Dangerous driving charge - update
Discussion
I recently mentioned (on a couple of threads) a friend of mine who was charged with dangerous driving after clouting a crash barrier on a motorway.
To recap, he was driving a powerful rear wheel drive car up a wet motorway, was pulling back to the inside lane after overtaking a middle lane crawler, and skidded. He found himself travelling sideways facing the central reservation, the car drifted to the right hand lane and suffered a light frontal impact and heavy near side wing impact against the crash barrier. No other vehicle involved.
Some witnesses complained to the police that he had been undertaking and changing lanes aggressively, and he was charged with dangerous driving.
His version is that he came up behind 2 middle lane crawlers, (I'm sure he was sensible enough not to call them that in court), while in the inside lane and moved to the right hand lane to pass the first, then returned to the inside because of faster traffic coming up behind, then repeated the process to pass the second. It was when returning to the left after passing the second when the accident occurred. He isn't sure what caused the skid, he says there was some oil in the road in the centre of the middle lane at about the point where he skidded, he also suggests a tyre failure as another possibility.
From what I've seen he is usually a pretty sensible driver, IAM member for cars and bikes, Rospa gold on bikes, very smooth, only once had points on his licence many years ago.
I felt he was bound to be done for careless driving, I don't know if he offered to plead guilty in return for the dangerous charge being dropped.
In court the witnesses accused him of 'weaving in and out of the traffic', though admitted they hadn't actually seen him undertake anybody. The witnesses had apparently been a few hundred yards back from these manoeuvres, none of the people supposedly endangered complained. Apparently the CPS solicitor made much of the fact that he 'admitted' moving between lanes 3 and 1 in one movement without stopping in the middle.
His solicitor argued that there was nothing wrong in this, quoting the highway code rule about 'returning to the inside lane after overtaking.'
The magistrates accepted there was no proof he had undertaken and that his speed had not been excessive, but still convicted him of dangerous driving. So a years ban and 400 quid fine. With luck he won't lose his job, but he hasn't heard officially yet.
Seems harsh to me I must admit.
To recap, he was driving a powerful rear wheel drive car up a wet motorway, was pulling back to the inside lane after overtaking a middle lane crawler, and skidded. He found himself travelling sideways facing the central reservation, the car drifted to the right hand lane and suffered a light frontal impact and heavy near side wing impact against the crash barrier. No other vehicle involved.
Some witnesses complained to the police that he had been undertaking and changing lanes aggressively, and he was charged with dangerous driving.
His version is that he came up behind 2 middle lane crawlers, (I'm sure he was sensible enough not to call them that in court), while in the inside lane and moved to the right hand lane to pass the first, then returned to the inside because of faster traffic coming up behind, then repeated the process to pass the second. It was when returning to the left after passing the second when the accident occurred. He isn't sure what caused the skid, he says there was some oil in the road in the centre of the middle lane at about the point where he skidded, he also suggests a tyre failure as another possibility.
From what I've seen he is usually a pretty sensible driver, IAM member for cars and bikes, Rospa gold on bikes, very smooth, only once had points on his licence many years ago.
I felt he was bound to be done for careless driving, I don't know if he offered to plead guilty in return for the dangerous charge being dropped.
In court the witnesses accused him of 'weaving in and out of the traffic', though admitted they hadn't actually seen him undertake anybody. The witnesses had apparently been a few hundred yards back from these manoeuvres, none of the people supposedly endangered complained. Apparently the CPS solicitor made much of the fact that he 'admitted' moving between lanes 3 and 1 in one movement without stopping in the middle.
His solicitor argued that there was nothing wrong in this, quoting the highway code rule about 'returning to the inside lane after overtaking.'
The magistrates accepted there was no proof he had undertaken and that his speed had not been excessive, but still convicted him of dangerous driving. So a years ban and 400 quid fine. With luck he won't lose his job, but he hasn't heard officially yet.
Seems harsh to me I must admit.
If it is exactly as you describe then the case sounds like a good one to appeal. If it's just your friend's account of proceedings I might be tempted to think there's more to it, though.
Worth reminding that as well as a 12 month ban, he'll be required to do an extended retest before he can get his full licence back, too.
Worth reminding that as well as a 12 month ban, he'll be required to do an extended retest before he can get his full licence back, too.
knight said:
Dr Jekyll said:
The magistrates accepted there was no proof he had undertaken and that his speed had not been excessive, but still convicted him of dangerous driving.
How the hell does the system work!!!!
The magistrates have taken the view that his driving fell far below that expected of a careful & competent driver. If they've accepted he didn't undertake & his speed wasn't excessive there must be something else.
Was he for instance cutting in front of the middle lane occupants to teach them a lesson ?
I don't know, but the magistrates were obviously entirely unhappy with what he did & based their decision on the evidence from all the witness testimony & physical evidence available (which is more than we have here).
Edited by vonhosen on Wednesday 21st May 09:28
There was no physical evidence other than the fact of the accident itself, no investigation was carried out at the scene.
It wasn't the drivers being overtaken that complained, so it's difficult to see how they could be regarded as having been endangered. Also he insists he hit the central barrier not the left one, so I don't see how cutting back aggressively to the left could have caused it.
The magistrates apparently considered the verdict for nearly 2 hours, so it can't have been that clear cut.
If he had been undertaking or flashing the middle laners from close behind I can see how that could be regarded as trying to teach them a lesson. But if he really did just drive round them on the right, I don't see the problem, that's the least aggressive way to pass them.
It wasn't the drivers being overtaken that complained, so it's difficult to see how they could be regarded as having been endangered. Also he insists he hit the central barrier not the left one, so I don't see how cutting back aggressively to the left could have caused it.
The magistrates apparently considered the verdict for nearly 2 hours, so it can't have been that clear cut.
If he had been undertaking or flashing the middle laners from close behind I can see how that could be regarded as trying to teach them a lesson. But if he really did just drive round them on the right, I don't see the problem, that's the least aggressive way to pass them.
Dr Jekyll said:
There was no physical evidence other than the fact of the accident itself, no investigation was carried out at the scene.
Police attended & reported didn't they ?They'd have looked to see if there was oil etc in lane 2 to act as a contributory factor.
Dr Jekyll said:
It wasn't the drivers being overtaken that complained, so it's difficult to see how they could be regarded as having been endangered. Also he insists he hit the central barrier not the left one, so I don't see how cutting back aggressively to the left could have caused it.
Dangerous driving doesn't necessarily mean that someone was actually put in danger. The question is did his driving fall far below that expected ?Dr Jekyll said:
The magistrates apparently considered the verdict for nearly 2 hours, so it can't have been that clear cut.
If he had been undertaking or flashing the middle laners from close behind I can see how that could be regarded as trying to teach them a lesson. But if he really did just drive round them on the right, I don't see the problem, that's the least aggressive way to pass them.
We see people here talking about lapping middle laners, cutting in on them sharply etc to teach them a lesson.If he had been undertaking or flashing the middle laners from close behind I can see how that could be regarded as trying to teach them a lesson. But if he really did just drive round them on the right, I don't see the problem, that's the least aggressive way to pass them.
I'm not saying he did, just that firstly for the Police to charge him, for the CPS to run with it & for the court to convict there must be something more to it than what we have here, after all moving back to lane 2 may be viewed very differently depending on how the action is carried out & described.
Oil on the road is a complete nightmare, I skidded round a roundabout (arse out in front drive pud) and the cops just coming on to the same roundabout put on the blue flashing lights and did exactly the same thing as they hit the same oil patch I did trying to catch up.
When they stopped me they told me they were going to b
k me for dangerous/careless driving until they did exactly the same thing, so they just checked if I wasnt too shaken up by the incident.
When they stopped me they told me they were going to b
k me for dangerous/careless driving until they did exactly the same thing, so they just checked if I wasnt too shaken up by the incident.vonhosen said:
Dr Jekyll said:
It wasn't the drivers being overtaken that complained, so it's difficult to see how they could be regarded as having been endangered. Also he insists he hit the central barrier not the left one, so I don't see how cutting back aggressively to the left could have caused it.
Dangerous driving doesn't necessarily mean that someone was actually put in danger. The question is did his driving fall far below that expected ?Dr Jekyll said:
vonhosen said:
Dr Jekyll said:
It wasn't the drivers being overtaken that complained, so it's difficult to see how they could be regarded as having been endangered. Also he insists he hit the central barrier not the left one, so I don't see how cutting back aggressively to the left could have caused it.
Dangerous driving doesn't necessarily mean that someone was actually put in danger. The question is did his driving fall far below that expected ?The test of what amounts to dangerous driving is how the events would be viewed by a notional careful competent driver. Would a careful competent driver viewing the driving displayed have considered it fell far below the standards expected of such a careful competent driver ?
Edited by vonhosen on Wednesday 21st May 10:47
Let me put it this way. If I have occasion to move from lane 3 to lane 1 while driving home tonight, how do I ensure I'm not regarded as driving dangerously?
I assumed in the past that providing nobody else has to change speed or direction I'm OK, but from Micks experience apparently not. Am I supposed to make the move in 2 stages? If so, why doesn't the highway code say that?
I assumed in the past that providing nobody else has to change speed or direction I'm OK, but from Micks experience apparently not. Am I supposed to make the move in 2 stages? If so, why doesn't the highway code say that?
I don't mean to be rude, but you wouldn't be prosecuted for dangerous driving for just changing lanes. Even if you did it pretty abruptly.
There is more to the story than just a lane change- at least part of which is the fact he crashed it on the motorway without anyone else making him do it or evidence of mechanical failure.
It's probably worth asking your friend, possibly after a few beers, to tell you how he really was driving.
There is more to the story than just a lane change- at least part of which is the fact he crashed it on the motorway without anyone else making him do it or evidence of mechanical failure.
It's probably worth asking your friend, possibly after a few beers, to tell you how he really was driving.
So all in all if he cruised in lane 3 none of this would have happened
although I suspect there is a lot more to this story than is being posted.
Seriously Von, did you/do you advocate pulling middle lane cruisers for education, as the route of this accident and many motorway problems such as apparent heavy trafffic can be squarely attributed to a lack of lane dicipline
.
although I suspect there is a lot more to this story than is being posted.Seriously Von, did you/do you advocate pulling middle lane cruisers for education, as the route of this accident and many motorway problems such as apparent heavy trafffic can be squarely attributed to a lack of lane dicipline
. Hang on, the guy crashed his car changing lanes, on a motorway? No other party involved? Thats hard to defend.
Unless it was a serious mechanical failure (which would be obvious) I'd say that was entirely driver error. You'd have to be pulling a pretty sharp manuouvre to spin, even on oil or on hitting a big puddle/rut. How many people replying to this thread have spun a car on a motorway entirely on their own? None?
Steve
Unless it was a serious mechanical failure (which would be obvious) I'd say that was entirely driver error. You'd have to be pulling a pretty sharp manuouvre to spin, even on oil or on hitting a big puddle/rut. How many people replying to this thread have spun a car on a motorway entirely on their own? None?
Steve
Driver error sure, that's why I'd expect a careless charge. But making a mistake does not automatically constitute dangerous driving.
There was a fairly well known individual that went through a junction on the wrong side of the road at 47 in a 30 and hit a pedestrian. He was done for careless but acquitted of dangerous.
There was a fairly well known individual that went through a junction on the wrong side of the road at 47 in a 30 and hit a pedestrian. He was done for careless but acquitted of dangerous.
Dr Jekyll said:
Driver error sure, that's why I'd expect a careless charge. But making a mistake does not automatically constitute dangerous driving.
There was a fairly well known individual that went through a junction on the wrong side of the road at 47 in a 30 and hit a pedestrian. He was done for careless but acquitted of dangerous.
You can't be convicted of dangerous driving for a simple mistake. The court aren't viewing the driving as that if they've convicted him. They are viewing a course of conduct that would to a careful competent driver have obviously been far below that expected. There must be more to it than what we have here.There was a fairly well known individual that went through a junction on the wrong side of the road at 47 in a 30 and hit a pedestrian. He was done for careless but acquitted of dangerous.
Forums | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


