RE: Casualty Signs Now A Hazard
RE: Casualty Signs Now A Hazard
Wednesday 21st May 2008

Casualty Signs Now A Hazard

Road signs showing number of deaths are distracting drivers



Signs showing the number of deaths on a stretch of road are being removed because they are now considered to be a hazard, it has been reported.

The signs on the A1 in Northumberland are thought to be an information overload, distracting drivers and making the roads more dangerous.

It is estimated that 20 signs have been put up on the long stretch of single carriageway since the early nineties in a bid to scare drivers into slowing down.

They show the number of casualties in the last three years, but are now all set to be taken down.

A spokesman for the Highways Agency said: ‘The signs were put up as an experiment in the early 1990s.

‘But research has shown that they have not had a noticeable effect on accident figures.’

It seems that recent studies have shown that drivers are now suffering from too many distractions on the roads, dubbed ‘information overload’.

However a spokesman for the AA said casualty information signs show the public that speed cameras are justified.

He added: ‘We need to keep the public on side with road safety initiatives and telling them why we are bothering to enforce the law is very important.’

Author
Discussion

MrKipling43

Original Poster:

5,788 posts

247 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Oh the irony.

I still think the worst ones are 'Speed Bumps 1/4 mile ->'. I mean, is that really necessary?!

LukeBird

17,170 posts

240 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
PH Article said:
It seems that recent studies have shown that drivers are now suffering from too many distractions on the roads, dubbed ‘information overload’.
No, really?!
Several bits of road I regularly drive on have these signs, I don't look at them and think "Oh, yeah, speed kills, better slow down a bit", I just ignore them. Reading about how many casualties there have been on said road in the last 3 years is vital as I pile into the back of the woman in front dawdling along.
Why not just have all the 'information' signs changed to -
"Unexpected events may happen at any time", those signs would be about as useful! rolleyes

Ravell

1,181 posts

243 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
"However a spokesman for the AA said casualty information signs show the public that speed cameras are justified."

I thought they just stated the accidents were due to information overload, not speeding. confused

Why the assumption that all of those accidents were caused solely by excessive speed? Methinks that's unlikely!

Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
As useful as this sign IMO:


puffpuff

23,221 posts

257 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Do-gooding 'Safety Partnerships' really do need their heads examined sometimes. In Somerset, signs have appeared on lamp posts reading, 'Don't drink and drive' or 'No mobile when mobile'.

Apart from the message, which is written quite large, there is something smaller and paler underneath which you have strain really hard to read as you drive past - it is the Somerset Safety Partnership logo..........

Skinner.Daddy

108 posts

229 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
77 Casualties in 3 years? Is it me or does this figure seem an acceptable amount anyway? That's just over 2 a month. I bet more people get injured acidently falling off their push bike along the same route!

madrob6

3,594 posts

251 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
I got caught out where I live as they've re-arranged all the roads and you used to be able to use a cut through to get to the other side of town quickly.

Not so anymore but there are two massive signs with loads of writing on them and you can only read it all if you stop in the middle of the road. I thought balls to that and turned off just before that section and was met with a new no entry sign after I'd already turned onto that road. They need a medal for coming up with that lot.

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
I bet more people that drive the route end up in A & E each month for DIY accidents around the home...maybe we should have a safety partnership that patrol B&Q car park and ask people pertinent questions - "are you experienced in the use of that ladder sir?"

Fury1630

393 posts

258 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
"However a spokesman for the AA said casualty information signs show the public that speed cameras are justified.

He added: ‘We need to keep the public on side with road safety initiatives and telling them why we are bothering to enforce the law is very important.’"

WTF has this got to do with the AA? If you can't support your members against Gov't bullying, tax, etc, then at least have the decency to keep your head down. Where was the AA when my wife got her car stuck in a muddy car park with two pre-schoolers in the back "sorry maddam we can't attend if you're not actually on the road" Or when the clutch cable went in the short stay at Gatwick with the same kiddies "we can get to you some time in the next four hours, but you need to stay with the car" Four hours? The parking cost would've made it uneconomical to repair!

Rant over.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Since the numbers on them aren't going down, yet the number of speeding fines are going up exponentially, the danger they're talking about is that Joe Public will see he's filling the pockets of speed camera businesses for no reason.

SM

handpaper

1,712 posts

234 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Definitely too much signage. If it's not warning of a non-obvious hazard it's a distraction.
Worst by far are motorway matrix signs - they're supposed to be for emergencies, not to tell me 'Don't drink and drive'. FFS, I'm on the M4, it's a bit late telling me now! And whose fking stupid idea was it to have every other sign display in Welsh?
'Let's provide vital information in a language less than 10% of people speak - that'll enhance our national identity'
Twats

Titan Simba

18,451 posts

225 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Perhaps they should replace it with this


Ritchie335is

2,162 posts

233 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
handpaper said:
Definitely too much signage. If it's not warning of a non-obvious hazard it's a distraction.
Worst by far are motorway matrix signs - they're supposed to be for emergencies, not to tell me 'Don't drink and drive'. FFS, I'm on the M4, it's a bit late telling me now! And whose fking stupid idea was it to have every other sign display in Welsh?
'Let's provide vital information in a language less than 10% of people speak - that'll enhance our national identity'
Twats
I once passed one of these matrix signs which said "Dont take drugs and drive" A couple of miles later I passed the next one which said "Watch your speed"
It made me chuckle anyway!hehe

peteA

2,762 posts

265 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
''A spokesman for the Highways Agency said: ‘The signs were put up as an experiment in the early 1990s.

‘But research has shown that they have not had a noticeable effect on accident figures.’''

At least they have reviewed the signs - no impact, lets remove them - shame the same cant be said of scameras eh...? The 'experiment' didnt mean points and fines just a 'reminder' that this stretch of road has claimed a few 'victims'.

I live in the area and use the stretch of road regularly and there are people who over take in stupid places as there are a few 'tempting' straights...

ayfy

8 posts

277 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
well I know I'm not going to be popular for saying this but I think these signs are very useful. Round where I live there's a stretch of country road near Aylesbury which has loads of these signs. The road is great fun and very popular with bikers because of it, however, being a biker myself, everytime I come across one of these signs I take caution. The signs tend to be quite specific, like X deaths at the next bend. If you see this then it's natural you must take caution. Obviously there are still psycho's who go round at stupid speeds, but any sensible person would take note and take the corner with care. And anyway, I'd much rather have these signs rather than speed cameras any day as at least you can make your own mind up how you want to drive, the signs just gives you a warning beforehand.

oh, and to address the information overload bit, maybe they should come up with a new road sign, like "Dangerous bend" rather than just "sharp bend", which can be put before corners that have a certain number of deaths on them. This way it's easy and quick to take in.

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

257 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
handpaper said:
Worst by far are motorway matrix signs - they're supposed to be for emergencies
No, they're not.

Never have been. Never will be.

jas16

378 posts

263 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
too many signs and too many traffic lights and too many speed humps = miserable driving

only if the ministers drove their Prius' everywhere then they might understand

Taita

8,021 posts

234 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
They are a hazard, I would be dead if I hit on of them on the bike.

peter pan

1,253 posts

255 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
There is a sign from Basildon council (Been there a few years now, so it has not been put up by the latest encumbents - I`ll leave you to guess who was in power at the time!)on (what was) a section of dual carriageway which has had one perfectly good lane closed off.its not even in a built up area as there are NO houses within at least half mile of it.
The sign reads, `lane closed to improve air quality'
So two lines of cars coming to a halt, and then crawling at a few mph, as they try to feed into one lane improves air quality? where in heavens name are their heads at?????

clarencegi77

100 posts

224 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
how about one i saw on the Simpsons 'Warning- sign ahead'
simply overkill, and besides, who seriously borders with the signs that just tell you lots of rubbish, the road is where your eyes should be when you're driving,