Paying for Unneeded Parts and Labour?
Discussion
A friend of mine is in a predicament. He bought a 1.0 Corsa auto as a runaround but it soon broke down and refused to even turn over. He took it to a Vauxhall specialist who diagnosed it as the transmission control unit (or something along those lines) which they supplied and fitted for around £500. At first it seemed to solve the problem, but a few days later the fault reappeared and back to the garage it went. This time, they've said the ECU has gone and are asking another £700 to supply and fit one.
So basically, he's paid half a grand for nothing and they are now asking for even more. Seeing as they supplied and fitted an unneeded part, then surely he shouldn't have to pay full whack for the ECU? The reason I ask is that I'm sure I've read on here that you are not required to pay for parts that aren't needed. Cheers!
So basically, he's paid half a grand for nothing and they are now asking for even more. Seeing as they supplied and fitted an unneeded part, then surely he shouldn't have to pay full whack for the ECU? The reason I ask is that I'm sure I've read on here that you are not required to pay for parts that aren't needed. Cheers!
You say this fitted control unit seemed to solve the problem for a while.... but now garage say ECU needs replacing.
If the ECU was/is duff, then that may indicate a fault with another item elsewhere, so Garage probably done the correct thing based upon the information they had.
As for wether your friend should pay.....How about if ECU is fitted, and it does solve the problem, then this proves first item fitted not neccessary, so credit required for that item at least. As for labour charges...much harder to avoid that, the garage did do work to investigate the fault, and deserve to be paid for that work.
Not an answer, but a possible course of action
HTH
If the ECU was/is duff, then that may indicate a fault with another item elsewhere, so Garage probably done the correct thing based upon the information they had.
As for wether your friend should pay.....How about if ECU is fitted, and it does solve the problem, then this proves first item fitted not neccessary, so credit required for that item at least. As for labour charges...much harder to avoid that, the garage did do work to investigate the fault, and deserve to be paid for that work.
Not an answer, but a possible course of action
HTH
Amused2death said:
You say this fitted control unit seemed to solve the problem for a while.... but now garage say ECU needs replacing.
If the ECU was/is duff, then that may indicate a fault with another item elsewhere, so Garage probably done the correct thing based upon the information they had.
As for wether your friend should pay.....How about if ECU is fitted, and it does solve the problem, then this proves first item fitted not neccessary, so credit required for that item at least. As for labour charges...much harder to avoid that, the garage did do work to investigate the fault, and deserve to be paid for that work.
Not an answer, but a possible course of action
HTH
SOGA - you pay for something to solve the problem.If the ECU was/is duff, then that may indicate a fault with another item elsewhere, so Garage probably done the correct thing based upon the information they had.
As for wether your friend should pay.....How about if ECU is fitted, and it does solve the problem, then this proves first item fitted not neccessary, so credit required for that item at least. As for labour charges...much harder to avoid that, the garage did do work to investigate the fault, and deserve to be paid for that work.
Not an answer, but a possible course of action
HTH
It doesn't
Therefore it contrvines the SOGA.
I agree you would probably have to pay for the labout investigating the issue, but not fitting.
Martin
I had a similar problem with my central heating. This was original diagnosed as a faulty pump and mine was replaced. This solved the problem until around three hours after the chap left. To give him his due he returned almost immediately and then said the only possible fault remaing was a faulty gate (whatever) that he must have dislodged when fitting the pump, hence the temporary solution. He didn't have a spare but returned the next day and fitted this new valve.
I then asked him to replace the original pump but he had 'dumped' it as was the norm in his company, the Gas Board. My feeling was that I was happy to pay the cost of labour but not of useless parts. The dispute went on for over a year, I was threatened with having my gas cut off, and I got on first name terms with the woman in the Dartford gas board office.
In the end we decided that I would pay for exactly what I offered originally. I asked for my costs - just a few letters and bus fares into Dartford - but was offered in return extended payment over the following year.
One thing that I was hit with from their solicitor was some case law which stated that I was expected to pay for the diagnosis. If, as in my case, this required something being replaced, the company had the choice of either refitting the original and charging for labour for the orginal work plus the replacement or else they could leave the replacement part in situ - their choice - and charge just for the labour of the original bit of labour.
This, of course, helped me in my case as I felt that as they had lost the original pump their choice must be to leave the original in place. Had they not sent me the stated case I would have been prepared to, in addition, pay them for the cost of labour for refitting the pump.
If this is translated into your case, the garage can demand the labour and, if your mate doesn't want to pay for the new item, the garage may, at their discretion, replace the old part and charge the cost of labour.
However, things might have changed since then.
I then asked him to replace the original pump but he had 'dumped' it as was the norm in his company, the Gas Board. My feeling was that I was happy to pay the cost of labour but not of useless parts. The dispute went on for over a year, I was threatened with having my gas cut off, and I got on first name terms with the woman in the Dartford gas board office.
In the end we decided that I would pay for exactly what I offered originally. I asked for my costs - just a few letters and bus fares into Dartford - but was offered in return extended payment over the following year.
One thing that I was hit with from their solicitor was some case law which stated that I was expected to pay for the diagnosis. If, as in my case, this required something being replaced, the company had the choice of either refitting the original and charging for labour for the orginal work plus the replacement or else they could leave the replacement part in situ - their choice - and charge just for the labour of the original bit of labour.
This, of course, helped me in my case as I felt that as they had lost the original pump their choice must be to leave the original in place. Had they not sent me the stated case I would have been prepared to, in addition, pay them for the cost of labour for refitting the pump.
If this is translated into your case, the garage can demand the labour and, if your mate doesn't want to pay for the new item, the garage may, at their discretion, replace the old part and charge the cost of labour.
However, things might have changed since then.
In the days when I worked in the motor trade this used to happen all the time. Usually due to a machanic plugging the diagnostic tool in and going with the first fault he sees instead of fully investigating. When ever it happened it always resulted in a damage limitation excercise and the customer facing staff trying to persuade the customer that both parts were actually the cause of the fault and they need to pay both bills.
Had a similar problem with the Corsa the missus used to have.
Kept cutting out after about half an hour. Wait for 20 mins and it would run again, but try and start it in that 20 mins, and you stood no chance.
Took it to the local dealer, and they said it was one particular part, (Idle Valve, I seem to recall). I then ran around in the car for a few days, but only 10 mins here and 5 mins there. Took it to work after my annual holidays, and the same happened again.
Took it back to the dealer, and they then said it was the crank sensor, apparently the most common cause of this fault.
Complained that they had mis-diagnosed the original fault, and that I had been mis-sold the part. They claimed that the ECU had the Idle Valve fault as the only fault when they checked the car.
Ended up explaining to the 'service manager' how ECU engine codes are stored, and the fact that there is only a limited space in the memory. Therefore if a fault exists that is writing multiple faults to the ECU, very frequently, such as whenever you lift your foot off the accelerator, then these errors would hide the true fault. I also pointed out that they clearly had not tested the car after 'repairing' it.
The final outcome was that I paid for the labour for both the idle valve and the crank sensor, and they paid for the parts.
Kept cutting out after about half an hour. Wait for 20 mins and it would run again, but try and start it in that 20 mins, and you stood no chance.
Took it to the local dealer, and they said it was one particular part, (Idle Valve, I seem to recall). I then ran around in the car for a few days, but only 10 mins here and 5 mins there. Took it to work after my annual holidays, and the same happened again.
Took it back to the dealer, and they then said it was the crank sensor, apparently the most common cause of this fault.
Complained that they had mis-diagnosed the original fault, and that I had been mis-sold the part. They claimed that the ECU had the Idle Valve fault as the only fault when they checked the car.
Ended up explaining to the 'service manager' how ECU engine codes are stored, and the fact that there is only a limited space in the memory. Therefore if a fault exists that is writing multiple faults to the ECU, very frequently, such as whenever you lift your foot off the accelerator, then these errors would hide the true fault. I also pointed out that they clearly had not tested the car after 'repairing' it.
The final outcome was that I paid for the labour for both the idle valve and the crank sensor, and they paid for the parts.
Sorry to take this off at a slight tangent, but it is relevant in a way.
We have a thread running over in CTF about a similar predicament that I, or technically my daughter is in, albeit we have refused to have the part fitted.
Short version of story is that car was being driven to dealer to fix a misfire which is throttle position related.
Car stalled and could not be restarted easily.
Breakdown service called and I and the guy got the car running cleanly but it was stalling frequently, still difficult to restart so deemed not safe to drive, towed in.
From there the dealer (Chevy) plugged in computer to find fault and deemed that it was an ECU / immobiliser fault.
Quoted £728 fitted with no guarantee that this will fix the fault. On a vehicle worth £1-1.1k as a good running example it's an easy decision ie uneconomical repair.
Now the dealer cannot explain to me how that position has been reached from a position where the car was running, if badly.
Thus a 6yr old car is facing the bin, because of the outrageous pricing of components which probably cost about £50 tops to manufacture.
The parts are unavailable from anyone other than the dealer, the kit to read the fault codes and interrogate the black boxes is unavailable, the manufacturer will only supply to dealer. You might say why not get the complete engine electrics off a rear end shunt scrapper with a running engine, well you still need the dealer to sort out all the codes so all the engine electronic components will talk to each other, as the manufacturer will not release the codes to the independant network. And of course the only dealer available in any reasonable distance is the one who buggered up (maybe) the original ECE and / or immobiliser.
To my mind that is clearly an abuse of a dominant market position contrary to EU Competition regulations by both the dealer and the manufacturer, but of course bloody motor industry has this block exemption malarkey.
I said this many years ago that we were going to see a disaster with vehicle life because of mechanically and bodily sound vehicles being scrapped because of the price of replacement black boxes made the vehicles uneconomical repair prospects.
Remember that many of these black boxes have been forced upon us due to the activities of the lentilists persuading Governements around the world that cars really need this or that. Similar things happened with the early cars fitted with cats when dealers were quoting £600 to fit something the car didn't acually need and the owner didn't want.
Don't get me wrong, this particular car is a cheap snotter and whilst it might be relatively young on an 02 plate, it's still a horrible little car which stands the owner in at very little money. What I'm complaining about is that due to the stupid prices charged for these components, unfair practices by the manufacturer and the trade, that resources are being wasted because vehicles are being scrapped before their time.
Madness, utter utter madness.
/rant
Thanks
F i F
edited to correct typing and spooling misstonks
We have a thread running over in CTF about a similar predicament that I, or technically my daughter is in, albeit we have refused to have the part fitted.
Short version of story is that car was being driven to dealer to fix a misfire which is throttle position related.
Car stalled and could not be restarted easily.
Breakdown service called and I and the guy got the car running cleanly but it was stalling frequently, still difficult to restart so deemed not safe to drive, towed in.
From there the dealer (Chevy) plugged in computer to find fault and deemed that it was an ECU / immobiliser fault.
Quoted £728 fitted with no guarantee that this will fix the fault. On a vehicle worth £1-1.1k as a good running example it's an easy decision ie uneconomical repair.
Now the dealer cannot explain to me how that position has been reached from a position where the car was running, if badly.
Thus a 6yr old car is facing the bin, because of the outrageous pricing of components which probably cost about £50 tops to manufacture.
The parts are unavailable from anyone other than the dealer, the kit to read the fault codes and interrogate the black boxes is unavailable, the manufacturer will only supply to dealer. You might say why not get the complete engine electrics off a rear end shunt scrapper with a running engine, well you still need the dealer to sort out all the codes so all the engine electronic components will talk to each other, as the manufacturer will not release the codes to the independant network. And of course the only dealer available in any reasonable distance is the one who buggered up (maybe) the original ECE and / or immobiliser.
To my mind that is clearly an abuse of a dominant market position contrary to EU Competition regulations by both the dealer and the manufacturer, but of course bloody motor industry has this block exemption malarkey.
I said this many years ago that we were going to see a disaster with vehicle life because of mechanically and bodily sound vehicles being scrapped because of the price of replacement black boxes made the vehicles uneconomical repair prospects.
Remember that many of these black boxes have been forced upon us due to the activities of the lentilists persuading Governements around the world that cars really need this or that. Similar things happened with the early cars fitted with cats when dealers were quoting £600 to fit something the car didn't acually need and the owner didn't want.
Don't get me wrong, this particular car is a cheap snotter and whilst it might be relatively young on an 02 plate, it's still a horrible little car which stands the owner in at very little money. What I'm complaining about is that due to the stupid prices charged for these components, unfair practices by the manufacturer and the trade, that resources are being wasted because vehicles are being scrapped before their time.
Madness, utter utter madness.
/rant
Thanks
F i F
edited to correct typing and spooling misstonks
Edited by F i F on Saturday 24th May 06:42
7db said:
My mechanic always pops the old part in the car. It's mine, not his and I can inspect it and see the condition in which it comes out of my car. I appreciate that.
If I'm having the car serviced and they phone up to say something extra needs replacing I always make a point of saying i want the old part, and that if the old part isn't in the boot when i pick the car up, I won't be paying. I then ask whoever is on the phone do they understand this, and make sure it's written on the invoice.Twice when I've done this in the past, the items mysteriously didn't need replacing....
Forums | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


