Drunk in charge
Author
Discussion

G C

Original Poster:

491 posts

227 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
Following this weeks Traffic Cops, BBC1, with the chap nicked for Drunk in charge, how hard is this to prove?

Or is it up to him to prove he wasn't planning on driving?

For instance, a man parked in a car park who blows over 100 and has a can of beer in his hand, 30 miles from work and 5 miles or so from home, who is "planning on walking home" as soon as BiB turn up? Is that drunk in charge, or not?

how would it be proved??

Thanks

G C

Mr Trophy

6,811 posts

234 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
Surely he would need to be sat in the car, with his bevy to be charged with Drink Driving?

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
Mr Trophy said:
Surely he would need to be sat in the car, with his bevy to be charged with Drink Driving?
Not if you can show he intended to drive and had the car keys etc on him.

Its a much discussed topic on here and it tends to go round and round in circles. It generally starts with someone saying they are going to a meet or festival and they will be drinking but staying in their car and then it goes from there...

G C

Original Poster:

491 posts

227 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Mr Trophy said:
Surely he would need to be sat in the car, with his bevy to be charged with Drink Driving?
Not if you can show he intended to drive and had the car keys etc on him.

Its a much discussed topic on here and it tends to go round and round in circles. It generally starts with someone saying they are going to a meet or festival and they will be drinking but staying in their car and then it goes from there...
Yea i read some of them in the past, and they along with Traffic cops made me write this.

all well and good going to sleep in the back if your drunk, but if your literally in the driving seat, drunk, still drinking, engine of keys in ignition, radio on, and when Mr BiB asks how your getting home you say "walking of course." Surely thats more clear cut than the "sleeping in the back at a festival?"

i'll try finding the legislation and see if that helps, but im not the smartest of tic tacs frown

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
G C said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Mr Trophy said:
Surely he would need to be sat in the car, with his bevy to be charged with Drink Driving?
Not if you can show he intended to drive and had the car keys etc on him.

Its a much discussed topic on here and it tends to go round and round in circles. It generally starts with someone saying they are going to a meet or festival and they will be drinking but staying in their car and then it goes from there...
Yea i read some of them in the past, and they along with Traffic cops made me write this.

all well and good going to sleep in the back if your drunk, but if your literally in the driving seat, drunk, still drinking, engine of keys in ignition, radio on, and when Mr BiB asks how your getting home you say "walking of course." Surely thats more clear cut than the "sleeping in the back at a festival?"

i'll try finding the legislation and see if that helps, but im not the smartest of tic tacs frown
As obvious as it may be, you have to still prove thier intention to drive - so unless they admit in interview you often struggle. mainly due to the CPS charging standards.

Put before a magistrate or jury and they would probably form the same opinion as the arresting officers, that matey was either just about to drive or would be shortly.

In reality you park up round the corner and wait..

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
Driving or being in charge of a motor vehicle with alcohol concentration above prescribed limit

(1) If a person—

(a) drives or attempts to drive a motor vehicle on a road or other public place, or

(b) is in charge of a motor vehicle on a road or other public place,

after consuming so much alcohol that the proportion of it in his breath, blood or urine exceeds the prescribed limit he is guilty of an offence.

(2) It is a defence for a person charged with an offence under subsection (1)(b) above to prove that at the time he is alleged to have committed the offence the circumstances were such that there was no likelihood of his driving the vehicle whilst the proportion of alcohol in his breath, blood or urine remained likely to exceed the prescribed limit.

(3) The court may, in determining whether there was such a likelihood as is mentioned in subsection (2) above, disregard any injury to him and any damage to the vehicle.

This is the basics of drunk in charge legislation.

It is for the defence to prove that there was no intent to drive, all the police need to prove is that he is in charge of a MV whilst above the drink drive limit.

So you are drunk in the car, keys in your posession. You need to prove that whilst you were drunk you did not have the intention to drive. (this is while you are above the limit) If you were to say i was gonna sleep it off for a few hours then drive home and you blew a high amount, and it could be proved that when you intended to drive the proportion of alcohol was still above te limit then you are guilty.

This is hard for the CPS to prosecute as Annie says, as intent can only be proved in interview. But it is for the defence to prove that you had no intention to drive whilst drunk.

It's a preventative offence designed to prevent the actual driving of the vehicle.

SS HSV

9,646 posts

289 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Mr Trophy said:
Surely he would need to be sat in the car, with his bevy to be charged with Drink Driving?
Not if you can show he intended to drive and had the car keys etc on him.

Its a much discussed topic on here and it tends to go round and round in circles. It generally starts with someone saying they are going to a meet or festival and they will be drinking but staying in their car and then it goes from there...
My next door neighbor in my first house was a plasterer. He went out one night and got.. yeah you know, then decided to kip in his Minivan. At some point during the night he was woken by officers that were wondering why his car was left in the pub car park (middle of the night not just after throwing out time) and discovered him there. He told them he was drunk and was sleeping it off, they asked him where the keys to van were and he said "here" pulling them from his pocket. They then arrested him, charged him and convicted him of being drunk in charge. He subsequently lost his license, business, wife left him and then his housed was repossessed. Nice bloke - never heard of him again frown

rs1952

5,247 posts

290 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
mickken said:
A story from the Queensland Police, Oz


Recently a routine Police patrol car parked outside a local
neighbourhood pub.

Late in the evening the officer noticed a man leaving the bar so
intoxicated that he could barely walk.

The man stumbled around the car park for a few minutes, with the officer
quietly observing.

After what seemed an eternity and trying his keys on five vehicles. The
man managed to find his car, which he fell into.

He was there for a few minutes as most of the other patrons left the bar
and drove off.

Finally he started the car, switched the wipers on and off (it was a
fine dry night). Then flicked the indicators on, then off, tooted the horn
and then switched on the lights.

He moved the vehicle forward a few cm, reversed a little and then
remained stationary for a few more minutes as some more vehicles lef t. At last he
pulled out of the car park and started to drive slowly down the road.

The Police officer, having patiently waited all this time, now started
up the patrol car, put on the flashing lights, promptly pulled the man over
and carried out a random breathalyser test.

To his amazement the breathalyser indicated no evidence of the man's
intoxication.

The Police officer said 'I'll have to ask you to accompany me to the
Police station - this breathalyser equipment must be broken.'

'I doubt it,' said the man, 'tonight I'm the designated decoy'.
Welcome return of an old joke first heard in 1968!

pits

6,704 posts

221 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
See now if i were to have a drink again, and had no where to sleep, so chose to sleep in the car. then i would lock the keys either outside, in the engine bay, or the boot, where they are not readily available and sleep in the passenger seat.

ff5317

453 posts

256 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
Sadly I can comment on this from personal experience. Drove to town with the intention of taxiing home, had a fair few and proceeded to the taxi office and ordered a taxi, was told there would be about a 20 minute wait. The taxi office was literally 20 metres from where I was parked and the taxi office was full of people waiting for their cabs. I said to the operator I would wait in my motor in the adjacent car park and to get the driver to honk when he pulled up. This was in the middle of winter so I sat in the car, fired it up to warm the heater up and fell asleep. Got woken up by a knock on the window by the Bib and breathalysed despite explaining I was waiting for a cab. Upshot was went to court the owner of the taxi company appeared to testify I had ordered a cab and stipulated I would be waiting in my motor for it. After presenting the evidence even the cps brief said there was no way I would get a guilty. Result 3 month ban and a dirty mark on my licence. So the message is if you have had a drink no matter what the reason stay away from any vehicle you may be deemed to be in control of.