RE: Call For Scamera Review
RE: Call For Scamera Review
Wednesday 21st May 2008

Call For Scamera Review

Demands for review of cameras in Lancashire after false convictions debacle



A review into speed cameras is being demanded after it emerged that over 500 drivers had unsafe convictions overturned in Lancashire.

It is understood that three members of Lancashire Police staff are now facing disciplinary action and £35,000 in fines have had to be refunded.

Many members of the public are now questioning the number of other unsafe convictions that have gone unnoticed.

The investigation focused on whether a speed camera had been wrongly set up or if paperwork had been wrongly processed at the central unit in Blackburn.

Motoring experts now believe it will be difficult for the police to rebuild the trust of motorists in the area.

Elizabeth Dainton, research manager at the RAC Foundation, said the police should not rely solely on cameras to catch speeders.

Ms Dainton said: ‘We do support the use of speed cameras where correct and appropriate but there needs to be traffic police on the roads to pick up offences such as drink and drug driving.

‘Police will have a struggle on their hands to restore public confidence. Lessons need to be learnt and appropriate training needs to be in place.’

Fylde MP Michael said how the cameras are used must be reviewed.

He told reporters: ‘The Chief Constable has got to do everything he can to put in place policies which reassure motorists that the use of cameras is justified and done by the book in future.

‘If it is not dealt with right, it will undermine the generally good relations police have with the public.’

The Lancashire Evening Post has revealed that there are now 184 officers patrolling the roads in that area – a drop of 13 on the year before and the lowest since 2002.

Author
Discussion

gopher cough

Original Poster:

127 posts

228 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
the three should be charged with 500 counts of perverting the course of justice!

Skinner.Daddy

108 posts

229 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
gopher cough said:
the three should be charged with 500 counts of perverting the course of justice!
I Agree +1

big_rob_sydney

3,671 posts

225 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
It really is disgusting. I trust the police less and less every day, and actually would rather deal with things myself rather than waste my time dealing with people who are more interested in raking in revenue, rather than making neighbourhoods safe from street crime.

wab172uk

2,005 posts

258 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
The Government may well review speed camera's.

After looking at how much money they make, £50 says their conclusions will be that we need more of them.

A Government survey will show the majority of the British public support the use of speed camera's.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
big_rob_sydney said:
It really is disgusting. I trust the police less and less every day, and actually would rather deal with things myself rather than waste my time dealing with people who are more interested in raking in revenue, rather than making neighbourhoods safe from street crime.
Thats right judge the whole service on the actions of a small percentage of a small percentage of their staff.

I had a tesco cashier be rude to me once, every tesco cashier is rude and horrible, I trust them less and less each day.

As for revenue- does it not occur that if it does add to the tax coffers it will off-set another increase elsewhere? I still do not believe its for revenue, I think its to off-set the lack of proper roads policing due to resources having to be used elsewhere and these and other automatic functions take up part of the slack.

If it was revenue only then no points would be involved full stop and the fines would be far far higher.

covertjouster

50 posts

233 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
On the basis of this news, and similar news in East Anglia, where a local TV news invetsigation found a large percentage of cameras weren't getting teh regular calibration and servicing that they have to get under their own operating rules and regulations, you can now get out of paying your fine and get points by - not refusing to pay, but agreeing to pay once the authorities have supplied appropriate proof that the cameras have been calibarted and run correctly. It is your right under the freedom of information to ask for this info, and as long as you dont 'refuse' to pay, most of the time they cant be bothered to supply the info, or in increasing cases they are running uncalibrated and therefore 'illegal' cameras.

And why should it be any surprise coppers would do this, with diodgy speeding tickets, painted up builders vans acting as speed traps, coppers running over 16 year old girls in Newcastle, etc etc.

And they wonder why we have no respect for them or the Government.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
By the way they are police staff. Slight difference.

planetdave

9,922 posts

284 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
big_rob_sydney said:
It really is disgusting. I trust the police less and less every day, and actually would rather deal with things myself rather than waste my time dealing with people who are more interested in raking in revenue, rather than making neighbourhoods safe from street crime.
Thats right judge the whole service on the actions of a small percentage of a small percentage of their staff.

I had a tesco cashier be rude to me once, every tesco cashier is rude and horrible, I trust them less and less each day.

As for revenue- does it not occur that if it does add to the tax coffers it will off-set another increase elsewhere? I still do not believe its for revenue, I think its to off-set the lack of proper roads policing due to resources having to be used elsewhere and these and other automatic functions take up part of the slack.

If it was revenue only then no points would be involved full stop and the fines would be far far higher.
It's not that the cameras rake in a fortune - it's the SCPs that are the villains. The revenue raised is a pittance (by tax standards) but it does allow the partnerships to build their own little empire and have an interest in preserving it.

It's a disaster from start to finish - presumption of guilt, self incrimination, petty bureaucrats with a interest in perpetuation and equipment that is not as infallible as they'd like us to believe.

It stinks all the way and, as it's the most likely point of contact betwix the public and the law, stinks up our relationship with the law and the BiB in particular.

I'm amazed more senior officers haven't come out against cameras as a disastrous PR own goal. Even Maggie backed down from the Poll tax, this would be much easier (apart from funding trafpol to reappear).

Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
big_rob_sydney said:
It really is disgusting. I trust the police less and less every day, and actually would rather deal with things myself rather than waste my time dealing with people who are more interested in raking in revenue, rather than making neighbourhoods safe from street crime.
Thats right judge the whole service on the actions of a small percentage of a small percentage of their staff.
You may not agree with it, but people are judging the police by the speed cameras brigade - the Scamerarti.

FACT 1: You are judged by actions of the SCP, of which the police are the enforcing partner.

It's actually worse than that however. For every person who contributes £60 to the 'Speeding Revenue', you get a new enemy. Earn 60million from cameras, welcome to 1million new enemies.

FACT 2: The SCP are creating enemies of the police with every ticket.

I know many police disagree with the greed over safety, but it counts for less than the association in the public mind, and that association is now on par with a tax collector. Huge fines for parking are not helping build trust either.

And before you argue with me, let me point out that this is not my fault, it's a situation created by councils and your very own chief constable: they are causing this, not me.



andyps

7,819 posts

313 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
planetdave said:
It's not that the cameras rake in a fortune - it's the SCPs that are the villains. The revenue raised is a pittance (by tax standards) but it does allow the partnerships to build their own little empire and have an interest in preserving it.
I agree with this. I am currently in discussion with the SCP in the area where I live about the a specific news item posted on their website which was a blatant mistruth, and possibly related to the installation of some cameras. There are people whose livelihoods depend upon the SCPs continuing, and they appear to be doing whatever it takes to justify their own existence. In the case of the current issue I have the SCP reporting falsehoods which many will think genuine - unfortunately they present these as facts but are actually spin.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Globulator said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
big_rob_sydney said:
It really is disgusting. I trust the police less and less every day, and actually would rather deal with things myself rather than waste my time dealing with people who are more interested in raking in revenue, rather than making neighbourhoods safe from street crime.
Thats right judge the whole service on the actions of a small percentage of a small percentage of their staff.
You may not agree with it, but people are judging the police by the speed cameras brigade - the Scamerarti.

FACT 1: You are judged by actions of the SCP, of which the police are the enforcing partner.

It's actually worse than that however. For every person who contributes £60 to the 'Speeding Revenue', you get a new enemy. Earn 60million from cameras, welcome to 1million new enemies.

FACT 2: The SCP are creating enemies of the police with every ticket.

I know many police disagree with the greed over safety, but it counts for less than the association in the public mind, and that association is now on par with a tax collector. Huge fines for parking are not helping build trust either.

And before you argue with me, let me point out that this is not my fault, it's a situation created by councils and your very own chief constable: they are causing this, not me.
I don't disagree on the impact, its due to a very very vocal anti-camera lobby.

The reality is at the moment for police forces its either this sort or no enforcement. I don't want a free for all on the roads. The money is not there for proper roads policing.

Skipppy

1,136 posts

241 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Burn the fking things out. They're in place to make MONEY. fk all to do with safety.

Byker28i

93,761 posts

248 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
As for revenue- does it not occur that if it does add to the tax coffers it will off-set another increase elsewhere? I still do not believe its for revenue, I think its to off-set the lack of proper roads policing due to resources having to be used elsewhere and these and other automatic functions take up part of the slack.

If it was revenue only then no points would be involved full stop and the fines would be far far higher.
Well, offset a lack of active police officers maybe whilst still giving the impression of an available police force. Most forces staff now have approx 1/3 staff as civvies in various roles, with an officers job being further watered down by PCSO's etc.

Points have to go with the revenue to be seen as a punishment, otherwise it would easily be accused of being a revenue gathering exercise and open to abuse. It's just that initially these were self governing, self financing, empire building institutions that got so much money in, bought more scameras to gather even more money. Ok they've tightened up on the rules (or the govt saw another pot of money to have) but they still had 5-6 years of raking it in.

And let's not forget - it's the only law on statue in the UK where you are guilty unless you can prove yourself innocent, and that's difficult as it's a partnership of
County Council\Borough Council, Highways Agency, HM Courts Service, Police, Crown Prosecution Service, NHS....

jas16

378 posts

263 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Skipppy said:
Burn the fking things out. They're in place to make MONEY. fk all to do with safety.
wish it was that simple! why have them in the first place, just waste of taxpayers money as well as on other things

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Byker28i said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
As for revenue- does it not occur that if it does add to the tax coffers it will off-set another increase elsewhere? I still do not believe its for revenue, I think its to off-set the lack of proper roads policing due to resources having to be used elsewhere and these and other automatic functions take up part of the slack.

If it was revenue only then no points would be involved full stop and the fines would be far far higher.
Well, offset a lack of active police officers maybe whilst still giving the impression of an available police force. Most forces staff now have approx 1/3 staff as civvies in various roles, with an officers job being further watered down by PCSO's etc.

Points have to go with the revenue to be seen as a punishment, otherwise it would easily be accused of being a revenue gathering exercise and open to abuse. It's just that initially these were self governing, self financing, empire building institutions that got so much money in, bought more scameras to gather even more money. Ok they've tightened up on the rules (or the govt saw another pot of money to have) but they still had 5-6 years of raking it in.

And let's not forget - it's the only law on statue in the UK where you are guilty unless you can prove yourself innocent, and that's difficult as it's a partnership of
County Council\Borough Council, Highways Agency, HM Courts Service, Police, Crown Prosecution Service, NHS....
Officers are elsewhere doing other things, dealing with threats by text, threats by facebook, nuisance calls, Mg6 series, disclosure, huge case files for no real end result, 6 hours for a £4.50 shoplifting, Two days for a large shoplifting by drug addicts who all claim no involvement but are all on cctv, then a remand file then no punishment.

If it was revenue the fines would be higher. Its about roads policing on the cheap.

Byker28i

93,761 posts

248 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Ah if only officers were doing other things, other than paperwork. My local force proudly announced last year they'd raised the times of officers spent outside the station by 1.2% to somewhere just over 52%!

Run down the number of officers, up the number of cameras (UK now has over 4 million cameras, CCTV included), employ cheaper, less qualified staff.

The obvious solution is to scrap scameras and put traffic police back on the roads, but that's never going to happen frown

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Byker28i said:
Ah if only officers were doing other things, other than paperwork. My local force proudly announced last year they'd raised the times of officers spent outside the station by 1.2% to somewhere just over 52%!

Run down the number of officers, up the number of cameras (UK now has over 4 million cameras, CCTV included), employ cheaper, less qualified staff.

The obvious solution is to scrap scameras and put traffic police back on the roads, but that's never going to happen frown
But that's what we all,and I include BiB I think, want.Really Gordy's "listening" government should take heed...

Apache

39,731 posts

315 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
I had a tesco cashier be rude to me once, every tesco cashier is rude and horrible, I trust them less and less each day.
Much as I agree with the sentiment annie, a Tescos cashier can't ruin your life

Skipppy

1,136 posts

241 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
jas16 said:
Skipppy said:
Burn the fking things out. They're in place to make MONEY. fk all to do with safety.
wish it was that simple! why have them in the first place, just waste of taxpayers money as well as on other things
I wonder how much money this country has spent on CCTV and Speed cameras over the years, and how much money is spent on their upkeep and administration as opposed to the revenue they generate and the crime they prevent.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Apache said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
I had a tesco cashier be rude to me once, every tesco cashier is rude and horrible, I trust them less and less each day.
Much as I agree with the sentiment annie, a Tescos cashier can't ruin your life
They could very easily.

The could make allegations against you based on your lack of response to their cheery hello.

They could steal your identity.

They could put dirty things in your bags.

They may not wash their hands thus transferring matter to you that leads to infection....

The point is there will always be corruption somewhere, there is far far less than ever before in the police service yet the public think its more corrupt than ever.

Three civilian employees do not a corrupt police force make.