Private road safety businesses
Private road safety businesses
Author
Discussion

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Saturday 7th June 2008
quotequote all
Ok so the public sector have totally failed to address the road crash problem, and instead have sub-contracted it out to a load of camera-cowboys in the private sector who say they're improving road safety, but are demonstrably not doing because all they've done is latched on to the lucrative speeding ticket gravy train. I don't know if the government are stupid and believe the speedcam propaganda or are too embarassed to change tack. Either way it's an almighty frickup that's costing lives and shows absolutely no sign of improving.

But the entrapreneur in me is thinking isn't there a case for private enterprise here? Obviously where stand-alone business is concerned it works or it goes bust. Risks are taken rewards are reaped or not, depending on how smart you are. Private enterprise will always move into a hole in the market and right now when it comes to road safety initiatives that's one great big mother-loving hole!

So I know of a junction with a bad safety record near my house. It needs to be re-engineered to discourage the number of imbeciles pulling out dangerously into the path of 70mph traffic. The speed camera bozos set up nearby sometimes to harvest cash citing the accident records as justification but of course nothing changes. When you ask them they'll just feed you the "x% reduction at camera sites BS" so no hope of anything good ever happening there.

But I wonder if I could put in a tender to pay for re-engineering that junction into a flyover/sliproad thing or some other design (obviously I'd be guided by experts!) for a share of the money saved from the first 10 years of reduced accidents. Aren't fatalities like six figures to investigate? If we expect 15 people to die and 250 to cost ~100k in injury investigation over ten years, that means if I can fix the problem for say £5M in engineering and get a share of the potential £40M I could make some decent money and everyone would be happy.

My company could get business from recommendations up and down the country in much the way property developers pay "spotters" of good land with potential.

I'd be taking the financial risk and paid out from results. Now surely this is a far better proposition than p1sspoor speed camera businesses that do nothing other than stiff the motorist??? How could a responsible council possibly turn down a zero risk proposition like that?

SM

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Saturday 7th June 2008
quotequote all
Accidents generally aren't predictable though.

Jasandjules

72,710 posts

260 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
I'd be taking the financial risk and paid out from results. Now surely this is a far better proposition than p1sspoor speed camera businesses that do nothing other than stiff the motorist??? How could a responsible council possibly turn down a zero risk proposition like that?

SM
I see your point. But the SCPs also take a financial risk, and get paid by results.

Whilst it is a better proposition to those with a sound mind, you would be pitching to a council.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
Nice idea but …..

As I understand it many of the costs associated with an accident are things like lost days off work etc. and that the public sector costs involved are things like police time to attend and investigate and NHS staff time to deal with injuries or to deal with bereavement etc. The council or the highways agency who is responsible for your junction would not get money out of the private employers, police or NHS for events that ‘didn’t happen’ thus the council would have to pay you out of its own coffers and there’s no incentive for that because accidents generally cost a council very little!

711

806 posts

256 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
Surely there must be some kind of statistical model that's being used? Perhaps one based on the traffic flows, road type, junction features, previous accidents, etc?

One could use that to set up the business case....

I take the point about who's taking the financial hit, and the fact that SM would be pitching to councils...

Don't councils indirectly pay for police and fire brigade? If their costs of attending accidents could be shown to be reducing, then that part of the council tax could be either reduced or reallocated?

Dunno...I don't know anything about how local government works. I've not bothered finding out either, 'cause it would probably raise my blood pressure too much!

Edited by 711 on Sunday 8th June 10:58

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Monday 9th June 2008
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
Accidents generally aren't predictable though.
You don't say? Let's test the theory, looking at the data for a fictional junction listing deaths:

1998 5
1999 3
2000 3
2001 4
2002 6
2003 6
2004 5
2005 6
2006 3
2007 5
2008 ? <- you tell me.

Go on, have a wild stab in the dark...
SM

g_attrill

9,179 posts

277 months

Monday 9th June 2008
quotequote all
The main costs of accidents are "pain and suffering" and "lost output" so aren't a cost that any person in particular can say they will be saved.