Whose right of way?
Author
Discussion

enginearin

Original Poster:

229 posts

283 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
The thread about BMW drive not indicating reminded me of an incident a little while ago that left me a bit shocked and wondering who would have been in the wrong if it had turned out worse.

I was approaching a t junction (two normal b roads) where i had to give way. I was turning left and slowed to approach the junction. Visibility was pretty good and i could see that nothing was coming from the right so began to pull off... in the middle of my right left right observations. As i pulled off and looked left i had to slam on the brakes as there was a subaru (travelling left to right on the main road) in the early stages of an overtaking manouver on the wrong side of the road.

Anyway i was pretty close to tagging the rear bumper of his car as he was pulling out to overtake and it left me wondering as to who would have been in the wrong.

Me for pulling out across a give way and hitting him, or him for being on my side of the road at a junction?

I decided that it was likely that the insurance co would see it as my fault though i am in some doubt as to the applicaton of right of way when on the wrong side of the road. Any thoughts?

john_r

8,354 posts

302 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
I 'think' that from an insurance perspective it would have been your fault; however from a Police perspective overtaking across the front of a junction or side road could be seen as dangerous driving?

allaway

353 posts

253 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
You said you were looking right left right as you approached the jcn. Presumably you were looking left to see if someone was on the "wrong" side of the road and thats why cos they were. The give way lines mean give way to all traffic on the main road.

peteA

2,762 posts

265 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Me for pulling out across a give way and hitting him, or him for being on my side of the road at a junction?

Not supposed to over take on the approach to a 'hazard' - bend, brow of a hill, 'junction', etc...

If I am reading you right - how many people approach a T juntion turning left and actually look left? They assume that they only have to check to the right.

IMO the subaru driver was at fault but guess its good practice to look left in case there are any other hazards that may mean pulling out is not a good idea...?

In this day and age not sure which way it would have gone insurance wise...

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
I suspect not giving way means its your fault. There could be any number of valid reasons why someone might be forced out onto the 'wrong' side of the road.

enginearin

Original Poster:

229 posts

283 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
peteA said:
If I am reading you right - how many people approach a T juntion turning left and actually look left? They assume that they only have to check to the right.

IMO the subaru driver was at fault but guess its good practice to look left in case there are any other hazards that may mean pulling out is not a good idea...?
This certainly what i have taken from the incident... I now always slow down enough to look both ways before entering the main road even when turning left. Generally you would have enough time to avoid hazards as you turn your attention back to the direction of travel so it's very easy to slip into the habit of only looking for traffic to the right.

peteA said:
In this day and age not sure which way it would have gone insurance wise...
Me neither... More educated opinions needed then wink

Thanks

JamesZS

541 posts

227 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Note my post on the other thread. This is basically what happened to me. It went as my fault on insurance, as I was emerging from a junction.

However, if i'd have been less preoccupied with kicking the f**k out of my newly smashed front bumper and truly finishing it off, I'd have probably called police and made an issue of careless driving against the other party, for overtaking near a junction (on a blind bend, in a left hand drive car, while in excess of the speed limit...not that i'm bitter about the smug tweed-clad t**t getting away with it and generally existing)

Major Bloodnok

1,561 posts

246 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
As I say to associates when emerging from a junction (especially when turning right):

"Look right at the first car that will hit you, look left at the second car that will hit you, look straight ahead at the car you're about to hit."

Blimey!

759 posts

226 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
The sub was on the right side of the road for overtakingwink

I had a near one once - a woman parked fully on a grass verge (with a kerb, not a drop kerb) decided to pull out onto the road when I was overtaking. I hadn't even noticed that there was someone in the car and she was pulling out "head on" while looking over her shoulder! It could have been very messy, the RS6 carries a lot of speed.

Edit: No junctions in my case, just a long straight with a car parked on the verge.

Edited by Blimey! on Thursday 5th June 17:07