caught on mobile phone
caught on mobile phone
Author
Discussion

360 detailing

Original Poster:

1,036 posts

231 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Looking for some advice for a friend ( honest, it really wasn't me this time!! )

He was pulled by the Bib yesterday for apparently being on his Mobile whilst driving. He swears blind that on this occasion he actuallt wasn't on the phone.

When they pulled him over, they offered a £60 and 3 points, but didnt ask for his phone number, IMEI ( if thats the term?!?! ) from his phone etc. He is going to get an itemised bill etc from his provider etc but is there any other way to prove he wasn't on the phone?! He is raging at this as he really wasn't on the phone (this time...................)

He offered his phone the the nice gents when they stopped him, to allow them to check the call times etc but they said the didnt need to check, they both seen him...........

Advice please!

Al


satchbot

1,916 posts

227 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
If they've seen it and decided to stop and issue an FPN the BiB must be prepared to go to court on the matter. Not normal practice to seize the phone. No real advise to pass other than for your friend to decide whether he wants to pay up or contest in court.

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Mobiles can be triangulated via which 'cell' they are in.

The time of the offence will be on the ticket, cross reference this with an itemised analysis from the network operator with triangulation.

As BiB did not take details of the IMEI you will have to prove that it was indeed this phone you had with you (triangulation which places it there at the scene at that time) and analysis from the network - your itemised bill won't be accepted as it only records outgoing calls.

IMHO.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
DonnyMac said:
Mobiles can be triangulated via which 'cell' they are in.

The time of the offence will be on the ticket, cross reference this with an itemised analysis from the network operator with triangulation.

As BiB did not take details of the IMEI you will have to prove that it was indeed this phone you had with you (triangulation which places it there at the scene at that time) and analysis from the network - your itemised bill won't be accepted as it only records outgoing calls.

IMHO.
The issue will be the officers will say they have seen it (they may believe they have). Cell stuff costs thousands and thousands and it will be the defence who bring it forward as the police have enough evidence. Phones are not taken anymore as that is not proportionate to the offence under the human rights act.

Was your friend doing anything that may have given the impression of using his phone?

He can try to produce phone logs etc but it may not prove anything.

Was he looking at his phone? holding it at all?

Where was the phone - was it in his pocket or was it in the centre console or somewhere easily accessed.


Mr Trophy

6,811 posts

234 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Im sure there was a post on here where the above subject happened.

However it got dropped 30 minutes before court. Not that this helps, but it he was'nt on the phone, I would fight the case until the bitter end.

forza whites

2,555 posts

226 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
What you need to confirm your statement/original post is a copy from the Network Operator
(Telecommunications EC/Directives allow you access to this data) of all CDR's = Call Detail Records.....These will either confirm or disprove what you say.

Whilst the other posts on triangulation are correct, its the switching on and reporting into
the Network and subsequent CDR's that will illustrate what happened. Every 'event' is a CDR
a text, call, message, network poll etc.

DJ

bi9_jk

883 posts

296 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
My advice to your friend is to fight this.

Firstly. Get an itemised bill and tell him to find evidence from his network operator about when the phone was used. Alternatively get them to confirm that the phone was inactive during this period. If they are alledging he was on the phone then he must have been talking to someone.

Once your friend has this evidence then he is pretty much sorted. My next question was did he try to call someone. If his operator can confirm this aswell then this will only strenghten his case.

If he has offered the officers the phone and they have not taken it then there is little they can say when they alledge that it was not that phone he was using. It is down to them any issues with identification.

They will be trying to bump up their offence ratings and your friend most likely did something which made them suspect he was using the phone. I cannot say what that is. It is down to your friend to try to offer some explaination about this. An itchy head, picking his ear or playing with his hair might do.

If he offers this evidence to the cps or pf then he may not have to go to court as they are unlikely to take it forward.

John57

1,870 posts

259 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Who is to say he doesn't have more than one phone ?

I have been offered a phone to show a driver wasn't on it - when I had clearly seen he was. He was arrested after a name check showed him as wanted for something else ..... and when searched he had two other phones on him. His reply when the three phones were mentioned - well, you've got to try haven't you rolleyes

andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Sorry - can't find the thread - there was one a few months back that has a guy in this situation more or less who went to court to find the CPS dropping it.

Richard C

1,685 posts

288 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
My wife got stopped last year by Cheshire police. Both insisted they had seen her using the phone as she drove past them parked in a pub car park at dusk on a NSL A-road. She argued with them that she was adamant that she hadn't. They said they knew she had a silver and black phone which to her surprise her's is. She drives a Smart roadster and had to search some time for it, finding it in her handbag wedged behind the passenger seat.

I know she wasn't using it as she is pretty deaf, only ever phones people and never answers it and would have had to stop to put hearing aid in. And unlike me, she never never breaks the law. She knows they were simply 'trying it on' and trying to browbeat hear into accepting a FPN. Since most mobiles are silver with some bit of black somewhere they must have dreamt that up. Having also been caught a fe mile/h over in a non built up rural 30 earlier last year is just starting to understand what its all bouth now.

forza whites

2,555 posts

226 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
This is not an anti Bib post!

=======================



Personally I think the Mobile Phone law is about revenue?

The current and in place Law of Driving Withput Due Care and Attention can/could
easily be applied to Folk using their phones whilst driving.

New Sat Nav systems also provide a similiar distration? Smoking/Eating also can
cause some people to lose concentration whilst at the wheel. Am sure others on here
can think up more 'gadgets' contained within modern vehicles that can contribute to
same scenario as the phone. Yesterday I swerved a (white) Van who's driver had pie in
mouth and phone on right ear, needless to say that he was in the middle of the road, tackling
sharp bend, with muggins (me) coming the other way.


This is not anti Bib as they are tasked to enforce the laws, not get them on the Statue Book.

DIW35

4,205 posts

231 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
It's getting to the point these days where you daren't scratch your ear whilst in the car in case a passing BiB thinks you're using a mobile.

insanojackson

6,030 posts

275 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
DonnyMac said:
Mobiles can be triangulated via which 'cell' they are in.

The time of the offence will be on the ticket, cross reference this with an itemised analysis from the network operator with triangulation.

As BiB did not take details of the IMEI you will have to prove that it was indeed this phone you had with you (triangulation which places it there at the scene at that time) and analysis from the network - your itemised bill won't be accepted as it only records outgoing calls.

IMHO.
there is no way the police would do a cell site analysis for this offence, it costs a fortune, serious authorities are needed to do it and its only used for serious crime and in life or death situations.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Richard C said:
My wife got stopped last year by Cheshire police. ... She drives a Smart roadster and had to search some time for it, finding it in her handbag wedged behind the passenger seat.
Now, I know Smarts are small, but just how big is your wife's handbag? - Streaky

Frix

678 posts

222 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
Driving Without Due Care is a bit of a blunt instrument when dealing with mobile phone. YOu have to prove the standard of driving rather than a specific action. Using a mobile phone won't necessarily make you fall below the standard required. The legislation is there as a preventative - you are much more likely to have a collision while on your phone. It's meant to stop the collision rather than deal with the aftermath.

Funk

27,821 posts

240 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
So all that happens is that a copper has to decide you're on the phone and *bam* 3 points, £60 and NO way of defending yourself?

The law really is an ass.

Frix

678 posts

222 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
Not strictly true. You can argue it and go to court. It'll then be up to them to decide using "beyond reasonable doubt".

You don't have to take the FPN.

King of Dings

437 posts

223 months

Tuesday 27th May 2008
quotequote all
360 detailing said:
Looking for some advice for a friend ( honest, it really wasn't me this time!! )

He was pulled by the Bib yesterday for apparently being on his Mobile whilst driving. He swears blind that on this occasion he actuallt wasn't on the phone.

When they pulled him over, they offered a £60 and 3 points, but didnt ask for his phone number, IMEI ( if thats the term?!?! ) from his phone etc. He is going to get an itemised bill etc from his provider etc but is there any other way to prove he wasn't on the phone?! He is raging at this as he really wasn't on the phone (this time...................)

He offered his phone the the nice gents when they stopped him, to allow them to check the call times etc but they said the didnt need to check, they both seen him...........

Advice please!

Al
If you were in Los Angeles, or any other major US city, you’d think having a mobile to your ear was a key part of the driving experience.

In the UK of course (where our laws and roads are the 'envy of the world' just like our NHS and police force), you’re a baby eating, maniac, endangering the public with your callous, selfish, disregard for public safety.

Don’t you realize you need two hands on the wheel and full concentration at 4mph (average London speed) these days.

The difference between someone holding a phone (illegal) and speaking into a poxy hands free unit (legal) is beyond me but will cost you points and money and I guess that’s the whole point here !

Seriously…What a total and utter disgrace the law is becoming in this country.

If only plods would realize what a bunch of automaton, enslaved Nazis they are becoming. What next I wonder ?

JamesZS

541 posts

227 months

Tuesday 27th May 2008
quotequote all
As said, it's a preventative measure to prevent the crash before it happens. I nearly got wiped out in the ZS by a driving instructor chatting away on the phone and not negotiating a bend on his side of the road. That was the beginning of last week and is a common thing.

IMHO, the easy way to avoid it is to get a handsfree, i bought my bluetooth one for a tenner off amazon.

We stopped a chap in a Corsa the other week, he was really aggressive with me from the word go. Saying he'd not been texting on his phone, his dad was a magistrate, he'd seen everything going on around him etc etc.
He went to get out of our car to get his phone, which I declined to see because:
- You can delete records of calls/messages from the actual phone itself on most, if not all handsets (nb: not the network).
- He could have been playing with his ringtones/drafting a text or reading a text
- Not all phone clocks are accurate (mine will display a random time as being when a text was sent/received due to software flaws)
- He may have been using a different phone altogether.

Now, he was adament he'd not been on the phone, but once this had all been explained to him, along with the fact that my colleague and I had both seen him on his black Samsung phone with blue background on the screen (not the actual specifics of the phone, but I quoted make, colour and the colour of the background)... he changed his tune, held his hands up to it and took the EFPN.