When they first came up with speeding offences/limits...
When they first came up with speeding offences/limits...
Author
Discussion

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
What was the spirit of the law?

I'm interested because sometimes you read judgements where the judge refers to what the original intent of the law was and how it applies in this case.

It would be interesting to consider in the light of the two usual cases:

1) Bloke doing 115mph at 3am on a clear motorway, well maintained car etc (lol, assuming they knew that cars would be made which safely cruise at >150mph)

2) Woman hacking past parked cars/houses at 45mph at 4pm on a weekday.

Do we have access to any of the original debate surrounding the spirit of the speeding laws? Did the original architects ever consider the proliferation of successful private businesses springing up to harvest speeding fines regardless of danger?

SM

Jasandjules

72,701 posts

260 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Well, it's a strict liability offence, so I'd assume the intent has always been to prosecute for a simple transgression - it would be too difficult to establish Mens Rea - but I don't think you'll find any law publicly debated to say "we'll do this and that will make it impossible to avoid paying, hey prest, tax money".....

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
The Motorway limits were brought in due to complaints about Aston Martin testing their vehicles at high speed, from memory about 1966, as for the other limits 30/40 etc no Idea.

Cheers
I was under the impression that the motorway speed limit was introduced after the AC Cobra appeared on the scene and started making widows?

forza whites

2,555 posts

226 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
The Motorway limits were brought in due to complaints about Aston Martin testing their vehicles at high speed, from memory about 1966, as for the other limits 30/40 etc no Idea.

Cheers
It was Jaguar actually on some sections of the newly completed M1. E-type testing.

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Always knew those Cobra drivers were not to be trusted!wink

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
PH said:
Some blame the reason Britain’s motorways have a 70mph speed limit on the Cobra after a coupe version was allegedly recorded at 185mph on the M1 in 1963.
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?f=23&...
Guardian said:
The 70 mph speed limit was actually introduced in 1967, around two years after employees of AC Cars were caught testing their new Cobra model on the M1. At erm... 190 mph. Admittedly they did it on an empty stretch, at 4 a.m., using lookouts to make sure there was no traffic, but the story was leaked to the papers and the resultant outcry led to the introduction of the motorway limit. Thanks guys.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/notesandqueries/query/0,...
Operation-Cobra.com said:
1964 was the year when an AC Cobra caused a sensation by “testing” on the unrestricted M1 motorway at speeds up to 183mph. Questions were raised in the British Parliament and this episode would eventually lead to the imposition of a 70mph speed limit on British motorways and two lane highways.
http://www.operation-cobra.com/AC%20Cars.htm
Yahoo Answers said:
motorway speed limited in 1964 after an AC cobra production car topped 183 MPH on the M1. This raised concerns in uk parliment, so the legend begins that a speeding Ac cobra is responsible not fuel saving. But yes i agree between midnight and 5 AM Lets go wild!!!!!
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=200610...
The above does mention the E-Type as the best answer though, but this was some years after the Cobra had caused questions in the Lower House.

Chrispy Porker

17,764 posts

259 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
I think the 30 limit was introduced, er, in the Thirties.
I expect before that it was down to 'furious driving of a carriage' or somesuch.

Chrispy Porker

17,764 posts

259 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Like to see them try it now.
Bit too busy methinks.

Dr Jekyll

23,820 posts

292 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
The first speed limit was a blanket 4 MPH. It was supposed to apply to agricultural traction engines but drawn up in such a way as to apply to cars once invented.

That was raised after a few years to 12 MPH, which was barely enforced. Then 20 MPH which was enforced. In about 1930 the limit was scrapped altogether, at least for cars, lorries might have been different. In about 1935 a 30 limit was introduced in built up areas.

I'm not sure when 40 and 50 limits began to crop up, I think the 50's or 60's.

The 70 initially applied to 'all previously derestricted roads'. During the 73 fuel panic it went down to 50 briefly, then got raised to 70 on motorways and 60 on dual carriageways. In about 1977 the dual carriageway limit went back to 70 and the single carriageway limit was raised to 60.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
It was the 1930 Road Traffic Act that abolished speed limits for all pneumatic-tyred passenger vehicles under three tons. Over that weight passenger vehicles <7 passengers the limit was 30mph and for the rest it was 20mph. There were some other limits with regards to vehicles towing trailers.

There were sections in the Act which allowed towns and public parks to set their own limits. Such limits were allowed under previous legislation.

Goods vehicle limits depended on weight and went from 30mph down in various stages to 5mph. Omnibuses and charabancs (express carriages) had other limits but in the main were limited to 30mph at best.

In essence what it meant was that outside of towns and parks there were no speed limits for cars and motorcycles. I know that in the 30s speedometers were not a requirement in cars and motorcycles but towards the beginning of the war were in virtually all.

Of note is the fact that express carriages did not have speedometers and there was case law to show that the drivers of these vehicles could not be expected to be able to tell what speed they were doing. But after the 1930 Act most had them retro-fitted and they became the first vehicles to be required by law to have them fitted when new.

Boring, I suppose.

forza whites

2,555 posts

226 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
DonnyMac said:
PH said:
Some blame the reason Britain’s motorways have a 70mph speed limit on the Cobra after a coupe version was allegedly recorded at 185mph on the M1 in 1963.
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?f=23&...
Guardian said:
The 70 mph speed limit was actually introduced in 1967, around two years after employees of AC Cars were caught testing their new Cobra model on the M1. At erm... 190 mph. Admittedly they did it on an empty stretch, at 4 a.m., using lookouts to make sure there was no traffic, but the story was leaked to the papers and the resultant outcry led to the introduction of the motorway limit. Thanks guys.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/notesandqueries/query/0,...
Operation-Cobra.com said:
1964 was the year when an AC Cobra caused a sensation by “testing” on the unrestricted M1 motorway at speeds up to 183mph. Questions were raised in the British Parliament and this episode would eventually lead to the imposition of a 70mph speed limit on British motorways and two lane highways.
http://www.operation-cobra.com/AC%20Cars.htm
Yahoo Answers said:
motorway speed limited in 1964 after an AC cobra production car topped 183 MPH on the M1. This raised concerns in uk parliment, so the legend begins that a speeding Ac cobra is responsible not fuel saving. But yes i agree between midnight and 5 AM Lets go wild!!!!!
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=200610...
The above does mention the E-Type as the best answer though, but this was some years after the Cobra had caused questions in the Lower House.
Nicely done, 1967 I wasnt far out then smile We should start a Poll E-type or AC who do we blame smile BTW how many people did the AC guys kill by their reckless speeds ?

I'll get me coat smile
You weren't far off mate! I remember reading old articles actually on both!
Am also thinking that it was Mary Whitehouse MP whom started the 'motorway' speed limit campaign
of 70 mph...

Richard C

1,685 posts

288 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Dr Jekyll said:
The first speed limit was a blanket 4 MPH. It was supposed to apply to agricultural traction engines but drawn up in such a way as to apply to cars once invented.

That was raised after a few years to 12 MPH, which was barely enforced. Then 20 MPH which was enforced. In about 1930 the limit was scrapped altogether, at least for cars, lorries might have been different. In about 1935 a 30 limit was introduced in built up areas.

I'm not sure when 40 and 50 limits began to crop up, I think the 50's or 60's.

The 70 initially applied to 'all previously derestricted roads'. During the 73 fuel panic it went down to 50 briefly, then got raised to 70 on motorways and 60 on dual carriageways. In about 1977 the dual carriageway limit went back to 70 and the single carriageway limit was raised to 60.
Actually an interesting excercise for the squints on here (I love that term from Bones) smile

Did we see a mass fall off in road casualties during the blanket 50MPH speed limit? There will undoubtedly be statistics for the period smile
I recall there was a reduction in fatals but a big increase in collisions and injuries

Cooperman

4,428 posts

281 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
The 70 limit was actually introduced in December 1965. I did 140 mph in a Jag 3.8 Mk 2 on the M1 about an hour before 70 became the legal max. In 1967 it was confirmed as a permanent limit. In fact the AC Cobras and other very quick cars being tested was only one factor in the decision to impose a limit. The other, and probably the main one, was the widespread publicity following a multiple fatal on the M1, near J13 in thick fog, in the November and this was a 'knee-jerk' reaction to it, coupled with the high speeds of the Cobras and, I think, some Astons at night on the M1 at claimed speeds of 180 mph.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
I was told, by a friend in the Home Office, that the original speed limits, 30,40,60,etc were set low with the expection that people would exceed them by a fair margin. And that did seem to be the spirit of the law for a long time.

welsh blackbird

692 posts

275 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
[quote=forza whites
You weren't far off mate! I remember reading old articles actually on both!
Am also thinking that it was Mary Whitehouse MP whom started the 'motorway' speed limit campaign
of 70 mph...
[/quote]

Don't think Mary Whitehouse was an MP (thank goodness!). Wasn't it Barbara Castle that introduced the motorway speed limit?

forza whites

2,555 posts

226 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Cooperman said:
The 70 limit was actually introduced in December 1965. I did 140 mph in a Jag 3.8 Mk 2 on the M1 about an hour before 70 became the legal max. In 1967 it was confirmed as a permanent limit. In fact the AC Cobras and other very quick cars being tested was only one factor in the decision to impose a limit. The other, and probably the main one, was the widespread publicity following a multiple fatal on the M1, near J13 in thick fog, in the November and this was a 'knee-jerk' reaction to it, coupled with the high speeds of the Cobras and, I think, some Astons at night on the M1 at claimed speeds of 180 mph.
Hi Mate
some Astons doing over 180 mph in mid 60's ?? Which ones? the new V8 wont quite top 180?

p1esk

4,914 posts

227 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
forza whites said:
Cooperman said:
The 70 limit was actually introduced in December 1965. I did 140 mph in a Jag 3.8 Mk 2 on the M1 about an hour before 70 became the legal max. In 1967 it was confirmed as a permanent limit. In fact the AC Cobras and other very quick cars being tested was only one factor in the decision to impose a limit. The other, and probably the main one, was the widespread publicity following a multiple fatal on the M1, near J13 in thick fog, in the November and this was a 'knee-jerk' reaction to it, coupled with the high speeds of the Cobras and, I think, some Astons at night on the M1 at claimed speeds of 180 mph.
Hi Mate
some Astons doing over 180 mph in mid 60's ?? Which ones? the new V8 wont quite top 180?
I thought it was AC Cobras or Aston Martins involved, or both, and rather than production cars I think they were Le Mans cars being tested. I also have a vague recollection that one of the drivers was Jack Sears, but this may be wrong. So far as I'm aware Jaguars were not involved in this particular episode.

Best wishes all,
Dave.