Failure to produce
Discussion
Hi guys,
I've recently had a bit of misfortune and got pulled because I stupidly was using my phone whilst driving. Fair cop, surrendered licence, paid fine, etc, no issue as far as I'm concerned. Whilst the licence was away having the points added I then got stopped (laser gun) for doing 37 in a 30 (triple carriageway) at 5.30am Saturday morning on my way into London. Was given another producer to surrender my licence to the local station accordingly.
Went to said local police station within the specified time limit and explained that I could not surrender my licence as they already had it - and also provided the yellow FPN from the earlier surrender, clearly showing that I had surrendered my licence a week or so earlier.
The guy in the station was sound, he understood what I was saying, filled in the form etc, but obviously had to state that I was unable to produce my licence. But he also added that this was due to surrendering it a week earlier on FPN ******* and photocopied the said FPN and attached it to the form.
Now, A) it took the police 2 months to return my licence to me from the first offence, and B) a week later I have received a refund cheque for the £60.00 from them and also a notice of intended prosecution due to failure to produce!
I mean, how brain-dead are they? They already had my licence as it was the same bloody force. I don't know what I'm supposed to do now, what a waste of tax payers money.
I don't know if any of you legal eagle's out there can advise whether I should just get myself a good lawyer, go to the papers, or what. The thing is, if I have to go to court over this pathetic situation, then I'm going to lose at least a days pay at the very least.
I've recently had a bit of misfortune and got pulled because I stupidly was using my phone whilst driving. Fair cop, surrendered licence, paid fine, etc, no issue as far as I'm concerned. Whilst the licence was away having the points added I then got stopped (laser gun) for doing 37 in a 30 (triple carriageway) at 5.30am Saturday morning on my way into London. Was given another producer to surrender my licence to the local station accordingly.
Went to said local police station within the specified time limit and explained that I could not surrender my licence as they already had it - and also provided the yellow FPN from the earlier surrender, clearly showing that I had surrendered my licence a week or so earlier.
The guy in the station was sound, he understood what I was saying, filled in the form etc, but obviously had to state that I was unable to produce my licence. But he also added that this was due to surrendering it a week earlier on FPN ******* and photocopied the said FPN and attached it to the form.
Now, A) it took the police 2 months to return my licence to me from the first offence, and B) a week later I have received a refund cheque for the £60.00 from them and also a notice of intended prosecution due to failure to produce!
I mean, how brain-dead are they? They already had my licence as it was the same bloody force. I don't know what I'm supposed to do now, what a waste of tax payers money.
I don't know if any of you legal eagle's out there can advise whether I should just get myself a good lawyer, go to the papers, or what. The thing is, if I have to go to court over this pathetic situation, then I'm going to lose at least a days pay at the very least.
LastCerbera said:
Hi guys,
I've recently had a bit of misfortune and got pulled because I stupidly was using my phone whilst driving. Fair cop, surrendered licence, paid fine, etc, no issue as far as I'm concerned. Whilst the licence was away having the points added I then got stopped (laser gun) for doing 37 in a 30 (triple carriageway) at 5.30am Saturday morning on my way into London. Was given another producer to surrender my licence to the local station accordingly.
Went to said local police station within the specified time limit and explained that I could not surrender my licence as they already had it - and also provided the yellow FPN from the earlier surrender, clearly showing that I had surrendered my licence a week or so earlier.
The guy in the station was sound, he understood what I was saying, filled in the form etc, but obviously had to state that I was unable to produce my licence. But he also added that this was due to surrendering it a week earlier on FPN ******* and photocopied the said FPN and attached it to the form.
Now, A) it took the police 2 months to return my licence to me from the first offence, and B) a week later I have received a refund cheque for the £60.00 from them and also a notice of intended prosecution due to failure to produce!
I mean, how brain-dead are they? They already had my licence as it was the same bloody force. I don't know what I'm supposed to do now, what a waste of tax payers money.
I don't know if any of you legal eagle's out there can advise whether I should just get myself a good lawyer, go to the papers, or what. The thing is, if I have to go to court over this pathetic situation, then I'm going to lose at least a days pay at the very least.
Why have you got to go to court ?I've recently had a bit of misfortune and got pulled because I stupidly was using my phone whilst driving. Fair cop, surrendered licence, paid fine, etc, no issue as far as I'm concerned. Whilst the licence was away having the points added I then got stopped (laser gun) for doing 37 in a 30 (triple carriageway) at 5.30am Saturday morning on my way into London. Was given another producer to surrender my licence to the local station accordingly.
Went to said local police station within the specified time limit and explained that I could not surrender my licence as they already had it - and also provided the yellow FPN from the earlier surrender, clearly showing that I had surrendered my licence a week or so earlier.
The guy in the station was sound, he understood what I was saying, filled in the form etc, but obviously had to state that I was unable to produce my licence. But he also added that this was due to surrendering it a week earlier on FPN ******* and photocopied the said FPN and attached it to the form.
Now, A) it took the police 2 months to return my licence to me from the first offence, and B) a week later I have received a refund cheque for the £60.00 from them and also a notice of intended prosecution due to failure to produce!
I mean, how brain-dead are they? They already had my licence as it was the same bloody force. I don't know what I'm supposed to do now, what a waste of tax payers money.
I don't know if any of you legal eagle's out there can advise whether I should just get myself a good lawyer, go to the papers, or what. The thing is, if I have to go to court over this pathetic situation, then I'm going to lose at least a days pay at the very least.
Can't you plead guilty by post with a covering letter explaining you'd have accepted the FPN but didn't have possession of your licence at the time in order to do so ?
Without wanting to sound too harsh why is it the fault of Police/CPS? Get pulled for two offences so close together - expect to get reported and explain why you can't stick to the road laws to a court. FPN's are there as an alternative to court when it is deemed appropriate. If your licence is away when you get a second then I think it would be a good idea to summons.
Frix said:
Without wanting to sound too harsh why is it the fault of Police/CPS? Get pulled for two offences so close together - expect to get reported and explain why you can't stick to the road laws to a court. FPN's are there as an alternative to court when it is deemed appropriate. If your licence is away when you get a second then I think it would be a good idea to summons.
They have the licence, ergo THEY have the information they require. I'd fight it personally.
There won't be any fighting to be done. There will be a summons for the speeding offence as documents aren't produced. You can't argue that they have been. There won't be a prosecution for Driving Otherwise Than In Accordance because the D/L is obviously held (even if you did get a summons for it if you take the licence to court it gets dropped there on the strength of what has been discussed). The summons will be for the speeding offence. I can't see the problem.
Frix said:
There won't be any fighting to be done. There will be a summons for the speeding offence as documents aren't produced. You can't argue that they have been. There won't be a prosecution for Driving Otherwise Than In Accordance because the D/L is obviously held (even if you did get a summons for it if you take the licence to court it gets dropped there on the strength of what has been discussed). The summons will be for the speeding offence. I can't see the problem.
Of course you can argue that they have been produced. Who had custody of them? Fool.HRG said:
Frix said:
There won't be any fighting to be done. There will be a summons for the speeding offence as documents aren't produced. You can't argue that they have been. There won't be a prosecution for Driving Otherwise Than In Accordance because the D/L is obviously held (even if you did get a summons for it if you take the licence to court it gets dropped there on the strength of what has been discussed). The summons will be for the speeding offence. I can't see the problem.
Of course you can argue that they have been produced. Who had custody of them? Fool.I find the whole thing a farse to be frank.
When I have been stopped by the side of the road, in an effort to do doubt nab me for another offence (which they tried to do), the police were able to access that fact that I held a full licence, and it's status in seconds.
Yet, somewhere along the line in this system someone actually thought in the circumstance it was in the public interest to further a claim against him as he had not brought his licence to a police station despite the fact that any police station has access to the details anyway, and he has informed them that his licence has already been surrendered.
My tact would be to plead not guilty to the failure to produce charge, and write a forceful, factual but polite letter to the court and ask this to be read at the pre-trial hearing. The CPS with a bit of sense will realise that the case will not stick and drop it.
Incidentally this worked for me when a while ago I had to defend myself against an allegation of me driving someone else's car in another part of the country, when my stolen driving licence details were used to nominate me. I heard nothing after a letter to the court.
When I have been stopped by the side of the road, in an effort to do doubt nab me for another offence (which they tried to do), the police were able to access that fact that I held a full licence, and it's status in seconds.
Yet, somewhere along the line in this system someone actually thought in the circumstance it was in the public interest to further a claim against him as he had not brought his licence to a police station despite the fact that any police station has access to the details anyway, and he has informed them that his licence has already been surrendered.
My tact would be to plead not guilty to the failure to produce charge, and write a forceful, factual but polite letter to the court and ask this to be read at the pre-trial hearing. The CPS with a bit of sense will realise that the case will not stick and drop it.
Incidentally this worked for me when a while ago I had to defend myself against an allegation of me driving someone else's car in another part of the country, when my stolen driving licence details were used to nominate me. I heard nothing after a letter to the court.
vonhosen said:
HRG said:
Frix said:
There won't be any fighting to be done. There will be a summons for the speeding offence as documents aren't produced. You can't argue that they have been. There won't be a prosecution for Driving Otherwise Than In Accordance because the D/L is obviously held (even if you did get a summons for it if you take the licence to court it gets dropped there on the strength of what has been discussed). The summons will be for the speeding offence. I can't see the problem.
Of course you can argue that they have been produced. Who had custody of them? Fool.With regard to the last poster I understand the frustration but RTA 1988 hasn't yet been amended to alleviate the requirement to produce the actual document notwithstanding the fact that yes - Insurance and D/L can be checked via computer.
So when the Licence was returned to you how many valid points in relation to 'totting' are on it.?
If there is 9 then they cannot action a FPN (Endorseable) and it has to go to Court.
If under 9 then you have very strong mitigation to be dealt with the same as a FPN as this was denied by the imcompetence of others and beyond your control.
dvd
If there is 9 then they cannot action a FPN (Endorseable) and it has to go to Court.
If under 9 then you have very strong mitigation to be dealt with the same as a FPN as this was denied by the imcompetence of others and beyond your control.
dvd
Production is taking your documents to a Police Station to have them checked or details recorded. If you don't have the document - you can't do that. Production is not covered by sending the document to any police or DVLA department (which is in effect what is being argued). The officer in the station has completed the procedure correctly and the FPU have decided that a summons is the best means of disposal.
Note to OP.
I had an experience that drew parallels with yours a while ago. I got a producer through no fault of my own then realised I couldn't find my insurance doc's.
(How on earth they couldn't just have used the ANPR on board the car in the first place I don't know!).
So I asked for a new set from my insurance company but I was going to overshoot the time given to me.
So after a few calls I was advised to visit my local Police Station to explain the situation.
Whereupon they charged me with failure to produce!!!!!
So a day later when my documents arrive I produce the paperwork and haven't had any update that this has been accepted. For all I know I'm still charged and it'll bite me in the butt one day. If the case has been closed then it's +1 for the BiB isn't it?
I posted the story on here and got flamed for it.
I can sympathise where you're coming from, there just doesn't appear to be any application of intelligence in situations like these!
I had an experience that drew parallels with yours a while ago. I got a producer through no fault of my own then realised I couldn't find my insurance doc's.
(How on earth they couldn't just have used the ANPR on board the car in the first place I don't know!).
So I asked for a new set from my insurance company but I was going to overshoot the time given to me.
So after a few calls I was advised to visit my local Police Station to explain the situation.
Whereupon they charged me with failure to produce!!!!!

So a day later when my documents arrive I produce the paperwork and haven't had any update that this has been accepted. For all I know I'm still charged and it'll bite me in the butt one day. If the case has been closed then it's +1 for the BiB isn't it?
I posted the story on here and got flamed for it.
I can sympathise where you're coming from, there just doesn't appear to be any application of intelligence in situations like these!
Frix said:
Production is taking your documents to a Police Station to have them checked or details recorded. If you don't have the document - you can't do that. Production is not covered by sending the document to any police or DVLA department.
I relly fail to see the sense in this, perhaps it's just me being silly, or then there is a serious flaw in the handling of cases like this?I feel quite relieved for having a non-UK, EU licence, at least I will not be in this situation for some time...
Finlandia said:
Frix said:
Production is taking your documents to a Police Station to have them checked or details recorded. If you don't have the document - you can't do that. Production is not covered by sending the document to any police or DVLA department.
I relly fail to see the sense in this, perhaps it's just me being silly, or then there is a serious flaw in the handling of cases like this?I feel quite relieved for having a non-UK, EU licence, at least I will not be in this situation for some time...
THe system has not moved on much.
Chrispy Porker said:
Finlandia said:
Frix said:
Production is taking your documents to a Police Station to have them checked or details recorded. If you don't have the document - you can't do that. Production is not covered by sending the document to any police or DVLA department.
I relly fail to see the sense in this, perhaps it's just me being silly, or then there is a serious flaw in the handling of cases like this?I feel quite relieved for having a non-UK, EU licence, at least I will not be in this situation for some time...
THe system has not moved on much.
Man, am I glad to have a photo on my EU licence, no need to check any signatures, just a quick glance at the photo and it's all oscar kilo.
Frix said:
Unfortunatly the system doesn't work for everyone. On he whole it does work well enough.
Trouble is Finlandia if you are prosecuted for anything in UK you will go to court as you won't be eligible for FPN. Don't get caught mate
and he'll still have to produce his licence at a Police Station. The HORT/1 procedure applies to all!Trouble is Finlandia if you are prosecuted for anything in UK you will go to court as you won't be eligible for FPN. Don't get caught mate

Forums | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



