SHOULD I FEEL GUILTY?
Author
Discussion

cornishgirl

Original Poster:

1,692 posts

223 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
I had a near miss followed by a road rage this morning but am I to blame?

I was taking the little ones to school in the rangerover, approaching the T junction at the end of our lane which joins a 'B' road. Already at the T is a big white van waiting to turn right. I want to turn left so drive up along side him.

Coming along the 'B' road to our right is a bmw with his left indicator on and obviously slowing to turn in to 'my' lane.

As I pass beside the van the BMW disappears from view. The van starts to move so I think it's OK to pull out on to the road.

Wrong. frown

I'm now on the 'B' road accelerating, hear a horn blaring and look in my mirror to see the van stopped halfway across the road and the bmw right up my rear. Obviously he didn't turn left but carried on. His indicator is still blinking.

He then follows me for about a mile, tailgating and flashing his lights and waving his fist, trying to overtake but can't because of the oncoming cars.

I stop at my friend's cotage to collect her daughter and he finally overtakes, window down screaming at me, calling me a "Stupid fcensoreding tart".

I know I pulled out but so did the van driver. If Mr Angry in his bmw had hit me would I be partly or wholly to blame, or was it all his fault?

Dibble

13,292 posts

271 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
You have to give way at a give way.

BMW driver may be partly liable in the event of a collision, but just because his indiocators are on, doesn't mean he's turning (and I'm resisting all the usual BMW/indicator jokes here...)

Best rule of thumb is what my instructor told me on my advanced car course: "Assume everyone else on the road is an idiot, and that they are all trying to kill you. And then remeber that you are an idiot too."

Always wait to see if there's anything else that show's the other driver os going to turn - slowing down, mirror/shoulder checks, devaitaion in course, before you pull out. Just because his indicator is on, doesn't negate the fact he still has right of way.

Of course, he shouldn't have then acted like a complete and utter nobber towards you. Best bet in that situation is just not to enage - no eye contact, no shouting back, no blocking, no hand signals - ignore them

wiliferus

4,225 posts

229 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
In the world of realistic driving - he was completely to blame. If he's paying so little attention to his driving that he can drive along with his indicator going, then he deserves to have someone pull out on him.

In the world of law - had he hit you it would have been your fault. As i understand it the Highway Codes says that an indication is only a 'signal of intention' and that you should always wait for the vehicle to begin it's indicated manouver (Sp?) before you commence yours.

No surprises that he was driving a BMW!! loser


JamesZS

541 posts

227 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
I had a similar incident that resulted in a smash.
I pulled out because the car was indicating left but not turning. The bloke behind the indicating car took it to mean that she was turning and overtook.

Bear in mind the car that overtook was:
- Left hand drive
- Overtaking near a junction
- Wrong side of the road on a blind bend
- In excess of 30mph (limit) so couldn't have stopped in the distance he could see to be clear.

Needless to say he smashed straight into the side of me... i wouldn't really have been able to anticipate it happening as the car that was indicating was over to the right hand side of his lane, making it unsafe to overtake.

Yeah, real world... it's his fault... insurance world, my fault and a £3000 repair bill on my insurance to my car. It's not been the same to drive since.
Still, I managed to hold myself back from punching the smug t**t in his tweed wearing face and got over it.

GTO Scott

3,816 posts

255 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Just out of curiousity, it wasn't a silver 3-series convertible was it? An S-reg one?

It's driven by a chap around the mid-Cornwall area who seems to go out of his way to be a complete prick, and has a habit of shouting at whoever has been unfortunate enough to get in his way.

Chrispy Porker

17,764 posts

259 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
GTO Scott said:
Just out of curiousity, it wasn't a silver 3-series convertible was it? An S-reg one?

It's driven by a chap around the mid-Cornwall area who seems to go out of his way to be a complete prick, and has a habit of shouting at whoever has been unfortunate enough to get in his way.
Is this unique to Cornwall though?

Poledriver

29,627 posts

225 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
unfortunately you can't rely on the indicator as positive intent. I have noticed recently, especially when I was teaching my daughter to drive, that I was predicting what other people were going to do NOT by their indicators but by the "invisible indicators"! Where they are on the road, which way their head is turning, wheel and hand positions etc. This is not taught and, as in my case, is not something you knowingly do, it just goes on in the subconcious (sp?.
In your case you should have been immediately suspicious! A BMW signalling? It's in the same group as older Volvo's and Taxi's!

:Run for cover:

RichBurley

2,432 posts

284 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
GTO Scott said:
Just out of curiousity, it wasn't a silver 3-series convertible was it? An S-reg one?

It's driven by a chap around the mid-Cornwall area who seems to go out of his way to be a complete prick, and has a habit of shouting at whoever has been unfortunate enough to get in his way.
Is this unique to Cornwall though?
Only when he's driving around Cornwall. See, you make it too easy for me...

heebeegeetee

30,270 posts

279 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
The worst drivers are those who make the biggest song and dance when they drive, and those who use horns and lights are in the wrong themselves 99%+ of the time.

Unfortunately we all have to suffer these totally st drivers.

F i F

49,061 posts

282 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
In answer to the question within the title.

Should you feel guilty?

No, put it behind you, do not dwell upon it but file it away as a valuable learning experience, safe in the knowledge that next time you'll do something different.

Personally when using another vehicle to protect me I always keep one eye in their direction so that I can keep them as protection and not be left out in the cold should they drop anchor.

Frankly I don't like using another as protection because it means you are alongside them and exposed to THEM turning into you. Sometimes however needs must.

Plus as others have said all that you can safely deduce from a flashing indicator is that the bulb works.

Akers

463 posts

266 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Sorry to be the bearer of bad news CornishGirl, but you made the assumption that the indicator meant the BMW was turning. 'Assumption is the Mother of All fk-ups' as they say!


On the plus side, lesson learned without injury to car or person. smile

HTH


EFS

Edited by Akers on Thursday 5th June 15:48

Blimey!

759 posts

226 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Sorry, but you were 100% to blame. You did two things wrong -

(1) you pulled out when it you couldn't see if it was clear
(2) you assumed BMW was going to turn

Never trust an indicator!
Even if BMW had been fully intending to turn, he may have been slowing down but he has the right to cancel indication and continue on the same road at any time before making the turn.

BTW, I was behind a people carrier today with the left indicator on for a good few miles, he braked occasionally and I kept thinking he was going to turn, but he never did. The indicator reset itself at a roundabout. Maybe his music was loud and he didn't hear the ticking.

Anyway, in your case you've learned a lesson - the easy way I might add. smile

Muzzer

3,814 posts

252 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Technically it was your fault because, as previous people have said, you should always wait and see if the other car will turn, indicators or not.

However, you should in no way feel guilty as the BMW driver was clearly a complete wr.

HTH thumbup

andye30m3

3,501 posts

285 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
It shouldn't be your fault but if there had been an accident i bet he'd not admit to having been indicating and you would have got blamed.

But i sure as hell wouldn't feel guilty if i was you.

JamesZS

541 posts

227 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Poledriver said:
In your case you should have been immediately suspicious! A BMW signalling? It's in the same group as older Volvo's and Taxi's!

:Run for cover:
Don't forget Rovers and delivery drivers (around this way certainly)

walm

10,644 posts

233 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Blimey! said:
BTW, I was behind a people carrier today with the left indicator on for a good few miles, he braked occasionally and I kept thinking he was going to turn, but he never did. The indicator reset itself at a roundabout. Maybe his music was loud and he didn't hear the ticking.
Or the flashing light on his dash. Or the indicator stalk lower than it's "at rest" position. Ct. I hate those people. Particularly the MLMs with their right indicators on; it makes passing them even more scary than usual.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Should you feel guilty? No

Should you learn from it? Yes

When I took my bike licence my instructor gave me a valueble piece of advice - don't trust anyone as an accident on a motorbike hurts way more than in a car.

I now generally take signals as another car's potential manouvre rather than intended manouvre. In your instance I would wait until the BMW starts to turn into the lane before pulling out.

Stick it down to experience, which is what driving is all about smile

cornishgirl

Original Poster:

1,692 posts

223 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Thanks guys, I sort of knew I was in the wrong but ta for your support.

It was not very nice having a red faced middle aged man shouting obscenities at me when I had 3 children with me who heard everything!

BTW I read what I posted and didn't make it clear that he had almost reached the turn, slowed down and indicating and that's when the van moved out. The bmw had to go right on to the other side of the road to avoid the van because when I looked in the mirror the van was stoped in the middle of the road. It was a blue 4 door 3 series.wink

freddytin

1,184 posts

258 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Only shows we are all human ( VH excepted )

If you are going to pull out , the very least you could do is floor it. That way Mr Bad Day who has slowed as if to take the corner, will not be inconvenienced and can proceed, to vent his anger on the World at a later date.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
get a big towbar, then panic & brake next time he does it.*







*this advice will not be popular with most posters here hehe