More HATO muppetry
Discussion
Southbound A12 last Thursday
Coming up to M25 junction and traffic slows to a stop
Then after 30 minutes a few hundred yards before slip there is a HATO on hard shoulder with lights on, a sign on ground at offside of vehicle pointing right and the display on back of vehicle says "Incident" - the latter a stroke of genius
So everyone indicates right to merge into the outside lane - as you would. Then back to turn off, the A12 is clear and the incident is on the M25 Northbound
There was nothing on Gantry signs ?
I remember the Police used to reverse up the hard shoulder ahead of the queue to act as a useful warning
Coming up to M25 junction and traffic slows to a stop
Then after 30 minutes a few hundred yards before slip there is a HATO on hard shoulder with lights on, a sign on ground at offside of vehicle pointing right and the display on back of vehicle says "Incident" - the latter a stroke of genius
So everyone indicates right to merge into the outside lane - as you would. Then back to turn off, the A12 is clear and the incident is on the M25 Northbound
There was nothing on Gantry signs ?
I remember the Police used to reverse up the hard shoulder ahead of the queue to act as a useful warning
same at J15 M4 on Tuesday afternoon. Muppets had "incident" on gantry and then as you get to the junction the hatos have blues and twos flashing, a huge quardened off area blocking off the left lane of the exit slip road. Blue sign pointing right to keep traffic right. Both hatos out but not doing anything other than watching the traffic.
The incident that blocked off the entire left lane and causing tail backs? A lorry that was actually on the hard shoulder with pleanty of space having its wheel changed. Thats right, tailbacks the lot all for a bloody tyre change on what is a slow slip road due to traffic lights/roundabout anyway.
Twunts
The incident that blocked off the entire left lane and causing tail backs? A lorry that was actually on the hard shoulder with pleanty of space having its wheel changed. Thats right, tailbacks the lot all for a bloody tyre change on what is a slow slip road due to traffic lights/roundabout anyway.
Twunts
Flintstone said:
stigmundfreud said:
blues and twos
HATO's have blues and twos? I thought blues were the domain of 'proper' emergency services only and I've never heard a traffic womble with sirens.Please don't tell me they're equiping them with the full kit and caboodle?
HATO's do NOT have blue lights. If you saw blue lights it was probably the BiB.
Police (and HATO) are not allowed anymore to reverse down the hard shoulder to warn of queueing traffic. It was deemed far too dangerous after a number of serious collisions involving the reversing vehicle occured and someone remembered it is the drivers responsibility to drive according to the conditions.
HATO's are required to place those white arrow when stopped on the hard shoulder for any length of time. Chapter 8 regaulations. All vehicles stopping for a decent period of time are supposed to do it. Many organisations can't be bothered - but the HA cannot take that view.
If you saw a lane closed, and nothing apparently there, did you consider a diesel/oil leak on the carriageway?
Lane closures for tyre changes are done out of peak so as not to cause too much congestion. Tyre fitters have a right to work in a safe environment just like anyone else. Why should they have to dodge straying LGV's? Although reaking Poster 2 comments that shounds like a safe enough area? Maybe the tyre fitter was jumpy? We'll never know.
Ref the OP comments on the TO on the A-Road. Maybe he was providing a warning that there was an Incident on the M25. Motorists complaint quickly enough when they don't get warned about incidents befgore joining the motorway. Can't have your cake and eat it!
Police (and HATO) are not allowed anymore to reverse down the hard shoulder to warn of queueing traffic. It was deemed far too dangerous after a number of serious collisions involving the reversing vehicle occured and someone remembered it is the drivers responsibility to drive according to the conditions.
HATO's are required to place those white arrow when stopped on the hard shoulder for any length of time. Chapter 8 regaulations. All vehicles stopping for a decent period of time are supposed to do it. Many organisations can't be bothered - but the HA cannot take that view.
If you saw a lane closed, and nothing apparently there, did you consider a diesel/oil leak on the carriageway?
Lane closures for tyre changes are done out of peak so as not to cause too much congestion. Tyre fitters have a right to work in a safe environment just like anyone else. Why should they have to dodge straying LGV's? Although reaking Poster 2 comments that shounds like a safe enough area? Maybe the tyre fitter was jumpy? We'll never know.
Ref the OP comments on the TO on the A-Road. Maybe he was providing a warning that there was an Incident on the M25. Motorists complaint quickly enough when they don't get warned about incidents befgore joining the motorway. Can't have your cake and eat it!
Edited by Sgt Bilko on Thursday 22 May 11:25
When faced with an "Incident" why not actually say something useful like "M25 North incident" ?
The sign with the arrow on is ridiculous - why is it needed ?. Big battenburg 4x4 and enough lights to guide a plane in. In this context it was moronic and only served to cause another massive tailback
WRT to reversing up the hard shoulder why is the risk greater than being stationary ?
The sign with the arrow on is ridiculous - why is it needed ?. Big battenburg 4x4 and enough lights to guide a plane in. In this context it was moronic and only served to cause another massive tailback
WRT to reversing up the hard shoulder why is the risk greater than being stationary ?
Sgt Bilko said:
HATO's do NOT have blue lights. If you saw blue lights it was probably the BiB.
Police (and HATO) are not allowed anymore to reverse down the hard shoulder to warn of queueing traffic. It was deemed far too dangerous after a number of serious collisions involving the reversing vehicle occured and someone remembered it is the drivers responsibility to drive according to the conditions.
HATO's are required to place those white arrow when stopped on the hard shoulder for any length of time. Chapter 8 regaulations. All vehicles stopping for a decent period of time are supposed to do it. Many organisations can't be bothered - but the HA cannot take that view.
If you saw a lane closed, and nothing apparently there, did you consider a diesel/oil leak on the carriageway?
Lane closures for tyre changes are done out of peak so as not to cause too much congestion. Tyre fitters have a right to work in a safe environment just like anyone else. Why should they have to dodge straying LGV's? Although reaking Poster 2 comments that shounds like a safe enough area? Maybe the tyre fitter was jumpy? We'll never know.
Ref the OP comments on the TO on the A-Road. Maybe he was providing a warning that there was an Incident on the M25. Motorists complaint quickly enough when they don't get warned about incidents befgore joining the motorway. Can't have your cake and eat it!
they have flashing lights it was HATO as they were doing sweet fPolice (and HATO) are not allowed anymore to reverse down the hard shoulder to warn of queueing traffic. It was deemed far too dangerous after a number of serious collisions involving the reversing vehicle occured and someone remembered it is the drivers responsibility to drive according to the conditions.
HATO's are required to place those white arrow when stopped on the hard shoulder for any length of time. Chapter 8 regaulations. All vehicles stopping for a decent period of time are supposed to do it. Many organisations can't be bothered - but the HA cannot take that view.
If you saw a lane closed, and nothing apparently there, did you consider a diesel/oil leak on the carriageway?
Lane closures for tyre changes are done out of peak so as not to cause too much congestion. Tyre fitters have a right to work in a safe environment just like anyone else. Why should they have to dodge straying LGV's? Although reaking Poster 2 comments that shounds like a safe enough area? Maybe the tyre fitter was jumpy? We'll never know.
Ref the OP comments on the TO on the A-Road. Maybe he was providing a warning that there was an Incident on the M25. Motorists complaint quickly enough when they don't get warned about incidents befgore joining the motorway. Can't have your cake and eat it!
Edited by Sgt Bilko on Thursday 22 May 11:25
k all to help the driver change his wheel (no diesel or oil or debris in the carriage way). It was just 1 truck changing its wheel on a slow slip road with pleanty of space on the hardshoulder (where he was parked) to do so.Sgt Bilko said:
Lane closures for tyre changes are done out of peak so as not to cause too much congestion.
Try telling that to the drivers in the miles of congestion I sit in on the M25 every so often in rush hour when a lane is closed so a truck can change its tyre on the hard shoulder. Seems to happen around once every month or so on the 10 mile stretch I do.Edited by Sgt Bilko on Thursday 22 May 11:25
cuneus said:
When faced with an "Incident" why not actually say something useful like "M25 North incident" ?
On the HATO vehicle? It's too small to display much and the messages are preprogrammed. Would be too much fun if we could make up our own.cuneus said:
The sign with the arrow on is ridiculous - why is it needed ?. Big battenburg 4x4 and enough lights to guide a plane in. In this context it was moronic and only served to cause another massive tailback
Procedure. It highlights that the HATO vehicle is indeed stopped, and you should not think about driving into the back of it. Although I don't think I've ever seen people move out of lane 1 into lane 2 because of a HATO on the hard shoulder with a 610 arrow out. Nice LGV drivers will if they see a tyre change going on etc.cuneus said:
WRT to reversing up the hard shoulder why is the risk greater than being stationary ?
It's harder to reverse than sit still. If any one decides to pull onto the hard shoulder towards you, the relative speed is greater. The procedure has been withdrawn - it's in an ACPO document:Guidance on Policing Motorways - 2006.
6.10 Tailback Procedures
Stationary traffic on motorways is now a regular, spontaneous occurrence. The dangers of carrying out tailback procedures outweigh the advantages. As such, this working practice should cease to be used.
Edited by Vaux on Thursday 22 May 15:52
stigmundfreud said:
they have flashing lights it was HATO as they were doing sweet f
k all to help the driver change his wheel (no diesel or oil or debris in the carriage way). It was just 1 truck changing its wheel on a slow slip road with pleanty of space on the hardshoulder (where he was parked) to do so.
You were the one who said they had blue light mate. I conceded to the point about being slow moving traffic/slip road.
k all to help the driver change his wheel (no diesel or oil or debris in the carriage way). It was just 1 truck changing its wheel on a slow slip road with pleanty of space on the hardshoulder (where he was parked) to do so.Sgt Bilko said:
Police (and HATO) are not allowed anymore to reverse down the hard shoulder to warn of queueing traffic. It was deemed far too dangerous after a number of serious collisions involving the reversing vehicle occured and someone remembered it is the drivers responsibility to drive according to the conditions.
Perhaps someone should re-itterate that to the HATO's around the M60, who I regularly see reversing along the hard shoulder.AndrewTait said:
Sgt Bilko said:
Police (and HATO) are not allowed anymore to reverse down the hard shoulder to warn of queueing traffic.
Perhaps someone should re-itterate that to the HATO's around the M60, who I regularly see reversing along the hard shoulder.cuneus said:
My other post seems to have vanished :{
So can some explain the difference in risk between stationary and reversing at 5 mph ?
Simple....If you are stationary you are probably not in the vehicle.If you are in the vehicle and stationary you are able to drive forward either away in lane 1 or up the bank/verge etc out of harms way.If your reversing at 5mph and something big like a lorry wanders onto the hardshoulder at 60mph a few meters behind you the risk of injury is going to be greater.So can some explain the difference in risk between stationary and reversing at 5 mph ?
Edited by TPS on Friday 23 May 09:07
cuneus said:
My other post seems to have vanished :{
So can some explain the difference in risk between stationary and reversing at 5 mph ?
If you are talking about the tailback prcoedure (where the vehicle reverses in line with the traffic slowing down to warn them) it was decided too dangerous as the traffic was generally watching the reversing vehicle more than the slowing traffic. There were a number of collisions where people instinctlively swerved to avoid slowing traffic only to hit the police vehicle. This is why it was removed from the ACPO guidance and why HATO's never did it (should of). So can some explain the difference in risk between stationary and reversing at 5 mph ?
If you are talking about standard reversing then yes it is dangerous as pointed out, since the combined impact speed is going to be greater, and due to the fact that you will rarely be able to "dive" out of the way (to the side) in a 4x4 quicker than you can on foot.
Reversing has to be done daily as again pointed out. Revese from a vehicle to build up speed to join the main carriageway. Reverse if you spot some debris (since you can't just dive on the hard shoulder and jump on the brakes), reverse to get back to a junction exit (we are allowed to, other cannot) and so on.
[quote] Then after 30 minutes a few hundred yards before slip there is a HATO on hard shoulder with lights on, a sign on ground at offside of vehicle pointing right and the display on back of vehicle says "Incident" - the latter a stroke of genius
[/quote]
Taking the points that the OP said, I read it that the HATO vehicle was on the H/S with the "blue keep right arrow" (Acutally known as a 610) behind the HATO vehicle.
As has already been pointed out, first they have to put the signs out if stopping for more than a few minutes (proceedures) They must have been there for a reason, if there was no vehicle, then it must have been an infrastructure problem, ie diesel spill, hole in H/S etc. Believe me, they won't sit there for no reason.
the message board only has a few preplanned messages, "incident" covers most, there's certainly not one with "hole in road" or "diesel spill"
That traffic moved over to the right into lane 2, again, some HGV drivers do this, the HATO signage wasn't in lane 1 telling you to move over, even if it was, there would have been a good reason.
There wouldn't have been anything on the overhead gantries, as there was no reason for signals, everything was on the H/S, why do we need signals??
So, at the end of the day, the only Muppetry was the muppets in the cars etc!!
HGV O/S tyre changes, HATO's will put a lane 1 closure on to give the tyre fitter a reasonably safe area to work, they will not do this in the 2 normal congestion times, ie morning and evening rush hour. the tyre fitter is told that he'll have to wait. Unfortunately, sometimes the motorway can be very busy most of the day, so sooner or later the tyre has to be changed.
Also if you don't think that a lane closure is required, or any signage, than tell that to the HATO that got hit my a car that didn't see the signals, HATO vehicle with flashing lights, and the HATO with hivis on! He was doing just just the same job, but did manage to warn the tyre fitter of impending doom.
By the way, HATO's are not allowed to assist in any pyhsical way with tyre/wheel changes, or any sort of repairing etc. this is on pain of being sacked! Hato's are not a recovery service.
HATO's can reverse on the H/S, normally just enough to give them room to get speed up before rejoining the main c/way, this means that they are only doing it for a few seconds before they're on their way again.
The old proccess of "Tail-end Charlie" where a Police vehicle reversed along the H/S so as to be just prior to standing traffic is no longer allowed, so HATO's don't do it either.
[/quote]
Taking the points that the OP said, I read it that the HATO vehicle was on the H/S with the "blue keep right arrow" (Acutally known as a 610) behind the HATO vehicle.
As has already been pointed out, first they have to put the signs out if stopping for more than a few minutes (proceedures) They must have been there for a reason, if there was no vehicle, then it must have been an infrastructure problem, ie diesel spill, hole in H/S etc. Believe me, they won't sit there for no reason.
the message board only has a few preplanned messages, "incident" covers most, there's certainly not one with "hole in road" or "diesel spill"
That traffic moved over to the right into lane 2, again, some HGV drivers do this, the HATO signage wasn't in lane 1 telling you to move over, even if it was, there would have been a good reason.
There wouldn't have been anything on the overhead gantries, as there was no reason for signals, everything was on the H/S, why do we need signals??
So, at the end of the day, the only Muppetry was the muppets in the cars etc!!
HGV O/S tyre changes, HATO's will put a lane 1 closure on to give the tyre fitter a reasonably safe area to work, they will not do this in the 2 normal congestion times, ie morning and evening rush hour. the tyre fitter is told that he'll have to wait. Unfortunately, sometimes the motorway can be very busy most of the day, so sooner or later the tyre has to be changed.
Also if you don't think that a lane closure is required, or any signage, than tell that to the HATO that got hit my a car that didn't see the signals, HATO vehicle with flashing lights, and the HATO with hivis on! He was doing just just the same job, but did manage to warn the tyre fitter of impending doom.
By the way, HATO's are not allowed to assist in any pyhsical way with tyre/wheel changes, or any sort of repairing etc. this is on pain of being sacked! Hato's are not a recovery service.
HATO's can reverse on the H/S, normally just enough to give them room to get speed up before rejoining the main c/way, this means that they are only doing it for a few seconds before they're on their way again.
The old proccess of "Tail-end Charlie" where a Police vehicle reversed along the H/S so as to be just prior to standing traffic is no longer allowed, so HATO's don't do it either.
Edited by Gafferjim on Friday 23 May 11:52
not a recovery service more of a hinderance service!
Seriously if you cant help, cant touch, cant lift, cant even offer someone to sit in the nice big luxurious 4x4 then what can you do other than to stop motorists crashing uncontrolably into a lorry on the hardshoulder - seemingly failing at that by your post.
And where are they at night when I would argue they are needed the most to ensure stranded motorists are looked after. Tucked up in bed?
Seriously if you cant help, cant touch, cant lift, cant even offer someone to sit in the nice big luxurious 4x4 then what can you do other than to stop motorists crashing uncontrolably into a lorry on the hardshoulder - seemingly failing at that by your post.And where are they at night when I would argue they are needed the most to ensure stranded motorists are looked after. Tucked up in bed?
stigmundfreud said:
not a recovery service more of a hinderance service!
Seriously if you cant help, cant touch, cant lift, cant even offer someone to sit in the nice big luxurious 4x4 then what can you do other than to stop motorists crashing uncontrolably into a lorry on the hardshoulder - seemingly failing at that by your post.
And where are they at night when I would argue they are needed the most to ensure stranded motorists are looked after. Tucked up in bed?
If you want a recovery service, join one.
Seriously if you cant help, cant touch, cant lift, cant even offer someone to sit in the nice big luxurious 4x4 then what can you do other than to stop motorists crashing uncontrolably into a lorry on the hardshoulder - seemingly failing at that by your post.And where are they at night when I would argue they are needed the most to ensure stranded motorists are looked after. Tucked up in bed?
We aren't nurse-maids or fuel bringers for everyone that breaks down either, call us on the ERT and we'll arrange your recovery, call your Mum, Dad, Wife, Girlfriend, Boyfriend etc. we'll give you safety advice (if you ignore it, that's your problem!) we will attend (if nothing more urgent like RTC's debris etc) if you have young children, disabled or any other vunerable person on board.
No-one sits in a big 4x4 on the H/S, not even the HATO's themselves, this is due the the muppets that can't see further than the end of their bonnet, are you blaming the HATO's for that!!
Over the last 3 weeks, A Traffic Officer has been hit by an out of control car (as mentioned above) a HATO vehicle has been hit (don't know the circumstances) an ISU (24 ton lorry, with enough lights for Blackpool, and a bloody big blue "Keep right" arrow on the back, has also been hit.
but, no, according to you lot, it's not the dick-heads that can't drive, don't look, think that signals etc aren't for them, it's the HATO's fault!!!
Edited by Gafferjim on Friday 23 May 12:13
Forums | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


