with unrestrained kids in their cars. Lunatics.


Almost as bad as those idiots who walk out on the road without looking leading with their pram. And of course, if anyone was to hit such a child, it would obviously be the fault of the motorist rolleyes

Finlandia

7,818 posts

262 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
isoproturon1 said:
Finlandia said:
Isoproturon1 said:
Why would you NOT wear a seatbelt?
If you have been in an crash, where the B pillar (which has the seatbelt attached to it) was pushed 20 inches towards the back of the car, then you might have second thoughts about seatbelts.

i was in that crash, and no i didn't wear a seatbelt, and yes I survived, badly injured but alive. Even the police confirmed that had I been wearing the seatbelt, it wouldn't have been a pretty sight.



Why can't seatbelts be mounted fully to the seat? I remeber an -72 Range Rover had this, and it would fully remove this crash scenario.
Not likely to happen that often though surely? So the risks of this happening are outweighed by the benefit in other forms of collision.
I'm not saying not to use seatbelts, but to have them mounted on the seats alone, not anywhere on the chassis.

It may not happen often, just once is enough if it's your life.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Finlandia said:
Isoproturon1 said:
Why would you NOT wear a seatbelt?
If you have been in an crash, where the B pillar (which has the seatbelt attached to it) was pushed 20 inches towards the back of the car, then you might have second thoughts about seatbelts.

i was in that crash, and no i didn't wear a seatbelt, and yes I survived, badly injured but alive. Even the police confirmed that had I been wearing the seatbelt, it wouldn't have been a pretty sight.



Why can't seatbelts be mounted fully to the seat? I remeber an -72 Range Rover had this, and it would fully remove this crash scenario.
As others have said, anecdotal evidence in one scenario is not proof as such.

However, on the same note, a lot of us will have knowledge of a very famous and tragic crash in a tunnel in Paris.

One of the four was wearing their seatbelt, and he is the only one alive today...

mph999

2,780 posts

251 months

Sunday 18th May 2008
quotequote all
Look at it another way ...

Many "minor" or no injury accidents with seatbelts, would most likely become "badly" injured or fatal !

Yes, I am sure there are cases where wearing belt may cause more injury (I'm struggling to image how), and there will be cases where people have got luckly without a belt on, but in the majority of cases they are a good thing.

Strangly enough, I was speaking with my sister and brother-in-law re. this a short while age. One is a GP, the other an orthopedic surgeon, so they have seen the results first hand. We were on holiday in Finland, and they took a cab instead of the coach with the kids, why, because the coach didn't have seat belts, and they won't take the risk. Apparently, the injuries sustained bouncing around a car are not pretty, nor is going through the windscreen, or the backseat passenger hitting someone in the front. Seatbelts do cause injury from "minor" discomfort to fairly major back injury, but in these cases, without them you're probably dead.

Persoanlly - I think a £30 fine for not wearing a belt is getting off lightly, though I'm not sure points are fair, just increase the fine.

Martin